Lyndsy Fonseca is the absolute wildcard on this list. She doesnt have the iconic red hair that we typically see on Mary Jane and shes most well known for her ass kicking roles a far cry from what weve come to expect from MJ. Despite these major differences, they also could be considered Lyndsys greatest assets. The hair can be dyed hopefully this time theyd do a better job than the mess they left Shailene Woodley with but, the thing that is so attractive about Lyndsy is how powerful she seems. You may know her from her silent role as one of the kids in How I Met Your Mother, but shes much more than that. With main roles in Kick-Ass, its upcoming sequel and spy drama series, Nikita, shes kicked some major ass over the years and looked damn good while doing so. As Mary Jane, she would bring a ferocious energy to the character that hasnt yet been translated into the films. Mary Jane is a free spirit with a party girl attitude; she can do anything she wants and not worry about the consequences; shell be nice to your face but ready to kick you to the curb if ever necessary all of which can be seen in Lyndsy. She may not look the part of Mary Jane, but she sure as hell can act it.