7 Greatest Fictional Presidents

If you could tailor make a President, what would they be like?

By Samuel Clements /

Paramount PicturesWhat qualities should the ideal President have? Personality is a must; they must be able to galvanise a crowd and keep the attention of the public. They must be able to keep calm and make a decision in a heated situation. It is crucial that they are not overly trigger happy, but they must also know when it is right to make strike against an enemy. Given this criteria, which fictional Presidents would make the greatest President in reality? We are drawn to aggressive and militaristic leaders in films, but in reality we would not want a President who is warmongering and aggressive; perhaps this is why the most likable fictional presidents are Democrats (or at least support their ideals, such as gun control or opposition to warfare). The Presidents included in this list are the ones who we would like to see in the White House; the ones who have the likability and the personality that would be crucial to a successful presidential bid. Hollywood is in the fortunate position of being able to custom tailor its politicians for its own purposes; this gift has given us an abundance of American Presidents on screen that enables us to see qualities in a politician that would be immensely popular in reality. Some presidents are intentionally terrible; in Superman II the President handed over control of the United States with almost no fight. Others are admirable; In X-Men 3 the President took an extreme yet understandable decision to launch an attack on Magneto at Alcatraz. Harrison Ford's President James Marshall in Air Force One showed necessary violence, but was arguably to happy to turn to violence to make it as a real President. Despite these poor presidents there have been many incredible presidents; these presidents are strong not because of speeches, but because of actions. They are the ones who have been rooted in some semblance of the reality of politics; partisan attacks, internal squabbling, tough decisions and an evaluation of the political implications of his decisions are crucial components for these presidents.

7. Matthew Santos In The West Wing

NBCAlthough he was introduced as a replacement for Martin Sheen's immensely popular President in Aaron Sorkin's West Wing, this President certainly matched the requirements to be a phenomenal President; He had an educational reform program as the centerpiece of his campaign, he had absolutely amazing oratory skills that allowed him to engage with the masses, and he was the underdog. He was a Hispanic candidate loosely based upon a little known Illinois Senator named Barack Obama, so perhaps it is not a surprise that he was gifted with the skills to become President. Although this entry is being judged upon his campaign promises, not his actual period as President (as this wasn't shown on screen.) He was clearly a good candidate as he had previously shown his capacity to make backroom deals in order to bring in change. We saw his period as President elect, where he was formulating a cabinet and beginning to influence policy; in this period he offered the important Secretary of State position to his Republican rival. This altruistic act ensures that Santos is seen as a clever politician and a respectable leader, both crucial elements of being a successful President.

6. President Tom Beck In Deep Impact

Paramount PicturesThe world is about to end... Is there any other voice you would want to listen to other than Morgan Freeman's? As President Beck in the 1998 disaster movie Deep Impact, Morgan Freeman reassured the public that they would survive, despite the imminent threat of a comet striking the planet and potentially killing every living thing. Faced with a situation that would test any President, Beck dealt remarkably well with the crisis. He kept reasonably calm and came up with some form of a solution. Obviously Matthew Santos, the previous entry, could not compete with Morgan Freeman's character since the scenarios are completely incompatible. However, despite this disparity, it is clear that in a potentially earth shattering situation you would feel some semblance of security knowing that the the President is at least capable of making good decisions in the heat of the moment. Then we come to the press conferences. This is where a Presidency is made or destroyed, and in Beck's case it is an absolute certainty that the defining moment of the term would be made in that tense room. Morgan Freeman's voice carries through like nothing on this planet, and his aura of authority means that this is one President who would definitely go down in history as one of the best had he existed in real life.

5. President Benjamin Asher - Olympus Has Fallen

FilmDistrictAaron Eckhart gives life to this president in the 2013 action bonanza. The character survives a terrorist attack on the White House, an event that would be almost catastrophic in reality. He portrays the character with incredible depth, with the first families death having a major impact on the character. Despite the attack on the White House, and the threat of imminent death, the President orders the Secretary of Defense and the Chair of the Joint Chiefs of Staff (both holding nuclear codes) to give up these codes and save their lives, while remaining sure that he will not waver and give up his code. This plan legitimises Asher's placement on this list as it shows a determination to see as many people survive as possible, while also recognising the necessary sacrifice that the position holds; as Spider-Man has taught us, 'with great power, comes great responsibility.' We did not really see enough of this president to see how he dealt with the everyday formalities of scathing political attacks by the opposition, but if we judge him by his handling of a crisis then it is clear that Benjamin Asher deserves to be recognised as a President we would want if such a position were to be encountered.

