20 Terrible Razzie Mistakes - Corrected

Who says the Oscars have the monopoly on terrible decisions?

By Robin Baxter /

The 2020 Razzie winners have now been announced (following the ceremony's cancellation for obvious reasons) and aside from one huge mistake (more on that shortly), it's been a good ceremony this year. It was certainly wonderful to see Cats clean up.

Advertisement

The reason why this ceremony has been so satisfying is that it's an unusually fair line-up for the Razzies, which is a fun award show to follow but does tend to make a lot of mistakes. The Razzies often nominate cool-to-hate blockbusters instead of the actual worst movies of a year, while valid questions have been raised about the credibility of the voting process too.

On the whole, as entertaining as the Razzies are, they arguably get things wrong just as much as the Oscars do. With the Razzies having recently turned forty it's a great time to look back on some of the most head-bangingly stupid Razzie nominations to date. If the Razzies really want to become a credible thing, they need to avoid mistakes like these in the future...

20. Gods Of Egypt - Worst Picture, Worst Director, Worst Screen Combo And Worst Screenplay

Gods of Egypt isn't particularly great, but if you watch it in the right mood you'll likely find it an amusing B-Movie that's surprisingly charming at times, meaning it was definitely not one of the worst films of the year. Remember, we are talking about 2016, a year containing films like X-Men: Apocalypse, High Rise, Bad Neighbours 2, Now You See Me 2, Inferno, Suicide Squad, London has Fallen, Office Christmas Party, Nine Lives and Fifty Shades of Black.

Advertisement

Generally, the 2017 Razzies were a complete shambles from top to bottom; it was 'rewarding' the films of 2016, which was a shockingly bad year for films, and somehow it completely missed the mark.

Gods of Egypt's nomination for Worst Actor (Gerard Butler) was OK since that was shared with the hideous London has Fallen, but it wasn't one of the poorest, worst-directed or worst-written movies of the year.

Corrected:

This one's easy. The worst film of 2016 was the execrable, 0/10 spoof movie Fifty Shades of Black, and that should've taken all four of these nominations. For some reason, it only got two nominations at the actual ceremony: Worst Supporting Actress (Jane Seymour) and Worst Prequel, Remake, Rip-Off or Sequel.

19. Batman Vs. Superman: Dawn Of Justice - Worst Director, Worst Actor (Twice) And Worst Screen Combo

A terrible movie it may be, but Batman Vs. Superman: Dawn of Justice was picked on excessively.

Advertisement

The nominations for Worst Picture, Worst Supporting Actor (for Jesse Eisenberg's embarassing performance as Lex Luthor), Worst Prequel, Remake, Rip-Off or Sequel and Worst Screenplay were fine, but Worst Director, Worst Screen Combo and two Worst Actor nominations? Really?

That was just targeting an unpopular film, not 'rewarding' the worst of the year. Ben Affleck is great and Henry Cavill is decent as Batman and Superman respectively, while Zack Snyder directed with a good visual style.

Corrected:

Nine Lives, the Kevin Spacey talking-cat film, was a dreadful movie and that should've taken Worst Director; there should've been room for it in Worst Picture too, although Batman Vs. Superman deserved to keep its place in that category.

One of the Worst Actor nods should've gone to Marlon Wayans in Fifty Shades of Black and the other should've gone to the South African rapper Ninja (a member of Die Antwoord, a hip hop band), who gave a horrendously dire performance as himself in the sci-fi misfire Chappie. The Worst Screen Combo nomination should also have gone to Chappie for Ninja and his co-star/band-mate Yolandi.

In terms of the awards Dawn of Justice won, Worst Supporting Actor was fine, but it wasn't the worst of the year in Worst Screen Combo, Worst Rip-Off or Worst Screenplay. Those awards should've gone to Collateral Beauty, Fifty Shades of Black and Suicide Squad respectively.

18. Waterworld - Worst Picture And Worst Director

Waterworld isn't the stinker you've heard it is. It's not that great, but it's got a fair amount of imagination and entertainment value, so this felt like another example of the Razzies picking on what was popular to trash. There was a lot of toxic buzz around the time of Waterworld and this is most likely what led to this being a major Razzie contender.

