One of the biggest dangers an actor can face is that of being type-cast. If an actor is well known and liked in a certain role, casting directors may get the actor to appear in a similar role so as to repeat the past film's success over and over again. Many actors have been critically derided for playing the exact same role continuously in every single film so as to be branded as "just playing themselves". If there's one actor that is never type-cast because he plays so many different roles, it's James Marsden. He's not a big movie star by any means, but he has all the makings of one: he's a good-looking and talented actor that oftentimes gets sidelined in favour of other "stars". The sad part about it is that nobody ever cares about him because of other people that steal his thunder. Nobody cares about him in Enchanted because of Patrick Dempsey. Nobody cares about him in The Notebook because of Ryan Gosling, nobody cares about him in Superman Returns because of Superman, nobody cares about him in X-Men because of Hugh Jackman and nobody cares about him in Straw Dogs because of Alexander Skarsgard. The fact of the matter is, nobody cares about poor James Marsden. Marsden always plays a different character in every film, but ironically the exact same thing happens to the guy: he always gets the short end of the stick no matter what. SPOILERS below.
5. Prince Edward - Enchanted (2007)
After saving Giselle (Amy Adams) from a giant ogre, Prince Edward (James Marsden) proposes to her and she immediately says yes. Their happy ending in Andalasia is all but assured until his domineering mother Queen Narissa (Susan Sarandon) pushes her down a magical well to New York City where "there are no happy endings". Edward travels all the way to New York to find Giselle. Upon hearing of her voice from miles away, he jumps off a bridge to chase after her, only to be knocked over by several cyclists. He spends a great deal of time searching a city of millions of people, and against all odds he does eventually find her. Much to Edwards's chagrin however, she's been saved by Robert (Patrick Dempsey). She claims that it's nothing, so Edward aims to return them home and marry his fiancé once and for all. Upon finally having Giselle in his arms, she convinces him go to a ball right before they get married. In one last attempt to destroy Gisele's happiness at the ball, Narissa tricks her into eating a poisoned apple, which puts her into a deep sleep. The only way to awaken his sleeping dear is through true love's kiss. He kisses her and she doesn't wake up, because she doesn't love him anymore. He gets unintentionally usurped by Robert who does awaken her with true love's actual kiss. After all of the painstaking and backbreaking work he did to find her, she's fallen in love with some other guy. As heartbroken as he is, he does bump into Nancy (Idina Menzel) who's Robert's shafted ex. They instantly fall in love and return to Andalasia for the planned wedding, albeit with a different bride. As forced and unbelievable as this pairing is, the worst part is just the fact that Edward wedding Nancy really feels like only coming in second place. He basically just gets a "Thanks for Participating!" medal. To quote the great Ricky Bobby: "If you ain't first, you're last!"
4. Lon Hammond - The Notebook (2004)
After Noah (Ryan Gosling) goes off to fight in World War II, Allie (Rachel McAdams) turns her time to being a nurse's aid at the hospital She happens up war hero Lon (James Marsden) who's contained in a full body cast due to injuries from the war for serving his country. Within seconds of talking to her, he asks her out on a date which she ignores. Then when he's all all better and gussied up in his army get-up, he asks her out to dinner. She falls in love with him instantly via a convenient romantic montage. They go dancing, watch movies and take romantic horse rides on the beach. He's also filthy stinking rich because he comes from "southern money". Then later on in their relationship he proposes to her and she says yes to the standing ovation of her parents. They're engaged, and a few days before the wedding she decides to go see Noah again. Lon being a totally upstanding guy lets her take the few days. Allie then meets up with Noah and it all falls apart for Lon after that. Noah takes her on the lake in his rowboat all romantic-like before they famously kiss in the middle of a rainstorm and subsequently have sex. Then Lon comes to see her and she tells him what's happened. Weirdly enough, he's more or less pretty calm about it and says "Look it's normal not to forget your first love. I love you Allie, but I want you for myself. I don't wanna have to convince my fiancé that she should be with me". To which she replies "You don't have to. I already know I should be with you." And then after ALL OF THAT, she ends up with Noah anyway, thereby leaving Lon entirely heartbroken and alone. If only Lon had gone on a total murder spree after finding this out would this part in the movie not be so absolutely ridiculous.
