5 Great Comedy Movie Sequels (And 5 That Were Disappointments)

Can you guess where Ghostbusters 2 falls in?

By Ken Guidry /

Anchorman 2 was released this past week and, so far, the response has been fairly positive. By now, fans of Anchorman are well aware of the difficulties that were involved in getting the sequel made in the first place, but given that the first one has become such a cult classic, it seemed weird that Paramount were initially so hesitant about the idea. Now that Ron Burgandy is back, we can rejoice, but it also gives us a chance to look back at other comedy sequels that were made in the past couple of decades. We all would like to see sequels to our favorite comedies, just like we want to see our favorite band get back together again. But it's hard to make a good comedy sequel, almost as hard as making a good comeback album. When you think of all the great comedies that have been made in the history of film, you rarely think of their sequels as being equal or superior. There's a pretty good reason for that. A sequel to a comedy has the odds stacked against it from the beginning. Sometimes a great comedy film is just the result of great timing. The cast establishes a good rapport with each other and the jokes feel new and fresh. The second time around, that cast is too busy getting massages between takes to care about being funny, thanks to the film's budget being increased tenfold. Often, the worst kinds of comedy sequels are the ones that have a specific concept. How do you repeat the same concept and still make it funny? There's going to be a Horrible Bosses 2 next year and it's as if nobody has learned their lesson. What are they going to do? Find new bosses to kill? It was moderately funny the first time around, you're going to try to do it all over again? On the other hand, the few comedy sequels that are great work because the comedies are more character-based. The sequel puts the characters in exciting new situations where the movie can still feel fresh and they don't repeat themselves. Of course, there's a flipside to that. As I hinted at before, a comedy that winds up becoming hugely successful is inevitably going to get a sequel with a ridiculously high budget. Suddenly, the movie is more about being "bigger" than being funnier. The worst example of this is with Bruce Almighty. They took a side character from the movie, played by Steve Carrell, and made him build a giant ark in the sequel. Over $175 million was spent on Evan Almighty and the film became more about the effects than the humor. Evan Almighty wound up being utterly humorless. I would have included it on this list, but let's face it, it was not expected to be that great in the first place. In fact, I did my best to keep out movies that were expected to be bad. Grown Ups 2 was always going to be a critical disaster, no matter what. So why bother? Caddyshack II has had enough vitriol thrown its way, it seems pointless to rehash the same points. So, generally speaking, the bad list has more to do with expectations being unfulfilled. These sequels could have been funny, but the magic just was not there, the concept was tired, and the jokes were too flat. On the "great" side, and believe me that word is being used a bit loosely, I included movies that I would have no problem watching again. Some I can watch over and over, laughing every time. With each case, the concepts seem more inspired, the jokes are still creative, and the movies feature characters that are always fun to revisit. Now let's get to the list...

The Greats

5. The Great Muppet Caper (1981)

When they brought back The Muppets a few years ago, nobody was more delighted than I was. The 2011 movie did The Muppets franchise justice, I thought, even if it could not quite compare to The Muppet Movie. There seemed to be a genuine joy in revisiting the world of the Muppets that I appreciated and even though the plot line was not particularly original, it did bring a smile to my face. But nothing brings a smile to my face more than the second Muppets movie, "The Great Muppet Caper." Shot entirely in England, Kermit, Fozzie, and Gonzo play investigative reporters who are assigned to investigate a thief who has stolen jewels from Lady Holiday, the biggest fashion designer in London. When Miss Piggy gets framed for the crime, it's up to Kermit and his crew to help clear her name. "The Great Muppet Caper" is one of those rare comedy sequels that manages to retain the charm of the first without rehashing all the same old jokes. Overall, I think I've revisited this one more than the first and it always makes me feel like a kid again. There's fewer celebrity cameos, better songs, and it's just a lot of corny fun. Charles Grodin plays the main antagonist, who is responsible for the jewel heist. Watching Grodin make an attempt to seduce Miss Piggy never fails to make me laugh. Aside from the usual gang, Dame Diana Rigg, John Cleese, and Jack Warden also make memorable appearances in the film. It's the last great "classic" Muppets movie.

