4 Most Important Trends in American Horror

By David Braga /

Good horror reflects the cultural and social fears of the time and place in which it was created. And while certain cultural fears never seem to lose their edge, others crop up in certain time periods and are reflected by the horror films created during that time. Consider the large number of giant monster movies produced in the wake of World War II, when fears of the atom bomb and radiation gripped America. Or how the uneasiness over changes in youth culture in the 60s and 70s led to the popularization of slasher films, where teenagers were routinely a target after participating in illicit activities. The past decade or so has been no exception. American horror films have been drastically affected by several new cultural fears that rose up in the wake of the September 11th attacks. These cultural fears have manifested themselves into a slew of different trends and techniques that have become ingrained in our horror films. Not all of them are easy to directly link back to a fear of terrorism itself, but they all stem from the overarching fear and uncertainty of the years following September 11th. Here are the most important trends in recent American horror...

4. Found Footage

Found footage horror films are not a new invention of the post-9/11 age. In fact, they aren€™t even a new invention at all, with 1980's Cannibal Holocaust serving as an early example of how a faux-documentary could be used to make horror seem more real. But recently, the found footage sub-genre has absolutely exploded, leading to some hugely successful films (the Paranormal Activity series, Cloverfield) as well as other films that may not have matched that level of financial success, but still made their mark nonetheless. One of the reasons for the explosion of found footage films is that they€™re extremely cost effective for studios to produce. Low production costs better the chances of a profitable return, so it€™s easy to green light these movies. But the audience still needs to respond in order for a film to sell tickets, so what is it about found footage films that taps into the audience's subconscious and makes them afraid? Most likely it€™s because found footage films greatly resemble the type of news footage we see when a real tragedy or horrifying event occurs. Think of the last time you saw a news report about a mass shooting, violent protest, or any other upsetting story. Almost always, some of the first footage that comes in is taken from the scene, and usually features an amateur using a shaking camera to document the event. This is how we€™ve been trained to take in tragedy and horror, and so when we see a found footage horror film use the same techniques, it automatically feels more realistic to us. Even though the subject matter may be out of the realm of possibility - exorcism, zombies, or hauntings - the way it€™s presented feels real enough to strike an authentic chord within the audience. That€™s why these films have been so successful and popular over the last few years.

3. Torture Porn

Violence, and the threat of it, is an essential gear in the horror machine. And though the amount of violence depicted in horror films had steadily been rising over the years, it reached extreme heights over last decade, creating a new sub-genre which many critics dubbed €œtorture porn". These films, including the Saw and Hostel franchises, take violence to a new level not only in its extremity, but also in the fact that the films are structured around the scenes of torture or self-mutilation. There isn€™t as much focus on suspense, or escaping a villain; rather, the violence and torture itself is the payoff. While some argued that this was a mere glorification of violence (hence the name torture porn), others felt that some of the films (specifically the first Hostel film) had real merit, and were commenting on the world around them. In his book €œPost 9/11 Horror in American Cinema,€ author Kevin Wetmore notes that torture porn films began emerging as torture entered the national consciousness. Not only the fact that members of the US army and civilians (journalists, contractors) were being tortured by the enemy during the War on Terror, but that the United States was doing its fair share of torturing as well. The idea of torture was a black cloud floating over America€™s collective cultural consciousness, so perhaps it is no surprise that these anxieties and fears found their way into our horror films. Torture Porn films reveal not only our fear of being tortured and subjected to intense pain, but also our guilt over committing the same crimes to others. It should be noted, though, that the number (and success) of torture porn films has declined over the last few years. Whether that is due to changes in US policy that restrict torture easing our fears, or a collective acceptance and numbing toward the subject over time, perhaps only time will tell.

2. No More Happy Endings

It€™d be a stretch to say that horror films had, until recently, provided happy endings, but typically they at least reached some form of catharsis before the credits rolled. The demon was defeated at the end of The Exorcist, Michael Myers was at least staved off at the end of the original Halloween, and likewise for many other horror films of the past. That€™s not to say that there weren€™t exceptions; The Blair Witch Project, Night of the Living Dead, and The Omen all ended on a down note. But by and large, the evil was defeated more times than not. Not so anymore. In recent years, the endings of American horror films have taken on an increasingly bleak perspective, with the protagonists routinely defeated, outsmarted, and killed by their enemies. The end of nearly every found footage movie features the camera operators and main characters dying (leaving the footage behind to be found by someone else). The Saw films, especially the early installments, show the Jigsaw killer outsmarting and outlasting his victims. And while their are survivors in Hostel, they only survive by becoming as bad as their enemies. Even in the remakes or revisions of classic horror films, the killer seems to win (see: the Friday the 13th remake, Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning). Hardly anyone gets away alive, and if they do, they don€™t get away clean. Where does this newfound bleakness come from? More than likely, it€™s from the persistent threat of terrorism and random violence that hangs over our society. Even discounting terrorism, there has been an upswing in random acts of violence throughout the country over recent years. Combine that with the fact that the victims of these acts are almost always innocent civilians, targeted at random, and you get a somewhat hopeless outlook at what it means to be an American today. Now, obviously most of us will (hopefully) never fall victim to one of these incidents, but the reality that they do and can happen still lingers in the back of our collective subconscious, and so our horror films have taken it upon themselves to explore that fear, wondering if maybe everything isn€™t going to be okay after all.

1. Fear of the Rest of the World

Many post-9/11 American horror films have also explored another new fear: the rest of the world. The Hostel films, along with Turistas, Borderlands, The Ruins, and others, all show Americans traveling abroad only to encounter horrific ends in foreign lands. In the Hostel films, it€™s noted that the Elite Hunters have to pay top dollar for the right to torture an American victim, making it seem like a killing a US citizen is the Dom Perignon of torture. In The Ruins, it€™s not even foreign citizens that kill the American travelers, but the plant life. Even the very soil of a foreign land seems out to get us. These films reveal a deep unease about America€™s place in relation to the rest of the world, and the fear that maybe those outside our borders don€™t think to highly of us. No doubt some of the reason for this fear is because of the fact that 9/11 and other attempts at terrorist attacks were perpetrated by those outside our country, but a lot of it also comes from the fact that in the past decade, specifically during the years of the Bush presidency, the image of America was not great outside our borders. When American marched to war against Iraq, it found itself without the support of many of its usual allies in the international community (besides the UK), and as the war dragged on and revelations were made about the way the US treated prisoners and tortured suspects, there was a very firm feeling that the rest of the world was looking down on our country. No wonder, then, that these horror films seem to show a world outside our borders that is ready and willing to harm Americans. Like Torture Porn, these sort of films have seemed to decrease in number over the last few years, perhaps an indication that with a new President and new policies, Americans are feeling better about the way the rest of the world thinks of them. Again, though, only time will tell. It should be noted that while I€™ve drawn many parallels between terrorism and changes in American horror, in no way am I trying to state that America is the only country affected by terrorism. Attacks in England, Spain, and countries throughout the world have had profound effects on their societies and cultures, and have certainly been integrated into their art, including film. However, since I am not an active member of those cultures and societies, I did not want to try to draw assumptions or conclusions about what those attacks meant to those nations, since I felt it would be irresponsible without firsthand knowledge. Feel free to comment with any major changes you see developing in American horror, what you think they mean, or where you hope the genre goes in the future.