5 Stand-Out Segments in Anthology Horror Films

By Brendan Foley /

There€™s something automatically appealing about the anthology format, isn€™t there? Feature length films require months and years of dedication and craft, during which the writer, director, producers and all involved have to slave to try and maintain a consistent tone, atmosphere and pacing and make sure that each facet of the film is contributing to a greater whole. But an anthology film? A film that, by definition, is comprised of shorts that can fluctuate wildly in story, look, feel, tone, length, purpose? Well, then you€™re free to let €˜er rip and really have some fun. While this frequently results in wildly varying levels of quality from segment to segment, it ensures that each anthology will have at least one tale resonate for the audience. Whether the film is the work of one mind or a collective of filmmakers the anthology format loans itself well to visceral thrills and taboo-shattering imagery. It€™s no surprise that the anthology format has supported dozens of films and goes through the same flare up-burn out-resurgence cycle as slasher and ghost movies. While anthologies died off for a while, there has been a boom in recent years as more and more producers realize that it€™s a great way to corral talent behind and in front of the camera to work quick and cheap. The filmmakers, for their part, clearly respond to the no-holds-bar approach and creative freedom that working quick and cheap provides. So, as we wait for S-VHS to be distributed out of Sundance, and wonder what fresh new horrors have been cooked up, let€™s look back at some of the finest, freakiest, most stand-out moments that horror anthologies have contained over the years.

5. Creepshow - €˜They€™re Creeping up on You€™

Loving the work of Stephen King and George A. Romero can be a tricky position. While both men are indisputable masters of their respective fields, both men also have problematic tendencies that mar even the best of their work. Without writing a whole essay about that, let€™s just say that both King and Romero have self-indulgent tendencies that all too often rear up. That€™s why the short format of an anthology plays so perfectly to their strengths. You get Romero€™s genius for crafting nightmare imagery and King€™s unerring eye for depraved scenarios and the hilariously deserving people the horrors choose for targets. Nowhere are either man€™s best qualities more evident than in the final segment of CREEPSHOW: €˜They€™re Creeping Up On You€™. Featuring a fantastic, all-in performance by E.G. Marshall, €˜Creeping€™ takes place in a semi-futuristic apartment, wherein lives Marshall€™s Upton Pratt (God, even the name makes you root for this guy€™s death). Pratt is a cruel, tyrannical businessman who regards all of humanity as little more than pests running beneath his feet. The man is an obsessive germaphobe, displaying Howard Hughes€™s most off-putting tendencies taken up to eleven. So he€™s a little upset when the armies of cockroaches start crawling out of the walls. Pratt€™s descent into madness strikes the perfect balance between humor and horror, balancing out the audience€™s repulsion for the cockroaches with their desire to see the 1%-er die in the most disgusting way possible. It€™s the kind of gleeful social justice that the real-world so rarely provides, but the fantastical world of horror fiction can. Added to that, the fluorescent lights and pure-white look of the apartment is a huge departure from CREEPSHOW€™s none-more-over-the-top visual palette, making this segment stand out from the pack even more. Runner-up: Not that the pack is all that bad! Every CREEPSHOW segment deserves to be seen at least once, if only for the novelty of which famous person agreed to get slathered in Tom Savini€™s goo (ewwww). Runner-up though is probably THE CRATE, featuring Adrienne Barbeau, Hal Holbrook and Fluffy. If you don€™t know who Fluffy is, go rent CREEPSHOW and find out.

