13 Movie Sequels That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Generic action flicks, superhero hiccups and the world's strongest fridge...
Sometimes a film sets up something big. A sequel? A trilogy? A whole franchise? Whilst some movies have been successful in their attempt to create one or more strong and faithful successors, not everyone can competently create a Star Wars, Godfather, or MCU. Others start off promising, even brilliant, but push their luck and keep making sequels in an attempt to get some quick cash, such as Die Hard and anything starring Jason Statham; they're great, then suddenly they're not.
Some ill-fated sequels can be good (though only marginally) in their own right, but when compared to their counterparts are nothing short of terrible, even disrespectful.
For the following list, we're going to focus on those movie sequels that didn't quite make the cut into "Well, that was a good idea" territory. Be them follow ups you may have missed (lucky you) and sequels everyone knows and universally hates, every entry on this list has let audiences down at one point or another.
The worst part of some of them is that they weren't even the last ones. Sometimes, they were merely the start of something altogether more awful and traumatising. Since every entry of this list could have been a horror sequel - Jason X, Nightmare on Elm Street 4: The Dream Master, and Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2, to name a few - we're steering clear of the genre entirely, and saving it for another day.
Some spoilers follow.
13. Every Terminator After Judgement Day
The first two Terminator films were fantastic pieces of cinema - daring, original, intense and compelling. It should have been then that Terminator: Rise of the Machines would follow suit and conclude a wonderful trilogy. Alas, this was not the case. With Linda Hamilton not wanting a part of it and Edward Furlong out of commission due to an unfortunate drug habit, the third Terminator was a disaster.
First of all, it was certified 12 in the UK, and watching it you can see why: the action is stale and predictable, the plot formulaic and boring. Secondly, the whole thing watches like one long chase interspersed with camp, cheesy dialogue. Kristanna Loken's T-X Terminator was a welcome addition to the franchise, but was not close to keeping the film afloat.
It should really, really have ended there, but six years later Terminator: Salvation hit cinema screens. It was a post-apocalyptic movie with plenty of violence (still predictable) and zero heart. Since then, the various string of follow-ups have made this once great franchise a series of dismal "successors", with each new film adding layers of complex and unnecessary backstory to a previously simple and affecting storyline.
It's clearly all about the money, as each installment has proven its salt when it comes to raking in some cash, and now the whole thing just feels like a brand of action flicks with incoherent arcs and characters who you forget as soon as the credits have finished rolling. And that really is a shame.
12. Batman And Robin
This may be an obvious pick, but it wouldn't feel like a complete "bad sequels" list without at least having a passing view at Joel Schumacher's Batman and Robin. Honestly, this film is awful; the kind of thing you watch and are marginally entertained by only because it's so bad and hysterically poor.
Schumacher and George Clooney may have apologised for this film on numerous occasions, and the late Schumacher has previously said he was only trying to make a "fun" movie, but that doesn't quite excuse the finished product.
Clooney is terribly cast as the titular hero, Chris O'Donnell is his usual level of bland, and Arnold Schwarzenegger is... well, he's something else entirely. The jokes, the delivery of his every line, his very appearance - it ends up watching like a spoof of the superhero genre rather than a respectable addition to the Batman canon.
Top it off with a Batman credit card, Bat-nipples and a basically career-ending performance from rising star Alicia Silverstone (seriously, where has she gone?), and what you're left with is a film that managed to make its already embarrassing predecessor Batman Forever look almost okay. If you ever feel like watching a film with the goal of mocking it incessantly, then this is your baby.
11. Jarhead 2: Field Of Fire
Jarhead was released in 2005 and is one of Hollywood's best modern war movies. Its unique plot, which focused on boredom and isolation rather than the battle-heavy pictures of Saving Private Ryan and We Were Soldiers, was well handled and powerful performed by its lead cast.
It should have ended there, then.
