8 Things Everybody Has Wrong About Batman V Superman

It isn't a sequel, it won't be too dark, and Warner Bros are smarter than you think.

By Sam Hill /

Batman v Superman is a movie of such importance to its fans that, without yet having even been released in theatres, it still gets spoken about and argued over like a cherished classic. In the long months leading up to the film's release rumours and theories have emerged in their droves, as fans and detractors alike attempt to decode trailers, interviews and promotional materials in a bid to unravel the mysteries of Zack Snyder's upcoming motion picture. But while there's a sense that a lot of the assumptions relating to Batman v Superman are grounded in a kind of logic, there are a few things about the movie that many people seem to have got wrong; things that they've misinterpreted, misconceived or have just blatantly misread. Which means, of course, that there are a lot of false factors and a high amount of conjecture to be associated with Batman v Superman that, frankly, need straightening out. Here are 8 things that seemingly everybody has wrong about Batman v Superman...

8. It's Not The Sequel To Man Of Steel

Advertisement
Though Batman v Superman is set to follow Man of Steel as the second movie in the DC Cinematic Universe, it's all been a bit unclear as to whether or not the movie is supposed to be viewed as Man of Steel 2, a Batman movie, or none of those things. And there are lots of conflicting facts out there which make it harder to work out what, exactly, is going on. First off, it seems important to clarify that Batman v Superman probably isn't a true sequel to Man of Steel. Most people seem to be under the impression that this is the second Superman movie, despite the fact that Ben Affleck - the new Batman - has received top billing above Henry Cavill. What kind of "sequel" replaces its leading character? Cavill, Superman himself, has also cleared up any confusion in interviews:
"I wouldn't call this a Superman sequel. This is Batman versus Superman. It's a separate entity altogether. It's introducing the Batman character and expanding upon the universe, which was kicked off by Man of Steel."
Words which kind of peg the movie as more of a Batman film, wouldn't you say? Then again, that label doesn't seem to quite fit, either, given that the movie is packed with more Superman characters than Batman characters. It seems wisest to just say that Batman v Superman is its own thing - especially since Batman is rumoured to have more screen time. It certainly doesn't help that Zack Snyder seems to go back and forth with regards to whether he thinks the movie is a sequel or not (he recently said that it was "in a way," but not definitively). Despite all that, though, the evidence suggests that it isn't - not really.

7. Lex Luthor Isn't Actually Lex Luthor

In the associated press material for Batman v Superman, Lex Luthor is been described as:
"A 31-year-old wunderkind who transformed an aging petrochemical and heavy machinery dinosaur into a tech darling of the Fortune 500."
There's a sense, then, that Zack Snyder is looking to position Luthor as something of a modern Mark Zuckerberg-type character. Not quite the Lex Luthor of the comic canon, right? And yet one major misconception that people seem to be having with regards to Batman v Superman is that Lex Luthor is... well, the Lex Luthor. The filmmakers, after all, have made a major effort to position this version of Luthor as one like we've never seen before. And why would they do that? Why would they go to such lengths to totally re-establish the character? Because Eisenberg's Luthor is the son of Lex Luthor. And no, that's not some crazy rumour or theory taken from the internet; it's a legitimate fact. This has even been proven by way of the official Lex Luthor Twitter account, where one "Alexander Luthor" tweeted the following:
".@FortuneMagazine Looking forward to reading about #LexCorp. Father would be proud. http://for.tn/1L2hjoZ"
That's right: Batman v Superman will feature a character named Alexander Joseph Luthor Jr., the heir to the Luthor fortune. The actual Lex Luthor died back in the year 2000, apparently. It appears as though they're looking to create a more realistic villain with his own reasons for trying to bring down Superman - not some crazed madman who wants to do it just for the sake of it. Which is assumedly why the filmmakers opted to make this character Luthor's son - in order to clear any tired tropes associated with Superman's nemesis and start from scratch.

6. Batman's Voice Won't Sound Robotic For The Entire Movie

One aspect that seems to have irked fans in these early stages is Ben Affleck's Batvoice, which is heard briefly in the Comic-Con trailer when he confronts Superman. "Tell me," he asks. "Do you bleed?" As he speaks, the voice comes through a kind of robotic filter, which makes the Caped Crusader sound a bit like an android or something. And, of course, said voice was not received very well at all, with many naysayers flocking to the realms of the internet to deride the robotic-sounding Batvoice, declaring it to be pretty much everything under the sun (from "worse than Christian Bale's effort" to "just sh*tty"). What many people completely seemed to miss, however (and it's hard to see how they did, given that it's super obvious), is the fact that said voice is not Ben Affleck's standard Batvoice. When he utters the line, he's clearly wearing a reinforced robot suit in order to face off against Superman - and the robot voice is a byproduct of wearing that suit. We're yet to hear what his proper Batvoice voice will sound like, so there's no use getting riled up about it just yet. Chances are Affleck will probably deliver a worthy interpretation.

5. It's Called Batman V Superman For A Good Reason (Instead Of "Batman Vs. Superman")

Lots of fans were shocked when the official title for the upcoming movie, "Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice," was first made public. The biggest criticism came due to the use of the letter "v" over the actual word "versus" (or its most common abbreviated form: "vs."), with many coming forward to say that it didn't feel right or make much sense. Why the heck did they opt for a "v" instead of a "vs."? Contrary to the popular belief that Zack Snyder just "messed up" the naming of his film, though, the movie was declared "Batman v Superman" for a reason. Yes, Snyder actually chose to use a single "v" instead of a "versus" because he purposely wanted - in his own words - "to keep it from being a straight 'versus' movie, even in the most subtle way." So for anyone wondering whether the use of a single "v" was a mistake or had been implemented at random, it wasn't: Snyder did it with the clear intention of ensuring that Batman v Superman didn't end up being considered a mere fight movie; it's much more.