Advertisement

Worst Actor (Kevin Costner) and the film's win for Worst Supporting Actor (Dennis Hopper) feel more acceptable since the acting in this movie is far from great and Costner is surprisingly dull and po-faced considering he's playing a mutant fish-man who's introduced drinking his own urine, but Worst Picture and Worst Director (Kevin Reynolds) were a step too far.

Corrected:

These nods should've gone to the train-wreck that is Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers, which is still the worst Halloween film ever made (yes, it's even worse than 2002's Halloween: Resurrection), but it got completely ignored and that's probably because it was more obscure. Just like the Oscars, the Razzies always go for whatever's high-profile and this always leads to unfair nominations.

17. That's My Boy - Worst Picture, Worst Actor, Worst Screen Couple, Worst Director, Worst Screenplay And Worst Screen Ensemble

Is That's My Boy really so awful? It's not very funny and doesn't make much of an impact, but it's oddly endearing as a story of a father re-connecting with his son and while it is offensive, it's no worse than many other modern comedies and people over-reacted to it a Lot.

Advertisement

Adam Sandler's performance is often annoying but it was hardly worthy of a nomination; ditto for Worst Screen Couple and Worst Screen Ensemble. The directing and writing weren't that awful either.

Overall, is this one of 2012's worst? Chernobyl Diaries, Snow White and the Huntsman, Safe House, Man on a Ledge, Dark Shadows, The Pact, Wrath of the Titans, Paranormal Activity 4 and The Devil Inside were all 2012 films, so that's a big "No".

Corrected:

2012's worst film was The Devil Inside, a painfully unscary and atrociously written horror film with one of the worst endings of all time, so that deserved to take the Worst Picture (frankly, a win would've been justified), Worst Director and Worst Screenplay nominations.

Sam Worthington deserved a Worst Actor nod for both Wrath of the Titans and Man on a Ledge, while Dark Shadows deserved Worst Screen Couple (Johnny Depp and Bella Heathcote) and Worst Screen Ensemble (for all the talented actors it wasted).

The two awards that it won, Worst Actor for Sandler and Worst Screenplay, should've been awarded to Breaking Dawn Part II (with Robert Pattinson taking the former award).

16. Independence Day: Resurgence - Worst Picture, Worst Director, Worst Supporting Actress, Worst Sequel And Worst Screenplay

Hello again to the 2017 ceremony.

Advertisement

Independence Day: Resurgence is undeniably weak, but it's OK as opposed to bad and is often a perfectly entertaining action film, while Jeff Goldblum is great in it, so it being so widely nominated was another bit of cynical pandering on the Razzies' part.

It wasn't one of the year's worst films and none of the other nominations were really justified either. In particular, Sela Ward's Razzie nomination for her straightforward, perfectly OK performance as President Elizabeth Lanford was beyond a joke. The only Razzie-worthy thing here was Liam Hemsworth's bland lead performance, yet he wasn't even nominated.

Corrected:

In the context of these five nominations, Resurgence should've been completely shut out.

The dreadful, yet heavily under-nominated Suicide Squad definitely should've been nominated for Worst Picture, Worst Director, Worst Prequel, Remake, Rip-Off or Sequel and especially Worst Supporting Actress for Cara Delevinge's ghastly performance as the film's villain, Enchantress. Unfortunately, it was only been nominated for Worst Supporting Actor (Jared Leto, which was hardly a Razzie-worthy performance) and Worst Screenplay.

As for Worst Screenplay, the shockingly awful and morally repugnant slice of racist garbage that was London has Fallen should've replaced Resurgence.

15. Battleship - Worst Picture, Worst Director, Worst Supporting Actor, Worst Screenplay And Worst Screen Ensemble

Why was Battleship so critically mauled?

Advertisement

Was it because it was based on a board game? That's the only logical explanation since this was a perfectly watchable blockbuster that was forgettable as opposed to bad, so this should Not have dominated the 2013 ceremony in the manner that it did.

Out of the seven nominations this received, the two Worst Supporting Actress nominations for Rihanna (who won) and Brooklyn Decker were fine, but Worst Picture, Worst Director, Worst Screenplay, Worst Screen Ensemble and Worst Supporting Actor (Liam Neeson; this was shared with his performance Wrath of the Titans) were wildly excessive.

