WBYouve probably seen it theres a meme that continues to buzz around the internet that goes like this: someone will post a questionable story of small-scale social injustice but replace the villain of the story with Bill Murray. Heres one variation from Reddit user Lurker32:
When I was waiting to cross at the 46th and 7th crosswalk I noticed a hand slip around me from behind and grab two of my fries. In my confusion I turned around and HOLY S**T ITS BILL F*****G MURRAY! Before I could get a word out, he yelled over the crowd, No one will ever believe you."
While the stories are rarely, if ever, true they originate through Murrays famously outlandish private life, with stories of firing his agent and replacing them with an answering machine, partying with random teenagers in foreign cities, or face-planting himself onto the floor during rained out baseball matches. But whether or not any of these happened - or to what extent they are exaggerated - is besides the point. Comedy is, after all a construction, one generated through surprise, the improper, and the unlikely. So, the joke - if you missed it - is that Bill Murray as a person even more anarchic than his on screen role. But while these stories are so befitting for the likes of Peter Venkman or Phil Connors, there has been a lot more to Murrays film career than the anarchic folk hero than the internet would have you believe.
8. Meatballs (1979)
Tripper: Kids are starving in Africa and youre walking around with a sombrero full of peanuts. The thought of Bill Murray as a father-figure is a somewhat terrifying one, but his career began with the role of Tripper, a developmentally arrested summer camp worker. The role was written specifically for him by Ivan Reitman following his work on The National Lampoon Show and a mere handful of sketches on Saturday Night Live, and thus was born the Murray persona, defined by Richard Kelly in Sight and Sound, as the countercultural lord of misrule. It was a somewhat controversial decision to cast Murray given his lack of name appeal but Reitman stuck by his decision with almost disastrous conviction. He has recently admitted that when he first approached Murray for the role his response had been Id rather play baseball or golf this summer. Reitman continued his approaches of Murray before finally the day before shooting was set to begin he relented and agreed to star in a move that Reitman attributes to pity. It would be anecdotes like this that Murray would thrive off for the rest of his career and gives some credence to the assertion that Murray is simply playing himself in all of his films. For instance, compare Murrays complete apathy to the opening scene of Meatballs, in which he struggles to rise from his bed to perform the mornings radio duties, to way in which Reitman has characterised him: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yPEfxNbvcjo
7. Stripes (1981)
Sony PicturesWinger: I just wish I hadnt drunk all that cough syrup this morning. Stripes perhaps beats out Signs as being the best example of two-thirds of a great film. Murray and Reitman again teamed up, with Murray playing John Winger, a slacker who, after his life falls apart, decides to enlist in the army. While its always dangerous to overanalyse a film that features a bulletproof caravan its important to note what a symptom of its time Stripes was. America as a nation can be seen to culturally depict itself as a loser during the 1980s following defeats or unresolved conflicts in the Korean War, Cold War and Vietnam and so the choice of a film focusing on the military is a very curious one, particularly given the assortment of losers the film represents the fat John Candy, the uninterested Harold Ramis, and the doughy, slouched posture of Murray.That makes the films final third, in which Czech-born director Ivan Reitman decided that a 1980s comedy was the perfect forum to make us all aware of the political strife the nation of his birth was going through, even more bizarre, as the film veers drastically into Saving Private Ryan territory in perhaps one of the most misplaced finales in comedy history. After absconding in said bulletproof caravan, Murray and his friends take it upon themselves to rescue a prisoner of war. Murrays performance in the final act of Stripes is quite a sight to behold as he begins a bona fide action hero. Perhaps it was with this in mind that made George Lucas tempted to cast him as Han Solo in Star Wars.
6. Tootsie (1982)
Columbia PicturesJeff: Im going to re-write the necktie scene without the necktie. Youd be forgiven for getting that Bill Murray appeared in Tootsie even though its hardly a blink-and-youll-miss-it performance. Murrays Jeff, a drunken writer, is the roommate of Dustin Hoffmans Michael, the struggling actor who cross-dresses in order to get a role in a soap opera. The American Film Institute obviously have a thing for cross-dressing as the only film higher than Tootsie on their list of "100 Laughs" is Some Like It Hot. Curiously, then, despite being one of Murrays lesser known roles, it was in a film thats gone on to by-and-large more critical acclaim than the rest of his roles; the only other entries of his films in the list (compiled in 2000) are Ghostbusters (#28) and Caddyshack (#71).As funny as a man in make-up is, its Murrays Jeff who steals the show as he turns up in a number of scenes such as this one, providing someone for Michael to deliver exposition to which doesnt actually sound that interesting. Murray, though, is probably one of the only actors who can make these scenes work. He blends what could be classified as the Murray persona minimalist acting, sarcastic asides with a real sense of authenticity. One reason for that is that Murray reportedly ad-libbed his entire role. Whether or not thats true is subject for debate but Tootsie would prove to be an early example for the venue for which Murray was perhaps best utilised, namely in a supporting or peripheral role, as can be seen in the likes of Rushmore, The Royal Tenenbaums, or Zombieland.
5. Quick Change (1990)
Warner BrosThe expression the part he was born to play is bandied around all too often in todays society, but Quick Change stars Bill Murray as a clown who robs a bank. You may argue that Murray playing literally the sad clown is perhaps a little on-the-nose in terms of performance signs, but the key to Quick Change is that it legitimately works as a crime film; the way the narrative unfolds, certainly during the bank robbery, are moments that rival the best heist films, and the gangs escape without providing spoilers is genius.The film also marks Murrays second foray behind the camera after 1984s The Razors Edge, written by Murray and based on the W. Somerset Maugham novel, which, despite having its staunch defenders, is generally regarded as a bad film with much of the blame was placed on Murray. With Quick Change Murray turns director a responsibility shared with fellow first-time director Howard Franklin with much better results. Geena Davis is cast as the female lead, perhaps not coincidentally a doppelganger for Signourney Weaver, who famously played Murrays comic foil in Ghostbusters.
