8 Animated Disney Films That Really Shouldn't Be Called Classics

Can you really call all the Disney back-catalogue classics? We'd argue not.

By Alex Leadbeater /

Ignoring those produced by other animation houses, Walt Disney Pictures have made 53 animated features. Or, as the company likes to phrase it, they've produced 53 animated 'classics'. Now Disney, even for you that's a little egotistical. In the early 40's, Disney was the Pixar of its day, casually churning out hit after hit that could conceivably be called classics; Bambi, Dumbo, Fantasia among others. But there's been seventy years of development with incredibly mixed results. From short compendiums to The Black Cauldron, Disney have been as well defined by their misses as their hits. So this classic labelling exists for one of two reasons; either the execs have incredibly selective memories or they're using gross exaggeration to ensure their reputation never takes the same knock in did in the mid-eighties. If it's the latter (and of course, we know it is), then it's been a major success. Fans will cherish the Disney Animation name, willing to pay the inflated DVD prices to own the films which are only available during limited release windows. But in all the hoo-ha some less than deserving films have become accepted by the public as real classics, be it through the companies reinforcement of quality or fondly remembered childhood viewings. Few of these films are godawful, but as we'll see with the eight on this list, they clearly don't deserve such lofty titles.

8. The Princess And The Frog

The Princess And The Frog marked a return to the traditional fairy tale story that had made Disney€™s name decades before but had since become clichéd and uncool. Adapting The Frog Prince (or rather, more recent novel The Frog Princess) in a New Orleans setting, the film caused a bit of a stir for bringing us the first black princess; why had it taken this long to happen and did it really matter? It turns it did matter; the film didn't perform as expected at the box office and the commonly accepted reason is that race got in the way. That initially crackpot (and potentially dated) theory gains some credence when you consider that both fans and critics responded with outpouring adoration. And that's in itself is strange. The film was certainly pretty, but it reached that point where things were moving so slowly and un-creatively that each new song (and there€™s a lot) elicits a groan; after the first three, the musical numbers only serve to pad out the run time. Of course there was a lot riding on The Princess And The Frog. As Disney€™s first 2D cell animated feature in five years, it was a last ditch effort for the medium and thus it was very easy for people to go easy on it. But as we'll see later on, importance to cinema isn't what you really want in a classic.

7. Alice In Wonderland

When it was first released in 1951 Alice In Wonderland disappointed. A very slight film, it was too strange for families and too unfaithful to Lewis Carroll's books for fans of the material. Over time, however, opinion changed. It€™s vibrant colours and psychedelic weirdness gave it a boost in popularity during the sixties and by the time Tim Burton€™s live-action misfire rolled around it was treated as if he was tackling hallowed ground. Quite why Alice's reputation has grown since release is perplexing; it seems much of the adoration has come from the context surrounding the film, rather than the seventy-five minutes themselves. The plot is prescriptively episodic and while the mostly unfazed protagonist is a lot of fun, it€™s only the designs that are memorable. And the designs were all that was needed to make this iconic. Alice is a mainstay of the Princess line and her strange cohorts with their instantly recognisable designs are a regular sight at Disneyworld. In fact, out of all the Princess-based films from that era Alice In Wonderland is the most recognisable. Don€™t be fooled by Wonderland€™s ubiquity into thinking the original product is the source of all the love; the characters are classic, the film itself is not.

6. The Aristocats

Yes, those kittens are incredibly cute. So cute it makes deconstructing the film they're in a very hard task. But The Aristocats is over-rated, so it must be done. The first film produced after Walt€™s death, The Aristocats is Disney working at half steam. There's some good ideas in there €“ the Parisian/French countryside is a unique setting and the villain actually has a motivation beyond being evil (something that, when you think about it, wasn't true in earlier flicks) €“ which, coupled with the adorable kittens, make it impossible to hate. But it's so middle-of-the-road that the adoration it still holds seems strange. It is undoubtedly a great movie for kids and it's not totally vapid for adults, but there's just nothing special about it. There's no surprises in the story or a sense of freshness, but I guess the real issue is that it feels like the bridge between the realistic, human world-dominated animal features 101 Dalmatians and The Jungle Book and the less parent-friendly fare to come. For every catchy song there's an irritating side character who has no business being there; each smart observation of how cat's really act is off-set by contrived storytelling.

5. Winnie The Pooh

Another outing for the inhabitants of the Hundred Acre Wood, Winnie The Pooh was Disney€™s final 2D animated movie, but after the disappointment with The Princess And The Frog it was given much less of a marketing fanfare. The press coverage it did get, however, was overwhelmingly positive. And the film does have some really strong elements; the songs are brilliant (up there with the studio's best), the voice acting spot on and the animation both polished and within the spirit of the original books. Unfortunately it commits that carnal sin of being completely boring. The film comes in at just over an hour and yet feels stretched beyond belief. There are two thin plots, one involving finding Eeyore€™s tail and another that shows the group rallying against a terrifying (and completely imaginary) monster. It's all tied together by Pooh€™s search for honey, and every bit of it feels inconsequential. When compared to The Many Adventures Of Winnie The Pooh, which runs only ten minutes longer but fits in five stories, the issue is only highlighted. It€™s good for young kids, offering nothing scary or complicated, but you feel their siblings only a couple of years older won€™t have had such a joyful time. There€™s much better outings for Christopher Robin and co. that deserve your praise.

