The definition of "method acting" has become so confused and so open to interpretation at this point that it's probably easier to just throw it out and start again. But here's a term that the world at large likes to bring into conversation at least once a week in order to sound hip, because what's cooler than an actor who starts acting like a fictional character in real life? "Nothing" is the answer, so don't bother trying to figure it out or anything. In the eyes of the movie-going public, method acting is the one gesture that an actor can make to prove that they like acting better and harder than all the other actors. I mean, think about Daniel-Day Lewis, who is perhaps the world's most famous and revered method actor ever. Three Best Actor Oscars, you say? I mean, if you're not willing to lose half your body weight to play a terminally ill patient on death row, what kind of actor are you? Some people don't think that dropping weight constitutes as method acting, but the best definition I can find denotes that method acting consists of "techniques used by actors to create in themselves the thoughts and feelings of their characters," so dropping weight (or gaining weight, for that matter) certainly makes sense in that context. Same goes for when Robert De Niro drove a taxi to prep for Taxi Driver. It's all method. Sometimes, though, your hard work won't find the appreciation it deserves, no matter how many taxis you drive or how much food you refuse to eat in the months leading up to production. In the cases of the 8 actors I've assembled here, the glory never quite came in the ways they probably expected it to: they were either ignored critically, or by the public at large, when they decided to get "serious" and go balls to the walls method...
8. Joaquin Phoenix - I'm Still Here (2010)
One day a few years ago, Joaquin Phoenix woke up and decided that he wanted to make himself look like a bit of a douchebag, and - alongside brother-in-law Casey Affleck - devised an incredibly unnecessary and elaborate hoax that deconstructed the idea of the "celebrity meltdown" and method acting to the point in which nobody actually cared. To create the illusion that he had gone insane, Phoenix lost himself in a newly-devised persona that saw him growing a huge beard and telling David Letterman that he was bound for a career in hip-hop. This all culminated in the arrival of the mockumentary I'm Still Here, which - at the time of its release - everybody thought was real. It later turned out that Phoenix was simply acting a character and Affleck was in on the joke. I mean, it was an interesting experiment, I guess, but the public weren't really enamoured with the concept in the way I think those two expected them to be (it made less than a $1 million at the box office), especially when they found out that it was all for the sake of art or something. It was, uh, kind of embarrassing.
7. 50 Cent - All Things Fall Apart (2012)
Presumably tired of selling his image for video games that had him shooting terrorists in the Middle East whilst trying to reclaim his diamond-encrusted crystal skull (I wish to God I had made that up), 50 Cent opted to do something a little more personal in form of Mario Van Peeble's AllThings Fall Apart, in which he plays a wannabe football player who suffers from a fatal disease... and must travel to the Middle East to reclaim his diamond-encrusted crystal skull. Not really - I added that crystal skull bit on, but the rest is real, I promise. To play his character, Deon, 50 Cent went all out, in which - I can only imagine - was an attempt to show the world that he can be serious and do good acting, too. Channelling a childhood friend who died of cancer for inspiration, the rapper also lost 54 pounds in 9 weeks, having adopted a liquid diet and an extensive treadmill-based exercise plan. Unfortunately for 50 Cent, Van Peebles isn't a very consistent director, and the movie sucked. Despite his efforts, there was little promotion, and - as far as I can tell - the movie grossed zero dollars.
6. Jared Leto - Chapter 27 (2007)
Maybe it's a musicianal thing, or maybe that's a word I just made up. As was the case with 50 Cent, though, Jared Leto tried to unleash his inner method actor by taking on what should have been a monumental role, and yet it turned out that nobody was interested in watching the singer from 30 Seconds of Mars wandering about looking fat and mental in a movie about the murder of John Lennon. I can't say I blame them, but it's certainly a shame for Leto, who probably thought that this was going to be his big break as a serious actor or something. Chapter 27, which has Leto as the embodiment of Beatle-killer Mark Chapman, was released to little fanfare and almost no critical acclaim, despite Leto's dedicated performance, which required him to "fat up" and wear goofy glasses. Well, he did a lot more than that, to be fair - he went on a liquid diet as soon as he was cast, and contracted gout because of the change in his weight. It also took him over a year to return to his normal body size. Though he did receive some acclaim for his performance, only sixty-eight people saw the movie, apparently, going by the box office receipts - Chapter 27 has grossed a mere $187,000 to date.
