The Wolverine was released in cinemas this week, becoming the latest entry in the highly enjoyable X-Men film franchise that first appeared on screen in 2000 and kickstarted the ongoing comic book adaptation trend. It serves as a sequel to 2006s X-Men: The Last Stand and sees Hugh Jackman portray the titular character for the sixth time (and for the second time in a stand-alone film, after 2009s X-Men Origins: Wolverine). Elements of the film tie into X-Men: Days of Futures Past, the upcoming release that will link the 60s-set X-Men: First Class (a prequel released in 2011) with the series original three entries (X-Men, X2 and X-Men: The Last Stand) through a time travel-orientated storyline, mixing the likes of Jackman, Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellen with James McAvoy, Michael Fassbender and Jennifer Lawrence. Whilst an interesting idea on paper (and one which will almost certainly make for a good film giving the calibre of the actors and director attached), the connection adds to a number of plot discrepancies and continuity errors, both minor and major, that the series convoluted chronology has already created. Eight of these shall be looked at on the subsequent pages of this article. Note that that entry #8 contains spoilers from The Wolverines post-credits scene, so if you are not yet familiar with this, you should skip directly to entry #7 by adding a /3 to the end of the article's URL.
8. Professor X's Apparent Revival
The Wolverine is effectively a standalone film, given that barring the title character; it only features one character from the rest of franchise Famke Janssens Jean Grey, who appears in a number of dream sequences. This is at least until the mid-credits scene, which is set two years after the films conclusion. It sees Hugh Jackmans title character arrive at an American airport only to be confronted by Ian McKellens Magneto, who Wolverine is wary of trusting until his onetime adversary reveals the presence of Patrick Stewarts Charles Xavier (Professor X). The scene makes for an excellent teaser, though it makes little sense continuity-wise given that the events of X-Men: The Last Stand resulted in the removal of Magnetos powers and Charles apparent death, though it is hinted that his consciousness was able to continue living in the body of another (though not his own) by that films post-credits scene The reversal of such significant developments will presumably occur during X-Men: Days of Futures Past, though using time travel to negate the happening of two such major events from the third film will be a tad extreme (not to mention convenient).
7. Who Created Cerebro?
Early on the first X-Men film, viewers are introduced to Cerebro, a machine that allows Professor X to use his powers and connect with the mind of every mutant and human on Earth. During the film, the professor claims to have built the device with his friend-turned-enemy Magneto, who is able to use his knowledge of the machines workings to shield himself from it using a specialist helmet. This explanation is more than sufficient, though X-Men: First Class made the decision to reverse it, attributing the creation of the machine to Hank McCoy (Beast), who is introduced as a mutant working within the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). The professor therefore has no involvement in its development, creating an error in continuity, though he does use it to locate and recruit a host of mutants to oppose the films vlllain, Sebastian Shaw. Shaws minions do destroy the device in an attack on the CIA facility where it is located, however, meaning that Xavier could be stated to have been referring only to the rebuilt version as his creation. In another minor discrepancy, the helmet Magneto uses throughout the original film trilogy to shield himself from Xaviers powers isnt his creation (as it is stated to be on numerous occasions) at all. Instead he merely takes possession of it from Shaw during the events of the prequel.
6. Unaltered Beast
Ostensibly, the first appearance of Hank McCoy (Beast) in the film series was in X-Men: The Last Stand, where he appears as an advisor to the American president on mutant affairs and is played by Kelsey Grammar. Throughout the entire film, he appears as a blue-furred being, indicating that he has no ability to change his appearance at will. This is correlated by the events of X-Men: First Class, which is set around forty five years before The Last Stand. Showcasing Hank as a young adult with a human appearance, it depicts him as wishing to remove his mutation (superhuman speed, as well as prehensile feet), though the vaccine he creates to do so instead permanently transforms him into his beastlike state. He presumably stays in this form for the next four decades, though a blink-and-youll miss it scene from X2 throws a spanner into the works, as a very-much human Hank McCoy is seen on a television in a bar scene discussing mutant affairs. This minor discrepancy can probably be written off, given that it was a background event that a significant number of viewers wont even notice, but it does seem to indicate that the writers of the film series didnt initially do much in the way of forward planning.
5. Sabretooth And Mystique's Relationships
Filmmakers often encounter a host of problems when it comes to creating prequels to established works, one of which is that the fate of main characters is known before events even begin and there can therefore be little in the way of shocking and unpredictable plot developments. Prequels do allow characters to be developed into the ones that audiences are familiar with from earlier works, however, though the versions of Sabretooth and Mystique developed in X-Men Origins: Wolverine and X-Men: First Class respectively are considerably different from the versions seen in the original trilogy, with little to no explanation. In Origins, it is revealed that Sabretooth is the half-brother of Wolverine and that they have a relationship/rivalry spanning more than a century, yet in the original X-Men film (set a few decades after Origins), Sabretooth is merely a mindless minion who serves as muscle for Magneto and no mention is made of his connection to the films anti-hero. In X-Men: First Class, meanwhile, Mystique is shown as a childhood companion of Professor X. She eventually joins with Magneto, whom she continues to serve in the original trilogy, though no mention is ever made of her familiarity with the professor or the burgeoning relationship she once had with Hank McCoy. Two prequels. Two major characters. Two starkly different characterisations that dont make a lot of sense if every film is meant to take place in the same continuity.
