13 Intense Movie Performances That Are Incredibly Difficult To Watch
The best films leave scars.
For all of the artful and subtle acting performances that permeate Hollywood history, and the critical acclaim that comes with their more restrained art, intensity in acting is as memorable and as important. Obviously, the likes of Al Pacino shouting, or Daniel Day Lewis spitting all over his co-stars in the name of The Method opens such an approach to comic criticism (even when those performances are successful), because it is invariably easier to ape something with bigger characteristics.
The search for intensity has of course also lead to the proliferation of over-acting, even from those actors like Pacino and DeNiro who were previously famed for their intensity, which serves to underline the difficulty in finding the balance between hitting the mark and leaving one and over-egging and turning in a performance more fitting to a pantomime stage.
With those pit-falls acknowledged and avoided, it is important that intensity does not disappear from the acting world in favour of reinforcing the mythology and brand of actors like Ryan Gosling (at least recently), or Channing Tatum. Because there is nothing quite like the feeling of a performance so gripping, that burrows so completely under the audience's skin that is impossible to pull away, but equally difficult to watch without something being left behind.
To celebrate those successes, we're running down some of the most intense Hollywood performances that almost made you want to turn away from the screen...
13. Charlize Theron - Devil's Advocate
If ever there was cause to doubt that getting between the devil and his quarry was a particularly bad idea, the perfect answer comes with Charlize Theron's astonishingly visceral portrait of despair as Mary Ann Lomax in the exceptionally affecting supernatural thriller from Taylor Hackford.
The Devil's Advocate did a lot of things right; casting Al Pacino as the devil, extracting a solid, atypically varied performance by Keanu Reeves, and chiefly bringing in Theron as Reeves' small-town wife, who finds herself an unwitting pawn in the devil's play to start a family and end the world. As her husband is swept up in a meteoric rise to success at Pacino's law firm (a cunning, and barbed front for his devilish activities), Mary Ann begins to suspect something is wrong, and her suspicions are dismissed as psychosis - something that the devil plays on to get rid of her.
The arc that takes Mary Ann from bright-eyed country girl to broken, suicidal victim is grimly extreme, and it is her final moment - when she offers a final note of love to Reeves before slitting her own throat that leaves the biggest scar in an entertainingly haunting film.
12. Ralph Fiennes - Schindler's List
The mark of a truly good villain is not just that they are memorable, nor even that their image transcends the limit of their film universe (like Darth Vader's costume has) - though both are important - it is more the scars they leave. Like a great horror movie, their most important impact arguably takes place outside of the cinema, when you recall and recoil at their most heinous crimes.
Ralph Fiennes is a master of such performances: he brought an immediate, awful elegance to Voldemort, a snarling, grotesque animalness to Red Dragon and more than any other performance, he got completely under the audience's skin as Amon Goeth in Schindler's List. The Nazi commandant is the archetypal mega-villain, cold, power-crazed and aloof, and like Tarantino's Hans Landa (who owes this performance a major debt) he is worryingly put in a job that takes advantage of his worst attributes.
Fiennes' performance is particularly difficult to watch because it completely defies expectations: he is set up as a redeemable villain (which is played when Schindler lectures him on real power) but then his evil escalates, and he drives himself under the audience's skin like a shard of ice. Perversely, he is charismatic and irresistibly watchable, but we are then punished for ever accepting that dynamic.
11. Natalie Portman - Black Swan
In the grand history of body-shock film-making, the moment in The Black Swan when Natalie Portman peels her cuticle back is quite possibly one of the most despicably affecting of all, but it is the perfect culmination of Nina Sayers' descent to madness.
Her portrayal of the unstable, unravelling ballerina is hugely difficult to watch, thanks to the rawness of Portman's performance, and there is something deeply unnerving in the way director Darren Aronofsky messes with the audience's expectations of reality, tearing down boundaries and making even the most jarring of scenes appear authentic.
Portman's performance descends to such a degree that she is no more than an angry open wound, and even as it becomes clear that she might well be evil (at least in her own psyche) it's hard to watch how far she falls.
10. Emily Watson - Angela's Ashes
Angela's Ashes is an ordeal. Though the adaptation of Frank McCourt's acclaimed memoir under-performed when it was released, it remains a smart version of the source, and it is full of some supremely impressive performances, particularly from Robert ne'er-do-well Robert Carlyle and even more so from Emily Watson, who plays the emotional epi-centre of the film.