5. Meryl Streep - Music of the Heart (1999)
Even when Meryl Streep is being ignored by the public, she still winds up getting nominated for an Oscar. For her turn in the movie Music of the Heart (which was, bizarrely, directed by horror maestro Wes Craven), the actress didn't settle for just learning a casual bit of violin in order to play real-life music teacher and violinist Roberta Guaspari, she decided to do it properly: Streep took up playing the violin for six hours a day for an entire month. Whether or not you're musically-inclined or not, I think we can all agree that that's a whole lotta violin. Anyway, despite the fact that she was nominated for an Oscar for her performance in Heart (like I said, it's impossible for her not to be nominated if she decides to act in any given year), the public didn't really feel like going to see a movie about a music teacher, and it flopped at the box office, raking in barely half of its $28 million budget. The movie received mixed reviews overall, too, which didn't help Streep's case. The actress also apparently played her character as "normally" as possible, as to be make her realistic. People didn't like that.
4. Antonia Campbell-Hughes - 3096 Days (2013)
Sometimes the only way to get into character is to put yourself through a similar experience to that of the character you're playing, which is what Antonia Campbell-Hughes opted for when she signed on to play kidnap victim Natascha Kampusch in little-seen movie 3096 Days. Well, I mean, she didn't get kidnapped or anything, exactly, but she did subject herself to psychical torment by way of a torn achilles tendon, a broken toe, a fractured rib and a whole bunch of cuts and bruises, as a result of the movie's dangerous dungeon set. Campbell-Hughes' most remarkable feat here, though, was her incredible weight lost, which attracted a lot of controversy at a time when a picture of the dramatic transformation was made public, and then everyone forgot about the movie and here we are now, in a world where people don't know how or what 3096 Days even is. To be fair, it isn't a particularly good retelling of what is obviously a very traumatic story, but a lot of critics deemed it unnecessary. It doesn't help that 3096 hasn't even been giving worldwide distribution yet, though.
3. Jim Carrey - Man On The Moon (1999)
You know Jim Carrey best for making funny faces and being generally hyperactive, so what business did this guy have trying to be, like, a proper actor all the way back in 1999, before we had accepted that it was okay for him to do that? None, apparently, going by the box office receipts for Man on the Moon, Milo Forman's biopic of comedian Andy Kaufman. To prepare for his role as Kaufman, Carrey decided that he should just be Kaufman, so that's what he set out to do for the entirety of production: he opted to stay in character. All the time. Those of you who are familiar with the movie might be thinking, "Wait a minute... didn't ol' Jim win a Golden Globe for his performance in this?" You would be right in saying that, but how often do you hear anybody talk about Man on the Moon? When was the last time somebody brought it up? Carrey's performance may have been well-received, but the movie lost $40 million at the box office and received mixed reviews. So although Jim got some recognition for his turn, what we were basically saying was, "Do The Mask 2 or something instead."
2. Adrien Brody - The Jacket (2005)
To get his teeth into his role as a man who spends a lot of time in a straight-jacket, Adrien Brody - best known for that time he dumped his girlfriend so he could feel "sad" for The Pianist - opted to get into a straight-jacket. It doesn't take a genius to figure out how this might've helped him to get into character. The Jacket has Brody starring as a war veteran who gets shot in the head, is accused of murder, and ends up in a mental asylum. There, he's subjected to things like being put in a morgue drawer in a straight-jacket for hours at a time. Aside from actually opting to get into the straight-jacket for real, Adrien Brody also spent time in a sensory desperation chamber, because he didn't feel like dumping his girlfriend again. The idea is that you lay in a thin saline solution and your mind opens, but Brody impressed the crew with his ability to do it for hours at a time. Come release time, nobody could face saying that they were "going out to see The Jacket" 'cause Batman Begins was out, too, and this one kind of died in the water. Or, you know, in a thin saline solution.
1. Christian Bale - The Machinist (2004)
What? The world ignore this? But... but I've seen this picture everywhere! Yes, you might be surprised to find that I've gone insane and included Christian Bale's turn in The Machinist on this list, but there's a totally legit reason as to why I've done that: everybody ignored that this event had even happened until, one day, Christian Bale became more famous, did a bunch more roles that required him to lose weight, and then this picture became, like, the picture for any articles documenting "method acting" or "extreme actor transformations." So, sure, it's a pretty famous image now, but at the time, The Machinist got about as much love as a rabies-infected puppy. It made just $8 million at the box office, during that period of time that has come to be known as "pre-Batman Begins." Bale lost a third of his body weight for his role as a machinist who suffers from a severe case of insomnia. He endangered his health in order to achieve skinniness (medical term), and though - to this day - nobody has actually seen this film, it's become shorthand for "Christian Bale is seriously dedicated to his craft." Like this list? Who have we missed? Let us know in the comments section below.