4. Disappearing Characters
Admittedly, this isnt so much of a discrepancy as it is an annoyance, but the X-Men films have seen a host of characters vanish from proceedings in between releases for no apparent reason whatsoever. The most notable of these is perhaps Alan Cummings Nightcrawler, who was featured prominently in X2 but was absent (and not even mentioned) during X-Men: The Last Stand, owing to the fact that Cumming declined to reprise the role because of the lengthy daily makeup application sessions that it required. Before him, there was both Sabretooth and Toad, who appeared as henchmen of Magneto in the first film but were not present in the sequels. Both endured defeat at the hands of the X-Men, but their injuries were seemingly not major enough to result in their maiming or deaths, making their subsequent absences somewhat inexplicable. With the upcoming release of X-Men: Days of Futures Past, it seems that this will become an issue again, as the merging of two timelines has necessitated a cull of several supporting characters, many of which were therefore pointlessly developed in X-Men: First Class, such as Emma Frost, Azazel, Riptide, Banshee and Angel Salvadore.
3. Trask's Size/Ethnicity
Recasting is an occasional necessity in film franchises, as sometimes actors need to be replaced for a host of reasons. The X-Men series is no different, though its latest change is pushing it a little bit, as the character played by an elderly black man has been reimagined as a middle-aged white dwarf. Details of Peter Dinklages casting in X-Men: Days of Futures Past were first revealed back in February, though it wasnt until Comic Con last week that he was officially confirmed to be playing Bolivar Trask, a scientist responsible for the creation of the mutant-hunting Sentinel robots. X-Men: The Last Stand, however, had Bill Duke play Trask, who functioned as part of the Department of Homeland Security with no apparent dislike of mutants or connection to robotics programs. The most convenient workaround is that Dukes character was only ever referred to as Secretary Trask and never by his first name, meaning that Dinklages character can theoretically be differentiated from his namesake with the explanation that the two are different individuals who merely share an uncommon surname.
2. Impossible Character Aging
Men of the world could be forgiven for failing to notice the inexplicable inclusions of Moira MacTaggart (Rose Byrne) and Emma Frost (January Jones) in X-Men: First Class, given the states of undress in which they appear on several occasions. MacTaggart appears in the 1962-set prequel as an American CIA operative that becomes involved with Charles Xavier and his growing group of X-Men. Byrne was 31 when the film was released and her character is presumably around the same age, which means that the appearance of a 37 year-old Olivia Williams as a British version of the character in X-Men: The Last Stand is somewhat astounding, given that films contemporary setting. This could possibly be remedied by having Byrnes MacTaggart give birth to a daughter with the same name at some point, though. Frost, meanwhile, appears as a fully-grown woman in X-Men: First Class, though she is depicted as a mere child in X-Men Origins: Wolverine, which ostensibly takes place a few years later. Like the aforementioned Bolivar Trask, however, the Origins version of the character is only referred to in the credits as Emma and it could be explained that the two are different characters, though the fact that both possess identical mutant powers complicates that solution somewhat.
1. Timing Discrepancies
In the original X-Men film trilogy, the character of Charles Xavier is introduced as an elderly wheelchair-bound man who maintains a rivalry with his onetime friend Magneto. Details are never explicitly given about when Xavier became paralysed or when he and Magneto became adversaries. A scene at the beginning of X-Men: The Last Stand shows him visiting Jean Grey twenty years prior to the start of the film (presumably 1986), able to walk and accompanied by a friendly Magneto, however, indicating that both events happened some time after that year. X-Men: First Class, explicitly showcases both events despite being set in 1962. If the film was still meant to be a reboot (as it was originally envisioned), then this divergence would be irrelevant, but now it is being linked to a series where Xavier was still mobile and friendly with Magneto twenty four years later, it is a somewhat glaring storyline inconsistency (and means that by the time of the original X-Men film, the two have been opposing each other for nearly forty years). And there you have it, eight discrepancies, both major and minor, that slightly hinder the overall plot of the X-Men film franchise in a variety of ways. I should point out that I have enjoyed each film in the franchise (barring Origins), and that this article should not come across as a rant, rather as a piece that merely illustrates the problems that can arise when film series attempt to branch together a host of sequels and prequels. Any discussions are welcomed in the comments section.