War movies rarely succeed with sequels, and this is a clear example of why. In 2014, a sequel, subtitled Field of Fire, was released direct-to-DVD and was a complete disaster in comparison to its much more powerful and well-made original. Though some of the themes were strong - including a decent look at how death effects the soldiers who witness it - it still falls short of being anywhere near what it could have been.
Perhaps if they'd only called it Field of Fire and stripped it of any association with the original classic, then it may have fared better. But as a sequel, it crashes and burns.
The worst part of all this, though, is that two more sequels (both direct-to-DVD) have been released since, and both are even worse than the second installment. Full of bad acting, effects, cliched dialogue and unrealistic depictions of life as a soldier, Jarhead 3 and 4 are abysmal attempts at raking in viewers by invoking the name of a film which really should have been left alone.
10. Speed 2: Cruise Control
Venturing now into some of the more ridiculous sequels that have somehow been produced, here is the questionable 1997 "action" Speed 2: Cruise Control. All you need to know about this film is in the title; it's cheesy (somehow more so than the original), lacks an exciting story, and is wholly unnecessary.
Whilst the original was kept up by a hyperactive villain in Dennis Hopper and a confident macho-man performance from Keanu Reeves, the sequel is forced to rely on Sandra Bullock as the leading lady, and the results are poor at best. Even Willem Dafoe, one of his generation's most daring and underrated performers, fails to hit any marks outside of "Look how evil and nuts I am."
But the acting isn't the only problem.
The dialogue is lousy, too, and the chemistry between Bullock and new on-screen love interest Jason Patric - the most uninteresting part of the entire film - is weak and the relationship unwelcome. On a whole, it's too silly, too predictable and unexciting, to be considered a worthy sequel to Speed.
And as a rule of thumb, if Keanu Reeves - star of Matrix: Reloaded and Revolutions, and The Day the Earth Stood Still - refuses to be in your film, maybe it shouldn't be made...
9. Blues Brothers 2000
The only silver lining that comes from Blues Brothers 2000 is that it's the kind of film you forget about as soon as it's over. Simply put, without John Belushi, this film sinks big time.
Sure, there are some interesting musical numbers and brief moments of effective comedy (Aretha Franklin's role is very funny and a nice nod to the first film), but the whole thing feels kind of forced and pointless. Even with John Goodman, one of Hollywood's best supporting stars, the void left by Belushi is too big to fix.
On top of this, the film suffers from a clear sense of confusion and a lack of originality. Of course, this can be said about all sequels, as their primary function is to capture the essence of what came before, but with Blues Brothers 2000 the journey feels like a bleak re-hash of the original, only much less fun and surprising.
The car chases and ridiculously fun effects were unlikely to top the original, let's be honest, but for the most part it doesn't even seem to be trying.
Overall, if you do watch this film, separate it from the first film and focus on the music, because that's the only thing worth you're time. On second thought, just buy the soundtrack.
8. S. Darko
Donnie Darko didn't need a sequel. It definitely didn't need this.
S. Darko was released in 2009, eight years after the first film. The ending of Donnie Darko is one of cinema's most unique and surprising climaxes, as Jake Gyllenhaal's titular character is crushed by a jet engine as he lays in bed and laughs. Richard Kelly, the mastermind behind the original, has gone on record to say he's never seen the sequel and never will, and that speaks volumes.
The problem with S. Darko is its attempts at re-living the oddities of the original. Samantha Darko is Donnie's little sister, played here by Daveigh Chase; the same actress who portrayed the character in the first film. Taking many themes from its predecessor - from ideas about teen life to time travel, sleep walking and bizarre hallucinations - the sequel butchers every attempt it gets to relive some of the highs of what came before.
As she tries to unravel some mysteries around town, Samantha orders someone to burn a church; there is a meteor strike complete with a subplot about radiation; and far too many ham-fisted time travel elements, all of which get cheaper and less effective as the film goes on.
It's a poor film in its own right. Compare it with the weird genius of Donnie Darko, and it's one of the worst sequels ever made. Luckily, Donnie Darko is too good to be weighed down by it, and hopefully it will be forgotten in time.
