As with Batmanthe X-Men, the journey to casting any comic book movie leads can be a complicated one, subject to some complex considerations: does the studio go with an established star and runt he risk of audiences bringing something of their past into the role - and of course the added financial requirements of going with fame - or do they cast unknowns and hope to mould them into a star. Both Marvel and DC have taken both approaches, and in both cases have enjoyed mixed success: for Marvel, Robert Downey Junior was an inspired move, but so too was casting Tom Hiddleston as Thor, while DC's greatest casting successes have come with established stars (though not necessarily the most expected ones). It's a mine-field, and the bigger issue for casting directors is that fandoms come into any comic book movie with entrenched expectations of the character: that's why both Michael Keaton and Heath Ledger suffered such backlashes when they were cast as Batman and the Joker. And when it comes to Superman, those concerns are on a whole other level. It's not enough to simply look like Christopher Reeve - as Brandon Routh found out - and it's not enough simply to be either a good Superman or a good Clark Kent: the role requires an actor who can comprehensively convince the audience of the most ridiculous conceit in comic book history: that Superman and Clark Kent are unrecognisable from one another. Because of those considerations, the list of actors linked to Superman is a vast one, taking in some truly odd-ball suggestions, as well as some of the finest actors of their generation. So with that in mind, we're running down the most intriguing and strangest of those near-miss casting decisions in the Man Of Steel's big screen history...
15. Will Smith
Before he played Hancock in what should have been a brilliant post-superhero movie, Smith was considered (and even offered) the role of Superman. What Happened? Despite the studio's willingness to offer him the part that eventually went to Brandon Routh, Smith turned down the opportunity to play DC's most famous alien, citing the difficulties of revisionism. As The Fresh Prince himself said:
The last Superman I got offered, the script came, and I was like, There is no way Im playing Superman! Because I had already done Jim West and you cant be messing up white peoples heroes in Hollywood. You mess up white peoples heroes in Hollywood, youll never work in this town again!
Putting aside the clearly false suggestion that Wild Wild West failed because of his casting, it's not a great leap to believe that Smith might have been on to something. Or maybe he just knew that Singer's Superman train was on a quick track to apathy. Would He Have Worked? Undoubtedly. Though Smith is probably right in his assertion that "messing with" Superman's race would have caused some outrage amongst hardcore fans - and racists - he boasts the perfect blend of bravado and vulnerability that would have worked for both sides of the Superman/Clark Kent divide, and he proved in Ali and Hancock that he has the physicality to match the requirements of the role.
14. Ashton Kutcher
As well as being strongly linked to the role of Batman before Christian Bale blew Christopher Nolan out of the water with his audition for Batman Begins, the Two And A Half Men star could also have played the other most famous JLA member. What Happened? Back when Brett Ratner was attached to direct JJ Abrams' Superman: Flyby, Kutcher was apparently offered the lead role before it was ultimately offered to Josh Hartnett. Unthinkably, Kutcher turned it down, apparently citing scheduling conflicts with That 70s Show, and proving that beggars actually can be choosers. Despite giving what was called a "very, very good" audition for Ratner, Kutcher also confessed that he was put off by the Superman curse:
"I think theres a bit of a curse behind that role the things that have happened to people. Also, I think once youve played that role then youre just forever known as Superman. Its kind of hard to play other things. I have a lot of other characters Id rather play."
He might have been right to swerve the role, but the second part of his reasoning was a bit rich. Would He Have Worked? Well, he can't act, but that wasn't really a requirement for Brandon Routh in Superman Lives either, so possibly. Unfortunately for Kutcher, it's too difficult to detach him from his stoner/surfer roles in That 70s Show and Dude Where's My Car, and that could only have hurt Supes.
13. Jude Law
Blonde and British... What could possibly have gone wrong? What Happened? The Brit was apparently approached by Bret Ratner for his take on Superman: Flyby (or Batman Vs Superman, depending on who you choose to believe), but ultimately turned the role down when he realised the contract would have covered multiple Superman movies. He needn't have worried. AICN confirmed that Law had the role for Batman Vs Superman but that contract talks stumbled because the actor wanted to commit to individual sequels on a case by case basis, based upon the quality of their respective scripts. A not unreasonable request, given what had happened with the original Superman franchise. Instead of bending to the will of their chosen star, Warner Bros. unthinkably swatted away his request and instead went with Josh Hartnett, much to Harry Knowles and co's dismay. Would He Have Worked? It's hard to say - of all of the actors on this list, Jude Law is probably the most inappropriate choice simply because the very idea of him playing Superman is completely obtuse. There's nothing in his career that suggests he would ever have succeeded in the role, and he doesn't exactly look the part either. You can at least partly understand the desire to hang a tent-pole release on him, but so far, that hasn't really proved all that profitable.
