20 Idiotic Decisions Made By Star Wars Characters

An epic saga. Not quite so epic decisions.

By Dan Curtis /

Without a doubt, one of the most beloved and excellent franchises in the history of cinema, the Star Wars series is not only the driving force behind the highly popular sci-fi/fantasy genre, but it also remains one of the most relevant pop cultural artefacts in the world today - despite originally gracing our screens for the first time all the way back in 1977. Fast forward over 30 years and we're on the precipice of a brand new Star Wars trilogy, scheduled for launch on December 2015 with the yet to be titled Episode VII. We now know that several original cast members will return for the picture, alongside a hearty selection of new faces - but what we're really hoping is that most of the characters will avoid making the sorts of idiotic decisions that they managed to make in such high abundance throughout both the original and prequel trilogies. Yes, unfortunate as it is, not all of the Star Wars saga is well thought through. Aside from having the odd plot hole here and there, the main problem stems from the characters totally going against logic and deciding to do things that ultimately create bad situations for everyone involved. Join us, then, as we look back to a galaxy, far, far away, where logic is thrown out of the window and everyone has gone totally mad...

20. Amidala And Co. Elect Palpatine During The Vote Of No Confidence - The Phantom Menace

The prequel trilogy is all about setting up Palpatine as the Emperor and the first step on this path is instigated by none other than Queen Amidala, who votes for the removal of the old chancellor after a few gentle nudges from Sidious himself. This decision is particularly idiotic because Palpatine is secretly pulling all of the strings behind everything that is happening. It's in his ten-year plan! Sure, Amidala didn't actually know that he wasn't who he was saying he was, but there's no doubt that this decision remains one of the daftest that any character took. Those who also decided to elect Palpatine would no doubt be regretting their actions in later years when the Senator revealed his true colours, embrace his inner wrinkles and went full Sith Lord on them.

19. The Jedi Council Allow Obi-Wan To Train Anakin - The Phantom Menace

Although apparently the wisest of the wisest Jedi all sit in a room and decide the fate of the galaxy, these apparently clever people decide that the best way to go about training the most potentially powerful Jedi in existence is to entrust him to the care of an experienced padawan who is just been forced out of the tutelage of Liam Neeson's Qui-Gon Jinn after his master was killed by Darth Maul. Literally every single person in the room, all of whom are Jedi Grand Masters apart from Qui-Gon, would be a more logical choice to train up the person who will apparently bring balance to the force and get rid of those nasty Sith types. Their stupid decision is certainly verified when Obi-Wan makes a mess of properly training Anakin and the latter is totally warped by Darth Sidious and ends up becoming Darth Vader, killing millions of people and causing despair and fear to become prevalent across the galaxy once more. Let us not forget that the Jedi Council also initially had reservations about training Anakin; if they decided to go with their gut and stick with their decisions, most of them probably wouldn't end dead a few years on.

18. Qui-Gon's Makes His Dying Wish For Obi-Wan To Train Anakin - The Phantom Menace

Unfortunately for absolutely everyone in the galaxy, the final desire of Jedi Master Qui-Gon Jinn is one that ultimately results in the creation of one of the most evil men in the entire galaxy. Despite the Jedi Council expressing their reservations about Anakin, Qui-Gon firmly believes in the young munchkin as the next big thing in the Jedi universe and - after being struck down by Darth Maul - simply insists that Obi-Wan must train Anakin before he kicks the bucket. Bear in mind that at the time Obi-Wan is merely a padawan and is totally unqualified for training Anakin, plus the warnings of Yoda and co and Anakin's clearly suspiciously-evil haircut, it'd be much easier for everyone if Qui-Gon just wanted one last kiss or something before he died.

17. Anakin Is Assigned To Protect Padme - Attack Of The Clones

In their infinite wisdom as dudes in charge of managing the galaxy's direction, the Jedi Council sure do know how to make daft decisions. Although many of them are gifted with the handy talent of foresight, they all blatantly cannot see that assigning Anakin Skywalker to protect a young, attractive female will have consequences. They're both in their late teens at this point, with emotions running high. Although Anakin, as a sworn Jedi, has renounced love and marriage for reasons (coz attachment leads to the dark side and all that), he pretty much instantly chucks these out of the window when Padme starts making the moves. This is a particularly bad decision on the council's part as not only does it cause one of their most promising students to declare a big eff you to the teachings, but this ultimately leads to a Padme pregnancy, Anakin's crazy visions of her dying and his fall to the dark side. All you had to do was send the aptly-named Jedi-Not-Appearing-In-This-Film!

