5 Comic Book Storylines That Should Never Be Adapted (Again)

Dark Phoenix has now been tried twice. Why bother with a third time?

By Fergal Harte /

Due to the vast amount of comic book content now in circulation, you would think that companies would think twice about re-using the same story arc as inspiration for more than one film, especially with how there are numerous decades of plots to draw on.

Advertisement

And yet, we have seen more than a couple of comic book movie franchises revisit stories that they have already told, be that in the same cinematic universe (looking at you, X-Men), or across works on both the animated and live action sides, with DC being the main culprit in this regard.

With that said, these stories are ones which the likes of Marvel and DC should best avoid from this point onward. Why? Well there are plenty of reasons; it may simply be because of how they have already been overdone, or - more positively speaking - because they have already been perfected; basing another piece of media on the same comic would just lead to an inferior version of what has already come before.

Comic book movies are always going to retread ground at some point or another, but when there are so many brilliant story-arcs to choose from, there's no excuse for rehashing old material.

5. Daredevil: Born Again

It really is understandable why there has been such a push for Daredevil to receive a fourth season, seeing as the first three were so high quality.

Advertisement

Part of the reason for the brilliance of this season was the comic that inspired it, that being the wonderful Daredevil: Born Again. Much like the book, the show tore down Matt Murdock's world, allowing for the Kingpin to rise up in his absence, only for the Man Without Fear to journey back up to his usual form to take the villain down a peg.

The show, much like some of the best comic book adaptations, played fast and loose with the source material - and it worked, creating a phenomenal season that other superhero series will have to try very hard to top.

As such, adapting this book again would really be a massive mistake, as while the Netflix show may have been cancelled, it doesn't seem like the Charlie Cox incarnation of the character will be replaced any time soon, so it wouldn't make sense to revisit old ground with the same character.

Plus, any other attempt to do the comic such justice would have a very tough time trying to best the utter perfection of this series, so why bother trying?

4. Old Man Logan

2017's Logan was only very loosely based on the Old Man Logan comic, basically only taking the theme of age and the idea of an older Wolverine to the big screen, but my goodness was it a masterful film.

Advertisement

The movie is easily the best of Fox's X-Men movies, the dark, sombre tone seen throughout making for some devastating gut-punches, especially for those who had followed this version of the character through all of his adventures.

The cast's performances were beautiful, the script was fantastic and the action was raw and painful; it's a near perfect film for many, and even thinking about it may bring some close to tears.

So, it's obvious why Old Man Logan should never be used as a basis for a movie ever again, shouldn't it? Another attempt would never match this one.

3. Batman: Year One

Batman: Year One is a seminal bat-tale, one which fans of the character should all really try to read at one point or another, but that doesn't mean it has to be constantly reused as a basis for adaptations.

Advertisement

The book was used as inspiration for the first of Nolan's trilogy, as well as inspiration in practically every other medium that has featured the Dark Knight.

So, while it may not have featured on the big screen as much as some of the other entries on this list, fans should be able to agree that the elements of this story are synonymous with early year versions of Batman, meaning that it is way past time that some new comics are used as a basis for adaptation.

Over the last few years we've received some excellent tales in this regard - whether that be Scott Snyder's Zero Year or Tom King's War of Jokes & Riddles - so it isn't as though such young-Bat centric stories are in short supply, it's just that script writers need to look beyond the work of Frank Miller, as good as it was.

2. The Dark Phoenix Saga

The recent conclusion to the Fox era of X-Men movies, Dark Phoenix, was quite the disappointment.

Advertisement

This is due in large part to how it, much like the similarly ill-fated The Last Stand, tried to cram a storyline that spanned months in the comics down into two hours, with incredibly little build-up to it in the movies prior.

It was basically like if Endgame was the second Avengers film, rather than the fourth one, and all the related movies never released in - between the two.

With two failed attempts at bringing this iconic saga to the big screen, it should be allowed to rest. At the very least, allow for Jean Grey to go through some actual progression before making her the Dark Phoenix.

1. The Infinity Saga

While it may not have seemed like it at the time of some of the movies' original releases, every film in the MCU was building up to Infinity War and Endgame - AKA the on-screen Infinity Saga.

Advertisement

Both of those pictures diverted massively from the same saga of the comics, but this worked to their advantage, with them being considered the best that Marvel's cinematic universe has to offer by most fans.

With such massive build up, along with how satisfying the end products actually were as a viewing experience, it would be foolish for Marvel to rehash a similar storyline further down the road, as the Avengers saga could have concluded with Endgame due to how well it wrapped up a lot of the threads of the MCU - why even risk ruining that?

Plus, it isn't as though Marvel have a shortage of event comics to draw on for future event movies. There are dozens of other arcs comparable to the Infinity Saga, and to retread Thanos and the Gauntlet would be to ignore all of them.

Advertisement