7. The Mummy: Tomb Of The Dragon Emperor
The first two films in this franchise were good; the first was actually pretty great. Full of strong visuals, action sequences, historical themes and likeable characters, The Mummy and The Mummy Returns were both fun, engaging, if slightly predictable action-horror flicks. Rachel Weisz was the best part of them both, and when she refused to return for the third film, they really should have scrapped the whole thing.
Taking the formula applied to the first two, Tomb of the Dragon Emperor takes audiences away from the legends and mystery of Ancient Egypt and drops them in China to face...well, the Dragon Emperor. And whilst it's always fun to see Jet Li in a film, he is painfully underused here and the whole thing seems like a forced attempt to make some money.
Yes, the action is still entertaining, and John Hannah is still a major, funny highlight, but the introduction of yetis, Mario Bella as Weisz's Evelyn (tough shoes to fill), and some weak CGI make this a film perhaps best left in the office.
It's a good, fun action flick in its own right, perfect for a night when you can't commit to anything on TV and think you might fall asleep on the couch, but if you want to see Brendan Fraser fighting mummies, you're best to stick with the first films.
6. Ocean's Thirteen
This is the controversial pick of the list, but hold off your anger. Whilst much of this film is pretty strong - George Clooney is okay and Steven Soderbergh's direction is as playful and well crafted as always - there is just a few things missing that keep it from being as good as Ocean's Eleven or Twelve.
Ocean's Twelve wasn't as strong as Ocean's Eleven, but it was still a strong heist caper full of some fun comedy, tightly filmed action and colourful settings. Ocean's Thirteen has all of this, but is lacking the one thing that made the first two so good: character.
Ocean's Thirteen completely fails its characters. There's no growth, no real excitement, and none of them are massively fun to watch. They're just sort of there, plot devices to move the story along without giving them any sort of engaging arc.
The absence of both Julia Roberts and Catherine Zeta-Jones, whose roles could have been detrimental in giving the rest of cast some emotional weight to work with, is a big issue, and Andy Garcia seems lazily written in to compensate for the change of antagonist, played by an underused Al Pacino.
All of this, mixed with some poor dialogue and a mostly rushed plot, makes Ocean's Thirteen an underwhelming sequel which seems like a forced attempt to relive the brilliance of the first movie. Stick to Ocean's Eleven, and you'll be much happier for it.
5. Son Of The Mask
Oh, this is bad. Really bad. The Jim Carrey original was great; a classic Carrey flick full of ridiculous humour, a brilliantly hyperactive performance, and some endlessly quotable lines ("P-a-r-t-why? Because I gotta!") It was a bad movie, but that was its charm. It knew it was bad and leaned into it, and because Jim Carrey was leading the way audiences were inclined to follow the film and laugh at its overt insanity.
Son of the Mask, meanwhile, is just bad. Not fun bad or likeable bad, but BAD.
Jamie Kennedy plays Tim Avery, who finds the titular Mask in a river and uses it to get a promotion at work and conceives a child with his wife. The child is born with the powers of the Mask, and from there it descends into deeper madness. The CGI is terrible, the dancing baby is more terrifying than humorous, and Jamie Kennedy is not a good fit for his role.
Oh, and Loki turns up.
Ultimately, though, the missing presence of Jim Carrey, some terrible effects, sloppy dialogue and painfully, cringe-worthy "humour", Son of the Mask is a film worth keeping yourself and your kids away from. Watch the original, forget this one was allowed to happen, and go on with your life.
4. Jaws: The Revenge
What is there to say about Jaws: The Revenge? The original was of course a classic. Simple, tense, brutal, scary, brilliantly acted and tightly written. Jaws 2 was strong, too, and didn't fully sully the film that came before it. Jaws 3 was a catastrophe, and could have easily filled this part of the list. However, that honour goes to Jaws: The Revenge, simply because it was the last in the series.