4. President Andrew Shepard - The American President

Warner BrosThis 1995 film by Aaron Sorkin (who we will come back to later) showed a President who was beyond electable. He was struggling to pass a piece of legislation that would restrict gun laws. He had a formidable presence and was resolute in the face of scathing criticism from his opponents. Unlike Benjamin Asher, President Andrew Shepard is almost real. Legislation restricting gun ownership is one that many Americans are still yearning for given the constant plague of gun violence, yet very few laws are passed, showing the idealism of this character. He is not the victim of a terrorist plot, he is a card carrying ACLU member who is seeking real political change, and in this sense he is perhaps one of the most realistic characters to make this list. Michael Douglas is incredible as President Shepard. He is passionate and dedicated to his cause. He is a testament to the skill of Aaron Sorkin in creating engaging, likable and realistic characters. In press conferences during the film there is a certain aura of authority that enables him to compel the audience to listen to him, and a persuasiveness that would make him a dangerously perfect politician. Who would not want to see this character in the White House?

3. President James Sawyer - White House Down

Columbia PicturesJamie Foxx's depiction of President James Sawyer in White House Down was phenomenal. Although the film shared a similar plot to Olympus Has Fallen, the President in this film was far more active in defeating the invasive forces. The way in which Foxx interacts with the daughter of Channing Tatum is remarkable and representative of what would make him such an incredible politician. Foxx's respect for the young girl shows how he would interact with people while campaigning; his personality would make him extremely electable. Foxx shows his intelligence when he works out who had masterminded the terrorist plot, and he was equally steadfast in ensuring that military force is only used when it is absolutely necessary (which provides the motive for the terrorist attack, with the enemy wishing to see a show of American force). The commitment to non-violent means is laudable, but it is equally matched by his decision to attack his captor in the films closing scenes, showing how he could make tough decisions. If we take these rather selfless actions and take them as representative of how President Sawyer would act in other situations, we can see that he would be a rather successful President, and given the power of his speeches he would be an exceptional candidate.

2. President Thomas J. Whitmore - Independence Day

20th Century FoxIn 1996's Independence Day the earth stood still whilst alien spacecraft ominously overlook monuments, waiting for the moment to strike a crippling blow to us. Prior to the final assault on the alien craft Bill Pullman gives what is quite possibly the greatest movie speech of all time: "We can't be consumed by our petty differences anymore"..."We will not go quietly into the night. We will not vanish without a fight! We're going to live on!" This speech rallying for a united front against a common enemy shows the incredible skill of this President. In the face of almost certain annihilation the President remains calm and formulates a plan of attack. It may not be as recommendable for the President to take part in a military operation in the real world, but it certainly shows dedication to the cause. President Whitmore's oratory skill is almost unparalleled, and in the real world this skill would serve him remarkably well in the campaign for the highest office in the land. In the context of the film he displays perhaps the greatest leadership role in cinematic history; unlike the other entries on this list he was not facing human threats, he was facing extraterrestrials who clearly had Earth outgunned.

1. President Josiah Bartlett - The West Wing

NBCCould it be anyone else? Martin Sheen is an immensely talented actor and social activist. These passions collided in his absolutely phenomenal depiction of the fictional Democratic President in Aaron Sorkin's West Wing. The show itself focused on the lives of the backroom staff, but the President played an important role in demonstrating quite how the leader of the United States should act, and how reliant he is upon his staff. Bartlett was a Catholic, and we saw him struggle with deciding whether it should be the job of the President too enforce his opposition to the death penalty on states who supported the punishment. Legislation was constantly passed through little deals with politicians, showing the realities of politics. Laws are not passed simply due to the President's wishes, they are the result of a long and tumultuous process. President Bartlett was often infuriated by this, but it is what ultimately made him such a great President. Rather than concentrating on the President's powerful personality and skill, the show illustrated the importance of the staff who wrote speeches and made decisions, as well as giving us an idea of the concerning power that is held by the Press Office. By placing the President in the context of those that make him so powerful, we saw what real politicians must cope with. Few would argue that Bartlett was anything less than the perfect President; he had the charisma, the skill and the beliefs that would make him the perfect politician. What did you think of our list? Who would you have included? What criteria should we judge a President on? Let us know in the comments section!