7 Times Hollywood Whitewashed (And Straightwashed) Comic Book Characters
Seriously, why is this still even a thing?
Monday's announcement that Ed Skrein would not, in fact, be taking on the role of Ben Daimo in Neil Marshall's upcoming Hellboy reboot generated a heck of a lot of interest this week.
The actor, most famous for playing Ajax in last year's Deadpool, was announced for the role the week beforehand, but many quickly alerted to the fact that Daimo was of asian descent in the original Mignola B.P.R.D. comic; Skrein's casting in the role, so to speak, seemingly typified Hollywood's laissez faire approach to casting, and - in the comic book genre at least - whitewashing has been a topic of conversation for a while.
Skrein's decision to resign from the role must of course be commended; it's a bold step for any actor to take, particularly one such as he, who would've undoubtedly benefited from a starring role in the already promising Rise of the Blood Queen. It must be said, however, that the genre (both on screen and off it), has a massive problem regarding representation. Both POC and LGBT* characters are frequently erased from the conversation, with whitewashing and indeed straightwashing having proven prevalent amongst the big two for what feels like decades at this point.
Things simply have to change, and we can only hope that Skrein's message - that representation matters - signals a change in attitude sooner, rather than later.
7. The Ancient One: Whitewashed
The most famous and indeed recent instance of whitewashing did, of course, come with 2016's Doctor Strange. British actress Tilda Swinton was cast in the role, who in the comics was originally a Tibetan Monk.
Granted, the original depiction of the character in the OG Strange series has faced its own fair share of criticism, but Marvel's decision to erase the character's Tibetan heritage felt calculated, and even cynical, with Robert Cargill in particular having surmised that the effort to change the character of the Ancient One came from the fear that China - itself having suppressed Tibet for decades - would ban the film from being screened.
It's no excuse, whichever way you look at it, especially in light of Marvel's other, more recent controversies...
6. Mystique: Straightwashed
Fox's X-Men series is a whole lot of things, but - when it comes to Mystique at least - they aren't all that authentic.
In the comics, Raven Darkholme (played by Rebecca Romjin in the original series and by Jennifer Lawrence later on) is bisexual, having had a longtime affair with fellow mutant Destiny. Mystique would, of course, give birth to Nightcrawler, and later fostered Rogue with Destiny too, but her love for her longtime partner was a constant force throughout.
While the character of Irene Adler is yet to get a live action nod, that shouldn't stop Fox from representing Mystique as she is in the comics. Portrayed as being somewhat one-note in the original series, the character has - for better or for worse - received a great deal of exploration in the post-First Class state of things.
Her relationship with Eric has, thankfully, received a more authentic portrayal in recent years too, so hopefully the character's sexuality will finally get acknowledged in the upcoming Dark Phoenix.
5. Ra's Al Ghul: Whitewashed
Since his introduction to the comics medium in the seventies, the Head of the Demon himself, Ra's Al Ghul, has always been depicted as being of Middle Eastern heritage. He's one of Batman's greatest enemies, and that's been a constant for the four or so decades he's been on the comics scene. As for that other, live action scene, however, well... it's been rather white, hasn't it?
Liam Neeson took on the part in Batman Begins, and Australian Matt Nable was cast in the role in... whatever Arrow is. Those two aside, the character has also been mainly voiced by white voice actors in both the gaming and animated mediums, with only the Israeli actor Oded Fehr having been appropriately chosen for the part in the short-lived (though soon to be revived) Young Justice.
Given the character's popularity, he's bound to get a live action appearance again later down the line - hopefully in a more authentic light.
4. Okoye And Ayo: Straightwashed
Another MCU controversy this time, and one that came off the back of Civil War too, no less.
In the comics, the Dora Milaje are the Black Panther's bodyguards. Introduced by writer Christopher Priest during the brilliant 'Client' storyline, Okoye and Nakia were the first bodyguards of T'Challa's reign, with the latter having vied for his affections until, wouldn't you know it, she double crossed the King, taking on the role of Malice after having been revived by Eric Killmonger (a perfect comic book name if there ever was one).
Anyway, Okoye remained a member of T'Challa's personal guard, with newcomer Ayo having been introduced during Ta-Nehisi Coates, Roxane Gay and Yona Harvey's seminal World of Wakanda. There, it was revealed that Ayo - now joined by Aneka - were romantically linked, and their relationship featured prominently throughout the series.