4. Dr. Terror's House of Horrors - €œFranklyn Marsh€

DR TERROR was Amicus Productions first anthology film, and its success resulted in a wave of follow-ups from both the studio and copycats. The villainous Dr. Schreck (Peter Cushing, of course) joins a group of four men (including a disturbingly young Donald Sutherland) and proceeds to use his Tarot cards to predict the upcoming calamities that will result in their deaths. Unfortunately, DR. TERROR doesn€™t work all that well nowadays. It€™s cheesy, slow and repetitive and most of the stories have since been done in other, better versions. Heck, CREEPSHOW redoes one story almost beat-for-beat but one-ups it in over-the-top grossness (CREEPSHOW one-ups most things in over-the-top grossness). There is, however, one story from DR. TERROR that stands as a work of cinematic genius that any and all horror fans must see. Now, I assume that everyone reading this site is a sane, intelligent person. And, like all sane, intelligent people, you will agree that EVIL DEAD 2 is the greatest great thing to ever be created in the history of great things. There€™s no room for debate on this one. And the stand-out sequence in what is essentially one giant stand-out sequence is Bruce Campbell fighting his own severed hand. It€™s awesome. Twenty years prior to that benchmark in cinematic history, DR. TERROR€™S HOUSE OF HORRORS told an evil severed hand story, and it trounces every other segment in terms of atmosphere, craft, chills and knowing black humor. Pushing this segment from €˜good time€™ to €˜MUST WATCH€™ is the casting of Christopher Lee as Franklyn Marsh. Lee appears in the film (but you already knew that. It€™s a British horror movie, so Christopher Lee WILL appear in it. It€™s like a law or something) playing an aggressively snooty and hateful snob. Christopher Lee could radiate dignified menace if he was appearing in a three hour long TELETUBBIES and SPONGEBOB slash fiction movie and he€™s in top form here. He goes so far over the top with the haughtiness of his art critic character, it drags the entire story into camp territory, which makes the craziness involving sentient hands and accomplished artist chimpanzees make way more sense than they should. And when Lee is fighting with the severed hand, you actually believe in the events on screen, such is his command of the screen. Runner-up: The wrap-around story is better than any of the other stories, thanks largely to more Lee and the presence of Peter Cushing, both of whom €˜get€™ the tone they have to play in a way that no one else seemed to.

3. Black Sabbath - The Drop of Water

Mario Bava did not have much interest in rational people doing logical things. His movies proudly denounced logic and realism in favor of gothic exaggeration and dream-like narrative flows. Blood was redder-than-red, every set was drenched in exaggerated color and spider-webs, and every behavior was magnified and out-sized. BLACK SABBATH takes that tendency and runs with it, unspooling three stories the seek nothing more than to unnerve and unbalance you with an assault of ghouls and monstrosities. The best of these is €˜The Drop of Water€™. The story is simplicity itself. A nurse is called to a mansion where a rich old woman has just died, expected to prepare the body for the funeral. It€™s while talking to the help that details start to mount up. Like the fact that the old woman had become obsessed with the occult. And that she began holding séances, quite successful séances, at that. And that she died during one of those séances. All this is fine and dandy, but it€™s with the first glimpse of the actual corpse that Bava grabs the audience by the nape of the neck and flings them into the deep end of his dream state. When we see the old woman, her skin has mottled to the green-gray color of an EC comics cadaver. Her eyes are bulging, too huge to be contained in her sockets. And she€™s grinning. Grinning a rictus smile that€™s wide, far too wide. And she€™s staring dead into the camera. It€™s while dressing the body that the nurse decides to steal a priceless ring off the woman€™s finger, accidentally spilling some water and causing a fly to begin buzzing around her head. The nurse leaves and returns home, but she continues to hear the water and be buzzed by the fly. She grows more and more frantic, taunted by the phantom noises into a state of hysteria. She comes right to the verge of madness€ And then the old woman returns for her ring€ €˜The Drop of Water€™ is perfection. Perfectly crafted in every area, from image to sound to performance, it is a story that was almost chemically crafted to send an audience into fits of terror. If this twenty-minute segment was released on its own, it€™d be in the top five horror films of any given year. BLACK SABBATH is an extraordinarily well-done horror film, and €˜The Drop of the Water€™ is the jewel in the crown. Runner-up: €˜The Wurdalak€™ is an off-kilter vampire tale featuring a diabolical Boris Karloff and one of the creepiest dead kids in horror€™s looooooong history of creepy dead kids.