4. Naked Gun 2 1/2: The Smell of Fear (1991)

I very much miss the days when Zucker-Abrahams-Zucker were at their peak. They're responsible for "Airplane!", "Top Secret!," "The Naked Gun," and Jim Abrahams was also responsible for the "Hot Shots" movies. When you think about all the terrible parody movies that have come out in the past ten years, it's amazing to think just how continually innovative, fresh, and silly all those films were back then. I could have easily picked "Hot Shots: Part Deux" to be on this list, but "Naked Gun 2 ½: The Smell of Fear" has always tickled my fancy. Lieutenant Frank Drebin is back and this time around, he has to save a scientist from being kidnapped by suppliers of the oil, coal, and nuclear businesses. Things get especially complicated when he discovers that his former girlfriend's new significant other is involved in the kidnapping plot. The main cast returns for this one, which includes Leslie Nielsen, Priscilla Presley, George Kennedy, and OJ Simpson. As usual with these types of films, there's rarely an unfunny moment. The difference between these movies, and the more recent monstrosities by Friedberg and Seltzer is that Zucker-Abrahams-Zucker actually cared about letting the movie stand on its own and they never relied too much on pop culture jokes. This is why the Naked Gun movies are endlessly rewatchable, even the third film is packed with plenty of laughs. But the main not-so-secret weapon is Leslie Nielsen, who always plays his character straight-faced in spite of the ridiculousness that surrounds him. Comic actors never get the proper credit they deserve, but Nielsen always had the most perfect facial expressions.

3. Back To The Future Part II (1989)

When people talk about the "Back to the Future" trilogy, it's generally accepted that the first one is way better than the last two. While that is an absolute fact, it's almost unfair as there was no way director Robert Zemeckis could ever top the first. "Back to the Future" is pure entertainment. It has a fun premise, a likable, charismatic lead actor, and the film never takes itself too seriously. There are very few blockbuster films that I enjoy more than "Back to the Future." Whenever it comes on TV, I immediately stop what I am doing and watch until the very end. So, "Part II" had all those odds stacked against it, but it still manages to succeed despite incredibly high expectations. The second one is guilty of having a much bigger budget than the first, which I previously cited as being a bad sign for a comedy sequel. But "Back to the Future Part II" has such a wacky concept that it all manages to work. I love that we go back to 1955 and attempt to re-do moments that happened in the first movie. I like the humorous little details and predictions that are made about the future, some of which have since come true. Even though the movie sort of gets lost in its own details, with their being various versions of the past and future, there's a light, humorous approach to the entire thing that makes it all worthwhile. Again, this is definitely not as good as the first, but if it was on TV, I would probably watch it too.. Now "Part III," on the other hand... I'd rather not talk about that one.

2. Toy Story 2 (1999)

While Pixar has been pretty sequel-happy these past few years, we can't forget that they made two Toy Story films before Monsters Inc, Finding Nemo, or The Incredibles. Thankfully, both Toy Story films are very fun to watch, and in many ways, it's an improvement over the first. This is why I had to include the film on the list even though it's an animated movie. First of all, there just aren't that many great comedy sequels to begin with, but most importantly, "Toy Story 2" is a damn good film. So good, they kind of repeated the formula for third one. What's great about the second one is that it really gets into the core of these toy characters, especially with Woody. Whereas Toy Story has that touching moment when Buzz Lightyear realizes he's just a toy, Toy Story 2 goes deeper into what being a toy is really about. Woody starts to realize that once Andy gets older, he'll have no use for him anymore. He has the chance to live on forever in Al's Toy Barn. Woody coming to terms with himself and what he means to Andy is what makes this so great, and dare I say it, superior to the original. Toy Story 2 would prove that Pixar would be an unstoppable force in the ensuing decade which is book-ended, oddly enough, with the very solid Toy Story 3. For eleven years, they were basically the only animated studio that mattered, though Dreamworks definitely made their own mark with the Shrek franchise. In between those Toy Story movies was a studio truly finding its voice and making consistently high quality work. They've been in a bit of a lull these past few years, but hopefully they'll continue to have more original and interesting ideas to explore in the future.

1. Christmas Vacation (1989)

More than anything, Christmas Vacation is simply another chapter in the life of the Griswolds. A family that, thanks to their father, bare witness to disaster after disaster. What made the first three Vacation movies so fun to watch, especially the third one, is the love that screenwriter John Hughes had for these characters. Everyone could relate to the misery that's involved in taking long road trips with your family, and Hughes struck that chord again by forcing this family to have the worst Christmas ever. This would be the type of Christmas Day that would haunt me for decades if I was in this family. Clark Griswold tries his best to make Christmas Day perfect for his wife and kids, but various shenanigans occur that prevents that from happening. A couple of trees get destroyed, a cat gets electrocuted, furniture is set on fire, and Clark winds up not receiving his holiday bonus. Could the day really get any worse? Christmas Vacation is an obvious choice for number one because it's mandatory viewing during the Christmas season. There's A Christmas Story, It's A Wonderful Life, and Christmas Vacation. By putting the Griswolds into an entirely new situation and setting, John Hughes was able to make a movie that is, more-or-less, just as funny as the first. Unfortunately, there's another film that he wrote that's on this list that wasn't quite as successful...

