6 Attempts To Deconstruct The Manic Pixie Dream Girl

She's not your miracle and she doesn't 'complete you'.

By Jack Kingston /

You know the character, she sweeps into the life of the repressed sadsack hero in a whirlwind of rainbow coloured hair and life affirming minor law breaking and her quirky attitude helps the mopey leading man to discover that life really is worth living. Yes, we're talking about that mainstay of offbeat indie romcoms, the Manic Pixie Dream Girl. While the term may have been coined by critic Nathan Rabin (who has since had a complex relationship with his own concept) in reaction to Kirsten Dunst's needlessly whimsical turn as Orlando Bloom's lover-saviour in Cameron Crowe's dire Elizabethtown, the MPDG has been around a lot longer, pretty much as long as there have been quirky indie films. Hell, the likes of Goldie Hawn made a whole career out of playing these kind of male fantasy untethered free spirits. As Rabin noted, the problem with all these films is that the MPDG is just a fantasy figure whose quirks only exist to pull the male character out of shell, whose personal problems are entirely superficial, making her feel nothing like a real, three dimensional person, and who has no arc of her own but only serves to advance the male hero's arc. Wising up to this, an increasing number of films are being made that present as conventional MPDG male projection fantasies and then begin to deconstruct the archetype into something more akin to a real person. With the latest attempt at rewriting the trope cropping up at the moment in Paper Towns, now seems the perfect to time to assess it and similar previous efforts.

6. Paper Towns

Sample Dialogue: "The fundamental mistake I had always made€”and that she had, in fairness, always led me to make€”was this: Margo was not a miracle. She was not an adventure. She was not a fine and precious thing. She was a girl." Lead actress Cara Delevingne drummed up some extra attention for the film recently when responding with appropriate sarcasm to a breakfast TV interviewer asking if she'd actually read the source novel by vlogger/Fault In Our Stars writer John Green. Judging by the movie's trailers, though, it would seem like the question would be more appropriately directed towards the studio's marketing team. Of course it's possible that the Fox marketing people want audiences to think that they're getting a conventional MPDG story in order to create a level of cognitive dissonance in the audience when it reveals itself to contradict that, but it feels more likely that they just see the simpler conceit as an easier sell. Perhaps this shouldn't come as too much of a surprise given the large numbers of both fans and critics of the novel who see the character of Margo, hero Quentin's quirky neighbour who suddenly appears back in his life climbing through his window and then disappears seemingly leaving some equally quirky clues for him to follow, as a prime example of the archetype. (And this is regardless of the fact that the whole point of the story is that people projecting such ideas onto her is precisely what Margo is running away from). Delevingne, the bisexual supermodel turned comic book movie villain, is probably used to the raft of male assumptions projected onto her based on the variety of associations that come from those various identities, making her pretty perfect casting for a character who is basically made up of other people's ideas of how she should behave. Ultimately, though, this is kind of the problem with Margo. While she rebels against being pigeonholed as an MPDG and Quentin sort of learns his lesson about viewing girls as people too, she doesn't actually get much of an alternative personality and the story really remains all about him.

5. Scott Pilgrim Vs The World

Sample Dialogue: "Look, I've dabbled in being a bitch. It's part of the reason I moved here. I was really hoping to just leave it all behind me." Perhaps the easiest way to tell an MPDG deconstruction story from a conventional MPDG story is how in looking at how pathetic we're supposed to perceive the protagonist taking his fixation with finding 'the one' and being saved by her to Ted Mosby levels of entitlement. Which brings us to Scott Pilgrim. In classic Michael Cera style, Scott is an awkward, geeky loser who, although we're obviously supposed to empathise with him, is also oblivious, self-absorbed, infantile and, on occasion, kind of an asshole. His perception of the world as one big video game is cool but also indicative of the movie's theme that he needs to grow up and get a life. And so it is with his relationships with women. Scott is both aware that his dream girl Ramona Flowers is well out of his league and yet also thinks he can 'earn' her by jumping through the hoops of defeating all her evil exes, even while not really appreciating how damaged her complex past has left her. In production while writer Bryan Lee O'Malley was finishing the innovative manga-esque series on which the film was based, its lack of sureness about what it's trying to say about Ramona and Scott's relationship is clear in how both versions feel a little uncertain of how to wrap up the story. While both conclude with the two of them giving the relationship a shot, it doesn't feel entirely convincing, to the extent that director Edgar Wright tried an alternative ending of putting Scott together with schoolgirl Knives Chau instead. Ultimately, the biggest issue with Scott Pilgrim the movie is that it has to condense the whole story of its characters' growth into one movie, thereby failing to do what Wright's TV classic Spaced did so well and show the bittersweet development of its geeky twenty-somethings into real adults the way O'Malley's books did.

