8 Sci-Fi Movies Built On A Lie
Science fiction? More like lie-ence fiction... *chortle*
While there is something magical as an audience to be toyed with and surprised by something truly unexpected in a movie, there's a fine line between a welcome surprise and an unwelcome one.
Given cinema is so often about keeping audiences guessing or looking to make an impact in serving up something out of the ordinary, taking too much of an advantage of your audience can backfire spectacularly. If rather than mixing up the truth or throwing in a curveball you end up making your audience feel lied to, then you're fighting a losing battle.
A mild bending of truth and logic? Sure, that's acceptable. But if your audience feels like it's been set up to look like an idiot, that's when it's a genuine struggle to win that audience back. This isn't something specific to sci-fi, of course, but it's the sci-fi genre that we're going to shine a spotlight on this time out.
Whether it was in the narrative, the marketing, factual inaccuracies, or some other sort of variable, here are eight science fiction pictures that were built on a throne of lies.
8. Waterworld
Waterworld has a special place in cinema history, with it often lambasted as one of Hollywood's most problematic pictures.
An idea initially conceived in 1986 from screenwriter Peter Rader, the film would officially be in some form of loose development from 1989 before it was finally released in 1995. But while the film did eventually swim its way to the silver screen, the initial budget of $100 million was blown out of the water when the movie ended up costing a reported $175 million to make.
That's enough about the production of the picture though, for there's one massive lie holding Waterworld together.
Set in the year 2500, Waterworld takes place at a time when sea levels have risen to over 25,000 feet, which in turn has sunk every single of the planet's continents and meant that the only way for humans to survive is to live in floating communities.
Putting a science cap on, and the whole premise of Waterworld just isn't at all possible.
Sure, there's always room for some liberties to be taken in sci-fi films, but there simply is not enough water in the Earth's atmosphere to make it possible for Waterworld's dystopian landscape to come to pass. Even if all of the ice caps melted, that would flood coastlines but leave any inland areas completely untouched.
7. Ex Machina
Alex Garland's 2014 Ex Machina is a sci-fi offering built around artificial intelligence. To be more specific, it's about Domhnall Gleeson's Caleb being tasked with assessing Alicia Vikander's A.I. being, Ava.
That task is handed to programmer Caleb as a reward from his boss Nathan (Oscar Isaac), and it's fascinating to see the relationship between Caleb and Ava develop and play out. Before you know it, Caleb's job of testing Ava's intelligence and emotions becomes compromised when the two develop feelings for each other. Deciding to come up with a plan to break Ava out of Nathan's swanky mansion, that's when we get the realisation that Ex Machina had been constructed on a lie.
While Caleb was indeed selected to test Ava's A.I., the test was far deeper than he'd realised.
Instead, Nathan had brought Caleb in with the sole intention of him being a guinea pig for Ava to work her charms on. Nathan wanted to see whether Ava could manipulate Caleb to the point that he'd conjure up a plan for her to escape from Nathan's clutches - and the A.I. of Ava had managed to do just that.
Of course, this would backfire spectacularly for Nathan when he'd be stabbed and left for dead by Ava and fellow A.I. Kyoko. As for Caleb, he'd be left imprisoned in Ava's old 'living quarters' in Nathan's elaborate abode.
6. Godzilla
Obviously, the headline act of the 2014 do-over of Godzilla was the titular King of the Monsters. But still, the pre-release buzz led us all to believe that Bryan Cranston and Aaron Taylor-Johnson were to be the other main players alongside Big G.
Instead, those no-good sons of b*tches lied to us all by going and killing off Cranston's Joe Brody in the film's opening act.
This was a Bryan Cranston whose star had never shone brighter, with Godzilla hitting cinemas barely six months after the stunning Breaking Bad had come to a close. Cranston had become one of the most familiar faces in the acting world, and so him anchoring Godzilla as a father-son duo with Taylor-Johnson's Ford Brody seemed like a masterstroke.
Not only did killing Cranston's character so ridiculously early in the movie shock audiences, it made viewers feel like they'd had the rug pulled out from under them. And not just that, Aaron Taylor-Johnson didn't have enough presence to hold the film together, with not even an impressive turn from Elizabeth Olsen able to save Godzilla from Taylor-Johnson's painfully wooden performance.
5. Prometheus
Since the early part of pre-production on Prometheus, Sir Ridley Scott insisted, insisted, insisted that Prometheus was definitely not a prequel to Alien.
Sir Ridley went hard across any and all press outlets to make everyone clear that Prometheus wouldn't serve as any sort of lead-in to Scott's iconic 1979 picture. Only, y'know, Prometheus totally was 100% an Alien prequel.
Scott had lauded Prometheus as a completely original story, going on to describe the project to The Guardian as "a new, grand mythology and universe" and how he'd found the "singular tale [he'd] been searching for".