4. Aladdin

Aladdin is a good Disney film. It€™s got characters that are individually given depth and there appears to be no limit in the ambition of the animation, which are the two key reasons you€™d watch any of the company's films. But that€™s not enough to crown it a classic. Aladdin came sandwiched between two of the finest films Disney has ever produced (Beauty And The Beast and The Lion King), and that really should only have highlighted the film for what it was. But instead it was swept up in the hype, with little attention paid to its deeper qualities. Front and centre there's the Genie. A massive audience draw upon release, Disney ignored Williams' request to keep a low profile by putting the lamp-dweller at the front of their advertising campaign. The real effect the decision had on the film is how dated it's become by his presence. The jokes are still funny today, but Robin Williams isn't so much, shattering the film's purported timeless quality. But, much more damning, the character interplay wasn't as natural as the surrounding films. Looking at how the relatively simple relationship of Aladdin and Jasmine plays out compared to Ariel and Eric or Belle and Beast there€™s a notable lack of chemistry; it feels like first love, not the Disney patented €˜true€™ love.

3. Robin Hood

The main criticism Robin Hood tends to draw is that it reused animation from previous hits to make up for its lacking budget. While that's certainly worth mentioning, it€™s neither a good or bad thing €“ a little uncreative, sure, but the idea€™s still quite smart. Besides, Robin Hood, whose fans do tend to be those who experienced it in an impressionable stage of childhood, has plenty else working against it. After so many adaptations of all manner of stories that feel like the definitive version, Robin Hood came along as just one indistinct reimagining among many. The big cause of this is the character designs. Anthropomorphised animals are fun, but here they€™re in a world of their own; we're not simply looking into a magical past or a community hidden amongst the human world. It€™s unjustified and makes the dark parts (hanging Friar Tuck) feel silly. Disney never made this mistake again, although Pixar did with Cars to a similar response. The project was originally going to be a version of Reynard the Fox, but after that was deemed not morally suitable it seems the idea of a fox was simply transferred across to the British myth. Now that's uncreative.

2. Snow White And The Seven Dwarves

Woah there. Put away the pitchforks, stop writing those angry comments and let me explain. Snow White And The Seven Dwarves is without a doubt the most influential animated film ever made. The new animation techniques of 101 Dalmatians and the CGI melding of The Lion King look simplistic next to the equally brave and genius decision to make a feature-length animated movie. People will never forget that, and they really shouldn't. But a film doing something groundbreaking doesn€™t instinctively make a classic. Toy Story may have shook up the world in a manner similar to Snow White almost sixty years later, but what makes that film endure is it€™s script; the characters are believable and the story has real, relatable stakes. Snow White€™s real problem in that area is it€™s titular heroine. The dwarves are purposely simplistic and the Evil Queen is an utter delight, but Snow White is bland. Just letting the plot happen around her, the passive characterisation could be chalked up to sexist hallmarks of the time, but really it€™s just poor writing. Alice was passive too, but she had moments of emotion that reminded us she was a real girl. It is an important piece of cinema history, but as a film taken on its own merits Snow White doesn€™t astound.

1. The Fox And The Hound

Every studio has a film that feels like an imitator has come in and tried to copy the patented formula. The film may not be bad, but it feels flat. Aardman has Pirates! In An Adventure With Scientists, Pixar has Brave and Disney has The Fox And The Hound. Like all faux-imitations, it feels like it could be a very good film. I like the idea of a fox and hound becoming friends and struggling with their prescribed roles in society. It€™s a deviously simple way to present a very important social topic to children. The execution of it in this film, however, makes it seem like the idea isn€™t strong enough on its own (which it most certainly is). Tod (the fox) doesn€™t need to be owned by an old lady or otherwise to come into contact with Copper (the hound), and in doing so the story is given a confusingly unnecessary emotional crutch. What€™s more ridiculous is that the film, rather than letting nature take its course, throws in a solely narrative reason for Copper to turn against Tod, with the former blaming the latter for injuring his friend/mentor. Now we€™re in generic friend-cum-enemy territory, with none of the social intrigue the base concept promised. All the other Disney traits are there €“ silly sidekicks, plenty of songs €“ to just the right level (even if the music is forgettable), but that can€™t save the irritating and over thought plot. Think any of these movies actually are classics? Which Disney movie do you personally find overrated? As always the comments are the place to say it.