7 Reasons John Woo Should Direct The Expendables 3

7 reasons why John Woo needs to direct the third Expendables film.

By Shaun Munro /

With multiple websites this morning picking up on the fact that an Internet campaign is fiercely underway to entice John Woo to direct The Expendables 3, we got to thinking about how awesome an idea this would actually be. Given the fairly middling returns of the first two films, inviting the heralded - and, admittedly, oft-criticised - action director into the fray will, above all else, have interesting results. Here's our 7 reasons why John Woo should direct the third Expendables film, which is all-but confirmed, given that the second film is gearing up to gross $300m worldwide in no time at all.

1. "A John Woo Film..."

Few will argue with the fact that the first two Expendables films were directed with a sure anonymity; there was no personality to the direction beyond Sylvester Stallone - who helmed the first film - opting for a relatively generic level of grit, emphasised by headache-inducing "shaky cam". For The Expendables 2, Simon West was brought on board, a maddeningly inconsistent choice, and his job largely consisting of undoing everything in Sly's direction that people complained about. The result was a film less of a pain to watch, but it still crucially lacked energy and a real strong, vocal charge at its forefront. A John Woo film, by comparison, is unequivocally an "event" film of sorts, which one can't really say about Stallone - who kept his directing credit advertised to a minimum - or the guy who directed Con Air, but also blessed us with cinematic atrocities like Lara Croft: Tomb Raider and The General's Daughter. While Woo's films have hardly all been excellent, the man's films are something that generate buzz by name alone, and in a business that's all about box office, that's a very important thing. If the first two films did solid business without this, the addition of Woo could be box office dynamite.

2. Unique Visual Style

But why has Woo earned this rep? Primarily, it is going to be for his striking and unique visual style which has been copied in everything from Hollywood action films (The Matrix) to popular video games (Max Payne). The "heroic bloodshed" subgenre that Woo fashioned was known for its hyper-stylised - though not epileptic - treatment of violence, turning ferocious gunplay into a balletic cadence that one might even be able to deem artistic. We all know the tropes; the super slow-motion, the shoot-and-dive manoeuvring, the doves flying out of harm's way, and it's all part of the man's personal directorial signature. It is easy to tell Woo's films apart from anyone else's, and it's undeniable that his unique take on the action film would only give The Expendables 3 a more macho, and indeed, more awesome sheen. Given the auto-direction of the previous films, rendered without much personality, Woo would give us that in spades above all else.

3. Versatility

Though Woo is best-known and most-applauded for his work in Hong Kong cinema - more often than not teaming with the likes of Chow Yun-fat - he has demonstrated a certain versatility in his later years, as he moved to Hollywood and continued to work as a commercially successful - if not critically acclaimed - action director, delivering the likes of Broken Arrow, Hard Target, Face/Off and Paycheck. Given the cast of The Expendables is primarily American, it's important that Woo has worked with American action stars, both so that he can cope with their massive egos and the super-stardom, and that he is better in tune with the American myth of the action hero; as such, he is extremely well-equipped to know what American as well as Asian audiences want. Having worked with Jean-Claude Van Damme (who played the antagonist in EX2 himself), alongside hugely popular Hollywood stars like Ben Affleck, Tom Cruise, Nicolas Cage and John Travolta, Woo knows what he's doing, even if he hasn't reached the heights of Face/Off ever since (at least in American cinema).

4. He Can Do Epic

John Woo returned to his native cinema for the five-hour epic Red Cliff, and with that, he made it abundantly clear that he can do action on not only a confined, frenetic scale, but a gigantic - and surprisingly intelligent, intricate - one, too. Depicting the Battle of Red Cliffs, which brought about the end of the Han Dynasty and helped establish the Three Kingdoms era of Ancient China, Woo's effort is surprisingly restrained, but still visually stunning and action-packed, simply reining in some of the excesses that he is usually known for. However, it is a film that fans of restraint and fans of Woo's other work both enjoy, because it is Woo at his most pragmatic; he works off of a fantastic script, and gets free-rein to work his magic on the plentiful action scenes, which take up a great deal of the latter part of the film. The point? Woo proved that if The Expendables 3 took things on a grander scale - a gigantic firefight over a large area, for instance - that he would be just as capable as if it were two men in a room ducking and diving at one another. Given how vast some of the set-pieces in the series have been so far, this is comforting to know, and a great reason why Woo would make sure we feel how epic it all is.

5. He Can Do Emotion

It goes without saying that both Expendables films thus far have absolutely suffered jarring shifts in tone; during the first, it occurred as Mickey Rourke delivered a meaningful, surprisingly well-acted monologue about a mission in his past gone awry. So well-acted and sombre was it that it really detracted from the fun temporarily, and didn't really feel like it had any place in what we were watching. Similarly, in EX2, Simon West gives us plenty of downtime in which the characters - particularly Liam Hemsworth's tortured young soldier - exchange graphic war stories, again diluting what is first and foremost meant to be a goofy homage to 80s action and a celebration of what is essentially irresponsible, consequence-free violence. If the screenplay again saddles the crew with an inconsistent tone, John Woo might have a better shot at pulling it off, if his CV is anything to go by. Bullet in the Head was a fiercely emotional film against expectations, and similarly, A Better Tomorrow and The Killer are completely rooted in well-drawn characters, much moreso than one would anticipate. Woo's knack for combining gratuitous violence easily alongside more tender, thoughtful moments makes it clear to us that he'll have a much easier time weathering a script that might try and derail the tone.

6. He'll Make It Go the Distance

If Woo's back catalogue is anything to go by, then he probably couldn't make a short film to save his life. If anything, the existing Expendables films really lack that "epic" feel because they're just too damn short, running in at 103 minutes a-piece (so that's about 95 minutes without credits). The run-time wouldn't be so much of an issue if brisk thrills were the order of the day, but EX2 in particular is steeped in far too much downtime, in which the characters gas over cheesy gags, rather than just getting on with the mayhem (almost 45-minutes goes by in EX2 without a proper set-piece in the film's middle section). Woo, however, clearly lives for excess and his films rarely clock in at much under 120 minutes, especially his Hollywood ones. Sure, we can joke that this is because he films so much of it in slow-motion, but you're guaranteed to get your money's worth and a story that doesn't rush itself when Woo is at the helm.

7. He Needs to Prove Himself

Though Woo went a fair way to redeeming himself with the stellar Red Cliff, his critical favour took a massive hit once he moved to Hollywood in 1993, and he has only made one inarguably great film there - the inscrutable Face/Off - such that he still needs to prove himself once again to American audiences. While it's certainly a question as to whether Woo was disappointed with his American films, and whether he feels at all inclined to prove himself, we as viewers need to see Woo make another classic actioner on the level of Face/Off. While a third Expendables film might not seem the arena in which to do that, one can only imagine that in the wake of the likes of Hard Target and Broken Arrow, critics and commentators said the very same thing about Face/Off, and look how that turned out. On the other hand, if Woo does feel up to the challenge and does want to prove himself, then we should buckle up, because when Woo goes all out - as we all know - there's virtually no rivalling him in the action arena, safe for perhaps the likes of James Cameron and Christopher Nolan. Time will tell as to whether this wish is fulfilled, but how do you think a Woo Expendables film would fare? Let us know in the comments below.