Studios love a good idea for a film. They love them so much they'll even use it again and again. For this reason we are bombarded with remake after remake every year. Sometimes we get surprised. Last year's Evil Dead remake had just enough mayhem and style to satisfy long time fans and silence most protests. It's rare but it does happen. Then there are those remakes that far surpass the original. Remakes like John Carpenter's The Thing or David Cronenberg's vastly superior The Fly. Whether they utilize modern technology to fully realize a film's potential or add a previously unrealized element to a film, they prove that sometimes a good idea can only get better. More often than not, there are the remakes that just don't cut it. Now and then it's a case of a lack of respect for the original material. When Samuel Bayer said his remake of A Nightmare On Elm Street was going to be scarier than the original it made people wonder if he had even seen the Wes Craven original. Needless to say Bayer failed and fans were not happy. Or there's the remakes that missed the point of the original entirely. One wonders in the case of Tim Burton's Planet Of The Apes if the studio thought the original's appeal was people dressed as apes and not the biting social commentary at the end. Here's a list of eight planned remakes that need to be stopped before they start:
8. Escape From New York
Escape From New Yorks plot is so perfect in its simplicity, youd wonder why no one thought of it before John Carpenter made it in 1981. Almost twenty years into the future and New York City is now a prison, closed off from the US. The president gets held hostage there and only one man can go into NYC and save him. That man is Snake Plissken, played perfectly by Kurt Russell. Hes got 24 hours to do it. Along the way he ends up becoming one of the most iconic cinematic antiheroes of all time. Heres a perfect example of the warped logic coming from Hollywood. For decades Kurt Russell and John Carpenter have wanted to bring Snake back with the epically titled Escape From Earth. It would be the third installment of the Escape franchise, following 1996s Escape From LA (ironically, a virtual remake of the original). Apparently theres no potential in another Escape film, which is why a possible Carpenter/Russell reunion is not in the cards. Instead, lack of potential translates to ripe for remaking. Thankfully, director Len Wiseman bowed out of ruining Escape From New York with Gerard Butler taking over for Kurt Russell. Instead Wiseman went on to remake Total Recall and ruin another classic altogether. For Escape fans a bullet was dodged. That is until producer Joel Silver stepped in. Now it looks like were in store for a prequel/reboot, delving into the origins of Snake Plissken. Because clearly showing a characters legendary backstory is far more effective than just letting the audience have an imagination. It worked so well for Darth Vader in the Star Wars trilogy.
7. An American Werewolf In London
If theres a list of cinematic crimes, the Weinstein Brothers have successfully checked off most of them. Whether its making needless cuts to the foreign films theyve acquired or just simply producing Shakespeare In Love, the duo truly know no bounds. If they succeed in remaking An American Werewolf In London they very well may top themselves. What truly makes An American Werewolf In London a classic is that it finds a perfect balance of gallows humor and horror. And since its not entirely a horror film, John Landis is in no rush to deliver the scares until were completely invested in the characters hes created. We dont even see the Oscar winning werewolf transformation scene into almost an hour of the movie. Sure, Landis delivers a few tropes of the horror genre but were talking about a movie with the world werewolf in the title. It doesnt matter though. Were along for the ride and were totally buying into David Naughton as an American backpacker cursed with lycanthropy and not as a spokesperson for Dr.Pepper. John Landis is less concerned with making a great horror film as he is with making a great movie and for that reason it works. Now the Weinsteins want to modernize American Werewolf in London. If the lackluster sequel, American Werewolf in Paris, is any indication that means ditching the clever soundtrack of the original in favor of flavor-of-the-month bands and get to them werewolves a lot quicker. Oh and that transformation sequence that is so memorable and still holds up to this day? Lets just use CGI, thus taking the magic out of that moment entirely. All bad signs so far. Not worried enough? Apparently the Weinsteins have secured The Number 23s screenwriter Fernley Phillips to bring this travesty to screen. To date he does not include movies like The Blues Brothers or Animal House on his resume. This does not bode well for fans.
6. The Exorcist
For a couple of years now theres been talk of adapting The Exorcist for television, either as a mini-series or an ongoing show. Television. Clearly the brains behind this operation havent been reacquainted with the source material for a while. Heres the Cliff Notes version: Innocent twelve year old girl starts acting weird, saying obscene things, and making very inappropriate use of a crucifix. Psychiatrists are baffled so her mom turns to a priest whose faith has been broken. Eventually he teams up with another priest to perform an exorcism and try to save the girl. It was a monumental bestseller. Then two years later it was made into a movie. An excellent movie that many consider the scariest film ever made. Now for those who are familiar with the book or the movie, you know that a lot would have to be lost before translating it to television. Theres a lot of shocking material in there but its not all for shock value. Being horrified and having our comfort levels completely thrown away by watching this child say and do these things we are left in the same boat as the characters around her. We need to believe that in no way is this a normal twelve year old girl suffering from some psychological illness. This is true evil at work here. Call me crazy but a twelve year old bellowing a television friendly line like: Your mother dates a lot of guys in hell doesnt have the same impact as the more R-rated alternative. Heres another thought: If they want to draw from the well and make more money off of the Exorcist why not just do what they did in 2000: They just rereleased the original and it made a lot of money. Twenty seven years after it was made and it still drew in money. Why? When your movie has a reputation of being the greatest horror film ever made people are going to see it no matter how old it is. Just food for thought.
