8 Sci-Fi Inventions Ruined By Science

Your hard science fiction is about to go soft...

By Ronnie Hill, II /

In the age where a great deal of our childhood science-fiction seems to become reality on an almost daily basis, we still find ourselves at a crossroads between our imaginative past and our realistic future.

Advertisement

However, with all the notorious achievements made over the past several decades, one really does have to start questioning whether or not we are about to reach our limitations when it comes to the more exciting inventions many of us have all been looking forward to.

Because to love of science comes with the burden of being both a dreamer and a skeptic, we have to accept the possibility that (*whispers*) we might never get our hoverboards.

Whether I truly want to admit it or not, if only for the sake of this article, I am cashing in on reality, and I am bringing you all down with me. So, grab some tissue and/or get ready to yell at me over social media. To be fair, though, it's really not my fault. Some of the blame is owed to the man, above. No. Not that one. Einstein. See him up there? He knew what he was ruining with the theory of relativity. He knew it.

Sigh.

Here are eight rather glorious concepts given to us by sci-fi and ruined by reality, and a little bit by Einstein.

8. The Flying Car

Where we’re going, we don’t need roads…

Advertisement

Our grandparents were promised a flying car. Our parents were promised a flying car. We were promised a flying car. It’s like we’ve been sitting in an Oprah audience for nearly a century but without the payoff. With the future from Back to the Future now in our rearview, most of us are still rocking the wheel - a technology that was invented in the Bronze Age .

But wait, you say! Less than a month ago, The Washington Post reported on an FAA exemption issued to Terrafugia for their vehicle, the Transition. A flying car, in other words.

Right you are, and although it may sound like we’re on the right track when it comes to regulating such a craft, can we really claim such a vessel is a flying car. I know I’m picking at semantics, but the Transition is just a plane that happens to convert into a car. Terrafugia’s next project, the TF-X, is closer to what we imagined, and more than a decade out, but, again, it’s still not quite what we envisioned. How many level clearings of at least 100ft in diameter do you have in your city? Doesn't this just seem like the Amphicar all over? Because that worked well...

What about drone based tech? Sure. Maybe. Although, considering we’re now debating legal No Fly Zones over private property, and that the FAA has already experienced drone issues at airports, our infrastructure just isn’t suitable.

7. Hover Board

This one hurts... and it's basically down to infrastructure.

Advertisement

Let’s go back to the future of Back to the Future for a moment. What’s the one thing we all wanted besides everyone’s favorite flux capacitor operated flying vehicle? Uh, huh, well, unless we travel to a designated location to use it, the hover board is not going to happen. Much like the flying car, it’s simply too inconvenient for practical use.

The one big issue with the hover board in the film was that it couldn’t work over water. Similarly, the one big issue with reality is how ineffective the technology would be over the majority of our existing surfaces.

The companies of Lexus and Arx Pax each have a hover board in production, but their respective technologies, albeit awesome, are limited to operating across a conductive material. As cool as all copper roads and sidewalks would be and all, anyone know how to handle the whole lightning sitch?

Hey, at least in the film Mattel's design still technically hovered over water, even if it couldn’t be put into motion.

6. Lightsaber

WAIT! Don't go!

Advertisement

Chances are that if you were to have sat in a room with your likeminded friends, you, like me, have probably argued in great length about the possibility of the lightsaber existing.

The Wars have been around since a long time ago, enough time in fact to make the lightsaber the new flying car. Site after site consider the prospect of a real life lightsaber, from the average layperson, or capable enthusiast, and even our physicists have chimed in.

Neil deGrasse Tyson once debated the possibility of the light saber with Brian Cox (not William Stryker, the other Brian) over Twitter:

We can debate all we want about why the force – a telekinetic magic that doesn’t exist – stops the beam from shooting off into space, or how there’s a magnetic field which somehow folds the “light” back into the saber, but as it stands, we don’t even agree on what puts the light in the lightsaber.

Despite my wanting nothing more than to add it to the collection, the infamous arm severing device is never going to happen. For one thing, the technology would probably be too dangerous to grasp with your hands (think about holding a lit explosive and then imagine that explosive is a compressed version of the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), the very thing referenced by Dr. Cox in his Twitter debate), or two, as summarized by Dr. Tyson, why not pull an Indy and just shoot the bad guy?

5. Light Speed

The universe has a speed limit and we’re stuck in the slow lane.

Advertisement

This one’s a total bummer when it comes to exploring the cosmos. We want so badly to achieve light speed because we’re currently sitting at point A with a point B marked in hundreds of locations across the cosmos.