12. James Caan
There was almost a (terrible) Godfather reunion that would have made Caan a fair, curly-haired Superman. What Happened? This revelation only came to light fairly recently, when Caan spoke to Howard Stern about roles that he had missed out on or rejected. In between dismissing Harrison Ford as "not an actor," based on some vague personal beef with the Han Solo star, Caan confirmed that he had been offered the lead role in the Mario Puzo scripted Superman that pre-dated Christopher Reeve's casting. And though the appeal might have been hard to resist in other circumstances, Caan also confirmed the reason he turned it down. It was too silly:
"When Clark Kent is just devastated cause she (Lois Lane) is so in love with Superman. Physically the office is setup in the paper (Daily Planet)... In order to get to Clark Kent's office you must pass through Lois Lane's office. So, there is no other way in. So, one day Clark is so pissed off (laughs) that she is in love with Superman, he says, aw screw it. And he rips his clothes off and he's got his Superman thing (costume) on under there. And he says, "Lois, come in here!" She comes in and looks at him, "That's sweet Clark, but you're no Superman." And she walks out. He looks and the mirror and says, "Maybe a little tuck here." It was all tongue-in-cheek."
Would He Have Worked? He might have in a different film, but not in the one he says was offered to him. He could also have been a great Lex Luthor.
11. Muhammad Ali
Could The World's Greatest have been a believable component of Earth's Finest? He did go on to fight Superman in comic form, but he almost got a chance to play the character on screen before that happened. What Happened? There was a period in the 1970s when Ilya and Alexander Salkind were trying to get Superman made that it looked unlikely that they'd ever be able to sort out the excruciatingly complex issue of rights with DC, which is perhaps why they went a bit mad with who should play the titular hero. For a while, the producers entertained the idea of bringing in Ali, despite his lack of experience in acting. Would He Have Worked? As Superman, unquestionably, thanks to his physique and that super-human spirit he already exuded, but it's hard to imagine The Greatest toning himself down to play Clark Kent. Occasionally, in his more reflective moments, Ali's vulnerability did shine through in interviews - particularly in times of turmoil - but there's not exactly a very grand history of sportsmen taking up acting roles that required a strong acting performance. And the lasting caveat that should always come with that suggestion is the ominous memory of what Vinnie Jones did to Juggernaut in X-Men: The Last Stand.
10. Clint Eastwood
From cowboy and hard-edged cop to inter-galactic messianic superhero in one easy step. What Happened? Just as he did with the opportunity to play James Bond in You Only Live Twice, the still working director confessed that he had turned down Superman. At the time he cited scheduling conflicts, but he has subsequently gone further to explain that he simply wasn't interested in the role:
"This was when they first started to think about making it. was like, Superman? Nah, nah, thats not for me. Not that theres anything wrong with it. Its for somebody, but not me. I always liked characters that were more grounded in reality."
And reality has been kind to Eastwood, no matter how tantalising the prospect of seeing him spread his wings (or cape) might have been. Would He Have Worked? He would have been great cast in the 1970s, even if became a lot cooler 20 or 30 years later to imagine him playing an aged Batman. In playing cowboys at the end of the genre's success, Eastwood knew exactly what it meant to play complex characters marked by internal conflict and by an inherent doubleness in their appearance. And he remains one of the finest actors in selling a character on the most minimal of outward performance; instead he has that intangible, irresistible ability to inhabit roles entirely without effort, like Philip Seymour Hoffman. So, Superman would have been in great hands. If anything would be amiss, it would be that his persona tended to lend itself to gruffer characters (hence the link to Batman), but that could have led to a more layered Superman performance.
9. Al Pacino
Another Godfather alumni linked to the role because of the Marlon Brando/Mario Puzo connection. What Happened? Back when the Salkinds were pretty much linking every actor, body builder, singer and boxer to their Superman project - probably in the hopes of whipping up a storm of anticipation for it - Pacino was one of the giant string of actors who was considered for the role. Despite having worked with Brando and original scripter Puzo on The Godfather, Pacino didn't get the gig. Thankfully. Would He Have Worked? He might have once been a fine actor - not any more sadly - but Pacino was far from the right candidate for this particular role. Superman is about as famous for his intensity as he is his pink hair and snorkel, and the idea of Pacino bringing his shouty, angry routine to Kal-El is a little offensive. It might have worked well in other roles, but sometimes actors just aren't the right fit.
