7 Most Overrated Comic Book Movie Performances

Are these acting turns as good as we've made them out to be?

By Sam Hill /

Warner Bros.

There are some comic book movie performances that are so perfect, iconic and revelatory that they cannot be considered anything other than brilliant: Heath Ledger as the Joker, Robert Downey Jr. as Iron Man, Jesse Eisenberg as Lex Luthor (just kidding on that last one).

Advertisement

As modern movie-goers obsessed with superhero movies, we do love it when a comic book movie performance goes right, because they're inherently tricky things to master; you've got a long and extensive character history to indulge and respect, whilst also ensuring to bring something fresh and progressive to the role.

Our enthusiasm for comic book movie performances that do anything other than suck therefore often results in them being given more credit than they deserve, though - either because audiences don't know any better and have nothing to compare them to, or because everyone decide to go along with everyone else out of fear of being in the minority. In some cases, a performance that was once deemed great has dated over the years, rendering it overrated because nobody has gone back to check whether it still holds up.

Advertisement

My intention here was to highlight some notable comic book movie performances that don't quite match up to the praise that they've received. In most cases, the actors in question delivered okay to fine turns in their respective roles, but have been vastly overvalued.

Time to bring them down a peg or two...

Advertisement

7. Willem Dafoe - Norman Osborn - Spider-Man

Sony Pictures

At the time of Spider-Man's release, this otherwise excellent actor felt like a perfect fit for the role of Norman Osborn, a once good scientist turned sinister by an experiment gone wrong - one which condemns him to a double life as The Green Goblin, a supervillain who flies around causing havoc in a costume that would look quite at home in an episode of Power Rangers.

Advertisement

Willem Dafoe has always been an actor known for his scenery-chewing approach to the art of acting, but here well, it's something else. Dafoe doesn't just play over-the-top villain here - he's operating on another level entirely, tearing the place apart and leaving nothing in his wake. To say it's a distracting performance in retrospect warrants a prize in this year's Understatement Awards: it's insane and camp and hammy in equal measure - an endless carousel of more, more, more!

Maybe you watched this as a kid and liked what Dafoe was doing, but witnessing his turn as Spider-Man's arch-nemesis now, in 2016 well, it's safe to say that the performance doesn't play anywhere near as well as I remember it. Mostly I gasped whenever Dafoe was on screen, wondering whether the actor had managed to take scenery-chewing to its absolute zenith.

Advertisement

6. Margot Kidder - Lois Lane - The Superman Quadrilogy

Warner Bros.

Nobody is all that fond of Amy Adams' portrayal of Lois Lane in Zack Snyder's recent Superman films, mainly because she's a boring, personality-less exposition machine and is completely beneath the actress who plays her. That being the case, it was inevitable that fans would look back at previous Lois Lanes and remember all the good times when the character was, you know, good.

Advertisement

It's not surprising that Margot Kidder's name comes up a lot, given that she played Lane in the original Superman movies - I, II, III and IV - and is therefore considered to be a great embodiment of Clark Kent's famous love interest.

But have you gone back recently and witnessed this character in action? She's near on insufferable. Seriously: whilst Amy Adams is as dull as a concrete post in the role, Kidder is irritating as hell - there's a weird "little girl" side to her performance that is plainly absent in the comics, and it just doesn't come over well on 21st century Earth. As an actress, she isn't bad, but the way she plays Lane simply pales in comparison to the way Teri Hatcher did in the '90s TV series.

Advertisement

Clearly the countless folk who cite Margot Kidder as the best incarnation of Lois Lane should revisit her turn just to make sure they've got it right. She's serviceable, but the best on-screen version of this character? Uh-uh. Is this, after all, the Lois Lane you'd want to catch, mid-air? God knows why Superman didn't drop her.

5. Michael Fassbender - Magneto - X-Men: First Class/X-Men: Days Of Future Past

20th Century Fox

There's no denying a simple truth regarding the on-screen Magnetos: Ian McKellen was the bomb. And so there is no use pretending that anything Michael Fassbender has done in the role since compares to what Ian McKellen did when he decided to wear that uncomfortable-looking helmet for the sum of five X-Men movies.

Advertisement

Fans have apparently taken to Michael Fassbender in the role of Magneto like a duck takes to water, though; they implored his initial performance in X-Men: First Class as if it was something of a revelation. Really? He's fine in the film, but it's not a performance you remember, is it? It doesn't stick with you the way McKellen's did.

As such, Magneto grants Fassbender one of his least interesting roles to date - he made more of an impression during the 20 minutes he was on-screen in Quentin Tarantino's war flick Inglourious Basterds than he does in any of these films.

Advertisement

Despite that, I still consider Michael Fassbender to be fair enough choice for the younger incarnation of the character, but can we talk about that accent for a second? It's all over the place! In X-Men: First Class, he sounds Irish/German, whilst in the next movie - Days of Future Past - he's English/Irish/German/Something. It's like he keeps forgetting and then remembering to do an accent.

So, sure, he's okay here, albeit inconsistent and a bit forgettable. Not a performance to exactly celebrate, though, c'mon.

Advertisement

4. Gal Gadot - Wonder Woman - Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice

Warner Bros. Pictures

If you read through a bunch of reviews for the recent Batman v Superman movie, you'll notice that the majority of critics found time to single out praise for actress Gal Gadot, who played Diana Prince - A.K.A. Wonder Woman - in Zack Snyder's critically-derided picture.

Advertisement

Reading these reviews, I was was struck with a single thought: "Why?" Gadot was barely required to do anything in the film; she spends most of the picture slinking around in revealing cocktail dresses and flirting with Ben Affleck because that's what the movie thinks that these characters need to do because they're different genders.

