20 Things You Didn't Know About Shutter Island
Revisiting Scorsese's Hitchcock homage a decade later.
Oh, how time flies. Martin Scorsese's Shutter Island turns 10 years old this month, and while certainly not among the most beloved or acclaimed offerings from either the filmmaker or his leading man Leonardo DiCaprio, it's nevertheless a distinctive slice of visceral noir that's challenging yet accessible.
As Scorsese's first film after finally winning the Best Director Oscar for The Departed, it's fitting that he opted to deliver surely the most frothy and unapologetic genre film offering of his entire career, albeit one shot through with his usual expert directorial heft.
Solidly received by critics and a box office hit, Shutter Island has stuck around in the public consciousness far longer than many blockbusters of its era - looking at you, Avatar - largely thanks to a deliciously ambiguous ending which continues to be debated to this day.
As with just about any Scorsese movie, the production itself is almost as interesting as the film we ended up with, and so, here's 20 stories, anecdotes, and tidbits that surely passed you by...
20. It's The Only Scorsese/DiCaprio Movie To Receive No Oscar Nominations
Shutter Island was the fourth of five collaborations between Martin Scorsese and Leonardo DiCaprio to date, and remains the only one to garner not a single Academy Award nomination.
Though those four other movies racked up more than 30 Oscar nominations between them - including Best Picture for all, with an actual win for The Departed - Shutter Island's pulpier tone caused it to be roundly ignored by the Academy.
The lack of attention to its technical plaudits proves especially surprising - particularly Robert Richardson's ravishing cinematography - though this is largely accepted to be a result of Paramount pushing the film's release to February 2010, causing it to largely be off the Academy's radar by year's end.
Though hardly one of Scorsese's best movies, it certainly deserved at least a couple of below-the-line nods.
19. The Title Is An Anagram Of "Truth And Lies" & "Truth/Denials"
As if Shutter Island isn't mind-blowing enough, there's a cute secret hidden within the movie's title itself.
As it turns out, "Shutter Island" is an anagram of both "truth and lies," and "truth/denials," which considering that the story's narrative centers around a traumatised man residing within a fabricated existence in order to deny his own truth, couldn't be more apt.
The anagram shenanigans fit even better when you consider that it's revealed later in the movie that the name of protagonist Edward Daniels (DiCaprio) is an anagram of his real identity, Andrew Laeddis, while Rachel Solando is also an anagram of Daniels' dead wife Dolores Chanal (Michelle Williams). Clever.
18. David Fincher & Wolfgang Petersen Were Originally Considered To Direct
Before Scorsese came aboard, David Fincher was originally considered to direct with Brad Pitt in the lead role, and given the filmmaker's aptitude for spinning pulp into fine-tuned genre mastery, it's easy to imagine how brilliantly he could've adapted the source material.
Long before Fincher, however, Paramount also considered giving Dennis Lehane's novel a more action-orientated treatment, and so toyed with handing the directing gig to Wolfgang Petersen (Das Boot, Air Force One), a well-versed filmmaker in the action genre.
Fincher was certainly a more inspired pick than Petersen, who clearly would've been making a very different movie, but it's tough to feel bad about the esteemed director we ended up with either way.
17. Mark Ruffalo Won His Role After Writing Scorsese A Gushing Letter
Mark Ruffalo was still a year away from being cast as Bruce Banner/The Hulk in the Marvel Cinematic Universe when he started shooting Shutter Island, and at that time had carved out a respectable niche for himself as a reliable character actor.
Basically, he wasn't quite the brand name we know him as today, and so Ruffalo had to fight to win the role of Teddy's new partner Chuck Aule, to the extent of writing a gushing letter to Scorsese detailing how badly he wanted to work with him.
With Scorsese apparently not averse to flattery, it worked. Ruffalo won the gig, presumably because Scorsese was also acutely aware of how terrifically talented the actor is, of course.
16. There's WAY More CGI Than You Think
In recent years, Scorsese has proven himself a master of integrating practical sets with digital embellishments, and while nobody will watch Shutter Island assuming that the titular locale was realised entirely practically, there's far more CGI in the final film than anyone would reasonably expect.
Yes, it's not terribly surprising that the exteriors of Shutter Island were achieved through a combination of practical locations, miniatures, and green screen compositing, but more unexpected is just how many of the Ward C interiors were shot on partial sets completed in post-production (see above).
This approach was reportedly a result of the technical complexities of building and lighting such large sets, and impressively enough, the results are near enough seamless in the final film.
15. Its Release Was Delayed By Four Months Due To Marketing Budget Issues
Shutter Island was originally scheduled to be released on the prime Oscar-friendly date of October 2, 2009, but Paramount ultimately delayed the film by over four months to February 19, 2010.
This was largely a result of the studio having spent their marketing budget for the year on Oscar campaigns for Up in the Air and The Lovely Bones, not leaving enough for the $50-60 million required to fund Shutter Island's own awards bid.
It was also suggested that Leonardo DiCaprio's busy schedule may have factored into Paramount's decision, as well as the feeling that the film might benefit from being released in the "dump month" of February without any substantial competition.
Though the film didn't net even a single Oscar nomination, it did give Scorsese the strongest box office opening weekend of his entire career, and remains his second highest-grossing film worldwide behind only The Wolf of Wall Street.
14. There Are Intentional Continuity Errors To Keep Viewers Uncomfortable
In order to reflect Teddy's broken mental state and keep the audience unconsciously uncomfortable throughout the film, Scorsese included a number of intentional continuity errors ultimately intended to foreshadow Shutter Island's big twist.
In one memorable scene, a patient can be seen "drinking" a glass of invisible water, only for the next shot to show an actual glass of water.
At first glance it might seem like a simple editing mistake, but when you consider that the film was edited by Scorsese's longtime colleague Thelma Schoonmaker, arguably the world's greatest living editor no less, it's clear that it was no accident.
13. The Title Was Changed To "Ashecliffe" Before Shooting
Though Shutter Island of course borrows its name from the title of Lehane's 2003 source novel, shortly before production started the film's title was actually changed from Shutter Island to "Ashecliffe," after the story's focal hospital for the criminally insane.
Logic eventually prevailed, however, and before the film's marketing push kicked off in late 2009, the original, source-accurate title was restored, much to fans' relief.
Had Paramount stuck with that original, less-snappy title, it's safe to say that the film's box office likely would've been impacted - if only by those who didn't realise it was actually a Shutter Island adaptation at all.
12. Robert Downey Jr. & Josh Brolin Were Considered To Play Chuck Aule
Before Mark Ruffalo managed to convince Scorsese to hire him to play Chuck Aule courtesy of that aforementioned fanboy letter, the director was actually considering two other far higher-profile actors for the part.
First and foremost, Ruffalo's MCU co-star Robert Downey Jr. was in contention, and though it's easy to see how he could've nailed the part, one suspects his busying Iron Man schedule likely kept him out of the picture.
Then there was Thanos himself, Josh Brolin, who was hot off a Best Supporting Actor Oscar nomination for Milk and also in Scorsese's crosshairs, though either didn't commit or otherwise lost out to Ruffalo.
As intriguing as these casting possibilities are, there's no arguing with how Ruffalo's stellar work turned out.