8 Simple Fixes To Improve Star Wars: The Last Jedi

Honestly, how hard would the green lightsaber have been?

By Scott Tailford /

Disney

Now we’re a couple of months removed from The Last Jedi - from all the hoo-ha around what it got right and wrong, which characters felt wrongly written, or if, actually, it was one of the best Star Wars movies of all time - how do you feel its reputation has panned out?

Advertisement

Time heals all wounds (just look at an entire generation of people who'll defend the prequels), but as for Rian Johnson’s history-making instalment in Star Wars canon, is it as bad/good/meh as we all thought?

Reopening old wounds brings all those conversations screaming back into view, but as both Star Wars fans and, erm, acceptors of history, this is the second instalment of the Sequel Trilogy and it's not going anywhere.

Advertisement

In truth, many things like Luke's big exit or Snoke's implementation would take entire script rewrites to get "right", so how about we take a look at what we DID get, and see which of the smallest tweaks could’ve had the biggest impact.

Note: Full spoilers from here on in.

Advertisement

8. Recut Luke's "Lightsaber Toss"

Lucasfilm

Bear in mind this needs to be a simple fix i.e. we can't remove Luke tossing the saber as it's an intentional metaphorical action that solidifies his attitude towards the Jedi order, and the beginning of his arc in the film.

Advertisement

We CAN cut around it, though. There's already footage of Luke holding the lightsaber, Rey looking inquisitive and then confused - we just need a reshuffle and one new image.

My fix: Keep the slow shot of Luke holding the lightsaber with the slow zoom, and the expression of contemplation on his face. You then cut to the reaction shot of Rey looking confused from after the throw in the movie, as in my version, go from that expression, into a new close-up of the ground, where Luke's lightsaber hits centre frame. Go back to the wide shot of Luke walking away past Rey, and we're done.

Advertisement

The audience thinks, "Did he just...?!", Rey is perplexed, Luke retains the seismic power of discarding his lightsaber, and the confirmation of where the weapon ended up still comes later on.

All of this, in a way that doesn't feel like a Saturday Night Live sketch.

Advertisement

7. The “Space Gravity" Issue

Lucasfilm

There are two parts to this that tend to annoy people - one of which, I can answer.

Advertisement

First, the bombs from the opening scene. Though yes, they're seen dropping through space, they first begin building momentum from inside Paige Tico's ship through simulated gravity. It can be assumed that they continue through space because of this, and honestly, that should be enough for anyone.

The arching bolts at the end though? They're more of an editing mistake, as throughout the movie, whenever we see the rebel fleet being fired upon, the blasts coming from First Order freighters fire straight.

Advertisement

It's only after Snoke reveals his plan and they open fire once again, that we see ship cannons firing bolts upwards - only for them to come back down on resistance ships. This gives the impression of an "arc" through space, despite - obviously - there being no gravity.

The fix is editing these blaster bolts so they fire straight in both specific shots, then boom, no more gravity problems.

Advertisement

6. Use Ackbar For The Kamikaze Instead Of Holdo

Lucasfilm

Granted this is more than editing, but dammit, Ackbar should've capitalised on his immortal meme-ness by being granted a fitting sendoff.

Advertisement

Instead, we got the utterly personality-less Admiral Holdo piloting the Raddus directly into Snoke's ship and its accompanying dreadnoughts - a "hero moment" that if it was given to literally anybody else, might have been remembered for something more than visuals.

I say, give it to Admiral Ackbar. Hell, give it to Nien Numb.

Advertisement

For the Admiral, he's of course known for "It's a trap!" in Return of the Jedi, only to pop up again in The Force Awakens, and essentially form the basis for Admiral Raddus in Rogue One. We don't need him to do anything else in the movie (his "shtick" is showing up for one big scene anyway), so when Holdo and Leia are discussing the need for someone to fly the lead ship, have him volunteer.

Sadly, voice of Ackbar Erik Bauersfield passed away in 2016, though Raddus' Paul Kasey is very much alive, and I bet can do a spot-on impersonation/tribute.

Advertisement

Also, it'd be Raddus' voice actor playing the character that inspired his performance, flying the ship then named Raddus later in the timeline. Perfect.

5. Reshoot Leia’s Fake Death/Flying Scene

Lucasfilm/Disney

Oooh boy, this thing.

Advertisement

The problem isn't necessarily with a "flying Leia" - it's more the way the sequence is shot.

