15 Things You Didn't Know About When Harry Met Sally
Over thirty years on, and we still want what she's having!
There is perhaps no better film to watch during perpetual fall than When Harry Met Sally. If not for reminding us all of the simple pleasures that come with the later half of the year (dinner dates, game nights, Christmas, New Years etc.), it’s set in beautiful New York City for the lovely romance between Harry and Sally.
Over thirty years on, When Harry Met Sally is still one of the greatest romantic comedy movies of all time. It’s head and shoulders above other films of the same bracket because it’s genuinely smart, well-acted and always heart-warming.
Had the project not featured the insightful direction of Rob Reiner, the potent writing of Nora Ephron or the effortless chemistry between Billy Crystal and Meg Ryan, it simply wouldn’t have been such a huge success.
A rom-com as intricate as When Harry Met Sally was quite a challenge to get just perfect. Allegedly, screenwriter Nora Ephron spent five years writing the script, whilst casting the film’s roles was no easy task either and many scenes were extensively rehearsed. Let’s find out more about what happened behind the scenes on cinema’s greatest rom-com.
15. When The Royal Family Loved This Film
When Harry Met Sally has many celebrity fans to its name because it's such a classic. But amongst them, one surprising fan is the late great Princess Diana.
She attended the film’s 1989 royal premier in London, where she met the film’s two leads and sat next to Billy Crystal during the screening. According to Crystal, she loved the film and laughed hard at the infamous orgasm scene (more on that later), before whispering to him “so naughty”.
In fact, Princess Di adored the movie so much, she arranged to have a private screening of it for her friends at Buckingham Palace.
There’s no word on what Queen Elizabeth II thinks of When Harry Met Sally, and maybe that's for the best.
14. When Billy And Meg Were Asked The Film's Central Question
One of biggest subjects the film poses is “Can men and women just be friends?”. The film’s two lead characters were asked this question, and both of them agreed that they can.
Meg Ryan said: "Yes, men and women can just be friends. I have a lot of platonic (male) friends, and sex doesn't get in the way."
Meanwhile, Billy Crystal’s response was: "I'm a little more optimistic than Harry. But I think it is difficult. Men basically act like stray dogs in front of a supermarket. I do have platonic (women) friends, but not best, best, best friends."
13. When Katz's Deli Became Famous
Good news for fans of this rom-com, the eatery where Sally has her orgasm is a real place which you can still visit today. It’s called Katz’s Deli, located on New York’s E. Houston Street.
The table where the scene was filmed now has a plaque on it which reads “Where Harry Met Sally…hope you had what she had”. Naturally, it has become a major tourist attraction, which even hosted a fake orgasm contest on the film’s 30th anniversary.
Meg Ryan has never entered the restaurant since acting that scene.
The Youtube cooking channel ‘Binging with Babish’ has also created a pastrami recipe, based on the sandwich Sally was eating (even though she was having turkey).
12. When Rob Reiner's Mother Cameoed
The movie’s most famous line? “I’ll have what she’s having”
It has become one of the most iconic quotes in cinema history, for its comical timing and delivery. It placed at number thirty-three on the AFI’s list of “Best 100 Movie Quotes in American Film”.
The woman who delivers the line was actually Estelle Reiner, mother of director Rob Reiner. It was the only line she ever spoke on film and the only quote on the AFI’s list to be spoken by a non-professional actor.
Rob almost makes a hidden cameo as the voice of the man who says “Hey, everybody, ten seconds until new year”.
11. Why Cast And Crew Believed The Film Would Fail
Throughout production, no one expected the movie to be a hit. Despite it being a rom-com with a different feel and a unique structure, most just saw it as another 80s romance movie.
When Harry Met Sally succeeded because it was a smart movie which went against the typical cliches of its genre. There was no third person involved in the romance, or a wild misunderstanding which Harry and Sally apart, only themselves.
It was especially considered doomed for failure because the movie was cinematically released at the same time as big Summer blockbusters, such as Batman, and Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade. Colombia Pictures relied on word of mouth to market the movie from opening it to just a select number of theatres, so that audiences would generate positive feedback before it rolled out to all cinemas.
Ultimately, When Harry Met Sally grossed $92.8 million, well above its $16 million budget and was a critical success too.
10. When The Romance Stories Were Real
Many of us were left wondering if those sweet segments of elderly couples and how they met were told by real people or whether they were made up stories performed by actors.
It’s actually a combination of both. Rob Reiner gathered real life stories from old married couples and had actors re-tell them. Apparently, the story of how Nora Ephron’s parents met even made it into one of the interludes (although she never confirmed which story belonged to them).
9. When The Phone Call Scene Took Sixty Takes
One of the film’s best moments is the phone conversation which involves Sally, Harry and their friends, Marie and Jess. It was the most complex scene to produce as it required three different sets, perfect timing and word perfect speech.
The first set had Bruno Kirby and Carrie Fisher, another for Billy Crystal and the third for Meg Ryan. They were all on the same soundstage, similar to a recording studio. The phones were all connected to each other because if one of the actors made a mistake, there was no way of covering it. It took over sixty takes before they got it right and the main problem was because the phones all had to be hung up in perfect unison.
According to Rob Reiner, take fifty-four was perfect until Bruno messed up his line which came AFTER the phones hanging up, and the whole scene had to be done again.
8. Why Sally Wore Glasses
There is a significant reason why Sally wore glasses, and to be frank, it’s a little bit shallow as to why.