Corrected:

Much like The Devil Inside, 2012's other found-footage horror turkey Paranormal Activity 4 was one of the year's worst films and should've been nominated for Worst Picture and Worst Director.

Meanwhile, Ben Kingsley deserved a nomination for his terrible villainous performance in The Dictator (if only because of how ridiculous it was that such a brilliant actor would sign up for such a silly part that didn't deserve him), Dark Shadows' tone-deaf script deserved a nomination for Worst Screenplay and Wrath of the Titans (which thankfully did get some attention from the Razzies, but not enough) would've been a better pick for Worst Screen Ensemble.

14. Fifty Shades Of Grey - Worst Director And Worst Actress

Just because a film is one of the worst of that year, that doesn't always mean it should be nominated in every category at the Razzies.

Advertisement

As awful as Fifty Shades of Grey is, Dakota Johnson's performance is actually rather good and she's certainly proved herself in numerous films since, so her being nominated and subsequently winning was completely unfair, especially since far worse performances like Gwyneth Paltrow in Mortdecai were also nominated. Similarly, Sam Taylor-Johnson did a solid job with the directing and both of them kept this at the two-star level when it could easily have been a one-star movie.

Corrected:

Pixels, an even worse movie than this, was one of the big nominees at that ceremony and that should've taken the Worst Director slot for Chris Columbus' thoroughly weak directing of it. As for Worst Actress, Yolandi's dreadful performance in Chappie should've not only been nominated but frankly won.

13. Robin Hood - Worst Picture, Worst Supporting Actor And Worst Rip-Off

The most recent Robin Hood film isn't particularly great, but it was hardly awful. It was watchable and fun enough and Taron Egerton, Jamie Foxx and Ben Mendelsohn gave very entertaining performances in it. Speaking of that, Jamie Foxx being nominated for Worst Supporting Actor was ridiculous as he actually did a good job in the film.

Advertisement

Additionally, since 2018 gave us films like Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom, The Girl in the Spider's Web, Ocean's 8, Peter Rabbit, Hold the Dark, I Feel Pretty, The Nun,, Skyscraper, Solo: A Star Wars Story, Welcome to Marwen, Truth or Dare, The Happytime Murders (which thankfully was actually given several nominations) and Slender Man, this wasn't one of 2018's biggest duds.

Corrected:

Slender Man was not only the worst film of 2018, but one of the worst films of the decade, so that below-the-bottom-of-the-barrel monstrosity should've taken a place in the Worst Picture line-up.

For the other two, Henry Cavill's terrible performance (complete with a laughably bad American accent) in the otherwise great Mission: Impossible - Fallout should've replaced Jamie Foxx and Peter Rabbit deserved a nod for Worst Rip-Off for being such a bad, insulting adaptation of Beatrix Potter's delightful work.

12. Rambo: Last Blood - Worst Picture, Worst Director, Worst Actor, Worst Supporting Actress, Worst Sequel And Worst Screenplay

This year's Razzie nominations were actually rather good, but this perfectly OK action flick getting eight nomination was a big mistake. In particular, Sylvester Stallone's excellent lead performance being nominated was awful.

Advertisement

Rambo: Last Blood wasn't among 2019's worst. Remember, 2019 contained Midway, X-Men: Dark Phoenix, The Lion King, Godzilla: King of the Monsters, Men in Black: International, Countdown and Serenity, as well as 2020's other four Worst Picture nominees (Cats, The Fanatic, The Haunting of Sharon Tate and Madea's Family Funeral).

Corrected:

This was nominated for Worst Picture, Worst Director, Worst Actor, Worst Screenplay, Worst Supporting Actress (Fenessa Pineda, who barely even appears), Worst Sequel, Worst Screen Combo (Sylvester Stallone and his Impotent Rage) and Worst Reckless Disregard for Human Life and Public Property.

Ignoring the latter joke category, let's throw out all these nominations shall we?

Firstly, the appalling Serenity deserved nods for Worst Picture, Worst Screenplay and Worst Screen Combo (Matthew McConaughey and a tuna called "Justice").