The Disappointments

5. Home Alone 2: Lost In New York (1992)

Home Alone 2 was one of those sequels that just had to happen, regardless of whether or not it was deserved. Don't get me wrong, I really enjoy the first one, but you knew exactly what was going to happen the second time around. Home Alone 2 is about a half hour too long and it features the same concept as the first one with very little changes. The obvious change would be the setting, but changing the setting to New York City only means that it will take even longer to give Kevin McAllister an appropriate place to defeat the bad guys. Unfortunately, what's lost in the sequel to Home Alone is the charm. Kevin is just a little too smug in the second film, and after watching the film a few times, I started feeling bad for the "sticky bandits." Everything is set up for the booby traps in Home Alone 2 to be even more elaborate and violent the second time around. And man, the older you get, the more you realize that this is a pretty violent movie. Sure, there are a few clever set-ups here and there, plus Daniel Stern and Joe Pesci are gifted slapstick comedians, but it's just not as funny the second time around. They even re-use a similar James Cagney-esque movie clip to fool hotel workers into thinking they're being shot at. I start to feel embarrassed when I watch that scene now. Tim Curry is such a gifted actor and he's so underused in the sequel, he deserved better than this. In fact, it would have been so much better if they changed the concept around and kept the film's plot more centered on the hotel staff. Obviously, not including Daniel Stern and Joe Pesci would be a cardinal sin, but surely John Hughes could have come up with a concept that brought them all together? Instead, they devote entirely way too much time on Kevin McAllister's "friend," the Central Park pigeon lady. Of all the people Kevin learns life lessons from, it's a woman obsessed with pigeons? Unbelievably, after being hit in the head with bricks, getting electrocuted, having their heads set on fire, falling from great heights with tons of paint cans falling on them... pigeons are what bring down Harry and Marv. Pigeons. Give me a break!

4. Ghostbusters II (1989)

The idea of a second "Ghostbusters" movie sounds much more fun than the actual movie that we got, which is forgettable to say the least. The first film is an absolute classic, made at a time when a big-budgeted comedy wasn't considered to be such a risky venture as it is today. Think about it, nowadays, the "summer blockbuster" is mostly devoted to self-serious superhero films. Don't get me wrong I like some of them, but why can't we have fun blockbusters anymore? Do people still like to laugh? Getting back on track, "Ghostbusters II" begins with the main characters' operation being put out of business. When Dana (Sigourney Weaver) turns to them for help, after her baby is threatened by an unseen force, the Ghostbusters get back together and find that the city is heading for doom. There's the mad magician, Vigo, trapped inside a painting, wanting to put his spirit inside Dana's baby. The gang must find a way to destroy Vigo and weaken the slime that's been building thanks to the overall negative attitude of city's citizens. The film's plot seems interesting enough, but the execution just feels off throughout. Bill Murray seemed to phoning it in the entire time, and despite there being plenty of reason given for the gang to get back together, "Ghostbusters II" just isn't funny. This movie is the prime example of going for "big" instead of trying to be funny. It's a movie that should have worked and we should have had a trilogy by now. Bill Murray has consistently and adamantly denied ever being involved in a possible third Ghostbusters film, and for good reason, he knows they would never be able to re-capture the magic of the first. "Ghostbusters II" is proof of that.

3. Austin Powers In Goldmember (2002)

When I was an adolescent, quoting lines from "Austin Powers" movies was just something that was done. "Yeah baby!", "Do I make you horny, baby?"---it was not long before people would only quote those lines when they were trying to be ironic. Now, it's very much a thing of the past. There's no irony involved anymore. Nobody dresses up like Austin Powers for Halloween. No one ever tries to do a Dr. Evil impression. It's done. The time has passed. So why did this happen? It's simple: Mike Myers & co. ran all those jokes into the ground with the third movie. Yes, it's very much safe to say that the "Austin Powers" movies have not aged very well over the past couple of years. The first one still has plenty of great moments and is often very funny, the second one took a bit of a dip in quality but it at least manages to take the series through some quirky directions. There's the introduction of a couple of new characters (Mini-Me and Fat Bastard) that now seem integral to the film series as a whole. And the film seems to have a lot of fun incorporating time travel into the plot. I don't have a problem with the second film. It's the third film that is very much guilty of rehashing all the same jokes that were introduced earlier in the series. Overall, I'm pretty sure "Goldmember" is the reason why the Austin Powers series has taken a dive in the public consciousness. "Goldmember" rehashes so many jokes from the second film that they actually have Ozzy Osbourne, featured in a cameo appearance, make fun of that fact. Oh yeah, that's another thing. "Goldmember" is filled with a ridiculous amount of celebrity cameos. Instead of the film being nostalgic for the '60s or the '70s, watching it now very much reminds you that the film was made in 2002. Remember when "The Osbournes" was a reality show that existed? Remember when Britney Spears was a pop superstar? Remember when Jay-Z's "Hard Knock Life" was a popular song? Actually, even that was a dated reference when the movie first came out. Out of the entire movie, only Beyonce is still relevant. She actually manages to have a great amount of fun with her role, unfortunately she and Mike Myers displayed zero chemistry between each other. Then there's the appearance of yet another Mike Myers character in the film: Goldmember. He's Dutch, he has golden genitals, he has a collection of his own dead skin, and he constantly makes '70s pop culture references. There was some comic potential there, perhaps, but the film is too busy being in love with itself that it never tries to enter new comic directions. Instead, they just go for the same jokes that made the first two movies work. By the time the movie was over, audiences all made a secret pact never to quote from an Austin Powers movie ever again. Eleven years later? The pact is still strong.

