8 Movies Where The Worst Version Got Made

No one can tell me The Amazing Spider-Man would've been better than Spider-Man 4.

By Ewan Paterson /

Sony Pictures

"What ifs?" are part and parcel of the moviemaking process. Drafts are revised, writers, directors and actors all come and go, and entire projects can fall to the wayside due to a mixture of the above or to a myriad of other factors, like scheduling conflicts or budget issues.

Advertisement

Movie production is fraught with peril, and while filmmakers perform little miracles all the time, sometimes those currents are too hard to battle, and the resulting product pales in comparison to what was initially envisioned - or at the least fails to live up to those early-production ambitions.

It's difficult to say whether or not an unrealised project would've bettered a disappointing release - filmmaking is a fluid process, and projects change all the time - but in premise alone it's easier to assess what would or would not be more compelling. The same could also be argued for the kind of talent attached, and wondering how they would've marshalled a given story differently.

Advertisement

From ill-fated sequels to doomed adaptations, here are those movies where the worst version ended up on the big screen.

8. Lethal Weapon 4

Warner Bros.

One of the most fascinating parts of Lethal Weapon as a series is the oscillating tonal battles that took place behind the scenes. The first film, written by Shane Black with some rewrites by Jeffrey Boam, is this gritty, post-Vietnam action film that tackles PTSD and the legacies of the conflict, while the second is a fun, slightly goofball adventure that sees Riggs and Murtaugh take on some apartheid gangsters while Joe Pesci tags along with the challenge of saying "okay" more times than any other actor in a single film. (Love Leo really.)

Advertisement

Lethal Weapon 2 was almost very different though. Black's script was tossed aside in favour of a rewrite from Boam, which toned down the darkness, and aborted an ending where Riggs would've died. Boam returned for the decidedly less-precise Lethal Weapon 3, retaining the previous film's antics but with a clumsy focus on gun crime. Lethal Weapon 4 course corrects ever so slightly, but it's not the gritty original nor the high-octane fun-fest that is the first sequel.

This is because Jeffrey Boam wasn't responsible for the Lethal Weapon 4 shooting script. Boam had developed a screenplay - one that would have, ironically, tapped into the dark roots of the Shane Black original by having Riggs and Murtaugh go up against Neo Nazis - but it was set aside by the studio, who ostensibly wanted LW4 to focus on the Triads.

Advertisement

Boam's script appeals way more on premise and reputation than what we eventually got - even if Lethal Weapon 4 (mostly) succeeds as a franchise send-off.

7. Ant-Man

Marvel Studios

If any film is more emblematic of the manufactured nature of the Marvel Cinematic Universe project, then it has to be Ant-Man. (Although, Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, which shackled the inventive brilliance of Sam Raimi, could give it a run for its money.)

Advertisement

Originally envisioned as a fun heist caper helmed by the Three Flavours Cornetto Trilogy's Edgar Wright all the way back in 2003, Ant-Man unfortunately found itself sucked up into the Marvel Studios apparatus, and thus had to conform to the rigid confines of the MCU.

Wright and screenwriting partner Joe Cornish went through several drafts over the course of Ant-Man's long gestating production, and were attached to the project as late as 2014 when the casting process was in full-swing. However, a few months later, Wright and Marvel ended up parting companies over creative differences, with the former stating in an interview with EW that he "[didn't] think [Marvel] wanted to make an Edgar Wright movie."

Advertisement

Some of the DNA of Wright and Cornish' script remains in the finished version of Ant-Man helmed by Peyton Reed, and while that version is entertaining, the prospect of seeing Wright's full vision away from the architecture of the MCU is way more appealing.

6. The Hobbit

New Line Cinema

Peter Jackson's The Hobbit trilogy was a far cry away from the excellence of The Lord of the Rings, mainly as a result of stretching out a concise, one-movie adventure into a bloated three-parter shot almost entirely on blue screen. While the majesty of Jackson's previous foray into Middle-earth occasionally bubbles up to the surface, The Hobbit parts one, two and three are sludgy and overwrought adventures with few redeeming qualities.

Advertisement

This makes the fact that Guillermo del Toro was initially attached to direct The Hobbit even more frustrating. The Pan's Labyrinth and Shape of Water director boarded the project in 2008, and collaborated with Jackson in creating the screenplays for a then two-picture effort. While still in tune with Jackson's vision of Middle-earth, del Toro's Hobbit would have differed in key respects, most notably in the effects department, which would have reportedly seen the director replicate animatronic techniques seen in his version of Hellboy (via BilboHobbit.com).

