We've all seen it dozens of times. The first movie in a sure-to-be successful film franchise is released to critical and financial acclaim. A sequel is green-lit and fast-tracked. The first one was great, the cast was great, and the audience expects to see everyone back for the second go-around. And then we hear the dreaded words: salary dispute. One or more of the actors feel they weren't paid enough in the first movie and now they're demanding more money. Sometimes the studios give in and pay what the actors ask for. Other times there are months of negotiations before both parties settle on a compromise. And other times the studios decide not to bring that actor back at all. We'll be taking a look at some of our most notoriously greedy actors that did not appear in the sequel and/or the greedy studios that screwed them over or refused to pay. I'll try not to make any judgments or cast any aspersions as who's right or wrong in these cases. We all know that greed is prevalent in Hollywood and as long as studios are willing to pay exorbitant amounts of money to actors and audiences are willing to pay ever increasing ticket prices, then Gordon Gekko's philosophy will continue to be the way of the (capitalistic) world: Greed is good.
7. Kirstie Alley - Star Trek III: The Search For Spock
Kirstie Alley played the role of Lt. Saavik in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan. Saavik would appear in the Star Trek III but allegedly Alley's agent asked for a massive salary increase to return for The Search for Spock. Her salary would have been higher than that of DeForest Kelley. Her agent's request was denied by producer Harve Bennett and director Leonard Nimoy and the role was recast with an unknown named Robin Curtis. Alley herself denies this, stating that she was surprised she was rejected for the role and that the studio offered her less money than she made for Wrath of Khan and never presented a counter offer. In another account by Alley, she was going through an emotional time after her mother was killed by a drunk driver in an automobile accident and that's why she refused to return for the sequel. Whatever the reason for Alley's departure, the fans and filmmakers were not pleased with Curtis' portrayal of Saavik. When Nicholas Meyer, director of Wrath of Khan, was brought on to direct Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country, he wanted Saavik to reappear and he wanted Alley to reprise the role. She was once again too expensive and/or unavailable (likely due to her role on Cheers) and they instead created a new character Valeris, played by Kim Cattrall.
6. Crispin Glover - Back To The Future Part II
Crispin Glover had played a few minor roles on sitcoms like Happy Days and in Friday the 13th: The Final Chapter. But it wasn't until his breakout role as George McFly in Back to the Future, that audiences really took notice. Okay, so "took notice" is maybe an overstatement. Glover has made a career of playing eccentrics and weirdoes in mostly supporting roles. But after the height of his Back to the Future fame, Glover and the film's producers could not agree on his salary for the sequels. Glover stated that he was offered $125,000 to return for Back to the Future Part II, significantly less than the rest of the cast. The producers thought Glover's salary demand was way more than they were willing to pay. George McFly's role in the sequel was therefore significantly reduced. Robert Zemeckis wound up casting actor Jeffrey Weissman, who wore prosthetics to resemble Glover, to play the role and also spliced in previously filmed footage of Glover to complete the George McFly affect. Glover wound up suing the producers for use of his likeness without his permission. In the end, did it really matter that Glover was recast? Personally, I never even noticed that it wasn't Glover in Back to the Future Part II until years after my initial viewing. And all without that crappy Polar Express style motion-capture CGI. Well done, Zemeckis.
5. Marlon Brando - Superman II
The casting of Marlon Brando as Jor-El in Richard Donner's 1978 Superman: The Movie lent a certain credibility to the production that few others could have provided. Unfortunately, Brando came with a hefty price tag: $3.7 million plus close to 12% of the film's profits. In total, Brando banked about $19 million for about 15 minutes of screen time. Brando was his usual notoriously difficult self: initially suggesting that Jor-El appear on screen as a suitcase or a green bagel and requiring cue cards as he refused to learn any of his lines. Brando had already filmed his scenes for Superman II as the two films were initially being filmed simultaneously. It was only after an overlong shooting schedule and after numerous production logistics, that director Richard Donner and the producers Alexander and Ilya Salkind decided to focus on the first film only. Superman: The Movie was a huge hit and work on the sequel would continue but Donner butted heads with the Salkinds over their desire to make the sequel more campy than the original, and he was eventually fired and replaced with Richard Lester. The Salkinds decided not to use Brando's already filmed footage to avoid having to pay his massive fee. Despite Jor-El's absence and Gene Hackman's obvious body double in the final scene in the Fortress of Solitude (Hackman quit in solidarity after Donner was fired and refused to reshoot any scenes for Lester) and the film's silly humor, Superman II was still a great film. For a glimpse of what might have been had Donner stayed on and Brando's footage been used, check out Superman II: The Richard Donner Cut.