That cut to the wide angle where she starts to move in tandem with the score just looked and felt a bit... naff. It's the moment many audiences reportedly laughed or sniggered (that happened in my screening) and I think it could be edited better, whilst keeping the essence of what's happening intact.

Advertisement

So, lose the close-up of her getting blown out the airlock, for a start. Leave it in our minds as to whether she survived the explosion that comes from Kylo's backup squad. Then show her in space after, slowly drifting - neither alive nor dead.

Cut to a close-up of her hand as she flexes her fingers and the stars start to move - like how her movement is portrayed in the movie. Hold this shot as they start to speed up, letting the accompanying score hammer home the magnitude of what we all now know is Leia's first big "force moment".

Advertisement

Utilising the wide shots is where it gets hard, but I think cutting to them after the music has swelled would look and feel better. Go from the closeups I've described to the "reaction shot" of Finn, Poe and Connix looking out the window, and then to the final wide shot where Leia comes in to "land" (urgh), as it's not as comical as watching her soar past the camera.

4. Give Luke His Green Lightsaber

Disney

Another REALLY easy one - why wasn't Luke's lightsaber at the end green?

Advertisement

Keeping it blue almost gave away the force projection twist too, as we'd literally just seen Kylo and Rey tear Anakin's lightsaber apart. We know he has the green saber because he almost murders Kylo with it during the flashbacks/dream sequences, but where was it in this final scene?

Blue sabered Luke vs green is a debate for the comments, but in terms of chronology, why wouldn't he use what is literally his weapon, first seen in Return of the Jedi?

Advertisement

Change the colour of the blade, and we're good.

3. Make The Praetorian Guards The Knights Of Ren

LucasFilm

This didn't need to be a major plot point, but including the Knights of Ren in SOME fashion would've at least made TLJ feel like a natural continuation of The Force Awakens - rather than that of a one-off, "to hell with its placement in the canon" passion project.

Advertisement

My way of implementing the Knights comes from the first scene with Kylo and Snoke, back aboard the Supremacy. Snoke discusses how Kylo is a "rabid curr" and how that could be a problem, yet he notes that "A curr's weakness, properly manipulated, can be a sharp tool".

Right here, instead of the camera staying on Snoke's face, have it pan over the Praetorian Guards by his side, as Snoke discusses how these 'angry young minds' are assumedly more easily swayed.

Advertisement

It'd be more than enough for the fans to connect the dots, and The Last Jedi's Visual Dictionary would've confirmed any resulting fan theories.

2. Luke & Kylo Clash Lightsabers In The Final Duel

Lucasfilm

Here’s a joke - What do you call a Star Wars movie without a clash of lightsabers?

Advertisement

Rogue On- What? No! The Last Jedi.

Hilarious.

Advertisement

Now, obviously in the pursuit of innovation and progression, certain expectations and conventions of any established thing should be challenged. What really didn't sit well in The Last Jedi though, was how Luke vs. Kylo boils down to the former dodging every blow instead of having a "proper duel".

Why? Because another plot twist needed to happen. Now, I and many can live with this being the case, but Luke's limbo-mastering 90-degree-back-bend-into-awkward-CG-pirouette isn't great.

Advertisement

Why couldn't we have the final swipe that separates the pair and leads into Luke's monologue be a clash of lightsabers?

Even taking the twist into account, we know physical properties can be applied to Force projections as the dice Luke gives to Leia fall to the floor and get picked up by Kylo. If nothing else, it would reinforce how much of Luke's power is being used to maintain the illusion, giving further reason as to why he had to die at the end.

Advertisement

1. Cut ALL The Goofy Comedy

Lucasfilm

There is a LOT of really goofy, awkward comedy in The Last Jedi, and it feels right out of the Disney guidebook on "How To Doctor Scripts To Make Them More Fun! Yay Edition"

Advertisement

Face-planting Hux, the “reach out” comment being taken literally, Finn's pratfall when first waking in the bacta suit, Luke's “Alright, that is pretty much nowhere” reply to Rey saying she's from Jakku...

Ditch the LOT of it. The movie simply doesn't need these scenes and immersion-breaking "gags", and a general sense of adventure and levity still comes from the way every other scene is shot. Y'know, like every other action movie in history?

Advertisement

The comedy annoyed far more people than it worked on, and The Last Jedi would be infinitely better without it.