For Worst Director and Worst Supporting Actress, the dreadful The Haunting of Sharon Tate deserved both of those nominations (for any of the terrible supporting actresses) and Midway deserved the Worst Actor nod (Ed Skrein).

Finally, Worst Sequel... should've gone The Lion King since it copied and pasted an amazing, beloved film and then sucked out all its joy and heart.

To make matters worse, Last Blood eventually won Worst Sequel over the deserving winner X-Men: Dark Phoenix. Just ridiculous.

11. Poseidon - Worst Remake

This loose remake of The Poseidon Adventure, the classic disaster film from 1972, is in no way worthy of a Razzie nomination.

Advertisement

Admittedly, the dialogue is awful (Kurt Russell: "It's a pressure valve. It won't open unless there's tremendous pressure!") and so is the character development, but brilliant special effects, strong directing and some brutally suspenseful set-pieces more than keep it afloat.

It's a three-star film and it bears little resemblance to the original film anyhow aside from the central concept, so this was a waste of a slot.

Corrected:

This was released in 2006. This was the same year as the absolutely ghastly remake of Black Christmas, another 1970s genre classic, which was one of the worst horror remakes of all time and makes the fairly weak 2019 Black Christmas remake look like Citizen Kane. How on earth was Poseidon nominated over that?

10. Rambo: First Blood Part II - Worst Picture, Worst Director, Worst Actor And Worst Screenplay

The Razzies need to understand that their vendetta against Sylvester Stallone and his movies is beyond tiresome at this point. He's made plenty of rubbish, but he is a good actor at his best and he doesn't deserve to be the most-nominated actor in Razzie history.

Advertisement

This action sequel was the big winner of the 1986 ceremony, including for Worst Picture, Worst Actor (for Stallone), Worst Screenplay and Worst Original Song and this was completely unfair. The film is a perfectly OK action movie, albeit a huge step down from the excellence of 1982's First Blood, and Stallone's performance in it is reasonably strong as well.

Worst Original Song, Worst Supporting Actress and Worst New Star (for Julia Nickson's performance, which is painfully bad in fairness) were fine, but Worst Picture, Worst Director, Worst Screenplay and Worst Actor were unjustified.

Corrected:

There was a certain other action sequel that could've replaced First Blood Part II in all four of these categories: A View to a Kill, the sloppy, abysmally written and goofy 14th James Bond film and the worst of the franchise's 24 films.

In particular, Roger Moore, who was far too old for Bond at this point, deserved a Worst Actor nod far more than Stallone did. Unfortunately, the only nomination it got was Worst Actress for Tanya Roberts, which was well-deserved, but it would've been nice to see more.

9. All The Acting Nominations For Michael Moore's Documentaries

At the 2005 and 2019 ceremonies, the Razzies gave real-life politicians, who appeared in documentaries by Michael Moore (Fahrenheit 9/11 and Fahrenheit 11/9) and Dinesh D'Souza (Death of a Nation), Razzie nominations and awards, which was just very irritating and unfunny. This ceremony is supposed to be about film quality, not how skilled or unskilled politicians are.

Advertisement

Fahrenheit 9/11 won four awards: Worst Actor (George W. Bush), Worst Supporting Actor (Donald Rumsfield), Worst Supporting Actress (Britney Spears, even though she's appears for less than 20 seconds) and Worst Screen Combo (George Bush and either Condoleeza Rice or his pet goat. Rice was also nominated for Worst Supporting Actress.

Fahrenheit 11/9 won Worst Supporting Actress (Kellyanne Conway) and Melania Trump was nominated, while Fahrenheit 11/9 and Death of a Nation won two shared awards: Worst Actor (Donald Trump) and Worst Screen Combo (Donald Trump and his self-perpetuating pettiness).

Corrected:

For 2005, Worst Actor and Worst Supporting Actor could've gone to Cary Elwes and Leigh Whannel for the otherwise strong Saw, Worst Screen Couple could've gone to Tim Allen and Jamie Lee Curtis for the terrible Christmas with the Kranks and the Worst Supporting Actress nods could've been given to any of the terrible supporting performances in Mindhunters.