4. Terrence Howard - Iron Man 2
Terrence Howard was the first actor signed onto 2008's Iron Man and was the highest paid of the group to boot. Yes, that's right. More money than Gwyneth Paltrow. More money than Jeff Bridges. And more money than Robert Downey Jr. himself. Of course, Iron Man was directly responsible for Downey's resurgence in Hollywood. But rumors about Howard being difficult to work with, reports about director Jon Favreau being unhappy with Howard's performance, and Howard asking for too high a salary for the sequel, led to Marvel Studios parting ways with the Academy Award-nominated actor and securing Don Cheadle to take the role of Rhoads in Iron Man II and III. Howard stated recently that being ousted from Iron Man II was "the surprise of a lifetime" and that he found about it through the press and didn't even receive a call from Marvel. He also claimed that Cheadle was always their first choice to play Rhodes and only after he declined for the first film, did they decide to sign Howard. Howard signed on for $4.5 million and his contract also suggested he would get $8 million for a sequel. Instead, they offered him a paltry (and I use the term loosely) $1 million for the sequel, basically begging him to leave and allowing Marvel the chance to once again cast Cheadle.
3. Richard S. Castellano - The Godfather Part II
Trivia factoid: Richard S. Castellano received the highest salary of any actor to appear in The Godfather. That's hard to believe given the phenomenal cast of the film but let's not forget that Marlon Brando was considered more or less washed up, Al Pacino was a complete unknown, and Robert Duvall and James Caan were hardly household names at the time. Add the fact that Castellano had received an Academy Award nomination for his role in Lovers and Other Strangers in 1970 and maybe his salary was not surprising. But when it came to The Godfather Part II, the producers were unwilling to give in to Castellano's new demands. In addition to a salary increase, Castellano wanted complete creative control over the Clemenza character, including having his wife Ardell Sheridan, who also played Clemenza's wife, write the character's dialogue. This was unacceptable to director Francis Ford Coppola. Instead the character was written out of the script (Clemenza having died between films) and replaced with a new character Frank Pentangeli. Sheridan, however, later stated that Castellano refused to regain the 50 pounds required to play the role, and Coppola replaced him. I guess no Clemenza was better than a non-Fat Clemenza. Luckily for audiences, Michael Gazzo was brilliant in his Oscar-nominated performance as Frank Pentangeli.
2. Will Smith - Independence Day 2
We have yet to feel the ramifications of this display of greed as Independence Day 2 is still in pre-production, but director Roland Emmerich has already announced that Will Smith will not be reprising his role as Captain Steven Hiller. The reason: he's just too expensive. In 2011, it was reported that Smith allegedly asked for a salary of $50 million to do the sequel to the film that launched him from a rapper and sitcom star to marquee superstar. It's a shame that Smith won't take a reduced salary to return to the franchise that essentially made his name, but with Bill Pullman and Jeff Goldblum both on board for the sequel, I'm still relatively optimistic about the film. After all, when people are asked to recall the most memorable scene in the first film, the answer is inevitably Bill Pullman's speech before the final aerial assault on the aliens. So with Goldblum...Goldbluming and Pullman reprising his role as the greatest movie President of all time, I think we're in good hands.
1. Edward Norton - The Avengers
Edward Norton is a notoriously difficult actor. He butted heads with American History X director Tony Kaye over the way he was editing the film and essentially cut the final version himself. He clashed with director Brett Ratner during the making of Red Dragon. He made it crystal clear that his participation in 2003's The Italian Job was purely the result of a contractual obligation to Paramount Pictures. So there is very little surprise that Norton clashed with Marvel Studios over 2008's The Incredible Hulk. When Norton signed on to play the title character, he also managed a deal to rewrite the script. Because Norton submitted his script with only two months before shooting was set to begin and he couldn't include any major changes, Nortons rewrite included mostly dialogue and character motivation for Bruce Bannerin other words, more Norton! When director Louis Leterrier cut all the footage together, Marvel was not pleased and insisted on a shorter, more action-oriented version. Norton, of course, was not happy. A feud of epic proportions ensued between Norton and Marvel, as Norton expected the studio to bow down to the considerable creative control he had been granted. Marvel, however, wanted the most commercially viable version of the film to be released. Eventually, Norton relented to Marvels cut of the film. The film wound up beingOK. Norton had intended to reprise the role of Banner in The Avengers and had even met with director Joss Whedon. Marvel, however, preemptively fired Norton to avoid similar drama on The Avengers, the studios flagship film that the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe had been building toward. Marvel Studios President of Production Kevin Feige stated that the decision was "not based on monetary factors, but instead rooted in the need for an actor who embodies the creativity and collaborative spirit of our other talented cast members." Nortons agent fired back, calling the statement purposefully misleading, inappropriate attempt to paint in a negative light. In the end, audiences wound up with a fantastic Avengers film and most were more than pleased with Mark Ruffalo in the role of Banner/Hulk. Still, can you imagine the off-screen battles between Norton and Robert Downey Jr. over who would get more screen time?