16. Jar Jar Purposely Gives Palpatine Even More Power - Attack Of The Clones

If it's not bad enough that some hapless idiot decided to give Jar Jar Binks, a bungling Gungan who is about as useful as a chocolate fire guard, actual powers in the Galaxy's council, he truly proves his ineptability by lobbying for Senator Palpatine to be given complete control over basically everything, including the newly-discovered clone army stumbled on by Obi-Wan. Not only does this allow Palpatine - who is secretly pulling the strings behind practically everything - the tools to bring about the Jedi's downfall, but it also ultimately leads to Palpatine having the means to control an entire army whenever he so chooses. He ultimately enforces this power during Revenge Of The Sith when the clone army is reprogrammed using order 66. Lesson here - never give power to a comedy character.

15. Jango Fett Leaps Carelessly Into The Arena For No Reason - Attack Of The Clones

He may have been a damn good bounty hunter, but Jango's decisions to jump headfirst into the arena and try to mess with Mace Windu is his downfall within a minute. Immediately after hitting the arena Jango is trampled on by a rampaging reek, bashing him around more than a little bit. He then decides to try to flee from Mace Windu, who promptly kills the reek before promptly beheading Jango immediately afterwards. If that's not bad enough, history almost repeats itself in the future as Jango's son, Boba Fett, decides to work closely with Jabba the Hutt's criminal organisation and tries to fight against the Jedi. This then leads to his jetpack being accidentally initiated by Han Solo and the bounty hunter's pathetic (presumed) death by slow digestion in the Sarlaac's stomach.

14. Anakin Actually Chooses To Join The Dark Side - Revenge Of The Sith

When it all comes down to it, the decision Anakin made to join the dark side is utterly ridiculous. He's been having some visionary dreams for a few months about his wife kicking the bucket, he feels slightly neglected because Obi-Wan keeps running off on errands and leaving him alone for ages (for reasons which aren't readily apparent) and strikes up a completely unbelievable friendship with Palpatine, aka Darth Sidious in disguise. When Sidious is eventually revealed to Mace Windu and he does battle with his awesomely purple lightsaber, Anakin must make a decision. Should he go against everything he's been taught for 20-odd years about being a good guy or totally forgo his teachings and embrace the dark side just for the hell of it? The latter, naturally. Anakin decides that the only way he'll save Padme is to be evil and kill everyone, including Mace Windu. He then goes on to lead an assault on the Jedi temple immediately afterwards and kills everyone, including the younglings with their sad faces. Yes, because the woman he loves is clearly going to fine with him murdering practically every Jedi in the galaxy.

13. Mace Windu Confronts Palpatine Without Bringing Serious Backup - Revenge Of The Sith

Part of the perks of living on Coruscant (apart from the spectacular views) is you always have access to some handy Jedi backup. Unfortunately Mace Windu's communicator is clearly broken when he decides to neglect to inform anyone else that he's just discovered the identity of the Sith Lord who has been causing so much havoc for the past twenty-odd years. After confronting Palpatine, now revealed by Anakin to be Darth Sidious, Mace and three chums go to confront the crazy old coot and administer justice. This decision is clearly idiotic as if you were capturing one of the most dangerous people in the galaxy we're sure that you'd make sure that you had all the backup you needed to succeed. But no - Mace and co are far too cocky and three of the Jedi are defeated within seconds by Sidious. Mace is successful in subduing the Sith Lord, but he is unfortunately betrayed by Anakin when he goes all Darth Vader. Thousands of Jedi at your disposal Mace, and all you take is three of them? Well done.

12. Anakin Attacks Padme For No Good Reason - Revenge Of The Sith

Although Darth Vader and his evil antics are much more to blame for Padme's death, her trip to Mustafar to try and convince Anakin back to the light ends up becoming the holiday from hell. Not only does Anakin completely spout a load of craziness about why he's gone evil and stuff, but he also decides to try out his brand new force power, the famous Force Choke, for the first time on his pregnant wife. This would result in Padme's heart being utterly broken, her giving birth to Luke and Leia and her simply giving up on life after Anakin joined the dark side and there's no hope of him coming back anytime soon. There's no particular reason for Anakin attacking Padme at this point other than a lot of bad writing. It's particularly idiotic because everything Anakin has done so far has been to protect Padme and his unborn child, but this is simply forgotten about because he needs to be evil and stuffs.

11. Yoda Just Gives Up On Fighting Sidious - Revenge Of The Sith

After a visually spectacular fight with loads of crazy leaping around, lightsabers twirling through the air with reckless abandon, a bunch of unnecessary snarling and a bit of council-chamber pod flingage with the power of the force, Yoda decides to just totally give up trying to fight the newly revealed Darth Sidious and decides instead to turn in early. He falls to the ground of the chamber and simply slinks away for a life of exile in a swamp. This is despite, for the most part, matching Sidious move-for-move and clearly being able to win the fight. Given Yoda's position as perhaps the wisest and most awesome of all the Jedi on the council, his sudden decision to just slink away without warning is one of the most idiotic moments in the entire franchise. A Jedi shouldn't give up - he should be right back out there, giving that evil Sith Lord what-for! This decision would lead to Sidious being left to have complete control over the galaxy and brought forth many years of despair for millions of people. Well done Yoda - when faced with an enemy, it's always best to just nick off and hope it'll all go away.