2. The Hangover Part II (2011)

There's rehashing jokes, and then there's "The Hangover Part II." I still like to think of the second "Hangover" as strictly being an experiment. Let's remake the first movie and see if anybody notices. I am pretty sure that's what the second movie tries to do. "Hey, it's not exactly the same! It's set in Thailand," says the movie's last remaining defender. Once again, like with the "Austin Powers" films, everything that Alan (Zach Galifianakis) did in the first film was considered the funniest thing ever. By "Part II," people had just about enough. His character isn't even the most annoying aspect of the movie either, that honor belongs to Ken Jeong's character Leslie Chow. Ken Jeong is best used in small doses. Here? He's practically been added to the gang. Do the filmmakers hate us or something? What have we done to deserve this treatment? The first film was great because it managed to successfully incorporate mystery elements into an R-rated comedy. It worked beautifully. The first time you watch "The Hangover," it consistently surprises you. While it doesn't hold up that well with multiple viewings, you can still appreciate the film on some level. The problem with the last two movies, and most specifically the second one, is that there's an insistence on making it more "outrageous" and "dangerous" than the first one without an attempt to make any of it funny. Again, another example of trying to be bigger instead of funnier. It's a shame too because right before it came out, "The Hangover Part II" actually felt like an event. That's why it did such huge business in the box office: everybody wanted to see the movie. Audience reaction to the second one was a bit more positive than with the critics, but considering the third film was not nearly as successful as the first two, they must've realized there was no point in coming back yet again.

1. Meet The Fockers (2004)

The experience of watching "Meet the Parents" is actually very similar to watching "The Hangover." Greg Focker visits his fiancee's family and a whole bunch of shenanigans take place. The film unfolds in such a manner that it's constantly surprising and enjoyable the first time around. While you pretty much know what to expect with repeated viewings, you can still appreciate it and have a good time. The end of the film has one of the more perfect sequel suggestions that I can think of, actually. Exhausted by the whole experience of meeting his daughter's fiance, Jack Byrne (Robert Deniro) suddenly realizes that they now have to meet Greg's family. That's a great example of being able to hint at a sequel while allowing the first film to work completely on its own. Moreover, it was fun to imagine what meeting the Fockers would be like, much more fun than what we got with the second movie. It really makes you wonder how they managed to screw it up so badly, but the answer is pretty much the same as with the others: they essentially rehashed the same Focking plot of the first. See what really ticks me off about "Meet the Fockers" is that the casting of Greg's parents is actually a stroke of genius. Dustin Hoffman and Barbra Streisand? Perfect! Knowing Barbra Streisand would appear in the film was the only time I ever got excited about anything related to her, but it made so much sense that she would play his mother. The comic possibilities seemed endless. Unfortunately, they only barely scratched the surface with his parents and primarily focused the film on Jack being suspicious of Greg the entire time. It was funny the first time because Greg actually had something to lose, but now that he's accepted Greg into his family, it made no sense to keep playing the Jack vs. Greg angle, especially when you have Dustin Hoffman and Barbra Streisand at your disposal. The sequel is so bad that it actually makes the first one seem weaker in retrospect and that's the biggest potential problem with all comedy sequels. It's important to have these characters be put in new situations where they're met with different challenges and it reveals more funny aspects of their character. Or, at the very least, it gives the character more ways to be funny. That's what you look for in a comedy sequel. Overall, the world of these characters should grow and expand well beyond what was introduced in the first film. Each of the first three "Vacation" movies, for example, feel like different experiences with the same characters. While the films still heavily rely on slapstick humor, you're still watching the Griswolds being put in situations that reveal more about their character. With "Home Alone 2", "The Hangover Part II", or "Meet the Fockers"---nothing happens in those movies that make those characters seem fuller or richer, and therefore, funnier. The film's writers rely on the same exact situations and jokes instead. The reason why the first films are funny in the first place is because they constantly play with our expectations and surprise us. When you take that away, you lose what makes those films special. What's your favorite comedy sequel? Least favorite? Leave your thoughts below.