For 2019, James Corden should've been nominated for Worst Actor for Peter Rabbit, Rhonda Rousey (for Mile 22) and any of the Slender Man co-leads should've been nominated for Worst Supporting Actress and Welcome to Marwen should've been nominated for Worst Screen Combo (any two dolls).

8. The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Parts I And II - Worst Director (In Both Ceremonies)

Don't worry, this isn't a defence of Twilight. Breaking Dawn Part I is one of the worst big-budget films of the 2010s and Breaking Dawn Part II is also terrible, although it's the second-best of the franchise after the original film (which was, as hard as it is to remember now, perfectly OK), so they deserved most of the Razzie nods (Eight for Part I and eleven for Part II, as well as seven wins for the latter), but there was one major anomaly: Bill Condon's nomination for Worst Director.

Advertisement

Bill Condon was by far the best director the franchise ever had and he actually did a good job despite how awful the material was, so this was very unfair. Worse still, he won in 2013 despite being the least deserving out of the five nominees. While the Razzies were doing what the Oscars did with the Lord of the Rings films and heaping awards on the final instalment, that doesn't mean they needed to give it everything.

Corrected:

For the 2012 ceremony, Joel Schumacher should've been nominated for Trespass and for the 2013 ceremony, Johnathan Liebesman should've been nominated for Wrath of the Titans. Bill Condon deserved so much better than this.

7. Hostel Part II - Worst Sequel And Worst Excuse For A Horror Movie

While not exactly the most pleasant of films, Hostel Part II is a surprisingly strong horror sequel that improves on its terrible predecessor in almost every way. As such, even if it is an acquired taste, it being nominated for Worst Prequel or Sequel and Worst Excuse for a Horror Movie (a special category that only featured in the 2008 ceremony) was ludicrously unfair.

Advertisement

Corrected:

There were some far more deserving choices this year, but the ones which really leap to mind are Spider-Man 3 for Worst Prequel or Sequel and Saw IV for Worst Excuse for a Horror Movie.

Spider-Man 3 was a colossal mess and is still one of the most-loathed sequels of all time; it also contains the Emo Peter Parker scene and that alone makes it worthy of a nod.

Saw IV, meanwhile, was a far worse horror sequel and if the Razzies wanted to nominate a Torture-Porn horror sequel, than Saw IV would've been a much better choice.

6. The Meg - Worst Rip-Off

Is this a joke?

Advertisement

The Meg is an absolute blast and a heart-warming, beautifully judged B-Movie that is legitimately one of the greatest shark movies ever made. This was in no way, shape or form worthy of this nomination and The Meg is a stand-alone, original film anyhow so how is it a rip-off?

The nomination described this as a rip-off of Jaws... but, the last time I looked, Jaws didn't involve Jason Statham fighting a giant CGI prehistoric shark.

Corrected:

There are several things that could've been chosen, such as Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom, Ocean's 8, The Nun and Solo: A Star Wars Story, but the one which truly deserved a nomination was the flaming train-wreck that was Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald.

Since it cast a damper over an otherwise strong franchise and is one of the worst-written blockbusters of recent times, it's mystifying that it wasn't nominated instead of this delightful monster movie.

5. The Blair Witch Project - Worst Picture And Worst Actress

Yep, this actually happened.

Advertisement

The Blair Witch Project isn't that good and is ageing about as badly as any movie has ever aged, but it remains a three-star film and was nowhere near one of the worst films of 1999. Worse still, Heather Donahue's performance is great and her even being nominated, let alone winning, was a complete embarrassment.

Corrected:

One of the very worst films of 1999 was The Rage: Carrie 2, an appallingly bad sequel to a horror classic that somehow got completely ignored by the Razzies. That should've been nominated for Worst Picture and many other things too.

As for Worst Actress, Saffron Burrows' terrible lead performance in the cult classic Deep Blue Sea deserved some 'recognition' here. Frankly, anyone but Heather Donahue.

4. The Lone Ranger - Worst Picture, Worst Director, Worst Actor, Worst Rip-Off And Worst Screenplay

The Lone Ranger being one of the most nominated films at the 2014 ceremony is one of the biggest injustices in Razzie history.

