If you were to compose a list (and many people have) of the important parts of movie script, it would include things like plot, conflict, and resolution. But it would almost always also include relationships. Relationships can certainly be defined as broadly as the relationship a character has with the audience, but more routinely thats viewed as the relationships that characters have with each other. Sometimes thats a best friends relationship or a siblings relationship, but in many, many movies there is a romantic relationship that is featured as central to the films storyline. Obviously we have a whole genre of films described as romances, but too often there is a Hollywood element to those relationships. As much as we swoon with Satine when Ewan breaks into the first lines of Your Song, were never going to be in that situation. (I mean, seriously, how many of us are currently wooing a courtesan who is secretly dying of tuberculosis in early twentieth century Paris?) Nor will we ever recognize our situations in a Nicholas Sparks adaptation or, thanks to our son, call into a radio show and met true love at the top of the Empire State Building. Many of these movies are good, but Hollywood is prone to being grandiose and it shows as the credits roll while the lovers ride off into the sunset. In fact, I would argue that these cinematic romances actually hurt our actual love lives. We have seen the magical kiss enough times that it becomes what we want or even need. You may be in a perfectly satisfactory marriage but pretty soon your subconscious starts yelling at you that you need to find someone who is going to fill your life with lines like, Heres looking at you, kid. But the thing is life is full of real people who are really in love. And every once in a while, a filmmaker realizes that he/she doesnt have to exaggerate to tell a compelling romantic tale. Im highlighting three films that I think get it right. These movies are mostly just conversations, because thats what people do. We talk with each other and through that exchange of words we determine affections; we fall in love.
3. Before Sunset Probably a lot of you saw this one coming. There is no film Im more looking forward to in 2013 than Before Midnight because Richard Linklater, Ethan Hawke, and Julie Delpy have, over the past 18 years, taken us on a remarkable (and remarkably realistic) journey of love. It began in Before Sunrise (1995) as two young people meeting by chance on a train and deciding to spend an evening together exploring Vienna. Not to give too much away, but we next catch up with Jesse and Celine nine years later in Paris in Before Sunset (2004). And this year we get to peek into their lives once more in Greece. I have occasionally heard arguments that these arent good movies and these mostly center around the fact that nothing happens. And its true that we dont have Cuba Gooding Jr. doing a touchdown dance that leads to Tom bursting into a living room and Renee interrupting him with, You had me at hello. But stuff does happen and I maintain that its absolutely as romantic as Jerry Maguire. The stuff that happens is, perhaps, more ordinary but ordinary doesnt have to be a synonym for dull. You catch someones eye across the aisle and theres that spark. You strike up a conversation and that spark grows. Dont we live for that sort of thing? There are a finite number of things that really make us feel alive, skydiving perhaps, or watching our team execute a perfect two-minute drill to win a football game. But that list would also include flirting, especially when its leading to love. And thats the thing that happens in the Before movies. Youll notice I specifically pointed out Before Sunset for this list. As much as I appreciate the first film (and as much as its important to the full story), this trio of filmmakers really nailed it in their second effort. Taking place in real time, we meander through Paris with Celine and Jesse as they talk about life and love. For their efforts, Richard, Julie, and Ethan were nominated for an Oscar for the screenplay (how often does that happen with a sequel?). I would have actually given them the statuette because the dialog is so spot-on that it doesnt take much imagination for me to picture having this exact conversation with an old flame.
Advertisement
2. Blue Valentine
The next entry on this list is much more somber, but no less important or true to life. In fact, my initial reaction was to suggest that if the Before characters had gotten married and realized they werent perfect together, Blue Valentine could represent the end of their relationship. This film got some press because the MPAA threatened to slap it with an NC-17 rating due to some sex scenes (including cunnilligus). Thats a whole other ridiculous issue, and this isnt the time to expand on that, but thank goodness Harvey Weinstein stepped up and persuaded the MPAA to rate it R. That way more people could see it and focus on the important pieces of the story, which surprise, surprise are not the sex scenes but the development of the relationship between Michelle Williamss and Ryan Goslings characters. Blue Valentine charts a relationship between a working class couple over several years. We get to see both the very sweet beginnings of Dean and Cindys love and its ultimate dissolution. And thats an important piece of this story and really of my whole article. Sometimes love ends or changes. The more Hollywood pushes us to believe in a happily ever after world the more were going to be disillusioned by the realities of life. Part of what makes Before Sunset (and if early reviews are to be believed, Before Midnight too) so good is that its not all whispering sweet nothings. Its discussing politics and perspectives and what might have been and at times they ruffle each others feathers. That sort of set up is on full display in Blue Valentine. Dean is a house painter who has a beer at eight in the morning as his daughter and wife are going off to school and work. Cindy thinks he could be making more of himself. Raise your hands right now if youve ever been in a relationship where your partner thought you could be more ambitious. They set up a romantic getaway to rekindle their passion, and yet the realities of life get in the way. I may not fit into the exact same mold as Dean and Cindy, but its not much of a stretch to imagine things turning out a little differently for me and I hear myself saying those words, having those arguments.
1. Liberal Arts
While the first two films on this list could have been anticipated (they were both highly reviewed and Oscar nominated), Im guessing few of you saw this one coming. Here we have a film that stars the other guy from that Neil Patrick Harris show and the little sister of the Olsen twins. Its not up for any awards and has a less than 70% positive rating on Rotten Tomatoes. And while there may be some little flaws in it, Liberal Arts is just as deserving of a place on this list as either of the higher profile entries. Josh Radnor and Elizabeth Olsens film succeeds because its based around the realistic conversations of two people excited by love. We remember enjoying the 90s film Beautiful Girls, right? (Actually, that film almost made this list, but I elected not to include it because it focuses on too many relationships.) And we remember one of the main reasons was because of the adorable but almost troubling friendship between 30-something Timothy Hutton and thirteen-year-old Natalie Portman. Well, what if that relationship was a little more legal and became the center of its own movie. Thats kind of what we have with Liberal Arts. Jesse is a 35-year-old admissions counselor and Zibby is a 19-year-old college student. Society says they shouldnt be together, but they connect. Thats the story and its good because their conversations are true. They write each other letters about good music and dive into the topic of whether or not Twilight is quality/enjoyable writing. And when the moment arrives to sleep together, the film takes a perfect turn. Perhaps even more than the other two, this film and Zibby and Jesses relationship in it rings true because weve all been on college campuses. Weve all had a crush on someone older or younger than us that society would suggest was inappropriate. Radnor (he also wrote and directed it) has taken that situation and crafted a beautiful little, life-affirming message to us. Exciting, enlightening, engaging conversation can come from unexpected places. Be thoughtful but also dont be afraid to embrace it. There are my three. I would love to hear the films you think get relationships right, or hear if you disagree with my selections.