3. Richard White - Superman Returns (2006)
Richard White (James Marsden) is engaged to Pulitzer Prize winning reporter Lois Lane (Kate Bosworth) and has a kid with her named Jason. It's a safe bet to say that the guy has it pretty good and is nothing but a supportive fiancé to Lois and a loving father to Jason. Needless to say, Richard goes through a lot of trouble for nothing. When an inquisitive and very stupid Lois takes Jason onto Lex Luthor's (Kevin Spacey) yacht, they get trapped. Richard has to go and save them, but not before an emerging Kryptonian continent underneath them punctures a giant hole right up the middle and causes it to sink. They almost all drown until Superman (Brandon Routh) saves them at the last minute. They go to take off in Richard's plane, but due to being in the middle of a giant storm in the middle of the ocean, Superman helps them flight out. At the behest of Lois, Richard turns the plane around in the less than desirable flying conditions to save Kal-El. In Superman's most desperate hour, he's stabbed in the back by Luthor with piece of Kryptonite and falls towards the icy water below. He's pulled out from the watery depths by Lois who dives into save him and is promptly assisted by Richard of course. Richard then has to take off again the eye of the storm and white knuckles it out of there all by himself. While this is going on, Superman picks up the entire Kryptonian land mass and flings it out into space right before he falls unconscious and plummets down toward the earth. Yes Superman saved all of North America, but had Richard not saved him first, all of those people would have been dead anyway. Being such a stand-up guy, Richard drives Lois and Jason to the hospital. On his deathbed, Lois confesses what we assume is that Superman is Jason's biological father, all the while Richard is stuck in a traffic jam outside for her own selfish benefit. At the end of Superman II Clark gives Lois a convenient case of amnesia so she forgets that that he's Superman and that they banged that one time in his Fortress of Solitude. That's the continuity that director Bryan Singer was using for Superman Returns. In that case, things really suck for Richard. Surprise! He's not actually your kid! If anything, these characters would have made for the best episode of Maury or Jerry Springer ever. At the end of the day Richard still has both Lois and Jason, but honestly for how long is that going to hold up? Eventually Lois will probably tire of him and want to be saved by Superman again and Jason will also probably tire of him as well and want to spend more time with his real dad, because that guy doesn't need a plane to fly.
2. Scott Summers/Cyclops - X-Men Trilogy (2000, 2003, 2006)
Scott Summer/Cyclops (James Marsden) is with Jean Grey (Famke Janssen), so life is pretty good for the guy. Scott is everything that a woman could ever want in a man. He's the good-looking, reliable and dependable guy you'd take home to meet your parents. Everything is good between them until Logan/Wolverine (Hugh Jackman) shows up. Now that there's the bad-boy thrown into the mix, things get complicated. Jean lusts after Logan like a phoenix lusts after a wolverine, because that analogy totally works. Then in X2: X-Men United, Cyclops has absolutely nothing to do but play bodyguard to Professor X (Patrick Stewart). He gets into a fight with Lady Deathstrike and then mysteriously disappears for most of the movie. Once all of the mutants are together in the finale, they have to try and escape. But they can't do so with the giant wall of water raging towards them. Jean decides to sacrifice herself so that they can get away, much to the protest of Scott. Scott watches helplessly as Jean saves them all from certain death so they can get away at the cost of her own life. In X-Men: The Last Stand, Scott broods and broods because of Jean's sacrificial death. While in pain, he goes out to the lake to be even more dark and brooding, until Jean comes back to him as Dark Phoenix. He can't believe that she's back from the dead and all of his emotions start swirling all over again in a cocktail of happiness and confusion. She asks that he take off his glasses, but he's terrified that he'll kill her. She claims that she can control his power, so he reluctantly complies. The glasses are taken off and "sees her" for the first time in his life sans shades. They kiss passionately and then that's it for Cyclops. What does he get for it? Unceremoniously killed off screen by Phoenix, never to be seen again, save for a grave stone at the end.
1. David Sumner - Straw Dogs (2011)
David Sumner (James Marsden) and his wife Amy (Kate Bosworth) are returning back to their hometown to get away for a bit. David is busy hard at work writing his screenplay about the siege of Stalingrad. It's not long after they arrive that Amy's old boyfriend Charlie (Alexander Skarsgard) introduces himself. Charlie and his group of friends are there to help fix the roof of the Sumner's barn. Much to the displeasure of both David and Amy, they show up far earlier than the couple expected to start working with all their loud power tools. They also take far more breaks than they should to go hunting, but worst of all, they all lust after Amy. Amy calls David a coward for not standing up to them from the beginning. In an attempt to smooth their working relationship over, David gets invited by them to go hunting in the woods where they all eventually abandon him. While David is fumbling around alone in what's he's lied to as "hunting season", Charlie and one of his cronies come back to see Amy. While David is aimlessly wandering around the forest, Amy gets raped by Charlie and his goon. David gives them their severance money for what little work they've done on the roof and fires them, thereby ending it, or so he thinks. Despite wanting nothing to do with the town, David and Amy go to the local football game because it's a Friday night tradition. Jeremy Niles (Dominic Purcell) who's mentally handicapped, is coaxed into hiding in a locker room by a cheerleader whose overly protective father (James Woods) wants him to stay far away from her. Her father goes looking for her, and to keep her quiet, Jeremy accidentally suffocates her to death. In a moment of panic, he run away and gets hit by David's car. The closest hospital is too far away, so David takes it upon himself to take care of Jeremy and call for an ambulance. Her father figures out that David is hiding Jeremy through a police scanner and drives to their estate. Her father, along with Charlie and his men demand that Jeremy be given back to them. David refuses because he's finally decided to not take their crap anymore. David kills the attackers with a shotgun and nails one of their hands to the inside of the house through the window with a nail gun. He also slams the bear trap onto Charlie's head, effectively killing them all. To top it all off, in the ensuing chaos and carnage, the house is set on fire. In the end, David and Amy have killed every one of the rednecks. Unfortunately they've now gone through multiple horrific experiences, their marriage is incredibly strained and David also has to watch their house burn down with his screenplay inside. So really all of the hard work he did or at least tried to do while they were there was totally for nothing.