12 Sci-Fi Movie Sequels That Deserve A Second Chance

Because sometimes we all have to ask, "What did Critters 3 ever do for us?"

By Cathal Gunning /

Ah, the sequel. Despised and beloved in equal measure, the follow up film has a long history of both delighting and appalling audiences who want more of the same, but different—really, with that description in mind it’s no wonder filmmakers often struggle to fulfil this impossible demand.

Advertisement

In the world of science fiction in particular, though, the sequel is a strange beast. No longer burdened with the heavy task of world-building and able to proceed straight into the plot without first establishing the rules of its far-fetched reality, the sci-fi sequel should be fertile ground for instalments which outdo their predecessors in terms of originality and daring.

However, for every Aliens there are a dozen Alien 3s, and often times sci-fi sequels fall victim to the “less is more” rule as their second trips to our favourite far-off worlds prove disappointing. In fact, critics and audiences can on occasion be quicker to write off sci-fi franchises due to the law of diminishing returns and miss out on stellar instalments as a result. Just look at these examples of less-loved sequels which deserve another shot at recognition.

12. Bumblebee

This is a strange one, as the latest instalment of Michael Bay’s much-maligned Transformers franchise was reasonably well-liked upon its arrival in cinemas in 2018. Starring Edge of Seventeen’s Hailee Steinfeld as the original owner of the eponymous car/ robot in disguise, the eighties throwback was an agreeably simple slice of nostalgia which made up for the franchise’s slide into incoherence in recent years.

Advertisement

However despite the decent reception received by Bumblebee, many viewers missed out on the flick solely because it was associated with the Transformers brand, a series which may have started off strong with 2007’s fun original but which soon became critical poison, toxic to the point that cinemagoers dismissed Bumblebee as "just another Transformers movie".

As such, we’d recommend that anyone avoiding this one due to its lesser predecessors give Bumblebee’s easy charms a shot.

11. Ghostbusters 2

This one was utterly reviled when released in 1989, and even embattled reboot helmer Paul Feig could take some solace in the fact that fans definitively did not want to revisit the world of 1984’s once in a lifetime hit Ghostbusters—and this was with the original flick’s director and cast on board, mind.

Advertisement

Nonetheless, and whilst this claim may be considered sacrilege in some corners of the Internet, we here at WhatCulture have been shocked to realise in recent years that, upon revisiting the much-maligned sequel, Ghostbusters 2 is actually… kind of good?

Maybe it’s the decision to make long suffering nerd Louis Tully an honorary member, maybe it’s the killer villain, hell maybe it’s just that anarchic sequence where all manner of ghouls are set loose on New York. Whatever the case, without the heavy burden of expecting it to outdo its classic precursor, this horror comedy is a pretty solid watch on its own.

10. Prometheus

Now, technically this one is a prequel, and in fact according to Gladiator helmer/ Alien franchise mastermind Ridley Scott it’s really a “story with strands on Alien’s DNA.” But let’s face it—sequel, reboot, or anything else, there are few people willing to defend Prometheus in any capacity so Scott can take it or leave it.

Advertisement

Yes, the mythology of the franchise is needlessly complicated by this instalment, and some characters do act moronically in order to ensure the plot remains in motion. But said plot is a relentless thrill ride, one which may be hard to untangle but nonetheless lands with visceral ferocity when it does hit.

Featuring a couple of the franchise’s most brutal moments, the flick is uncompromising enough to make up for its pseudo-philosophical detours. Just try to forget the upsetting image of our protagonist desperately scrambling to remove a rapidly germinating alien from her body before it leaves by force and try telling us that the boring backstory is enough to derail this space-set chiller.

9. Bill And Ted's Bogus Journey

There’s really no defending the bad reputation which this film received upon release—outside of being a sequel to a successful sci-fi adventure comedy caper, Bill and Ted’s Bogus Adventure did nothing to earn the critical ire it was handed when it hit theatres in 1991.

Advertisement

Funnier, zanier, and faster paced than its already great predecessor, the flick managed to fuse an upbeat parody of Bergman’s arthouse classic The Seventh Seal with a wild teen comedy and the chemistry between loveable leads Alex Winter and Keanu Reeves as the eponymous duo was as reliably strong as ever.

So what did critics have to hate on? Well, nothing really, but this one really does prove that often times sequels are held to an impossibly high standard, and as such it’s well worth revisiting this madcap flick for a couple of campy laughs and a reminder that critics don’t always know what they’re talking about when they reflexively dismiss the later instalments of a franchise as inherently inferior to their predecessors.

8. Quatermass And The Pit

A tense and thoughtful sequel, Quatermass and the Pit is one the better aged Hammer horrors, a sci-fi mystery wherein an enigmatic buried deep beneath the streets of London is revealed to be a Martian craft which, once disturbed, begins to manifest its power in strange ways through the minds of innocent onlookers.

Advertisement

This one was well liked upon release, but unlike its pair of predecessors The Quatermass Xperiment and Quatermass 2, Quatermass and the Pit is rarely singled out by sci-fi retrospective for a repeat viewing, and it’s a damn shame.

After all, this late sixties curio features some of the first depictions of alien civilizations influencing human evolution, an idea which the genre has repeatedly returned to in the decades since. However, few approaches to the material feature this flick’s hypnotic pace and chilling atmosphere, both of which make it a must watch for genre completists and casual fans alike.

7. Universal Soldier Regeneration

Of all the entries on this list, this must have been one of the most unexpected even for the filmmakers. The original film in the series, 1992’s Jean Claude Van-Damme-starring R-rated action thriller set in a dystopian future, saw a regenerated Vietnam vet escape a program intended to create the perfect… well, the clue’s in the title.