First of all, there's the terrible effects. Looking back, it's hard to understand how the films' special effects got worse as time went on, but the fourth Jaws is arguably the worst of the bunch. Secondly, there's the plot. Like many entries on this list, this is a film borne out of a need to force a sequel out. There's no tension in the story, the characters are thin and weakly acted, and the dialogue is uninspired and often cheesy.
Also, it takes a lot to make Michael Caine look bad, but this film pulls it off it spades.
It's a shame, too, that it came to this. The 1975 original should have been left alone, sequel-less, but its legacy ends with this bland, wholly pointless flick. Dead in the water has never been such an apt expression.
3. Home Alone 3 (And 4)
There's no Macaulay Culkin, no Joe Pesci and no Daniel Stern. Rather than looking like a sequel, this feels more like a tepid remake with no taste, no direction and no highs. Also, the fact that Home Alone 3 was written by franchise creator John Hughes makes it all the more tragic that these two "sequels" even exist.
A complete change in family and setting make both films feel detached to the originality and genuine humour of the first two films. Watching Pesci and Stern hilarious chemistry is always brilliant; the villains in both Home Alone 3 and 4 (subtitled: Taking Back the House. Sigh) are not even close to emulating the brilliance of the Wet/Sticky Bandits.
But the big miscalculation is simple to pinpoint: the two films lack the heart of the originals. The family themes are left behind for a ridiculous plot about international thieves and a missile-cloaking computer chip. It's over the top and far too obscene to be a Home Alone film audiences are used to enjoying. Instead, both films are a weak attempt to keep a money-making franchise alive; a franchise which should have ended in New York.
2. Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull
A sequel no one asked for, The Kingdom of the Crystal Skull is everyone's favourite archaeologist's fourth and weakest outing.
There's a lot to love in this film before it descends into madness, most notably Harrison Ford's welcome return to the role (the strongest part of the film) and some pretty fun action sequences. But there's also a lot wrong with it, from a rare poor performance from Cate Blanchett's villain, Ray Winstone's mostly infuriating bad-guy-good-guy routine, and a weak attempt to make Shia LaBeouf the future of the franchise.
The effects are hit and miss, the villains cliched caricatures of the previous films, and the final reveal of the space ship is an ill advised addition to the Indy canon.
And, of course, there's Indy's sudden ability to survive a nuke by hiding in a fridge. Sure, it was lined with lead and would have protected him from the radiation, but the explosion expels the fridge from the area, flying through the air at impossible speed, and Indy just climbs on out. It was a bad move, and pushes the boundary between fun and leave-your-brain-at-the-door action to an overwhelming feeling of "Oh, come on!"
Here's to hoping the upcoming fifth installment pulls this iconic series back to where it's meant to be.
1. Die Hard 4.0 (And A Good Day To Die Hard)
Die Hard is one of the best action movies ever made. Bruce Willis' John McClane is a wonderful creation, witty, strong, clever and likeable. Die Hard 2 and Die Hard with a Vengeance were also quite strong, despite both switching up the formula slightly.
The fourth outing, then, should have followed suit. Improved the series, even. This was not the case for Die Hard 4.0 and its successor, however, and the component which once made the franchise brilliant became its downfall: John McClane.
Over the years, Bruce Willis has brought out a string of terrible, unseen action flicks with no substance, character development or intensity. In many ways, this all started with the fourth Die Hard. Bad characters, poorer villains, cheesy dialogue and pointless cameos (Kevin Smith? Okay...), both films disrespect the vision of the original trilogy massively.
They watch like generic action flicks which just happen to have Bruce Willis in them. The charm and tightness of the previous films are gone, replaced instead by incredibly over the top action sequences which push McClane further and further into the realm of immortality. He's also less likeable in the last two films, his charm and wit replaced by weak, flat acting from Willis.
As with many on this list, stopping whilst they were ahead would have maybe been a wise move, and saved audiences a lot of unwanted anger and disappointment.