Del Toro had also considered different casting choices to Jackson, with longtime collaborator Ron Perlman revealing in a 2010 interview with CBR that the part of Beorn had been written with him in mind.

Advertisement

While production deadlines almost certainly proved to be the undoing of The Hobbit movies, del Toro's two-part effort sounds like it would have stood alongside the original Lord of the Rings trilogy as its own distinct creature, rather than as a sluggish, belaboured trilogy.

5. The Amazing Spider-Man

Sony

The winding path that took us to The Amazing Spider-Man's release in 2012 epitomises the worst trends of the comic movie genre, enacted by the studio with by far the most weird, ill-thought out superhero schemes in the business. Yes, give it up for Sony folks - the company that swapped out Sam Raimi's Spider-Man to create a contrived cinematic universe populated entirely by B-tier Spidey villains, led by an incarnation of the wall-crawler whose most memorable trait was being way too cool to actually be Peter Parker.

Advertisement

This might be harsh on Andrew Garfield, who made valiant attempts to uplift the material he was given as the web-slinger in Marc Webb's Amazing Spider-Man movies, but it wasn't enough to stop the weight of Sony's clunky franchise machinations from crumbling down around them.

Adding insult to injury, though, is that we could have had Spider-Man 4 instead of The Amazing Spider-Man - a fourth film from Sam Raimi that was set to include The Lizard, Black Cat, and a bigger role for Bruce Campbell (the main draw of the franchise to begin with, as well all know).

Advertisement

For his part, Raimi has spoken out regarding his dissatisfaction with getting Spider-Man 4 off the ground, and it was him who pulled the plug on the project down to frustrations with the script (via Vulture). Even so, a less than stellar work from Raimi would have still had twice the amount of personality, pathos, and investment than what was seen with The Amazing Spider-Man - or any of the other Spider-Man films that released afterwards, for that matter.

4. Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise Of Skywalker

Lucasfilm

J. J. Abrams and Chris Terrio's story for Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker is a perfect lesson in how not to make a sequel, from its infuriating attempts at relitigating Rian Johnson's The Last Jedi, to its cheap shots at invoking nostalgia for the original Star Wars trilogy. It is a bad film - easily the worst Star Wars entry (I will not hear a bad word about The Phantom Menace, sorry) - and one that could have easily been less bad had Lucasfilm committed to the story being developed by the director Abrams' replaced: Colin Trevorrow.

Advertisement

Jurassic World director Trevorrow was originally unveiled as the director of Episode IX in 2015, a few months prior to the release of Star Wars: Episode VII - The Force Awakens. However, Trevorrow was booted off the project in 2017 as a result of creative differences, with Abrams replacing him as director and Chris Terrio also stepping in to draft a new screenplay, which included the now infamous "somehow, Palpatine returned" zinger in the opening 10 minutes.

Trevorrow's script, titled Duel of the Fates, was leaked shortly after the release of The Rise of Skywalker in 2019. While bizarre in some respects, Duel of the Fates swings for the fences where Skywalker merely piddles sadly in the corner. It drew upon the themes of The Last Jedi, committing to Kylo Ren as a villain haunted by the ghost of Luke, continuing Rey's journey as a Jedi with her own double-bladed lightsaber, and even having Finn and Rose in a Les Mis-style uprising on Coruscant, which had fallen under Imperial control.

Advertisement

It's impossible to say whether or not Trevorrow would've nailed the landing (and it is doubtful, given the director's track record on Jurassic World). But in concept alone, Duel of the Fates is way more fascinating, ambitious, and cohesive than The Rise of Skywalker.

3. The Black Dahlia

Universal

Brian De Palma and James Ellroy should have been a match made in heaven.

Advertisement

De Palma, one of the greatest filmmakers of his generation, had developed a reputation for fusing lust and violence in a number of erotic and psychological thrillers, while Blow Out, released in 1981, is itself a neo noir classic. Ellroy, whose L.A. Quartet had masterfully grappled with the socio-political landscape of post-war Los Angeles and had touched on similar subject matter in the process, should've been the perfect launching pad for De Palma to make a late career marvel.

