8 Disappointing Endings To 8 Awesome Films

It’s a sad fact of life that even the most enjoyable of movies can be let down by a lacklustre ending...

By Robert Keeling /

It€™s a sad fact of life that even the most enjoyable of movies can be let down by a lacklustre ending. It can be a mighty fine piece of filmmaking, gripping, tense and engrossing, only to leave you completely deflated come the dénouement as all that good work suddenly goes to waste. Sometimes it€™s a completely illogical turn of events, a completely crowbarred in deus ex machina or perhaps just a really dull and unimaginative resolution to a film€™s story. The movies I€™ve chosen here represent a wide range of genres and include some big name directors too, proof that even the masters of the art form can occasionally have an off day. Just a brief warning, as this is a list about movie endings, I cannot emphasise enough how much of a big fat SPOILER ALERT is required here.

8. The Birds

Even the maestro himself is allowed to make the odd mistake I guess. The Birds is a typically Hitchcockian thriller and though not amongst his every best, it€™s nonetheless a tense and gripping film as one would expect from the Hitch in his prime. The effects may look a touch dated to our 21st Century eyes, but the peril facing Tippi Hedren€™s Melanie and Rod Taylor€™s Mitch as they and the rest of their community are continually attacked by flocks of birds, is ramped up brilliantly as the film goes on. It€™s all racing towards a big climax as Melanie, Mitch and his family take refuge in their home as the birds close in. They even break through the roof and viciously attack Melanie, leaving her in a state of shock. How will they ever get out of this terrible situation? Well, they just stroll out of the front door, saunter over to their car and drive quietly away as the birds suddenly go all docile. Talk about an anti-climax. It is slightly eerie seeing all the birds sat there watching the humans leave, but it is still ultimately a bit of cinematic shrug of the shoulders. Imagine if Zulu ended with Michael Caine and his mates just wandering out of Rorke€™s Drift midway through the battle and slowly shuffling past the watching Zulu warriors who decide to have a bit of a breather. Ok, so it€™s not an exact comparison, but you see my point.

7. Sunshine

Danny Boyle€™s Sci-Fi movie Sunshine has divided critics since its release, some singing its praises, others left bored and disinterested by the whole affair. I imagine many who have seen the film however fall into a third category of viewer. They enjoyed it for the most part, namely while it was atmospheric , unsettling and full of an unmistakable creeping dread as the crew hurtled ever closer to the sun, but who were then disappointed with the film€™s out of place ending. After all the slowly building tension and questioning of the origins of the Universe and matters of God and atheism and so forth, it is slightly strange to then shift to the tried and tested horror movie cliché of numerous slasher movies and have a crazed mad man unrelentingly stalk our heroes. Suddenly it goes from existential Sci-Fi to I Know What You Did Last Summer. By throwing this curve ball in at the film€™s end, perhaps in an attempt to up the excitement quota as the movie neared its climax, the film loses a lot of its impact and all that good work Boyle did in the first three quarters of the movie feels a little bit wasted.

6. War of the Worlds (2005)

Maybe I€™m stretching the €˜awesome€™ tag here a little bit, but hey, my list, my rules. Spielberg€™s adaptation of H.G. Welles€™ classic Sci-Fi tale is, for the most part, a fairly enjoyable big-budget romp. The fact that the aliens die thanks to micro viruses and other such tiny organisms, we have to let go as, despite it being a bit of a cop out, that€™s what Welles said in his book and so we can€™t lay the blame at Spielberg€™s feet there. However the decision to make everything all sunshine and lollypops we very much can. After all the death and devastation, Tom Cruise€™s Ray rather easily finds the surprisingly unscathed home of his in-laws and who€™s inside, why only his long-assumed dead son who somehow survived an incredibly violent attack and made his way to Boston all on his own. Now that€™s just frankly ridiculous. Come on Steven, let the kid die. Let him go. It makes so much more sense and is one less plot contrivance to worry about.

Advertisement

5. The Lord of the Rings : Return of the King

Ok, I know this has been done to death and it will come as no surprise to anyone that this ending makes the list, but we can€™t ignore the fact that Return of the King really does take about 25 minutes to just bloody end. Ahhhhh they€™ve made it to Mordor€..oh, now the Hobbits are bowing to no one is that the€..oh wait they€™re back in the shire and Sam€™s getting married, seems a little superfluous but there we€.oh no wait, Frodo€™s writing his memoirs, fair enough it would make a good book one day that€€.oh what now? They are going to the undying lands€..good€be gone€..I€™ve needed a wee since the eagles finally arrived, I just want it to be over now. Obviously, the filmmakers want to be loyal to their source material and need to make sure they wrap everything which is covered in the books, but they€™ve already skimped here, seen as they miss out the whole €˜returning to the shire and finding it overrun with orcs€™ factor, so a bit more trimming wouldn€™t have hurt. My point here is that books and movies are two very different mediums and what goes for one may not necessarily work for the other. Any film which resolves its main story arc and then has about four more endings on top of that is always going to lose a bit of impact.