4. What About Bob? (1991)
Buena Vista PicturesBob: What if Im looking for a bathroom, I cant find one, and my bladder explodes? There is a great myth amongst Hollywood, at least according to Robert Zemeckis, that film titles with question marks in them are destined to fail hence the grammatically incorrect title Who Framed Roger Rabbit. While Zemeckis rule may in fact be referring to Betteridges rules of headlines (Any headline which ends in a question mark can be answered by the word no) there is still no proof that the exclusion of a question mark puts a film in any better stead, with the correctly titled What About Bob? being one of the more frequently cited examples. It is nonetheless one of Murrays more controversial roles, the source of most of the humour coming from Bobs myriad phobias, introduced to us in a torturous opening scene in which Murray tries to make his way through a building to meet his new psychiatrist, Dr Leo Marvin (Richard Dreyfuss). As the film continues and after a handful of convenient plot turns Marvin grows increasingly frustrated with Bobs behaviour and the lines of whether we are laughing withmental illness or at it comes to the fore. Its a touchy subject, and one that the film has come under a lot of fire for, but the combination of Murrays effervescent charm, the fact that under the surface its a good-hearted film, and a desensitisation to shock comedy in recent years keeps What About Bob? reined in.
3. Mad Dog And Glory(1993)
Universal StudiosFrank Milo: Woman, you cant live with them and you cant kill em. To say the set-up of Mad Dog and Glory is contrived is an understatement. When a timid crime scene photographer saves the life of a mobster who moonlights as a stand-up comedian, he is rewarded with a beautiful young woman. Alongside Murray is Robert De Niro, three years removed from Goodfellas, but in a subversion of what you may be thinking, it is Murray who plays the mobster and De Niro who plays the photographer. How director John McNaughton would want to take credit for this genius casting, but it was actually at De Niros insistence that he didnt play the mobster, opening up the role that would go on to change Bill Murrays career trajectory over the last twenty years. Many cite Rushmore as Murrays renaissance as the darkly comic supporting character, but this was the film that Wes Anderson cites as being the reason he cast Murray in Rushmore. That the film generally received mixed reviews from the public (currently only holding 6.2 on the IMDb) but has garnered great reception from respected critics says a lot particularly given that it is foremost a comedy, where the public tends to be more forgiving. The late, great Roger Ebert wrote that the people who made it must have come to know the characters very well, because although they seem to fit into broad outlines, they are real individuals. However, it is Vincent Canby, writing in the New York Times, who hit the nail on the head: The great satisfaction of Mad Dog and Glory is watching Mr De Niro and Mr Murray play against type with such invigorating ease.
2. Get Low (2009)
Sony Pictures ClassicsFrank: I sold twenty-six of the ugliest cars in the middle of December with the wind blowing so far up my ass I was farting snowflakes into July. If you think theres something unusual about the way Get Low looks its because its shot digitally, something which most will agree does the Western film no favours whatsoever. The reason its pertinent, though, is that digital film is cheaper and more versatile and has thus become synonymous with lower budget films. Get Low is the epitome of independent film drifting somewhere between drama, comedy and folk tale and tells the story of a grouchy old man (Robert Duvall) who hires undertaker Frank Quinn (Murray) to prepare his living funeral.Not much more than that happens but its nonetheless truly captivating viewing, if not for anything other than the repartee between cinematic stalwarts Bill Murray, Robert Duvall, and Sissy Spacek. The role signifies the shift Murray has made towards not only more dramatic roles but more adventurous, riskier, and ultimately fringe filmmaking he has come to make almost exclusively in the past few years. Murray is no longer at the centre of the action but much like the earlier Tootsie pops up every now and then with a comic aside in that knowing, glassy-eyed look of his.
1. Broken Flowers (2005)
Focus FeaturesDon: Well, the past is gone, I know that. The future isn't here yet, whatever its going to be. So, all there is, is this. The present. Thats it. One undeniable truth about the Bill Murray of Broken Flowers is that the past is gone. Gone are the days where Peter Venkman kisses Dana at the end of Ghostbusters or Phil Connors wakes up next to Rita in Groundhog Day. No, now Broken Flowers Don Johnston a name that so cruelly places him in him native 1980s as the Miami Vice hero he never was is a "confirmed bachelor" who trawls through a series of failed past relationships in attempt to find out which of them wrote him a letter claiming to be the mother of his child. Early in the film, Johnston's neighbour, Winston (Jeffrey Wright) a happily married man argues that only Johnston can embark on the trip because you understand women. Sure, Johnston might get the women, but never has the Murray persona been able to understand women. Was the charm of Peter Venkman not how badly he misread situations? His half-jesting comments of I'm going to go for broke, I'm madly in love with you and teasing comments of Look at all the junk food! are here replaced with a truly broken man lost in the world.Its an acting tour de force that brilliantly deconstructs everything that we admired and despised in equal parts of Murrays roles; the charm that made us want to talk about him and sliminess that made us actually believe hed steal fries from strangers on the streets. Murray reportedly considered quitting acting after Broken Flowers as he thought it was the best acting he could ever do and while none of us can ever imagine a time when Murray isnt making films the final moments of Broken Flowers would hardly have been a bad way to bow out.