Nora Ephron felt there was quite a difference in terms of attractiveness between Meg Ryan and Billy Crystal, and felt that a set of glasses would have brought her down to his level.
Cheryl Schuman presented Ryan with over 200 pairs of specs, and there was only one which she wanted to wear. They were actually prescription glasses which belonged to Schuman herself, and were a very expensive La Roche pair. Several replicas were made in order to appease to Meg’s wishes.
We’re just sad that the purpose of the glasses were to make Sally look ‘uglier’.
7. When Tom Hanks Could Have Been Harry Burns
It’s not really surprising that Billy Crystal and Meg Ryan weren’t the ultimate first choices for the film’s leading romance. But it does make us wonder just who could have been the sarcastic Harry Burns or the picky Sally Albright?
For Harry, Tom Hanks was a potential but he turned it down because he thought the role was “too lightweight”. Michael Keaton was also considered, as were Bill Murray, Jeff Bridges and Harrison Ford.
In terms of Sally, 1980s teen queen Molly Ringwald was one of the main choices but producers felt she was a bit young for the role and filming would have collided with her busy schedule anyway. However, Ringwald did eventually get to play Ms Albright in the stage version, on London’s West End.
6. Why The Film Featured Pretty Orange Trees
When Harry Met Sally is renowned for its stunning setting of New York in perpetual fall. With the seasonal clothing, wintery weather and jazzy underscore, the staging is what helped to define the film as the quintessential romance to watch during autumn. One frame that has become a signature shot of the movie is the titular characters facing each other against the backdrop of some beautiful orange trees and leafy grounds.
But the picturesque cinematography had a greater purpose, other than just to look good on screen. The production team chose these features to convey the main characters’ lack of awareness. They represent their blindness to the relationship growing between them as they are to the romance of their surroundings.
This was also used for Harry’s new apartment. The windows have a view of the empire state building – it could be either the nicest view or the most isolated view in the world.
5. When Harry And Sally Improvised
Part of the tangible chemistry between Harry and Sally, and all other cast members, came from a lot of the dialogue and scenes being improvised right on set.
For example, the museum scene, where Billy ad-libbed the line “but I would be proud to partake of your pecan pie”. You can see Meg look to her side and laugh, where an unseen Rob Reiner silently prompted her to go with it.
The entire Pictionary scene was improvised too as a way of creating authenticity and more spontaneous laughs. In Harry’s new years speech, Crystal added certain lines into it which weren’t in the original script, one being – “I love that you get a little crinkle above your nose when you’re looking at me like I’m nuts”.
Additionally, the final segment on Harry and Sally’s story was entirely extemporized.
4. When The Film Had No Name
The movie’s name ‘When Harry Met Sally…’ took ages to decide on, and there were several other potential names thrown in the mix beforehand.
Between Rob Reiner, producer Andrew Scheinman and Nora Ephron, they came up with: "Just Friends," "Playing Melancholy Baby," "Boy Meets Girl," "Blue Moon," "Words of Love," "It Had To Be You," "Harry, This Is Sally," and "How They Met."
It got so desperate, Reiner created a competition between his Castle Rock Entertainment employees to get more suggestions, the prize being a full case of champagne.
Ironically, Ephron claimed that she was happy with how all the film turned out, the exception being that she detested the title.
3. Who Harry And Sally Were Based On
The character of Harry Burns was somewhat based on director Rob Reiner himself. At the time, he was deflated, derisive and neurotic but always a good guy deep down. His thoughts and feelings post-divorce and single were written into Harry’s character.
Sally Albright was also somewhat inspired by writer Nora Ephron. She was easy going, generally positive, cheerful and the type of person who was “just fine" with everything.
Also, Sally’s infamous picky eating, which you either relate to or find completely irritating? They are also based on Nora Ephron. Reiner noticed it after she ordered her food in such a particular way, and when he questioned it, her response was “I just want it the way I want it”, a line spoken by Sally in the film.
Allegedly, years after the film came out, Nora gave a very precise order on a plane journey and the stewardess asked “Have you ever seen the movie When Harry Met Sally?”.
2. When Harry And Sally Almost Spilt Up
The original ending was the complete opposite as Harry and Sally would depart ways instead of getting married. The producers wanted something with a bit of realism, as well as answering the question that men and women can just stay friends. Nora Ephron and Rob Reiner eventually changed their minds on the separation because they thought the story was leading to a happier ending.
In particular, Reiner’s cynicism on relationships changed because during production, he met the woman who would eventually become his wife.
Beforehand, Rob had such mistrust on love as he had been stuck in a decade of relationships that he couldn’t make work, and it made him wonder why Harry and Sally would ever get together. After finding true love of his own, he realized Harry and Sally were destined to be with each other.
Phew!
1. When There Was Almost No Orgasm Scene
Without a doubt, the most well known moment from When Harry Met Sally is the fake orgasm scene. It’s the pinpoint which made the romantic comedy stand out from the rest for being hilarious, unexpected and genuinely thought provoking for the male demographic.
However, it was originally not in the script as Harry and Sally were merely going to talk about orgasms. Meg Ryan came up with idea and also suggested that it should be performed in a public place. Reiner loved the idea and it was written into the story. Furthermore, it was Billy Crystal who thought of the iconic “I’ll have what she’s having” line.
Meg had to repeatedly perform the scene over and over again but it was worth it as extras, cast members, crew and audiences all loved it. More importantly, it gave the movie the legendary status it needed.
When Harry Met Sally without the orgasm scene would be like an apple pie without the strawberry ice cream on the side.