Attraction is a very scientific process. People from all walks of life, compelled by a biological imperative to reproduce, set out to achieve coupling. Neurotransmitters are sent, hormones are released, and subconscious bonds are formed with that dashing twentysomething across the bar. There is a method to attractions perceived madness. Yet, in spite of attractions logic, human beings tend to muck it up with all kinds of societally imposed decorum and tradition. Attraction is not a permanent condition, but rather a temporary state. It would seem obvious that people should be allowed to roam, as their heart desires, and to come and go as they please, free from judgment. Unfortunately, great pressure exists in many social circles to maintain a relationship long past its expiration date. Long-term relationships require forward momentum that our fleeting desires often wont accommodate. Rejection is a natural part of life, every bit as natural as attraction, and just as formative. Though time heals all wounds, even the most hardened among us can experience loss like a hot knife cutting to the bone. Without further ado.
7. The Social Network (Mark & Erica)
The Breakup: It only took a minute to feel this fight had been a long time coming. The conversation between Mark and Erica was as flat as the half-empty beers before them. Their dimly lit table at some shabby Boston-area college bar felt lived in even though theyd been sitting for mere minutes. Theyd had this conversation before. Final club. Exclusive. Got it. As the beat between words intensified, their subtext became text. Routine conversation about Marks impending pledge to frat life boiled into his being unimpressed with Ericas education, her position in life, and her ability to support him in his accomplishments. Basically, he had been a delusional, arrogant, selfish prick. In no uncertain terms, Erica explained why she (and scores of other potential lovers) should avoid Mark at all costs: Okay, you are probably going to be a very successful computer person. But youre gonna go through life thinking that girls dont like you because youre a nerd. And I want you to know from the bottom of my heart that that wont be true. Itll be because youre an a**hole. What Makes It So Brilliantly Devastating: It is clear that Mark and Erica werent attracted to each other anymore long before they entered the bar. This information was apparent to everyone except Mark. He was genuinely surprised by Ericas reaction, unaware that his dismissive comments were indeed the last straw. He couldnt see the irreparable damage hed done to their relationship because he was incapable of being present with another human being. When Erica justifiably attacked Mark, he was unable to defend himself. He knew that hed been a truly awful person. Her final condemnation was fuel for his insecurities, which clouded his decision-making for the rest of the film. To know that youd been repugnant to the point of being irredeemable was truly an awful fate, even to the deserving.
6. Scott Pilgrim vs. The World (Scott & Knives)
The Breakup: A heavy bass line vibrated through the local record store. Knives bounced up and down the isles, cutting off Scott repeatedly. Theyd only been dating for a bit, but she was sure it was true love. These trips to the record store had been labeled as dates in her ledger. Attending her first concert together had been a sure sign of long-term commitment. It was young love at its finest. Scott was noticeably uneasy. His personality oscillated between quirky and comatose most of the time, so not noticing would be forgivable. He knew their breakup was imminent, though hed been too timid to bring it up before. When Knives asked him to meet her parents, Scott knew his window had arrived. Listen, I was thinking we should break up or whatever. The record store background faded away, and she replied with an oh that echoed into an abyss that formed around her. Scott left her in that complete darkness, feeling guilty about it only momentarily before turning his attention to the next girl. What Makes It So Brilliantly Devastating: Director Edgar Wright knows how to put his visual stamp on a film. This film, full of vibrant images and alluring graphics, often resembles a cartoon. Knives and Scotts breakup is noticeably understated compared to the rest of the film. It is perhaps best marked by its economy of movement and dialogue. While other scenes seem to be never-ending, this one took only seconds. Both reactions perfectly capture the painful awkwardness of teenage rejection. Scott carries around his relationship with Knives as if he were Atlas holding up the Earth. Likewise, Knives has made her entire life about a boy that she sometimes holds hands with. It is completely overdramatic, and yet still manages to find a level of truthfulness that is readily accessible. Even when the background fades out and Knives is shown in a literal pit of despair, the heart of the scene feels incredibly realistic.