When she finally arrives as Wonder Woman, dressed in the iconic garb, she doesn't say much at all. How was it possible for so many critics and fans to make their mind up on Gal Gadot so quickly? She didn't give us anywhere near enough to prove herself as a great Wonder Woman, not to mention her accent felt a little bit off.

Advertisement

That's not to say she was bad; she was just okay. To suggest that she "stole" the film on the basis of her performance, though? It's just lunacy. Unless you count "typing on a laptop" as good acting.

3. Andrew Garfield - Spider-Man - The Amazing Spider-Man/The Amazing Spider-Man 2

Sony Pictures

Imagine my shock when the news came that Spider-Man was to be rebooted again and a whopping 25,000 people signed a petition in order to keep Andrew Garfield in the lead role. Had we all seen the same movie? Didn't everyone agree that Garfield's casting had been a well-intentioned mistake, guys? Why bother to keep him around?

Advertisement

When I first heard that Andrew Garfield (who I'd deemed to be "very awesome" after his memorable turn in David Fincher's The Social Network) had been cast as the new Spider-Man in the wake of Spider-Man 3's failings, I was overjoyed. Here was an actor who would gel with the role in all the right ways, thus ensuring that the rebooted franchise had a proper, well-fitting actor leading the proceedings.

It's in my opinion that he never lived up to the hype, though; the movies were relatively lackluster affairs, and Garfield - a guy who had once seemed so perfect - came across as a relatively flat and forgettable Peter Parker. He lacked personality, and - despite appearing in two whole movies - he was never made to feel like a believable human beings. That's not all Garfield's fault, of course; the scripts weren't up to scratch, and Garfield proved too old for the role. Also: they made his Peter Parker into a skateboarding science dude. What the?

Advertisement

Still, by way of that petition, it was brought to my attention that 25,000 or more people have overvalued Garfield's turn as Peter Parker; his take lacked any coherence, and proved inferior to even that of Tobey Maguire (yep - I'm serious). To place him above Maguire, as so many fans do nowadays, feels like a huge oversight. McGuire, at least, felt like an essential part of the Spider-Man films; Garfield never did. He was just "there."

Most importantly, it's good thing that Garfield gets to move on - he was wasted here in a role that didn't allow him to breathe or stretch his legs.

Advertisement

2. Mark Ruffalo - The Hulk - The Avengers/The Avengers: Age Of Ultron

Marvel/Paramount

When Mark Ruffalo replaced Ed Norton in the role of Dr. Bruce Banner in the MCU (Norton left over "creative differences"), there was a collective sigh of relief from Marvel fans the world over, all who deemed the actor to be perfect for the part. Ruffalo merged effortlessly with the established Avengers, of course, and gave a performance that was both endearing and memorable? Uh, maybe.

Advertisement

All these years later, nobody has ever stopped to consider whether Mark Ruffalo really is as great a Banner as we've all proclaimed him to be. Or, you know, whether he's just a lot better than Ed Norton in the role (which isn't saying much) or - worse of all - just kind of playing Mark Ruffalo.

Because there is an argument to be had, unfortunately, that Mark Ruffalo's performance in The Avengers movies is average at best. Of all the Avengers, he's the one member of the cast who doesn't really lend himself to the comic book aesthetic in full force; everyone else has a cartoonish or tongue in cheek way about them, but Ruffalo - he's straight out of an indie drama.

Advertisement

This isn't supposed to be an attack on this talented actor's performances in these films; he's perfectly fine in them, but what about Ruffalo screams "perfect Bruce Banner/Hulk" in the same way that Robert Downey Jr. screams "perfect Tony Stark/Iron Man"? Not a whole lot. I often find myself getting caught up in the idea that Mark Ruffalo is an amazing Hulk, followed by a niggling seed of doubt at the back of my mind. One which says: "Have we given the guy more credit than he deserves?"

1. Christian Bale - Batman - The Dark Knight Trilogy

Warner Bros.

If asked what your favourite part of Christopher Nolan's Batman movies happened to be, chances are you'd end up saying something like Heath Ledger's Joker, or the dark aesthetic, or the Batman Begins training sequence, or - why not? - Michael Caine's Alfred Pennyworth. Rarely, though, would you find a response to this question to be: "Christian Bale as Batman."

Advertisement

And yet Christian Bale has often himself pegged as "the best Batman" on account of his involvement in what are without a doubt the best Batman movies to date. Fans often deem him to be the Dark Knight incarnate because he happens to be the main character in three rather excellent films. In a way, that makes sense.

But he's not really the person who springs to mind when you you think about The Dark Knight trilogy, is he? And there's a scientific reason for that. Okay, it's not really a scientific reason, but it might as well be: as a performer, Bale doesn't really bring anything memorable or interesting to the table as the Caped Crusader.

Advertisement

We have come to think of him as the definitive Batman, but for all the wrong reasons; through his association with Christopher Nolan, and because the competition - Val Kilmer, George Clooney, to name but two previously erroneous Batmen - had been mostly unsuccessful in their attempts.

In reality, Christian Bale is a rather a plain and generic rendering of the iconic superhero; Bale gives one of his least interesting performances in the role, and has even admitted to being disappointed with his own achievements as the iconic superhero (especially when compared to what Heath Ledger did with the Joker in The Dark Knight).

Advertisement

When you think of Batman v Superman, you think about Ben Affleck. For all that film's flaws, you still come away from Zack Snyder's overtly bombastic film with Affleck's version of the character heavy on your mind. Christian Bale never managed that across three movies. As such, it only makes sense that we stop with these empty declarations, praising him as "the best Batman." He isn't.

Oh, and his Batgrowl was plainly silly.

Advertisement

Which other comic book movie performances do you think are over-rated? Share your picks below in the comments thread.