The story is a tale of woe to end them all - not so much a portrait of triumph in the face of adversity, but more a celebration that the slightest glimmers of hope could exist in the worst possible circumstances, like life clinging on when it should surely die. And whenever it seems like there's about to be an upturn in the fortune of the McCourts, their worlds come crashing down around them, killing children, shattering dreams and building a boulder of grief that crashes down on Watson's stoic, wilted Angela.
The performance doesn't have the flamboyance of others on this list, but there is a horrifying quiet resilience that says so much more about the burden of her grief, and it is truly difficult to watch her deal with what her life throws at her.
9. Gary Oldman - Hannibal
You'd be forgiven for not knowing that Gary Oldman ever starred in one of the Hannibal Lecter movies, so thoroughly swamped in prosthetics was he in wayward sequel Hannibal. The film might have been a relative disaster - especially considering the success of The Silence Of The Lambs - but in antagonist Mason Verger, a Lecter survivor with a penchant for feeding people to pigs under a horrible mask of scars, we still had a brilliant performance.
Oldman's performance is so disarmingly unfamiliar and beautifully affecting that he chose to remain uncredited, preserving the magic of the performance (rather than disowning the quality of the rest of the unfortunate film). Though it subsequently became clear it was Oldman behind the mask, for a while the performance existed in haunting isolation, and it is a true portrait of the grotesque.
It's not just the delivery of his lines - which is awful enough - but the physical performance combined with the character's design is a living reminder of one of Lecter's most heinous crimes, which is hinted at in the film, which makes him difficult to watch at all.
8. Al Pacino - Scarface
Like Fiennes' performance as Amon Goeth, Pacino's provocative turn as Scarface is difficult to watch because of its animalism, but unlike the Nazi commandant, Pacino's holds some perverse familiarity - and even empathy - which makes it doubly difficult to watch.
Tony Montana's rise to power and descent to depravity and evil is the archetypal bad guy story, without restraint or restriction, as he seeks to make the entire world his, regardless of what it costs him. Ultimately, we can see Tony's fatal end coming a long time before he can, and the film is careful not to stand as an aspirational tale gone wrong (which can be said more obviously of the likes of Goodfellas). You aren't supposed to want to be be Tony, really, but you're also not supposed to hate him.
But, the irony of Scarface is that that agenda failed, mostly thanks to how iconic Pacino's performance was. Yes, the film is depraved, and the performance hugely difficult to watch when he loses control, or when his personal world caves and he can't deal with loss like a normal human, but audiences found an unlikely poster boy in Montana, and proclaimed him a hero. So the over-riding experience of Scarface is wanting to learn the lessons offered by Tony's death, but simultaneously thinking he's got some really nice stuff, and fostering the worst aspirational feelings towards his lifestyle, despite the moral lesson that pummels you in the face.
7. Anthony Hopkins - The Silence Of The Lambs
From Al Pacino's explosive, almost pantomime grotesque to something at the opposite end of the performance scale, which is part of Hopkins' success in the role. The contrast of his ice-cold, calculating Lecter and the more volatile, dangerous psychosis of Buffalo Bill is one of his fundamental pillars of success, and in an utterly perverse manner the audience ends up cheering Lecter as an anti-hero, precisely because his approach to being a villain is better than Bill's.
And therein lies the difficulty in watching Lecter. It's not simply that the intense physical performance that Hopkins offered was so utterly disarming - all precise creases and clinical cleanliness - but also that we found ourselves suckered into loving him. He is one of the most iconic characters - and not just villains - in all of cinema, and it is for good reason that he has now appeared in four films and a TV show, and that appeal can all be traced back to Hopkins' stunning, skin-crawlingly provocative performance.
It might be brilliant, but still to this day that nitrogen dipped voice, and the mischievous eyes send tingles up even the most familiar spines.
6. Robert Carlyle - Trainspotting
Like Daniel Day Lewis and Ralph Fiennes, Robert Carlyle is at his best when given the opportunity to flex his volatile muscles in performances. He might be disarmingly charming in The Full Monty and Carla's Song, but he is far more memorable for his psychotic turns in The Beach, The World Is Not Enough and as Adolf Hitler, so it's not surprising that his most affecting, and most disturbing performance should be his most unleashed.
As self-styled patriarch Francis Begbie, Carlyle is an explosive bottle rocket, with a great big red button that says do not press, but which occasionally just defies logic and presses itself, leading to a hail of hellfire.
Begbie is the kind of character who makes every scene that he appears in unavoidably tense, a ticking time bomb who can and will explode at regularly intervals so it's impossible to watch him in comfort.