8. Brendan Fraser
George Of The Jungle almost made it as JJ Abrams Superman. What Happened? When Superman: Flyby was still in production back between 2002 and 2004, Brendan Fraser was apparently asked to take the lead role, and got as far as testing for the role before Flyby collapsed in on itself entirely and Warner Bros. instead went with Superman Returns. By all means, Fraser was incredibly excited by the prospect - and why wouldn't he be? He apparently considered taking the role for a grand total of 28 minutes before jumping at the chance, but the film's production problems saw him robbed of his opportunity to really make it as a gigantic star after the success of The Mummy. And it was all because the goal-posts were apparently moved:
"It seems as if then the big monster studio machine and all the machinations behind it, all the cogs and wheels rolling, suddenly it went from an 'offer' to 'subject to a screen test' blah, blah, blah, 'subject to approval'..."
He did however confirm that the film would have been better than Superman Returns:
"In my view, and I say this with respect, it's far superior t... J.J. had a vision that was larger. It spanned galaxies. It was Lord of the Rings. I mean, it was that huge. It was like a Third World War on Earth involving different planets and universes, and brotherhoods - sibling rivalry and the collision of enormous powers. I mean, come on, it wasn't smacking you over the head with a symbolic hammer till you weren't paying attention. That's how good J.J. is."
Would He Have Worked? Had it been a comedy, perhaps. But it wasn't, so that's a big negatory. Even though casting a comedic actor for Batman worked with Michael Keaton, that was very much a blip, and casting Fraser would have been more like casting George Clooney, which didn't turn out very well.
7. Zac Efron
Remember when Justin Bieber was linked to Robin? Yeah, that. What Happened? Ok, so Efron isn't quite the disaster that Bieber would have been, but he was a little too Disney to really pull off Superman, and too apple pie good-looking to pull off Clark Kent. But somewhat unthinkably, the role was apparently Efron's to turn down ahead of Brandon Routh's casting. And the only reason he turned the role down was because of some advice from Leonardo DiCaprio. The Examiner broke the story that DiCaprio had cast doubt on whether or not Superman was right for Efron - in the process saying what everyone else around the world other than Warner Bros. was obviously thinking. Would He Have Worked? Efron is actually not a bad actor: the reductive influence of High School Musical aside, he has put in some reasonable performances (most notably in the horribly unbalanced The Paperboy), but DiCaprio was right when he said it wasn't the right role for him. He wouldn't have sold the movie, and he wouldn't have had that intangible aura required of Superman. Meanwhile, DiCaprio might actually have been right, considering what happened to Brandon Routh, and also taking into account what has happened to Efron since. Despite not really pulling up too many trees in his performances since High School Musical, Efron's stock has soared, and recent news had him linked to Star Wars VII as well as an unnamed upcoming Marvel movie project.
6. Nick Nolte
From wild man to Man Of Steel? What Happened? You might not think it now - particularly since the enduring image of Nolte these days is of that regrettable, wild-looking mug-shot - but Nolte was once classed as one of Hollywood's hot young things. As a result, before Richard Donner officially signed on to direct the movie, Nolte was pitched to the director by madcap producer Ilya Salkind based on his acting ability. Or perhaps on his physique depending on how you read Salkind's comments here:
"We found guys with fabulous physique who couldn't act, or wonderful actors who did not look remotely like Superman."
But then despite the urge to classify Nolte as one of those rejected actors, the imposing figure - then a relative unknown - was actually signed for the part of Superman when Mario Puzo came on board to script, with Brando and Gene Hackman already signed up. Unfortunately for him, Richard Donner wasn't overly impressed with Puzo's script and delayed the production for some substantial rewrites, forcing Nolte to drop out. Would He Have Worked? It would at least have been interesting. Nolte isn't exactly known for his restraint, and the idea of an angry slurring Superman is an intriguing one, even if it would have horribly tainted the original movie.
5. Dustin Hoffman
Yes, really. What Happened? Another of the Salkinds' odd-ball suggestions for the role, Hoffman seems to have been one of those actors under consideration because of the quality of his acting ability, rather than any semblance of suitability for wearing spandex and looking muscular. Thankfully someone came to their senses and apparently offered Hoffman the chance to play Lex Luthor before Gene Hackman signed on, but he passed, possibly because of the devastating realisation that he wasn't cut out to play one of Earth's mightiest defenders. Would He Have Worked? Watching All The President's Men proves that he could have been a good Clark Kent, and he certainly knows how to play vulnerability into his performances, but the idea of him wearing a muscle suit for Superman is a bit like imagining Woody Allen as Batman. Yes Christopher Reeve almost lost the role himself thanks to a lack of physicality, but he at least had a strong foundation that allowed Darth Vader actor David Prowse to help build him up to play a more believable Superman. Hoffman meanwhile had the perfect figure for Tootsie.