These proclamations from Scott were in stark contrast to his initial plan to do a two-part Alien prequel, and thus he went hard to hammer home the point that those Alien prequel plans had been scrapped in favour of a completely new story and property.
By the time Prometheus hit the silver screen in 2012, though, it soon became perfectly clear that Sir Ridley had either been telling porky pies or had had second thoughts over his plan of attack for Prometheus - for Prometheus was totally an Alien prequel.
Going even further, Sir Ridley Scott followed Prometheus up in 2017 with another Alien prequel, Alien: Covenant, to further tether Prometheus to Alien.
4. Lucy
If 2014's Lucy was based on truth, Scarlett Johansson's Lucy Miller would likely have ended up dead by the end of the film's opening act.
At the start of Lucy, the titular character ends up being tricked into becoming a drug mule. After her boyfriend is shot and killed, Lucy has a packet of the CPH4 drug sewn into her stomach. When someone kicks Lucy in the stomach, that then leaks this drug into her system and allows her to access the full capacity of her brain - in addition to essentially gaining superpowers.
This is also, of course, lazily based on the notion that humans only ever use 10% of their brains.
In reality, we humans actually use far, far more than 10% of our brains. Different areas of the brain are reserved for different uses, such as storing old memories, for creative purposes, or even for sleeping. If, like in Lucy, someone was to miraculously be able to use 100% of their brain capacity all at once, the tragic result would be that that person would immediately fall into a coma and would have an extremely high chance of dying.
The other elephant in the room here, is that if Lucy Miller had an entire bag of high level drugs emptied into her system then she would have again been facing the Grim Reaper - this time due to a drug overdose.
3. The Day After Tomorrow
As a dumb big-budget spectacle, The Day After Tomorrow is an enjoyable beast that ticks a whole load of the right boxes.
While climate change is a very real thing and a genuinely worrying topic that needs to be addressed on a daily basis, The Day After Tomorrow takes this concerning matter and gives it a large dollop of Hollywood glitz and glamour.
By that, it means that rather than the centuries required for extreme weather changes to happen, Roland Emmerich's 2014 picture ushered in a whole new ice age in just a matter of hours. Not only did numerous scientists call out this cinematic lie, but those same scientists went even further and insisted that it simply would not be possible for the Earth to be plummeted into a new ice age.
Still, The Day After Tomorrow works well as a mindless popcorn movie that you can just sit back and enjoy for its visuals and sense of grandeur - just make sure to be well aware that the immediate nature of the extreme climate change depicted in the film is far from being true.
2. The Terminator Franchise, Period
The Terminator introduced the plot point that the then-unborn John Connor would grow up to become the saviour of mankind in our battle against the machines. By the time of Terminator 2: Judgment Day, not only do we now have a ten-year-old John, but we have the looming prospect of Judgment Day on the horizon - a Judgment Day which will see the artificial intelligence of Skynet granted control of the United States' nuclear weapons and instigate a nuclear holocaust.
After convincing Miles Bennett Dyson from putting into place his work that would eventually lead to the creation of Skynet, T2 ended with a landscape where Judgment Day had seemingly been prevented and John Connor was still alive and well.
*Sigh*
Where to begin with this one?
11 years after T2's release, we'd get Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines in 2003 and find out that Judgment Day wasn't actually stopped - more just delayed. As Rise of the Machines come to a close, we see millions of people killed as the full destruction of Judgment Day begins.
Terminator Salvation would again mess with the narrative of T2 by delaying Judgment Day, before Terminator Genisys rebooted the franchise and put its own spin on the lore of Judgment Day.
Even then, last year's Terminator: Dark Fate picked up directly after T2 and muddied the landscape even more by killing the teenage John Connor in its opening moments - which made the very foundations of the Terminator franchise look like total bullsh*t.
1. Alien 3
Built on a lie? Maybe. Marketed on a lie? Absolutely.
The production of David Fincher's Alien 3 is one of the most notoriously problematic in the history of modern-day science fiction cinema. Having a whole lot more downs than ups, the production saw changes consistently made to so many elements of the threequel throughout its development and even during shooting.
As for lying to the franchise's fanbase, that came when the promotional push for Alien 3 promised us the mouth-watering prospect of seeing the Xenemorphs arrive to cause chaos and carnage on Earth.
Straight from the early trailers for Alien 3, we had a booming narrator's voice tell us that:
In 1979, we discovered, in space, no one care hear you scream. In 1992, we will discover, on Earth, everyone can hear you scream.
The acid-blooded menace of the previous two Alien movies? Heading to Earth? That all sounds absolutely phenomenal, right? Yes, yes it does. Unfortunately, that was all a complete lie, with Alien 3 again taking place up in the stars - this time largely on the Fury 161 foundry.
Then again, when the Xenemorphs did land on Earth in Alien vs. Predator and Alien vs. Predator: Requiem, the less said about those crossover offerings the better.