5. Adrien Brody - The Pianist
Despite a very varied career - and some less than impressive decisions - in the 12 years since The Pianist was released to a tide of critical acclaim, Adrien Brody is still considered an accomplished, dependable actor because of the raw brilliance of his performance as Wadysaw Szpilman.
Gifted incredible material, and one of the most important stories to tell in cinema, Brody's haunting performance as the titular pianist is an enchanting, despicable ordeal punctuated by unimaginable horrors that remain completely relatable because of Brody, and the direction of Roman Polanski. Never attempting to preach, Polanski instead decided to strip his story back to visceral flashpoints, turning Brody into a walking stripped nerve and putting him through inconceivable horrors in the name of telling a bigger, horribly true story.
Brody's performance is a haunting walking allegory for the plight of his character's whole people, and the difficulty in watching him comes not just from the True Story label, but also from the fact that at some point in human history people just like us either helped, or didn't do enough to hinder the same happening to millions of people.
4. Paddy Considine - Dead Man's Shoes
Watching Shane Meadows' brilliant film first time around, without the knowledge of the utterly affecting twist Considine's bad-ass performance is completely disarming: he is visceral, unhinged and terrifying and even without context, you want him to achieve his agenda to wipe out the men on his list.
But then, when the narrative reveals its completely heart-breaking secret, the true horror of his seemingly unhinged actions changes the make-up of the entire film. A group of supremely unlikable, and needlessly cruel hoods become something else entirely, and the unquantifiable anger behind Considine's eyes is given appalling context and take the shape instead of unknowable grief.
Richard is the embodiment of pain, focused on a singular agenda of revenge, but haunted by the impotence he feels in not being able to protect his brother, as well as by his actual ghost, and his final moments are testament to the intensity of what has driven him through the rest of his story.
3. Heath Ledger - The Dark Knight
Despite how exceptional Ledger's performance as The Joker for Christopher Nolan was, and how incredibly entertaining the manner in which he burrowed beneath the skin of the audience and into the special vault of the most praised villain performances in Hollywood history, it is something else that makes the performance difficult to watch.
In the revelation of Ledger's untimely, tragic death at the start of 2008, the film scored a horrible, unwanted publicity boost for the actor's performance, when it was also revealed that suspicions suggested that it had played some part in affecting Ledger's mental state and lead directly to his death. The subsequent release of his Joker Diary, and set stories detailing his commitment to method further added to the sense that the performance was in some way responsible, and it was impossible to resist that ominous sense when watching the film for the first - and indeed subsequent - viewings.
It remains difficult to reconcile the admiration for the film, and for Ledger's performance with the dreaded knowledge that without it, he might still be alive, and that is truly a haunting revelation.
2. Christian Bale - The Machinist
Inevitably, the performances that are deemed to have had the most work put into them are proclaimed the most successful when they turn out to be actually watchable. DeNiro's weight fluctuation for Raging Bull is remembered far more than the intricacies of the rest of his performance, Ledger's tragedy will eventually be more memorable than his performance, and Daniel Day Lewis' method is far more note-worthy in the long-term than the subtleties of his roles.
That approach however can reduce the impact of those performances unfairly, and the same is true of Christian Bale's harrowing performance Trevor Reznik, which is remembered now mostly for the dangerous weight loss that transformed him action star in Equilibrium to the skeletal form that is the most enduring image from that entire film. That was an astonishing commitment to the method, but the performance itself is a lot more than a visual impact thing - the commitment continues through to his portrayal of Reznor and it is both spell-binding and viscerally difficult to accept.
1. Ezra Miller - We Need To Talk About Kevin
Few early performances have ever been as profoundly affecting as Ezra Miller's haunting, alien turn as Kevin Khatchadourian in Lynne Ramsay's adaptation of Lionel Shriver's psychological drama about a fictional school massacre.
Tilda Swinton's performance as his mother was similarly affecting, but her portrayal of a mother unravelling as she attempts to look after a child who seems like evil incarnate and openly hates her is too sympathetic and engaging to be difficult to watch (which is its chief power), but as the modern day Damien, Miller is like car crash acting.
His picture of contempt is sold completely, and he drags around a looming sense of dread that something bad is going to happen, which eventually it does on an unimaginably horrible scale, as he kills first his father and young sister, and then his schoolmates with a bow and arrow. The entire film is a creeping situational horror from which there is little respite, and Miller's despicable child killer is the traditional slasher, atypically given far more focus than the likes of Freddy Krueger or Michael Myers.
Which intense film performances do you think deserve to be on this list? Share your picks below in the comments thread.