20 Movies That Are Flawed Masterpieces
Works of outstanding artistry - but not quite perfect.
All things considered, is there any type of movie more inherently fascinating and endlessly interesting than that of the "flawed masterpiece"? Arguably not. Because a flawed masterpiece is a motion picture that manages to be both brilliant and questionable in equal measure; a movie that struggles in its attempts to touch greatness, and yet manages to do something else all together in the process - something more, because isn't something flawed almost always more interesting than something perfect?
And the very notion of a flawed masterpiece resonates because it is usually a result of somebody's intention to create something amazing; something new and special and unique and different. The idea that said person wasn't entirely successful, but came very close, tells a lot more about somebody and than a work of relentless, certified genius ever could.
What follows then, is a list of 20 motion pictures that one might classify as flawed masterpieces; these are works of huge and sometimes bewildering ambition; movies that shot for the stars and just missed their target; movies that - despite their noticeable flaws - there is an undeniable sense of important, relevant and brilliant about them, nonetheless. Whilst many will agree on these picks, the inclusion of others is sure to enrage a few. All things considered, though... isn't that the point of a movie made in such a vein?
20. Noah (2014)
Darren Aronofsky isn't the first person that springs to mind when you say "biblical blockbuster," but who'd have thought a $150 million dollar film based on the story of Noah could find itself made in 2014? But as one has come to expect from the likes of Aronofsky, this work is a strange, flawed and yet somehow riveting piece of cinema - a blockbuster unlike any other and the very definition of a "flawed masterpiece."
To tell his version of the Noah story, Aronofsky enlists Russell Crowe to play the man of the title, essentially an anti-hero, tasked with saving the world from sin. What is unexpected, however, is the way in which Aronofsky renders his film with a tone that feels like a cross between a young adult fantasy adaptation and a historical epic. The results are jarring, because who anticipated giant rock monsters and huge, violent battle scenes in Noah? And yet there is a strange, otherness to Noah that means that it lingers with you afterwards. There is a fine line between tosh and genius, and this movie emphasises that brilliantly.
19. The Master (2012)
An inescapable feeling washes over you as you sit down to Paul Thomas Anderson's The Master: you are watching either the greatest movie of all-time, or the worst movie ever made. And for that reason, The Master - Anderson's alleged take on Scientology - cements itself as a rather fascinating film. It's also probably better off as a flawed film, because what use is a "perfect" movie on the bizarre subject matter that Anderson explores here?
The film itself follows a young drifter (played by Joaquin Phoenix) who finds himself drawn to a mysterious man, rumoured to be based on Scientology founded L. Ron Hubbard, and played here by the late, great Phillip Seymour Hoffman. Before The Master hit cinemas, of course, it was talked up as a masterpiece - the trailer, after all, showcased Phoenix doing some phenomenal acting, whilst the movie itself - Anderson's follow-up to his actual masterpiece, There Will Be Blood - seemed pre-destined for greatness.
But The Master is a weird and difficult film - one that may or may not get better with every viewing, but is undoubtably brilliant and special at the same time.
18. Cloud Atlas (2012)
Without a doubt, Cloud Atlas is one of the most ambitious movies ever made. In fact, you'd have to be a little bit mad to even think you could pull it off, given that it plot involves dozens of characters spread across six different time frames, all of which are completely different from one another. What's more, the Wachowski siblings - those of The Matrix fame - decide to cast the same actors in multiple parts, further adding to the head-spinning nature of it all. So the movie itself is, of course, a total and utter mess... but what a crazy, wonderful, brilliant and visually stunning mess it is!
Cloud Atlas had "ill-judged" written all over it, and yet it's hard to look away because the movie is rendered with such affection for its source material (the original novel was written by David Mitchell). It's tough not to laugh at Tom Hanks wearing bad prosthetics, but it's tougher not to awe at the sheer insanity of it all. As a tribute to the imagination, to adaptations in general, to the notion of storytelling, and to the Wachowski's willingness to create something as weird and unruly as Cloud Atlas, there will surely come a time when people in the future will gaze upon at this movie and declare it to be a masterpiece. A flawed masterpiece, mind you - but a masterpiece nonetheless.
17. Margaret (2011)
The story of Margaret is arguably just as interesting as the movie itself; shot in 2005, the film didn't see the light of day until six years later, in 2011, due to on-going - and seemingly endless - arguments between the director and the studio. The director, Kenneth Lonergan, wanted a three-hour cut of the movie; the studio plainly didn't. Eventually - with the help of Martin Scorsese - a two and a half hour version of Margaret was finally unveiled. And it's this version that you can watch today.
The first thing to know about Margaret - which stars Anna Paquin as the character of the title - is that it is plainly the work of somebody with huge vision, and yet the movie constantly struggles to keep up said vision for a number of reasons. The plot is strange (almost otherworldly), as Margaret attempts to come to terms with a death she inadvertedly - and accidentally - causes at the beginning of the film.