4. Arnold Schwarzenegger
If you think there was outrage at a British Superman, imagine what might have happened if Arnie had got his way in the late '70s and he'd been cast as Superman... What Happened? The hulking actor, who hadn't yet scored mainstream movie popularity - but who had starred in the God-awful Hercules In New York - campaigned for the role, probably based on his belief that the most impressive man in the universe should be played by a genuine Mr Universe. Unfortunately for him, Richard Donner didn't agree, and the thick-accented action star was overlooked for Christopher Reeve, who was far less of an imposing physical specimen. But then Reeve could at least speak English convincingly, which produced Ilya Salkind hinted stood in Arnie's way:
"When I met [Arnold] at the premiere of the first film, he said 'Ahhh I should've been Superman'. With that accent... not too good."
Would He Have Worked? Arnie certainly had the size for a super man, but he would have been the least convincing Clark Kent in the history of the character, and his size and accent wouldn't exactly have fit the need to hide in plain sight. As fellow almost Superman Jon Voight later confirmed, Arnie had actually offered to help him bulk up when he thought he wasn't a good physical fit for the character.
"He said: 'Will you do me a favour? Talk to a friend of mine. Do you know who Arnold Schwarzenegger is?'. So I said 'Yeah, I know who Arnold is and I think he's terrific'. "He gets Arnold on the phone and he says: 'Jon, listen! Take the part!'. I said, 'Arnold. I'm not right for it'. He said: 'Take the part. In two months I make you as big as a house!'. I said 'Arnold. I don't want to be as big as a house!'. It was a cute conversation and Arnold was very charming, and enthusiastic, and he was trying to help his buddy."
3. Burt Reynolds
Could the cockiest of '70s actors really convincingly played a mild mannered reporter? What Happened? The Smokey And The Bandit star has a history of passing on potentially great roles: he turned down Pretty Woman, Die Hard and Flashdance after all, but he has also been considered for some of the greatest geek-friendly roles in Hollywood. Not only was he up for Michael Corleone in The Godfather (with rumours that he was actually cast but fired when Marlon Brando wouldn't work with him), he was also considered for James Bond, Indiana Jones, Han Solo and Rocky, without success. You can also add Superman to that list, as Reynolds was eventually discarded as a possibility when Richard Donner decided he wanted someone less recognisable. Would He Have Worked? Shorn of his more recently trade-mark beard, the young Reynolds would have been the perfect look for Superman, thanks to a brief flirtation with a greaser quiff, but his on-screen persona would probably have been too jarring for Clark Kent, and picking an actor based on only one side of a duplicitous character is a disastrous plan. And as Richard Donner so astutely stated in later years, Reynolds would have brought a spirit that wouldn't have matched his vision of Superman:
Everyone said put Burt Reynolds in a Superman suit. Well, for a certain kind of movie where you want to camp it up, Burt Reynolds would have been wonderful.
2. Neil Diamond
"Sweeeeet Lois Lane...!" What Happened? Some suggestions are made for the "what were they smoking?!" mantra, and the near-casting of Neil Diamond as Superman sits pretty much at the top of the pile. In the early days of Superman's production, Richard Donner and the Salkinds had originally planned to bring an athlete or body-builder in for the lead role, which is why they decided that Neil Diamond, scrawny, gigantic haired singer of "Sweet Caroline" could be a good choice... Diamond supposedly worked hard for the role, despite the fact that he looked and sounded suspiciously like Neil Diamond - which in itself should have given him an indication of how badly suited he was to the role. Ilya Salkin later spoke at the Wizard World Anaheim Comic Con to admit that Diamond had seriously been under consideration:
"After meeting a lot of actors, such as Jon Voight we even met Neil Diamond, dont ask me why - I knew in my heart of hearts it had to be an unknown."
So, apparently he was turned down because he was too famous, and not because of the glaringly obvious fact that he was Neil Diamond and should never have been suggested in the first place. Would He Have Worked? No. Just no.
1. Sylvester Stallone
Yo, Lois, we did it! What Happened? Before Richard Donner decided to spend some time developing Christopher Reeve's physical appearance so he was a more impressive fit for Superman, the Salkinds had looked at sportsmen and body-builders like Arnold Schwarzenegger, and they briefly flirted with the idea of casting an actor with a more hulking phsyique in the form of Stallone, who had just scored a major success with Rocky. He wasn't yet the walking bag of muscles that he is now, some forty years later, but Stallone certainly had the size and imposing presence for Superman, which is presumably why he considered himself a strong enough candidate to audition. Stallone was another to lobby hard for the role, and he apparently got close, but he was another of the potential Superman candidates who was allegedly nixed by Marlon Brando, who was living up to his reputation by making his presence felt on the production. At least this time he was right. Would He Have Worked? In Rocky, Stallone had a disarmingly charming demeanour: he was the nice, normal guy who happened to do something brutal for his job, and there is something in that contradiction that might have worked for Superman. But then it's too difficult to imagine Superman as a backstreets tough with a drawling accent, and in the end Stallone just didn't have the regal essence to match the character's needs. Which of these potential Superman candidates do you think would been the biggest disaster? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.