4. That "Red Capes" Line Is Supposed To Be Hammy & Awkward

Here's a moment from the full-length trailer that really seems to have irked a bunch of people - especially those who are against Jesse Eisenberg's casting as Lex Luthor. The moment in question has Eisenberg's Luthor theatrically declaring: "The Red Capes are coming... the Red Capes are coming..." - a reference to the poem "The Midnight Ride of Paul Revere" by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, which has the character of Paul Revere famously warning the American military of an attack ("The Redcoats are coming!"). Lots of people attacked Eisenberg's reading of the line, calling it "awful" and "hammy." What these folk seemed to have missed, however, is the fact that it was plainly supposed to be - Eisenberg's Luthor is clearly delivering the dialogue in question in a mocking, ironic manner. The fact that it has been labelled as "hammy" by a bunch of people makes no sense at all because that is obviously the way the line was intended to be read: weird and goofy. What's more, a lot of folk seemed to have missed what is perhaps the true meaning behind this utterance: whilst it is clearly supposed to juxtapose the Superman-marked soldiers also glimpsed in the trailer, it actually makes more sense as a declaration of a new age of superheroes. Luthor is literally pointing out that the arrival of Superman has triggered the arrival of other superheroes ("Red Capes") such as Wonder Woman and Batman.

3. The Studio Always Knew That Ben Affleck Would Be A Controversial Choice

Movie-goers like to assume that the people running Hollywood are stupider than they are, and whilst that's true in some cases, in most cases it really isn't. Case in point: Ben Affleck being cast as Batman, which was originally deemed to be a mistake by the majority. And yet one of the most bizarre things to have come out of Affleck's casting as the next Bruce Wayne stems from the overwhelmingly negative reaction that met the initial announcement, with Batman fans from all over the world fighting to tell Hollywood how dumb and crazy and misguided they were for opting for such a bizarre choice of actor. The only dumb thing would be to assume that Hollywood didn't expect a backlash when they cast Affleck. On the contrary, it's probably what they planned for all along. You don't cast somebody with a history like Ben Affleck unless you're purposely trying to create a sense of controversy. What most forgot in the moment was that casting Affleck got everyone talking about Batman v Superman - it started a huge, sprawling conversation. Also: the studio actually warned Affleck that casting him would likely instigate a backlash. In the actor's own words, speaking on Last Night With Jimmy Fallon, he revealed as much:
"I said; 'Okay, I really want to do this.' And people from the studio were like, we're thrilled, we're so excited, and we arranged it, and then they said... listen, we want to talk to you, because people go through this process and it can be trying. And I said: 'What do you mean?" So we wanna show you some of the reactions that past cast members have got on the internet. I said: 'I'm a big boy.' They said: 'Just don't use the internet for a few days."
Even if you're against Affleck's casting in the role, chances are you'll still go to see the movie anyway; those who want him to fail will still pay the price of a ticket to do so. Indeed, casting Affleck was something akin to a stroke of genius - especially if he turns out to have been a great choice all along. It's silly to think that Warner Bros. ever thought otherwise.

2. Those "Desert" Scenes Are Almost Certainly Part Of A Dream Sequence

One potentially curious aspect inherent to the full-length trailer for Batman v Superman shows a strange, desert terrain with a sort of war-esque Batman figure being attacked and apprehended by soldiers with Superman symbols on their clothes. The big question on everybody's lips regarding this scene, of course, is: "What the hell is going on and how does this scene fit into the movie?' Which is probably the wrong question to be asking, actually: in all likelihood, given what we know of the movie itself, said scenes are the result of a dream. Batman is anxious about the power that Superman wields over the planet, and thus the desert-world in which he is forced to face up against "Superman soldiers" is a kind of nightmarish worst case scenario. According to the established plot, Batman v Superman has no room for a reality like this to actually exist outside of it being a dream scene, which means that it seems safe to just assume that these scenes aren't "real," but are visions brought on by Batman's anxiety.

1. It Isn't Going To Be "Too Dark"

"Too dark" is a criticism that gets thrown around in high abundance these days, which is somewhat ironic given that - not too long ago - "dark" was what everybody wanted out of their motion picture ventures. Remember when "the darker the better" was the big thing? Of course, Batman v Superman has already been attacked on account of its perceived seriousness; lots of fans who have sat through the trailer have written the movie off for being "too dark," a criticism that was also thrown at Man of Steel (in the case of that movie, the naysayers might have had a point - the film was executed in a rather drab fashion). That said, it might be way too premature to deride Batman v Superman for being "too dark." Sure, the trailers thus far have been on the serious side, but that doesn't tell us anything in actuality. Not to mention that Warner Bros.' President of Creative Development & Worldwide Production, Greg Silverman, disagrees with said criticisms outright:
"There is intensity and a seriousness of purpose to some of these characters. When you're trying to make a good movie, you tackle interesting philosophies and character development. There's also humor, which is an important part."
That's right: there's going to be humour, people, which Silverman has deemed to be an "important part" of the film. That confirmation aside, though, what is "too dark" anyway? Surely the only thing matters is that the tone of the movie is justified by the actual story? Whatever: it's no use worrying about it right now, nor is it helpful to plaster Batman v Superman with labels of darkness. More than likely, the film will find the right balance. Need more proof? Amy Adams, who plays Lois Lane, has talked up the "funny" nature of movie, including a comical scene featuring the Batsuit. Too dark, they say? Pah!