5. I Love You Phillip Morris (Steven & Phillip)
The Breakup: Being a con artist had improved Stevens life immeasurably. Hed lived a comfortable life, riding around in expensive cars, wearing elegant suits, and dining in the finest restaurants Miami provided. His ability to lie, impersonate, and forge gained him prosperity in every aspect of his life except one: love. It was only after being caught and imprisoned for his crimes that he met the love of his life. Phillip, a fellow convict, began an unexpected relationship with Steven that seemed tender and loving despite their harsh circumstances. Their relationship continued to flourish upon their release. Stevens second arrest, for embezzling company funds, also landed an uninvolved Phillip back in prison as a suspected accomplice. Phillip fumed as both men were held in a police station waiting area. You were supposed to protect me. But you just did nothing but make a fool out of me. And you expect me to love you? Phillips words left Steven in rubble. He remained silent, only later to reveal that he would never see Phillip again. What Makes It So Brilliantly Devastating:Stevens ability to lie was often used as a survival mechanism. He lied to obtain money, power, and love throughout the film. It can be difficult to maintain the intricate system of deception he crafted, and it inevitably unraveled like a ball of yarn. His biggest con might have been played on himself; by the end, he was unable to differentiate between the stories he told himself and what had actually happened. When truth and fiction became indistinguishable, Phillip denounced their entire relationship. I dont even think you know who you are. So how am I supposed to love something that dont even exist, you tell me. It was the first time Steven had ever been seen for what he truly was: nothing. And isnt that the greatest fear of any person, really?
4. Milk (Harvey & Jack)
The Breakup: Harvey was late again. He lumbered up the staircase to his San Francisco flat, grumbling about the messy state his boyfriend Jack had left it in. Papers and pots were strewn about the apartment. The disarray was most likely the result of an earlier tiff about Harveys recent work schedule. Several notes had been pinned on the walls leading to the dining room. One such note read, You always loved the circus Harvey. How do you like my last act? Harvey pulled back the curtain it had been pinned to, and revealed Jacks limp body hung from a rope in the kitchen. Harvey pulled a knife out from a nearby drawer and cut Jack free from the rope in an instant. Later that evening, several friends came to the apartment to console Harvey. They told him there was nothing he could have done to stop Jacks suicide. Tears streamed from his face as he slumped forward. In his horror, Harvey managed to let out one more sentence, I could have come home at six fifteen instead of six oclock. What Makes It So Brilliantly Devastating: Relationships are difficult enough in nature. When combined with substance abuse or mental illness, they become downright impossible. Jack and Harvey always had a tempestuous relationship. Their first meeting, a drunken encounter, plays like fun romp until you realize that chaos and disorientation became commonplace in their household. Harveys guilt over having been an absentee partner is something many have experienced, though hopefully with less dire consequences. He should know that he wasnt responsible for Jacks suicide, that he couldnt have possibly predicted such an event. Like many in relationships marred by drugs, alcohol, or mental illness, he may not have been able to separate his own actions with Jacks distorted interpretation and response. Jacks inner turmoil caused him to view Harvey as a funhouse mirror, something to project an exaggerated vision of his own flaws and insecurities. It was a near-impossible position for any person to be in.
3. Blue Valentine (Dean & Cindy)
The Breakup: Dean looked older. His hairline had fallen back a few inches. He was bespectacled, his eyes barely visible through his prescription tint. A sharp sigh fell from his mouth as he leaned into the kitchen doorway. You know its not just us, we got a little girl we gotta think about, Dean said. His face contorted, scrunching and pulling in every direction at the sound of his own words. He didnt look or feel anything like the man Cindy had met several years earlier. Big tears dropped from Cindys eyes between each of her pleas for Dean to stay away. He didnt hear her, and she didnt hear him plead to keep their family together. Theyd both heard little of what had been said in the last few years. They had always been talking at each other. Cindy apologized. It was impossible to say what for. She apologized over and over again as her husband made his case for a second chance. Again, their words seemed to miss each other. After a few moments, Dean stumbled out of the house. Not even their daughters cries could lure him back. What Makes It So Brilliantly Devastating: Blue Valentines brilliance is that is manages to focus on the small moments that comprise a long relationship. This breakup occured after a major event: Dean punched Cindys boss, resulting in the termination of her employment. Of course, the fistfight wasnt the cause of their split; it was just a symptom of a much greater problem. This films depiction of love is a lot like a sickness, slowly spreading through each scene. This particular scene was intercut with several shots from Dean and Cindys wedding. Their marriage was largely a reaction to her accidental pregnancy. Marrying someone you hardly knew, and with the intent of raising a child together, seemed like an ill-formed idea from the start. Given their respective family histories, it is perhaps a bit more understandable. They imagined themselves able to improve upon the mistakes others had made before them. The follies of youth. Both Dean and Cindy apologized to one another throughout the scene. Their apologies, somehow simultaneously empty and emotionally heavy, seemed to be the only constant in the later years of their relationship. These apologies would be better spent said to a mirror. Theyd built their entire adult lives around a simple mistake of their youth. If only they could get it all back.