Marvel's reaction to the buzz generated by their inclusion in Civil War was crass, to say the very least. Instead of even offering the slightest encouragement that fans would, in the next few years at least, see an LGBT* hero in the MCU, they simply turned around and said that their relationship was not, in fact, "a romantic one".
We're still waiting on that LGBT* hero, Marvel...
3. Iron Fist: Whitewashed
Yes, we get it, Danny Rand has always been white in the comics. But the whitewashing here, so to speak, is more historic and contextual than it is necessarily traditional.
You see, the character of Iron Fist was created at a time when comics were dominated by white male voices, and, for the most part, white male readers. The thought of having an Asian-American protagonist simply wasn't broached, and so the character of Danny Rand - a caucasian millionaire and martial-arts master - was created as an analogue for the seventies' newfound martial-arts craze: a process that the character's co-creator stands by (wrongfully) to this day.
What many readers fail to understand is that the Iron Fist mantle is so much more than Rand himself. In Matt Fraction and Ed Brubaker's criminally overlooked run on the character, the full history of the Iron Fist is explored in depth, with there having been 65 other incarnations of the Immortal Weapon prior to his assumption of the mantle.
One such character was Wu Ao-Shi, the so-called Pirate Queen of Pinghai Bay, who assumed the mantle in the 16th century. Other Iron Fists include Bei Bang-Wen - who fought against the British Empire during the Opium War - and Wah Sing-Rand, who took on the mantle in the 31st century. Point being, the character of Danny Rand isn't intrinsic to the role of the Iron Fist; Marvel could've quite easily created a whole new character to fit the bill - one that divested from the original Gil Kane, Roy Thomas creation.
And let's be honest, in spite of Danny's somewhat tempered onscreen redemption, he's never going to get a warm reception. Marvel could (and should, really) shake things up with a Daughters of the Dragon show, which would feature Colleen Wing and Misty Knight as the leads.
Hey, it certainly beats Heroes for Hire for now...
2. Fox: Whitewashed
Granted, 2008's Wanted wasn't all that great to begin with, but still, a whitewash is a whitewash, and the film featured one in a key role.
In the original Mark Millar and J. G. Jones comic, Fox - portrayed by Angelina Jolie on film - was modelled on Halle Berry. And while Jolie certainly worked the part well, that doesn't detract from the fact that the character was party to a particularly toxic Hollywood trend - one creator Mark Millar didn't seem to mind at all, seeing as how he had an influence in the casting process itself.
Halle Berry will, however, be making an appearance (for real) in the upcoming Kingsman: The Secret Circle - another Millar project - and will mark the star's first return to comic book-dom since 2014's X-Men: Days of Future Past.
1. John Constantine: Straightwashed
As opposed to Deadpool, whose creators willingly approached the idea of having a same-sex relationship depicted on the big screen in the future, bisexual Liverpudlian John Constantine has received no such luxury on either film or TV.
Created by Alan Moore as a guest character in a 1984 issue of Swamp Thing, England's premier occult detective has received not one, but two live action adaptations over the years. The 2005 Keanu Reeves feature was, while passable, just not a Constantine story in any sense of the word; never mind the fact they americanised the anti-hero and his pronunciation (it's Constan-tyne, guys), they totally erased any semblance of the character's canonical bisexuality too.
And then came NBC's much maligned though wholly enjoyable TV show, which starred Matt Ryan as the eponymous character. Produced by David S. Goyer, calls for the series to acknowledge some of the character's most iconic traits - including his chainsmoking and, y'know, the whole bi-thing - fell on deaf ears. Worse yet, Goyer (who's no stranger to unfaithful comic book adaptations, let's face it) straight up condescended fans who'd rallied behind the #BiBlazer hashtag, as did Daniel Cerone, who said that they'd maybe - potentially - get round to depicting the character properly "20 years from now". Nice.
Constantine is still waiting on Hollywood to acknowledge his sexuality, twelve years after they got it wrong the first time. Time will only tell if the long-gestating Dark Universe will go there (and there's really no excuse that it shouldn't), but still, the character's treatment exemplifies a worrying Hollywood trend that has not only afflicted comic book characters throughout the years, but wider literary figures too.
So yeah, stop with all this washing stuff, Marvel, DC, Dark Horse - whatever; follow in Ed Skrein's footsteps, and make sure that the marginalised characters of the genre get the respect - and indeed, the representation - that they so sorely deserve.
-
Are there any other characters out there that we missed? Be sure to let us know in the comments below!