2. Trick R' Treat - Sam

If TRICK €˜R TREAT had been made only a couple of years later, we€™d probably be neck-deep in a franchise by now. Unfortunately (or fortunately, depending on how you view the endless system of sequels that is the horror genre) TRICK €˜R TREAT hit at a point when anthology horror didn€™t exist in the marketplace anymore, let alone anthology horror with overtones of comedy. It€™s a shame because TRICK €˜R TREAT is a delight, and one that was immediately embraced by the online horror community as a new classic. While not on the level of something like John Carpenter€™s Halloween, TRICK €˜R TREAT makes excellent and effective use of the holiday€™s mythology and iconography. While it can occasionally be too clever for its own good, thanks to shifting timelines and character overlap, more often than not writer-director Michael Dougherty knows when to bring the hammer down on his audience and hit them with some red meat. This is best displayed with the film€™s final story, simply titled €˜Sam€™. It is the story of a very bad man (Brian Cox, because why not) and his very, very bad night at the hands of the child-sized pagan deity he has offended. Watching Cox get beat into a pulp by a little kid is, of course, hilarious, and Dougherty wrings strong splatstick laughs out of the scenario before pulling the rug out from under viewers with bursts of unexpected brutality. Dougherty also under stands pacing, making the rise-and-fall-and-rise-again of Sam€™s assault a roller-coaster ride. You€™ve hardly finished laughing by the time the next scream gets you. Runner-up: The School Bus Massacre Revisited runs right up the edge of being in the poorest of bad-taste, but Dougherty understands that we watch horror movies as much for the joy of retribution as we do for the visceral experience of fear, and he brings this story to two separate conclusions that are stand-up-and-cheer inducing as the bullies get their just desserts.

1. Dead of Night - The Wraparound

DEAD OF NIGHT is one of the original horror anthology films and has by hailed by many, including Martin Scorsese, as being one of the greatest horror films ever made. While it may seem somewhat quaint to today€™s audience, there€™s something wonderfully offbeat and creepy about the film that lasts to this day. For the right sort of viewer, someone with an appreciation for stories like €œThe Turn of the Screw€ or €œThe Woman in Black€ the low-key spookiness of these stories that will linger. In a lot of way€™s, DEAD OF NIGHT more easily recalls the TWILIGHT ZONE than modern horror. There€™s an off-handed ease to the way the supernatural and natural worlds overlap, and to the character€™s reactions to these events. Take a wrong turn in a mansion and you€™ll come unstuck in time. Buy the wrong mirror at a boutique and you can suddenly peer into the land of the dead. Nowhere is this ease with other-worldliness more appreciable than in the wraparound segment. Usually the weakest part of an anthology film, relegated to little more than an after-thought, here the linking story (directed by Basil Dearden) sets the exact right tone for all the tales to come and is able to mount its own crawling sense of dread. A man arrives at a country house, finding a small party underway. Everyone€™s friendly, but he€™s put-off: He€™s seen all this before, in a dream. He can€™t remember how it ends but he knows that something terrible happens, something he must stop. But is this just a coincidence or a true premonition? You can probably guess where this is going, but the film does an excellent job of keeping you off-balance mounting tension and when the ending does spring, it allows the story to fold back in on itself and return to each previous story with a nightmare logic that€™ll leave the audience staggered as the credits begin to roll. Runner-up: The Ventriloquist dummy sequence is probably the most influential and well-known (with good reason.Ventriloquist dummies are an easy mark for horror because VENTRILOQUIST DUMMIES ARE FREAKIGN TERRIFYING WHY DO THEY EXIST WHYYYYYY sorry, had to get that out there) but my money for best goes to the Haunted Mirror story. Marred by an ending that obliterates all mystery, the rest of the story hits the perfect note of overwhelming dread. At its best, the mirror story broaches the notion of a malicious, otherworldly intelligence asserting its will with the finest of Lovecraft and King.