2006's The Black Dahlia, adapted from the first of Ellroy's Quartet, was anything but. Poorly cast and muddily shot, Josh Friedman's script failed to condense Ellroy's weighty source into a two-hour runtime, excising large swathes of the novel and losing much of its horror and tragedy in the process.

Advertisement

In retrospect, adapting a work as dense as Dahlia into a two hour film should've been a non-starter. While Curtis Hanson and Brian Helgeland had achieved wicked results with 1997's L.A. Confidential - the third entry in the L.A. Quartet - it's kind of miraculous that they managed to do just that. L.A. Confidential lost much of the grim nuance of the original text, but still managed to maintain its spirit. Dahlia, which is more of a slow burn, had so many disparate moving parts that any film adaptation was always going to struggle.

Interestingly, before De Palma became attached to The Black Dahlia, Se7en filmmaker David Fincher had proposed a mini series adaptation of the novel.

Advertisement

Having read Ellroy's books, this really seems like a no-brainer. I'm a movies guy first and foremost, but Ellroy's prose is so sprawling and ambitious that it's difficult to condense into a 90 minute or two hour picture. A mini-series would've made much more sense, particularly as it could have been a springboard to adapt the full L.A. Quartet, with The Big Nowhere and White Jazz still waiting on their own adaptations.

2. Batman Forever

Warner Bros.

Joel Schumacher's Batman Forever offered a fun, neon-drenched take on Gotham City, but as much as I myself may have a soft spot for it, Val Kilmer's Bruce Wayne and Jim Carrey's endlessly quotable take on the Riddler ("does anyone else feel like a fried egg?"), I'd take a third movie from Tim Burton over it every time.

Advertisement

Burton had begun work on a third Batman film following the release of Batman Returns in 1992, with Michael Keaton once again set to reprise the role of the Caped Crusader. However, the controversy surrounding Returns' dark content mixed with its diminishing box office returns compelled Warner Bros. to take the series in a lighter direction, which saw Burton and Keaton depart the project and Schumacher and Kilmer step in.

It's unclear what direction Burton would have taken the series, given his departure happened so early into Batman Forever's production, but it wouldn't have been a surprise to see the return of Michelle Pfeiffer's Catwoman. Batman and Batman Returns screenwriter Sam Hamm explored the possibility of a third Burton movie with the Batman '89 comic series, which was published by DC Comics in 2021 and featured art from Joe Quinones. The comic explored Burton-esque takes on Robin and Two-Face, with Billy Dee Williams' Harvey Dent getting his villainous turn, and paints a compelling picture for what a third Burton Batman movie could have looked like.

Advertisement

As things stand, Schumacher's Batman Forever is a fine but flawed comic book movie. However, given the cuts made to the film, the brilliance of Burton's previous two movies and the fact that Warner Bros. considered Sam Raimi and John McTiernan for the director's chair as well, it's easy to see how much stronger it could've been.

1. Alien Vs. Predator

20th Century Fox

Alien vs Predator has to go down as one of the greatest bag fumblings in movie history. While the film returned a significant sum at the box office, it squandered the easiest home run premise ever in pitting two of sci-fi's most iconic creatures against each other - the Xenomorphs from Alien, and the Yautja from Predator. The two franchises had crossed over numerous times on the page in comics from Dark Horse and in video games following a genius Easter egg tease in the underrated second Predator film, so by 2004, a big screen crossover had been over a decade in the making.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, neither Alien vs. Predator nor its sequel, Alien vs. Predator: Requiem, were able to deliver. While the latter gets some gnarly bonus points for being so thoroughly nasty in its approach to the material, both films failed to do justice to the comic book meetings between the two franchises, taking place in the 21st century rather than in the more interesting setting of the far future.

Alien is simply way less compelling as a concept when given a contemporary setting, and the idea of pitting the Predator against the Xenos and soldiers with Colonial Marine-style technology would've made for a refreshing change of pace.

Advertisement

Tragically, this is the exact kind of AvP movie that Hellboy screenwriter Peter Briggs pitched to Fox back in 1991. Briggs' script, The Hunt: Alien vs. Predator, took significant inspiration from the Dark Horse comics and was set in the future. It's gone down as one of the best scripts that was never filmed, and reading breakdowns it's easy to see why. Just expect to end up despairingly laughing as you set your explodey wrist thing off, because of all the AvP movies Fox could've gone with, it's a real shocker this wasn't it.