7 Cancelled Movie Sequels Saved By Comics

Is it possible to actually save the RoboCop sequels?

By A.J. Carey /

Films take a lot of money and manpower to make. The average Hollywood film takes $125mil to make and only about 250 movies are recognized by Hollywood every year. With those numbers working against the average creator, there's very little wonder that so many films never receive the sequel or franchise that those involved had planned in their head.

Advertisement

Luckily, comics are cheaper and usually less reliant on needing to make the annual national budget of Greece to have a job the next day.Developing a comic book off of an existing script or idea is not a hard thing to do, with the biggest issue coming down to licensing.

Some creators use their existing ideas and shape them to fit outside of the film they were working on, such as Alejandro Jodorowsky who spent years working on the Dune film adaptation before that fell through, so he adjusted the story notes into what is now called the Jodoverse of comics.

The few who are able to save their sequel ideas through proper application of writing and rights are the luckiest few of all. They're so few and far between that we couldn't even get a full ten for this list!

7. Freddy V Jason V Ash

Freddy Vs Jason was an oddly entertaining flick, combining the pop icons from the Nightmare on Elm Street and Friday the 13th franchises.

Advertisement

Naturally, after quadrupling it's budget at the box office, a sequel went immediately into production and then slipped firmly into production hell. Granted, the film did start development in 1987 and came out in 2003, so there's always hope for a film version.

Many of the sequel ideas were about adding another horror icon, like Pinhead or Michael Myers, and that's where this comic comes into play. Jeff Katz had a treatment all worked out and ready to go, introducing the one-hand camp wonder known as Ashley Williams. The fun bit is that because of an easter egg in the film Jason Goes To Hell, there was a natural angle for the story to have Ash enter the fray.

Filled with the same carnage, sex and bad one-liners, it is a fantastic sequel to a bombastic movie. There's even a sequel to this comic out that plays with the whole mythos of Freddy and Jason than this does, though.

6. Super Mario Bros. 2

If there's always one cheat on these lists, this would be it. The Super Mario Bros. movie has a very sordid history, and a legacy that is less than spectacular. That doesn't mean there weren't fans drawn in by the sequel hook of Daisy kicking down the Mario Bros. door saying "you're not going to believe this".

Advertisement

Ironically, there was no sequel planned at the time and that scene was just a way to homage Back to the Future.

However, in 2012, fans in collaboration with one of the writers of the film, Parker Bennett, began the Super Mario Bros. 2 webcomic as a sequel to the film. That's where the cheat comes in.

Technically it is a fan-made webcomic. Yet, with Bennett assisting in the scripting and story, there's a certain semi-official feeling to the work that is just enough to stretch what would be a "saved sequel".

5. Frank Miller's Robocop

Robocop is a cinematic masterpiece using the story of a man dealing with his humanity after becoming a cyborg while slamming the growing control corporations had over everyday life.

Advertisement

It was also bloody, brutal, and a spectacle to behold.

The sequel that actually did hit theatres was more focused on the action and violence in the same life cycle as the Rambo series. Oddly enough, they both had Saturday morning cartoons during this period too.

Frank Miller would be hired to write the scripts for the sequel films, however his script was reworked by the first film's writers into what eventually would be the movie. It wasn't until 2003, strangely enough, that Frank Miler's Robocop vision would debut. While not written by Frank Miller, Steven Grant adapted the original unused script and notes into this strange book.

It had roughly the same reaction coming out that the film versions had, but with so many changes such as the whole Nuke facility scenes being film-only, it has become a name that comic readers know and a book worth buying to see how a script can change from start to finish.

4. Chaos Comics' Halloween #1

Halloween is just an awkward franchise, all things considered. On a continuity level it's all over the place, with many films omitting the existence of other films in the franchise to try and salvage something out of the timeline. With how Halloween H20: Twenty Years Later ended, it was assumed the series was over. Decapitating Michael Myers is a pretty final way to kill him, but that didn't stop the films.

Advertisement

Daniel Farrands, the writer of Halloween 6, pitched a follow-up movie to H20 but it would not happen. However, the now-defunct Chaos! Comics took that idea, and with Farrands helping with the story, put out Halloween #1.

The plot acts itself is a prequel, with an older Tommy Doyle reading the journal of Dr. Sam Loomis to showcase the life of Michael in the sanitarium and Dr. Loomis' connection with him.

It's a surprisingly good one-shot that would have definitely been a much better instalment to the Halloween franchise than what fans eventually got with Halloween: Resurrection.

3. The Power Of The Dark Crystal

When The Dark Crystal debuted, it was not well-received. While turning a profit, the critical and audience reception was lukewarm at best, hindering any potential for a sequel. During production though, Jim Henson and David Odell would talk about the potential sequels, expanding the universe and generally do with a passion project that hopefully would be a hit.

Advertisement

It wasn't until 25 years later that David Odell and his wife would use their memories and notes from the time to piece together a draft for a sequel. That draft would be ignored for another twelve years before finally becoming a highly-praised comic.

The Power of the Dark Crystal is an amazing comic, with an expansive world set centuries after the original with truly stunning art by Kelly and Nicole Matthews that makes it one of the best saved scripts out there.

2. William Gibson's Alien 3

Aliens was the sequel no one expected. It was bigger, better, and elevated Ripley to being truly one of the most badass women in movie history.

Advertisement

Alien 3 came out six years later and it sucked. Some like to defend David Fincher's ill-fated sequel, but the studio mishandled it, with the finished product only a shell of what the original film could have been.

All of that changed in 2019 when the original draft of famed cyberpunk William Gibson was unleashed unto the world. Gibson's script was wholly original without neglecting the claustrophobia and terror of the first, or the action and spectacle of the second.

Without spoiling anything, this comic is a prime example of the different paths a franchise could take - and one, in Alien's case, that fans may have preferred.

1. Buckaroo Banzai

The Adventure of Buckaroo Banzai Across the 8th Dimension is both a fantastic way to pad out the length of any writing assignment and a fantastic film that was hurt at the box office, being slaughtered by Star Trek: The Search for Spock, Ghostbusters and Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom.

Advertisement

Despite this hard-hit at the box office, Buckaroo Banzai would be saved through comics.

In 2006, Moonstone books began publishing tales of Buckaroo Banzai with the original creator, Earl Mac Rauch at the helm. These stories were adaptations of the dozen or so starters that Mac Rauch had worked on from the initial scripting of the film, and established a far more expansive world than what was shown in the film.

While a now-cult film being reevaluated by general audiences, the comics have become fantastic reads for comic fans and film aficionados alike.

Advertisement