4. (500) Days Of Summer

Sample Dialogue: "This is a story of boy meets girl. The boy, Tom Hansen of Margate, New Jersey, grew up believing that he'd never truly be happy until the day he met the one. This belief stemmed from early exposure to sad British pop music and a total mis-reading of the movie 'The Graduate'. The girl, Summer Finn of Shinnecock, Michigan, did not share this belief." Created to be an antidote to typical romcoms, (500) Days Of Summer explicitly sets out from the start to tell a story of what happens when its hero, Tom, has a view of romance entirely developed from watching movies and tries to project those ideas onto a real woman. It shows how Tom expects the eponymous Summer to be the MPDG that will bring him to life and how hard she tries to resist it. Unfortunately, perhaps more than any other movie on this list (all of which suffer from this problem), the film's fanbase is primarily made up of people who not only root for Tom and Summer to end up together, but really support Tom's misguided worldview. But I guess this is hardly surprising, since obviously the people watching are themselves movie fans whose opinions have been formed as much by the movies Tom loves as his have. In fact, even though it sets out its stall pretty directly from the opening narration, Marc Webb's film is constantly undermining its cynical message by proving far more adept when it's being a straight up example of the charming, quirky indie romance than it is when being much more ambitious and trying to subvert it. (In a similar way to how Webb's two Amazing Spider-Man films were full of charming romantic chemistry and utterly devoid of interesting superhero action). At the end of the day, the director might be better off reeling in his ambitions and just making a good old fashioned romcom. Of course, it doesn't help that casting Zooey Deschanel, practically the patron saint of Manic Pixie Dream Girls, as Summer may have seemed like a decision that would help the film's subversion of the archetype, but actually only serves to bring out those qualities in the audience's mind rather than her more cynical ones.

3. Ruby Sparks

Sample Dialogue: "You haven't written a person, okay? You've written a girl." Perhaps the least well known film on this list, Ruby Sparks also stands out as being the one and only film here to come from a female authorial voice. The film feels very much the work of its teenage screenwriter Zoe Kazan, who also appears as the eponymous Ruby, a character that meta-fictionally is the in-universe literary creation of novelist Calvin (played by Kazan's real life partner Paul Dano). Ruby is literally the girl of Calvin's dreams, someone that the blocked novelist writes about after he dreams of her and gradually falls in love with the idea of. As he writes that Ruby is also in love with him, she magically comes to life and he has to deal with actually having a real relationship with someone who is more an idea than a real person. Directed by Little Miss Sunshine's husband and wife team of Jonathan Dayton and Valerie Faris, Ruby Sparks is interesting as a film that attempts to replace a fictional ideal of love with the real thing as produced by a creative team made up of two real world couples. Kazan has denied that the focus of her 'effervescently joyful' character is to deconstruct the MPDG specifically, but did admit that the film and the character are about confronting the way that the male gaze projects an ideal of women that real women struggle to live up to. The more fantastical element of the story makes it feel more of a piece with magical realist metafictions like Stranger Than Fiction, but the strengths of the film are ultimately more in what it has to say about relationships than as a work of fantasy.

2. Annie Hall

Sample Dialogue: "You know, you're so ego-centric that if I miss my therapy, you can only think of it in terms of how it affects you!" Probably the best known and most widely acclaimed example of both the MPDG archetype and an attempt at its deconstruction came decades before Rabin coined the term. The role of Annie Hall was written specifically for Diane Keaton ("Keaton" is a stage name for the actress, commonly nicknamed Annie, whose real surname is Hall) and she has admitted that the la-dee-da free spirit's character is a version of her own. Bearing that in mind, it's tempting to see the film dramatising Annie's relationship with Woody Allen's neurotic Jewish New York comedian Alvy as a way of Allen attempting to come to terms with their failed relationship in the real world as much as it is a wider attempt to talk about love, relationships, gender and psychology as a whole. Allen won Best Picture, Director and Screenplay Oscars, with Keaton picking up the Best Actress award, for a film that remains hugely acclaimed, endlessly quoted and analysed by film students, but it remains a story about Alvy, about how he perceives his connection with Annie, his attempts to figure her out and his ultimate disconnect from her worldview. For all that she is the title character, we never really get a sense of who Annie is in the way that we do with Alvy's endless self analysis. However autobiographical or not Annie Hall itself is, it does seem a little odd to place a great deal of value on the romantic insights of an actor-writer-director whose own romantic life is so troubled and demonstrates continued struggles properly to understand women.

1. Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind

Sample Dialogue: "Too many guys think I'm a concept, or I complete them, or I'm gonna make them alive. But I'm just a f**ked-up girl who's looking for my own peace of mind. Don't assign me yours." Perhaps the best version of a deconstructed MPDG appears, like much of the rest of this list, in a film written by a man (in this case Adaptation's Charlie Kaufman) and taking place within a meta-fictional environment constructed around the perspective and internal world of the male protagonist (Jim Carrey's Joel). Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind seems initially quite similar to many of the other films listed here in using a fantastical narrative device to view its love interest as a construct before things go wrong when she turns out to be more of a real person. The difference is purely in how successfully it manages to navigate that complex narrative conceit. Through career best performances from Carrey and Kate Winslet as the colourfully haired Clementine, as well as insightful writing from Kaufman and director Michel Gondry, the relationship feels real even amongst the sci-fi trappings. Yes, the Clementine we see through much of the film is filtered through Joel's mind, but she still feels more like a real woman than most of the "girls" on this list. Clementine doesn't just insist that she's a "f**ked-up girl" looking to find her own place, not wanting to complete some guy's fantasy, she shows it. Thanks to Kaufman and Winslet, she is charming, exciting and free spirited in a way that you can see why Joel imagines her to be an MPDG, but she is also selfish, irritable and overly impulsive, qualities that make her personality feel more rounded. The original script was to end with the relationship disintegrating again and the mind wiping happening all over again and again, showing that, like Days Of Summer's Tom, Joel hadn't really learned anything. The more hopeful, romantic ending that we got, though, feels more satisfying. Here is one couple that feels enough like two real people for the audience to root for.