10. Anakin Ignores Obi-Wan's High Ground Advice - Revenge Of The Sith

After a ridiculously massive lightsaber fight complete with super-duper twirly moves, erupting volcanoes, droid-riding and a great deal of anger, Obi-Wan and Anakin come to a bit of a stand-off where Obi does a massive force-powered leap up to the top of a hill, leaving Anakin to look all cindered and miffed on a robot in the lava lake. At this point, Obi Wan does his best to assert his victory by proclaiming that he has the high ground. Anakin, declaring that his former master underestimates his power, then decides to leap up the hill and promptly has several of his limbs removed by Kenobi. If that's not bad enough, Anakin then falls down the hill and manages to set himself on fire by partially falling into the lava lake. This in turn leads to severe respiratory problems, being modified extensively with robotic parts and leads to Anakin becoming a slave to Palpatine's bidding for basically the next decade. If that's not a daft decision, we don't know what is.

9. Obi-Wan Chooses To Hide Baby Luke With The Skywalkers - Revenge Of The Sith

Picture the scene. Your order is completely destroyed, with only a fragment of the thousands of Jedi left alive. You've just came back from chopping up your best mate/pupil to bits and burning him in a lava lake and found out that his secret wife has kicked the bucket after giving birth to two children. Naturally, you want to hide these children as the dark evil people are still rounding up Jedi and everyone else associated with them. Leia is taken away to a secret place where she'll clearly be hard to find, but Obi-Wan, in his infinite wisdom, decides to take Luke to live with his relatives on Tatooine. Er, hello Obi-Wan? These guys have the name Skywalker! Surely that makes it incredibly easy to find Luke? Can't be a common name, surely. Somehow this does play out just like Obi-Wan wanted, but this is mainly down to having a major ludicrous plot hole in between Revenge Of The Sith and A New Hope where Darth Vader and co completely fail at finding the last of the Jedi order.

8. Obi-Wan Gets Cryptic With The Truth - A New Hope

As Luke starts to get to grips with everything that's happening around him with revelations flying from all angles, Obi-Wan decides to withhold the truth about Luke's dear old dad from him, ultimately setting up Luke for a hell of a shocker when Vader reveals he's his father in Empire. The reason he does this is all metaphorical - when he said that Darth Vader killed Luke's father, he is referring to the fact that Vader (Anakin's dark side) basically killed Anakin Skywalker (his good side). It'd be a damn sight simpler if he just told the truth from the start and probably wouldn't have led to the massive despair Luke felt when he found out straight from the wheezy mouth of Vader. It's all a bit cryptic and ultimately a bit unnecessary. But such is the way of the Jedi - if they're not speaking in riddles, they're simply not happy.

7. Tarkin Parks The Death Star, Does Nothing - A New Hope

Good old Grand Moff Tarkin. General of the Death Star, unflinching in the face of death and completely stupid when it comes to battle plans. After moving the Death Star to Yavin, where the Rebel's base is on a nearby moon, Tarkin and co then decide to completely wait for the moon to come into orbit before doing anything whatsoever. This stupid decision leads to Tarkin and co being blown up by the Rebel Forces who used Tarkin's tea break as a chance to amass a counterattack and exploit the stupidly-designed bits of the Death Star. To all the bits of Tarkin currently floating around in space - you're officially an idiot.

6. Princess Leia Leads The Empire Straight To The Rebel Base - A New Hope

Most of the plot of the first (well, technically the fourth) Star Wars film focuses on the Empire's desire to find and crush the Rebel Alliance's base into little bits using their uber-powerful Death Star. To do this, a lot of the Empire's focus in the film is on Leia Organa, that pesky rouge princess who holds the location of the Rebel Base somewhere in her hair buns. Naturally she blatantly refuses for the entirety of the film to divulge this information, only sending out a plea for help via R2-D2 which is picked up by Luke Skywalker and Ben Kenobi on the sandy shores of Tatooine. Unfortunately, after recruiting Han Solo and Chewie and staging a daring rescue of the princess, Luke and company ship the newly-rescued princess directly onto the Millennium Falcon. What happens next is truly idiotic - Leia, despite knowing that the ship has a tracker on it, then advises the group to travel immediately to Yavin, where the Rebel Alliance's base of operations is. Given that she'd just seen the awesome destructive force of the Death Star blow up her home planet a few hours previously, this was a gamble and a half. Thankfully due to a good bit of luck and cinema magic, the Rebel Alliance was able to stop the evil Empire from blowing them to smithereens. Risky though, Leia!