Advertisement

It wasn’t loved by critics and its first sequel was widely reviled, but when the third instalment was released straight to DVD in 2009, a funny thing happened. Critics raved about its innovative sci-fi action sequences, praising the flick’s inventive direction and impressive brutality and thus leading the film to find legions of fans outside of the usual late-night action flick crowd.

Now Regeneration is seen as a solid cult classic well worth revisiting, and even the fourth instalment, 2012’s Day of Reckoning, garnered praise for its offbeat Lynchian atmosphere and original action.

6. Spider-Man 3

Sacrilege! Okay, so we’re well aware that defending the third and final instalment of Sam Raimi’s self-consciously corny Spider-Man trilogy is dangerous territory since it means justifying the inexplicable Peter Parker dance scene, but hear us out.

Advertisement

Yes, the flick is overstuffed and as a result none of its trio of villains are given sufficient screen time to do their respective baddies justice. Yes, Topher Grace is miscast as Eddie Brock and his Venom occasionally looks a little embarrassing. Yes, even the eternally likeable Bryce Dallas Howard struggles to make this film’s Gwen Stacy interesting.

But!

The chaotic villain pile up does provide some impressive action set pieces, particularly the finale, and whilst his screen time is limited Thomas Hayden Church does an incredible job humanising Sandman, providing a rare villain which can stand toe to toe with Alfred Molina’s Doc Oc in terms of poignant believability.

So it’s far from perfect, but there’s more than enough good in Spider-Man 3 to deserve another re-watch—although yes, you can feel free to fast forward through the dance scene.

5. Men In Black III

So most critics are willing to concede that the belated second sequel to Men in Black, 2012’s MIB III, managed to salvage the failing franchise by changing up its formula through hiring Josh Brolin to play a younger version of Agent K, as well as bringing back a genuinely threatening villain in the form of, er, Flight of the Conchord’s Jermaine Clement.

Advertisement

But this consensus ignores the fact that, whilst 2002’s first sequel is admittedly an undeniable re-tread of the first film, it’s not without its own charms and doesn’t do a terrible job of making the franchise a little lighter in tone.

Okay, so it’s not for everyone, and maybe we just like the coffee-addicted worms too much to deny them more screen time. But Lara Flynn Boyle and Johnny Knoxville make a solid villainous pairing, Rosario Dawson is as engaging as ever as J’s love interest, and even the ending is… Okay the ending doesn’t work, but the rest of the film is nowhere near as lame as some claim, and worth revisiting to see for yourself.

4. The Lost World: Jurassic Park

Yes, the movie that Spielberg famously broke his usually strict no sequels edict for is often used as evidence that the director should have stuck to that formula—even by this very writer in earlier articles. But as flawed as The Lost World is, when taken as a standalone adventure and not a follow up to 1993’s iconic original, it’s a solid enough flick which really only suffers due to existing in the oversized shadow of the franchise’s first film.

Advertisement

Consider the recent Jurassic World Fallen Kingdom, which would have had an inexplicable cloning subplot and some disbelief-destroying-ly cartoony villains even if Jurassic World hadn’t been an enjoyable slice of blockbuster mayhem. Whereas The Lost World has a fantastic Pete Postelwairthe performance, those chilling sequences with the tiny dinosaurs ganging up on a hammy Peter Stormare, and a T Rex roaming through suburbia—What more could you ask for?

3. Gremlins 2

Unlike fellow 1984 horror comedy Ghostbusters, Gremlins 2 The New Batch wasn’t outwardly reviled upon release. Nonetheless critical consensus did come to an agreement that the focus-free, overstuffed, and altogether far zanier second flick suffered from comparisons to its darker and more coherent predecessor, and so the prevailing wisdom has gone for decades since.

Advertisement

However, a recent trend in the Gremlins fandom has begun reconsidering the second film as an anarchic masterpiece of its own, as evidenced by cult podcast Chapo Trap House’s recent interview with director Joe Dante and the satirical Twitter page The Institute of Gremlins 2 Studies which claims to be committed to untangling the film’s vast depth of social commentary.

Dante went for broke with this cartoonier, stranger, and in many ways much more daring sequel, and it’s well worth revisiting for its prescient satire and demented hilarity alone.

2. Back To The Future 3

Often singled out as this beloved franchise’s weakest link, there’s no denying that the third instalment of the time travel comedy adventure series Back to the Future is a considerable departure from the established norm of the films.

Advertisement

Where the first flick was a likeable teen comedy with elements of sci-fi, the second flick focused more on the time travel to become a trippy but no less light and fun adventure set in the near future. However the third film upended expectations entirely by taking its heroes Marty McFly and Doc Brown back in time once more—way back, this time, to the Wild West.

So we got a Western instalment at odds with the style of the first two films but which, upon a re-watch, is actually arguably the strongest single flick in the series. The third film gives Christopher Lloyd’s loveable Doc a shot at centre stage and his love story, along with the satisfying conclusion to Marty’s arc make for a pretty perfect closer to this much-loved trilogy.

1. Critters 3

Taken on its own merits, Critters 3 makes for a pretty standard outing as far as the goofy “Gremlins, but they’re aliens and eat people” eighties horror comedy franchise goes. Sure, the action may be uprooted from the small town of Grover’s Bend into a cramped inner-city apartment block and the gore may be toned down (save for the landlord, who more than deserves his fate).

Advertisement

But by and large this’s a pretty pedestrian outing for the chattering extra-terrestrials, and as such it’s worth a watch even if it doesn’t hit the inventive heights set by the 1986 original. But that’s not why we recommend giving Critters 3 another chance.

No, this one deserves to be seen because it features the first film appearance of a very young and adorable Leo DiCaprio, who plays the protagonist and shows a little of the promise which would one day make him a Hollywood superstar.

Advertisement