2. Closer (Anna & Larry)
The Breakup: A silence crept across Larrys London flat. It broke with a confession. Larry had slept with a woman on his recent trip to New York. Anna, his wife, answered back with a quick word of forgiveness, followed by a vacant stare. Larry knew his marriage hadnt been well, but was still willing to believe that love would redeem what once shined. Anna knew that she was going to leave Larry that night. His admission of infidelity had only made it easier. She couldnt be upset about Larrys fling because shed fallen in love with another man. Shed been with him only hours before, playing out her own martial indiscretions on the living room couch. Still, she felt overcome by guilt. There was inequity in their transgressions, or so he thought. Where Larry had sex, Anna made love. Over the next few minutes, Larry interrogated her about the details of her affair. He wanted to know everything. Was this interloper a better partner? A better lover? Did he kiss her as passionately, hold her as tight, and love her as oft? He demanded explicit answers. Thats what he received. But were happy arent we? Larry tepidly asked. Anna replied with a look, and the answer was no longer in doubt. What Makes It So Brilliantly Devastating:Closer is a film about relationships that fall apart, and the brutal, deliberate steps their participants take to harm each other. None of the couples intend to harm initially. They only commit to emotionally destroying one another when they feel backed into a corner. It is the type of break-up you cannot come back from. Larrys insistence on knowing every detail of Annas affair is borderline sociopathic. He pushes her to reveal deeply personal information in hopes that she feels guilt like white heat. He doesnt necessarily take pleasure in the act, but indeed feels retribution for exerting control over her one last time. In forcing her to purge every disgusting detail of her affair, Larry cleanses himself of any sympathy or desire for Anna. Relationships built on passive-aggressive emotional abuse are bound to escalate. After taking a few verbal blows, Anna began using her answers to inflict damage back. They cut each other repeatedly, using verbs like knives, with hugs and tears interspersed. Is there any doubt theyll repeat the process?
1. Pariah
The Breakup: Some relationships end as fast as they begin. Alike and Binas fast friendship turned into something more after a bonding experience over a creative writing assignment. Poetry turned into a kiss, and a kiss turned into a sleepover. Alikes initial hesitance, the kind that only exists for first kisses or leaps off mountains, was soon subsided by Binas reassuring glances. The next day, Alike awoke to Binas hurried cleaning. Clothes were put away, sheets tucked, and blinds opened. It was almost as if Bina had been trying to erase all evidence of the night before. Alike pulled Bina back down to the bed. Last night was amazing and thank you, Alike grinned. The words came out as clumsy as one might expect. Bina appeared less than enthused, saying last nights action had been nothing special, just play. When Alike pressed her to admit her true feelings, Bina responded that she wasnt really gay, she was just doing thing. As Alike made her way to the door, Bina reminded her not to tell anyone. What Makes It So Brilliantly Devastating:Binas callousness was overwhelming. From the beginning of their relationship, she was the one that pressed to move further. She invited Alike into her home, she initiated the first kiss, and she proposed the sleepover. As soon as the relationship was consummated, Bina emotionally and physically distanced herself from Alike. These were malicious acts committed by a person probably too young and foolish to realize the extent of their damage. It was the kind of cruelty that ruins love for life. Alikes face noticeably contorted as Bina smoothed out her bed sheets. Each wrinkle represented a tussle, a twist, and tug between the two. By straightening them out, Bina was erasing Alikes existence from her bed. Alikes familiarity with this type of denial was too painful to be subjected to again; especially after thinking shed finally found a home in Binas arms. In reality, another person too ashamed to be seen with Alike had just used her.