Alpha Centauri, the nearest star system, is 4.37 light years from our solar system. Even at the speed of light it sounds like a terrible road trip, but it would be far better than travelling the 39 trillion km in our current fastest vessel, New Horizons, at 58,536 km/h. Juno achieved a speed of 266,000 km/h as it plunged into Jupiter’s orbit this summer but that was owed to gravity. Averaging the speed between the two crafts would still cost us upwards 27 thousand years to get there. Bummer dude…

Why won’t we achieve light speed? Because Einstein declared it.

Short story, we haven’t figured out a way to propel matter without expending infinite energy, meaning that the faster we send something along, the more energy we use. As matter, even a particle, moves closer to the speed of light, its mass increases and, as a result, it would require an infinite amount of energy to achieve light speed. There was a report about five years ago that a neutrino was detected at the LHC that had traveled faster than the speed of light, but the claim was quickly debunked.

Only light will travel the speed of light.

Einstein! *shakes fist*

4. Perpetual Motion

Speaking of infinite energy. We’ve postulated three kinds of perpetual motion machines over the last 500 years. They don’t work, and won’t, not just because of force (not that force, young Skywalker), but specifically because of the first and second laws of thermodynamics.

Advertisement

The first is that energy, although it can be conserved, can never be destroyed, only converted. The second is that entropy, the measure of disorder within an isolated system, never decreases.

In grade school we did an experiment with a bowling ball attached to a string that hung from the center of a room. We each stood on one end of the room and pulled the ball back to our nose. When we let go, the ball would swing away but fail to strike us in the face upon its return, not unless Tommy, the secondary system standing on the other end, pushed it back with added force. Poor Brooke.

Now, think back to the hover board and watch this vid on the Lexus design:

This is an example of an open ended system (using secondary cooling systems to operate) and it is unable to operate indefinitely, in or out of its restricted environment.

We need energy to maintain energy.

3. Technological Singularity/Mind Uploading

I'm sorry. Were you planning on living forever?

Advertisement

Futurists have had immortality mapped out for a while all thanks to Moore’s Law, which effectively states the complexity of the computer doubles every two years. That law was established by Gordon Moore back in 1965 and many cling onto it as evidence we will achieve computing powers that will exceed the human brain (i.e. the technology singularity) by sometime in the mid-2040s. However, roughly nine years ago, Mr. Moore himself stated the law will expire by the early to mid-2020s.

So, why is this important?

Well, in order to upload a human mind, we need to trust the computer we’re plugging into can first support the human mind, something we ourselves don’t fully understand. A computer can calculate faster than the brain, and it will only get faster as time progresses, but a computer cannot do what our brain does. Not without programming.

Imagine seeing person’s face across a crowded room. Without breaking so much as a proverbial sweat or perceived devotion to thought, we draw several simultaneous conclusions: how we know them; where we last saw them; why they’re present, now - hell, we can tell what they’re feeling based on their expression, and we even know, based on experience, whether or not it’s a good idea to approach them, all while we calculate the distance to the nearest exit.

If a computer cannot recreate the essence of what it is to be human, humans shouldn’t try uploading their minds to one. Additionally, philosophically speaking, many argue whether or not the mind would really be moved or just copied. Which brings us on to...

2. Teleportation

Speaking of copied. Just how many times did Scotty kill Kirk?

Advertisement

A lot.

In fact, every time he beamed him up. This why Bones never wanted to use the damn thing.

To be fair, Scotty did duplicate Kirk each time, but in representing another philosophical dilemma, how much of Kirk was still Kirk? Think of Theseus’ paradox in which parts of a ship are replaced to such an extent that one could argue it is no longer the same ship, but actually a new one.

How much of the essence remains intact?

We’ve been teleporting photons the better part of a decade, with the last record set in 2012, but we’re talking about a single photon at a time, not trillions upon trillions of atoms – at the light speed, no less, lest we forget about the need for infinite energy and all.

Thanks again, Einstein.

1. Real Holograms

Real. In the substantive, literal sense. Real.

Advertisement

I don’t want to hear about the time you saw Tupac perform on stage with Snoop. That wasn’t a hologram. It was CG smoke and mirrors. It's called a Pepper's ghost.

The problem with the construct of the hologram (i.e., light), as mentioned in the lightsaber post, is that we have no way to limit its projection. That is to say, until we block the projection using a material. We’ve been able to store/stop light (read about it, here) but we cannot limit the distance it travels by arbitrary means.

I know, I know. Researchers at NYU are currently working on creating a virtual environment designed to mimic a holodeck but, and this may be me picking at semantics again, we’ll still need goggles. The only way I'm signing up for that is if they make them look like Geordi's visor.

I suppose our deceased rappers are limited to the second dimension for the moment but, hey, at least we know we can bring them "back" from the comfort of our own homes. Something to think about this Halloween.

You could write for WhatCulture Science! Click here to find out how you could get paid to write about what you love.

If science gives you the warm fuzzies, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter to stay up to date.

Advertisement