5. Luke Ignores Pretty Much Everything That Yoda Says - The Empire Strikes Back

Admittedly, the Yoda that Luke meets in Empire is a far cry from the one seen in the prequel trilogy. Where before he was a wizard with a saber and quite coherent (apart from the bizarre mixing up of words, naturally), the Yoda who lives in the swamplands of Dagobah is quite honestly as mad as a box of a frog and would give Batman's The Riddler a run for his money with all his cryptic nonsense. Even so, Yoda is one of the greatest Jedi masters of all time, and Luke basically decides to ignore absolutely everything Yoda tells him during his training. The main offences here by Luke are not discarding his weapons to enter the evil Force cave of doom and blatantly rushing off to rescue his friends from Cloud City, despite not being ready at all to face Vader. If only you actually listened to the crazy swamp hermit Luke - you might have actually finished your training properly, beat Vader a bit later on, not lost your hand, not had to fall down a really big hole and cling to a antenna before conveniently being rescued by the rest of your chums who basically escaped entirely without your help. Listen to Yoda, you must.

4. Jabba The Hutt Refuses To Make A Deal - Return Of The Jedi

Honestly, Jabba the Hutt hasn't done too badly for himself. Although he is, at best, a useless pile of slug gunge, he's somehow managed to become a criminal mastermind and has his own palace and slaves and stuff. Well done him. Unfortunately, his decisions show him as more of a blundering fool than a true mastermind. Not only does Jabba decide to imprison Han Solo in carbonite and keep him as a wall ornament, but he also then pinches Leia as well and has her in a gold bikini for reasons that aren't quite apparent. This then prompts the might of the Jedi to come down upon Jabba's palace, with the newly-trained Luke hot on his heels. After arriving, Luke tries to make a deal with Mr Hutt, only to have it declined twice. What follows is rather spectacular - within minutes, Jabba has lost Leia, Han Solo is unfrozen and practically everybody - including the bounty hunter Boba Fett and a giant Rancor pet - are all dead, beat up or missing limbs.

3. Palpatine Totally Neglects Old Family Issues - Return Of The Jedi

From the prequel films, we now know that the reason that Anakin Skywalker ultimately fell to the dark side of the force was his desire to keep his family (Padme) alive at all costs. He wanted the power that Palpatine promised to save his love by any means necessary, even if that meant ultimately turning his back on the Jedi. Since we know that Darth Vader's one weakness in his otherwise pretty stellar being evil record is his affinity for family, severe threats by others to his only son are probably going to strike a bit of a nerve with the Sith lord. Palpatine, at the climactic moments of Return Of The Jedi, finds this out first-hand. After extensively torturing Luke using his Force Lightning powers, Darth Vader finally breaks, his desire to help his family coming out once more as he seizes Palpatine and chucks him immediately down the nearest chute. This decision is particularly baffling because Palpatine was the one who actually gave Anakin the nudge over to the dark side in the first place and knows fine well that Vader has these issues. Perhaps he thought years of servitude after massive suffering didn't leave a person with all kinds of problems?

2. Darth Vader Chooses To Throw The Emperor Down A Shaft - Return Of The Jedi

Darth Vader doesn't have it easy. Not only does he manage to basically kill his wife, thousands of other people and get his own limbs amputated and be burned to a semi-human flesh monster state before being grafted into a suit of armour, he also decides ultimately to kill the Emperor in an extremely idiotic way. After watching Palpatine torture Luke and finally snapping, Vader seizes the enwrinkled crazy Emperor from behind, lifts him over his head and chucks him down a big shaft. In the process Vader's life-saving suit is completely damaged by Force Lightning, leading to his death in the next few minutes. The main reason this is particularly idiotic is because there are surely more practical ways of killing the Emperor? Push him, even.

1. Obi-Wan Constantly Makes Terrible Decisions - The Entire Saga

Is there any Star Wars character in history who makes such utterly baffling decisions as Kenobi? Across the span of all six films, this apparent Jedi mastermind is instrumental in causing several massive screw-ups wherever he goes and truly is the master of the whole ridiculous plot. Here's just a few of Kenobi's ridiculous decisions: Complete failure to train Anakin and lets him fall to the dark side of the force by repeatedly abandoning him Defeats Anakin by chopping off his limbs and then decides to not finish the job, giving birth to Darth Vader in his robotic form Takes Luke Skywalker and hides him on a planet with relatives who share the same name Sits in a cave for years, essentially becoming a hermit until R2-D2 - by chance - lands on the planet Talks in riddles constantly Sacrifices himself for no apparent reason while fighting Darth Vader and still insists on coming back as a Force Ghost For an elite Jedi, good old Obi-Wan really did make some truly awful choices. What other idiotic decisions did the characters in Star Wars make? Add your own in the comments section below.