5. Highlander
On paper the original Highlander shouldve never worked. French actor Christopher Lambert as an immortal Scotsman, Sean Connery as an Egyptian/Spaniard, and lots of sword fighting in New York City. Maybe it was the amazing Queen soundtrack or maybe it was the fact that sword fighting in NYC is actually awesome, but Highlander did end up working and worked real well. Unfortunately There Can Be Only One just turned out to be a clever catchphrase because sequel after sequel was released, tarnishing the original with each subsequent film. They even released a television show which in itself wasnt too shabby other than the fact that it retconned every movie that came before it including the original. The goal, like most remakes these days, is to modernize the dated material. In the case of Highlander, what does that even mean? Instead of just sensing when another Immortal is around are they just going to check one anothers Twitter feeds? Is the Gathering just going to end up as a Facebook event? One shudders to think. The only thing the remake had going for it was the casting of Ryan Reynolds. Unfortunately he walked away from the project last summer, perhaps knowing the people would be clamoring to see him get his head cut off on camera and not the other way around. All in all, the original Highlander was a fluke. A good fluke but a fluke nonetheless. Theres something rather special about it that makes it continuously enjoyable to watch. However, each Highlander film that has followed has proven that you cant capture lightening in a bottle- no matter how awesome of a song Princes Of The Universe is.
4. The Warriors
This is a remake that has been in the works for almost a decade. Director Tony Scott was on board to make this film, often commenting on its eventuality before his untimely passing. One would believe that the project would have now reached a dead end. Unfortunately, there is still buzz on the internet that this movie is still going to happen. The Warriors is about the titular gang, falsely accused of murdering the leader of the biggest gang in NYC. Somehow they have to go from the Bronx to Coney Island, through various rival gang territories to get home. Sounds pretty simple, right? But its not so easy when you have to contend with gangs like the Baseball Furies or the Lizzies. And all of this is done with a color palette that feels like a seventies Marvel comic brought to life. The proposal behind this planned remake is to drop all of the exaggerated and stylish gangs that fill the screen in favor of ones that seem more realistic and edgier. Which is the exact opposite of the appeal of The Warriors. This is an adventure film at heart and while it has a very larger than life aesthetic, it still manages to feel dark and gritty. The Warriors dont just bop their way through New York City, its almost as if theyve journeyed through another world that somewhat resembles the real one.
3. Gremlins
They dont make kids movies like they used to. Case in point is Joe Dantes 1984 Gremlins. It introduced the world to Gizmo the Mogwai and the three famous rules: Never expose him to bright light, never get him wet, and never ever feed him after midnight. Of course, rules this rigid are only bound to be broken and the result is one of the best horror comedies ever made. For many a child of the eighties it was their first horror film and holds a very special in a lot of hearts. While Gizmo still holds the prestigious title of most adorable animatronic puppet in cinematic history, the movie is clearly remembered for the pure insanity caused by the gremlins. After all, the movie isnt called Gizmo. When these monsters show up on the screen, audiences are subjected to live action mayhem that resembles the best slapstick only found in cartoons. Granted, a lot of parents were not as amused but the kids loved it. With films unfortunately becoming more and more blamed for real life violence, a Gremlins remake would not bode well in this day and age unless you stripped of its mayhem and anarchy. But without it, its not Gremlins, just some movie that bares a strange resemblance to it. More disheartening news for fans. Rumors are flying that none other than Seth Grahame-Smith is on board to produce. For those who may not remember, Seth Grahame-Smith was the scribe who wrote the Dark Shadows remake. Doesnt anybody remember how that went down?
2. Poltergeist
This remake clearly wants to be good. Having Sam Raimi in the producers seat shows that they want to guarantee the scares. After all, this is the guy who brought us the Evil Dead films and even produced the decent remake of that film. Sounds great. Except Poltergeist isnt The Evil Dead. Not at all. In the original Poltergeist a typical suburban family gets an unpleasant surprise when they find out that their home is haunted. To make matters worse, their adorable but creepy youngest child is abducted by the ghosts and taken to the other side. Desperate for help they turn to an even creepier medium played by the legendary Zelda Rubinstein. Needless to say the ghosts arent too keen about this. The original Poltergeist is the cinematic equivalent of the best haunted house attraction youve ever been to. When all hell breaks loose, you strap in and go for the ride. But behind people ripping their faces off in the bathroom theres a real heartfelt story about a family coming together to face the unknown. If theres one person who knows family its original Poltergeist producer and co-writer Steven Spielberg. Say what you will about the Spielberg, the guy knows how to juxtapose that rollercoaster intensity with sincere sentimentality like nobody else does. Can Sam Raimi really say the same? Sadly, the Poltergeist remake is in real danger of becoming just another horror film and stands to lose the heart and soul that made the original a classic.
1. Videodrome
If youve seen Videodrome theres a chance you havent forgotten it. If you dont remember it for its classic body horror moments, you certainly remember it for being one of the few films where James Woods is actually likeable. Its also an incredibly risqué movie that doesnt fail to shock even now. While its themes about the obsession of masochism and the effects it has on audiences is relevant in todays age with subgenres like torture porn becoming more and more prevalent, the delivery of those themes is a bit dated. James Woods plays the programmer of a small almost pirate television station. He stumbles across a broadcast of a show called Videodrome that is plot-less and features extreme violence and torture. Basically the Hostel films. His obsession with it leads to hallucinations and some very unsavory bodily changes and leads to him discovering a huge conspiracy. To explain more would give away some of the originals finest moments. Television has changed. Small and pirate television stations simply dont exist. We live in a digital age and the internet has taken over. Videos (and beta) have gone the way of the dinosaur and kids born today will never understand that once upon a time we couldnt stream movies or buy them on a disc. The world has gotten bigger which unfortunately means the world of Videodrome has gotten a little smaller. By no means is Videodrome a terrible movie, its just an amazing product of its time. If this wasnt reason alone to leave the original alone, the brains behind this remake is none other than Ehren Kruger who plans to write and produce. Because if anybody should be tackling material originating from the mind of David Cronenberg its most certainly the guy who brought us Scream 3 and two of the Transformer movies. Common sense has left the building.