4. Superman

Richard Donner€™s 1978 superhero film was quite rightly a smash hit and paved the way for numerous comic book movies which followed. For the most part it€™s a great movie with Christopher Reeve giving a career-defining performance as Kal-El/Clark Kent/Superman. As Lex Luthor€™s dastardly scheme hurtles towards its fateful conclusion, Supes is left with a devastating choice as two missiles are heading in two different directions and even he can€™t be in multiple places at once. After saving Hackensack New Jersey, he is too late to save his beloved Lois Lane and she dies a tortuous death by suffocation. How are they going to get out of this one? Obvious isn€™t it? Just hit the reset button. Have Superman fly around the world really REALLY fast and it will reverse time and allow him to save his beloved. Two things spring to mind here, firstly going back in time is a massive deus ex machina and is perhaps the ultimate screenplay cop-out next only to €˜it was all a dream€™. Secondly, and this is perhaps less important given the type of film Superman was, but it makes literally no sense. Why would flying around the world turn back time anyway? I know I€™m looking for logic in a film where people are fooled merely by a pair of glasses, but still.

3. Source Code

Duncan Jones€™ debut feature Moon was a superb Sci-Fi movie, novel, innovative and excellently executed. As such there was a lot of anticipation surrounding his follow up Source Code, and the trailer certainly whetted appetites further. The premise is a great one, put simply, when somebody dies their brain stays semi-alive for a brief spell after death, during which time, scientists have invented a way to plug into the last 8 minutes of their memory and allow another person to relive those final minutes as the deceased. The whole movie is built around the idea that what has been created is only a simulation, it is not real, it is merely a fully immersive replica of life itself. So (and stick with me on this one) when Jake Gyllenhall€™s Colter has served his purpose and located the deadly bomb which has struck/will strike, and his 8 minutes are up, he should, by the logic set out in the film itself, cease to exist. Yet somehow, after the 8 minutes runs out, he is still alive and kicking and seemingly living out a life in an alternative reality. The scientists themselves in the film, the ones who explain to us the film€™s central premise, are proven wrong. This in itself is a rarity for a Sci-Fi film as whilst such a movie may not abide by the standard rules of time and space, they do operate within their own set of rules. So in Inception, if you die in a dream, you die in real life. In Back to the Future, if you cease to exist in the past, you are erased from the present. These are concepts that do not apply in our real world, but are cast iron in the movies themselves. In Source Code though, the entire logic of the movie itself is thrown out in favour of a happy ending where Colter inexplicably continues to exist in a parallel universe which has also somehow inexplicably been created. It was so close to being a brilliant movie too!

2. American Gangster

Ridley Scott€™s crime epic is for the most part a riveting cat and mouse character study following Russell Crowe€™s determined Detective Richie Roberts and Denzel Washington€™s ruthless drug dealing gangster Frank Lucas. Lucas is a formidable presence but also a strangely likeable one. Yes he€™s a drug dealer peddling his poisonous narcotics upon vulnerable addicts, but he€™s also charming and charismatic and looks after his ma, so you€™re in effect manipulated into wishing him well. Nevertheless, he€™s a ruthless criminal and he has masterminded an incredibly effective operation for many years. Come the end of the movie though, when Roberts finally has his man, Lucas decides to rat everyone out in order to shorten his sentence and suddenly he€™s something of a hero. Wait€what? Charismatic he may be, but he caused a lot of pain and suffering and killed people in cold blood. Not to worry though, he€™s naming names now so it€™s ok to like him. Now obviously, this is a film based on real life events, yet by all accounts it€™s hardly an accurate depiction of the actual story. Numerous people involved with the case have confirmed that the real life Lucas was a fairly vicious, violent and altogether unlikeable chap, not the loveable rogue portrayed by Denzel. Even the real life Richie Roberts criticised the decision to make Lucas into a noble character. I really love American Gangster, so it€™s all the more disappointing that the ending which paints Lucas in such a positive light, just seems so ill-conceived.

Advertisement

1. Return of the Jedi

Ahhhhh Jedi, for so many years the ire of many a Star Wars fan, and then the prequels came along and suddenly you looked like Citizen Kane in comparison. For all your faults, there was no Jar-Jar, no Hayden Christensen and no €œnooooooooooooooooooooo€ either. Yet there was always something slightly unsatisfying about the end of Jedi somehow. The Ewoks, already too cute, cuddly and annoying by half, have rocks and sticks to fight with, yet somehow they take on and beat the heavily armed stormtroopers using only these rudimentary tools and some surprisingly effective hastily set up booby traps. The Ewoks scream of being brought in purely for marketing reasons and after two films of general space bad-assery, it€™s a touch deflating to have the whole saga resolved in a jungle with midget teddy-bears clubbing storm troopers to death. It€™s widely known that there were original plans for a much darker ending to the Star Wars saga and that George Lucas nixed this idea and decided a unrelentingly happy ending was the order of the day. So, after all those awesome space battles, after Vader and the Emperor almost leaving triumphant and the final reconciliation of father and son on that exploding space station, how does one of the all-time greatest film trilogies end? An Ewok dance party. Oh George. What were you thinking? It€™s all far too sugary and lacks any power as a result. It sees the whole saga end on a massive saccharine anti-climax.