Advertisement

The Lone Ranger was evidently attacked because of the budget and the troubled production, not because of the film, which was a good, thoroughly enjoyable (although overlong) blockbuster with some amazing set-pieces. It also got mixed-to-positive reviews in the UK, which says it all really.

All five of these nominations were ridiculous, especially for Gore Verbinski's visually strong directing, and all needed to go.

Corrected:

Four of these nominations should've gone to A Good Day to Die Hard, one of the worst, most boring and most poorly-done action films of the last 20 years, as well as one of the worst sequels ever made. It was criminally 'snubbed' by the Razzies and should've taken nods for Worst Picture, Worst Director, Worst Screenplay and Worst Prequel, Remake, Rip-Off or Sequel.

To make matters worse, The Lone Ranger won that latter award over Grown Ups 2, which is arguably one of the worst movies ever made and, shockingly, didn't win a single award at this ceremony despite being the most nominated film of that year.

For Worst Actor, since Bruce Willis' performance in A Good Day to Die Hard was fine, Jesse Eisenberg deserved a nod instead for his awful, insufferably annoying performance in Now You See Me.

3. Mother - Worst Director, Worst Actress And Worst Supporting Actor

Suburbicon. The Snowman. The Book of Henry. Downsizing. Alien: Covenant. Naked. Geostorm. Rings. Flatliners. 9/11. Those are just a few of the terrible 2017 movies that could've been nominated instead of Mother. What the hell were they thinking?

Advertisement

Mother is a flawed but fascinating art-house film with amazing directing from Darren Aronofsky and a great central Jennifer Lawrence performance, so those are two of the worst Razzie nominations ever. Javier Bardem's performance, meanwhile, isn't that great but was still nowhere near a bottom-five nominee.

Corrected:

While The Book of Henry was arguably the worst film of that year, the performances were fine and the directing wasn't bottom-five level either, so these three nominations should've gone to 9/11, AKA the Charlie Sheen 9/11 movie, which is one of the most offensive and incompetent films of recent times.

For 9/11, Martin Guigui should've been nominated for Worst Director, Gina Gershon should've been nominated for Worst Actor and the Worst Supporting Actor nod could've gone to either Wood Harris or Luis Guzman.

2. Batman Returns - Worst Supporting Actor

This is another credibility-defying blunder from the Razzies' early days. Batman Returns itself might be a bit of an acquired taste but Danny DeVito's great performance as the Penguin is an absolute masterwork of villainous acting and him being nominated for a Razzie is simply impossible to understand.

Advertisement

Corrected:

What makes this nomination even more mysterious is that there was a far more obvious and far more deserving nominee right in plain sight: Keanu Reeves' widely-maligned turn as Johnathan Harker in Bram Stoker's Dracula, a performance which also gave us one of the worst fake British accents ever committed to film.

Had he been nominated, he could easily have won and it'd have been hard to complain if he had.

1. The Shining And The Thing's Nominations For Worst Director And Worst Musical Score Respectively

Here they are: the two Worst Razzie nominations of all time. These nominations came from the 1981 and 1983 ceremonies (the first and third ones) respectively, so this was when the Razzies were in their infancy; with these two mistakes they nearly destroyed any semblance of credibility before they properly started.

Advertisement

Ennio Moriconne's score for The Thing is a brilliant work of film music and one of the finest horror movie soundtracks ever crafted. There will have been tens, if not hundreds of other musical scores in 1982 that lacked this soundtrack's artistry and skill, so what the hell were they thinking?

Meanwhile, The Shining's nomination for Worst Director is so unjust and so appalling it could be enough to make one hate the Razzies for life. It's bad enough that Stanley Kubrick, perhaps the most ingenious artist in the history of the film medium, is a Razzie nominee but what makes it worse is that The Shining is one of his finest feats of directing.

The Shining is the most visually stunning horror film ever and Kubrick's flawless use of cinematic space, mise-en-scene and tracking shots show an unparalleled cinematic master at the top of his game. Nothing happens by accident and every shot is brilliant. It's a film so meticulously constructed there was a whole documentary analysing it.

Corrected:

Literally anything else would've been preferable to either of these. Even now, around forty years later, it's arguable that the Razzies have never lived this down.

Advertisement