Margaret is too long. That's its biggest flaw, by far. There is a true masterpiece hidden in a much shorter version of the film, perhaps, but the length of the movie brings it down to "flawed masterpiece" level. Still, it remains a vivid, stunning portrait of a troubled teenager attempting to gain control of her life - one that lingers with you long after the credits roll. Side note: Margaret stars both Mark Ruffalo and Matt Damon in supporting roles.
16. The Big Red One (1980)
Sam Fuller's underrated war flick, The Big Red One, received a restoration in 2004 that factored in 50 minutes of previously unseen footage. This was seen as "long overdue." Though said footage is interesting enough, it doesn't improve the movie and it clashes with the established style of the film - that is, the inherent rawness of it all. The better version - the "flawed masterpiece" version, in fact - is that of the original cut, which feels more like a Fuller movie because it is plainly rough around the edges.
It runs at 113 minutes. Starring Lee Marvin, Mark Hamill and Robert Carradine as three soldiers caught up in the blistering hellfire that is World War II, The Big Red One wears its imperfection on its sleeve; it is a big, loud and obnoxiously silly at times - to the point where one might declare it as a "B-movie masterpiece." But the way in which Fuller hones in on the soldiers, and ultimately makes the movie about each of them, marks it out as something more: a near classic.
15. Babe: Pig In The City (1998)
There's no denying the inherent weirdness of Babe: Pig in the City, which plays - for the most part - like a nightmare instead and not as a sequel to a beloved children's film. But that's all part of its downright bonkers appeal. No, it is not perfect and there are sections that do not work entirely, but through its attempts to be more than just a sequel to a film about a cute pig - in its attempt to brush shoulders with the mad and the surreal - Babe: Pig in the City transcends its own origins; it's an utterly crazed, inconsistent masterpiece.
George Miller, director of the Mad Max movies (the most recent of which, Fury Road, has just been hailed a modern action classic), took the reins for this follow-up to Babe (he penned the first instalment), and uses the film as a vehicle to do whatever the hell he likes. It's scary, funny and unexplainable in equal measure. As a result, Babe: Pig in the City stands out as one of the most curiously brilliant - and nutty - kids' films ever made.
14. Gangs Of New York (2002)
Gangs of New York is all over the place. Though that effect was somewhat intentional, it does mean that the picture feels consistently chaotic; rough around the edges. It's a mess, and yet - despite it shortcomings - one can't help but feel it is a frustrated masterpiece. Which makes sense, given it was chopped in half by Harvey Weinstein from its original length of 3 plus hours to a mere 168 minutes (Scorsese was very unhappy with that).
Daniel Day-Lewis gives the film its fire, as the mob leader battling it out in the Big Apple in 1846, where machetes and knives were a man's best friend. Leonardo DiCaprio, Scorsese's 21st century Robert De Niro, seems oddly out of place here - as does Cameron Diaz, who feels uncertain of her own casting. But Day-Lewis is the reason that the film comes alive; his "Bill the Butcher" Cutting ranks as of the great screen performances. There is as a Scorsese masterpiece here, just trying to break free. There are flaws (in casting, in pacing and in execution), but in the end they make the movie what it is.
13. Sunshine (2007)
Written by Alex Garland of recent Ex Machina fame, and directed by Danny Boyle, Sunshine has all the makings of a sci-fi masterpiece. At least, it does for the first two thirds of the movie, until - all of a sudden, out of nowhere - it goes completely off the rails, switching from intelligent sci-fi thriller to terrible slasher movie in a few mere seconds. It's a jarring turn of events, and one that has plagued fans of the film ever since its first release.
But look past that rather ill-judged third act (which is what most people tend to remember) and Sunshine certainly feels like something akin to a flawed masterpiece; everything from its high-concept visuals and scientific approach to the central premise ("What would happen if the sun started to die?") feels weighty and ambitious. It's a dense and complicated film.
Then there are the performances - subtle, realistic - which, coupled with the production design (2001: A Space Odyssey, eat your heart out), renders Boyle's film as a modern sci-fi classic. Despite its failings, Sunshine shoots for the stars - and mostly hits.
12. Interstellar (2014)
There is the sense of overreaching to be associated with Christopher Nolan's sci-fi epic, Interstellar, which orbits around a plot that sees a team of astronauts heading deep into the far reaches of space in an attempt to re-colonise the population of Earth elsewhere. Much of the film's marketing campaign focused on Nolan's intent to keep the blockbuster grounded in scientific fact - something that continually eludes him across the span of the picture.
And yet Interstellar, for all its very noticeable flaws, could very well be Christopher Nolan's ultimate masterpiece. It is, after all, one of very few Nolan movies which attempts to embrace the heart as well as the mind in what feels like equal terms, thus imbuing the film with an sincere and personal tone that plays to its favour.
If the attempt to gel head and heart clashes somewhat, Interstellar makes up for it in sheer scale and ambition: the visual effects are mind-blowing, whilst the size of the movie is literally out of this world... and then some. A movie like Interstellar - which fumbles and misses its target fairly frequently - would have been great without its flaws, of course, but it's actually a far more compelling - and therefore rewatchable - movie in spite of them.