From my experience bad films come in two varieties; the ones that are bad from start to finish and the ones that before turning bad give you a glimmer of hope. The former is a remarkably predictable beast, a category normally only populated by films destined for one star from conception. Even the biggest hack of a director knows that you have to start strongly; whats the point in trying in last hundred minutes the if youve lost the audience after ten? To this end, most filmmakers put a lot of effort into making those opening minutes the best they can be. Voiceovers, styled opening logos, sudden bursts of action; anything to get the viewers interest piqued. This is such accepted wisdom (well, it does make sense, doesnt it?) that rarely does a film that starts iffy actually end up any good, let alone engaging you. Obviously this couldn't always work, but you can't knock a director for trying. Unless you write for a film website, in which case you can. Today I bring you eight such films. By all reckoning they are damn fine movies (yes, even number four), but somehow ended up with a shocking opening that had us tempted to up and leave.
8. Pacific Rim
Opening credits have been a mainstay of cinema since the very beginning. Although over time as productions grew in size theyve become less comprehensive (thats what those new fangled end credits are for), some directors are done with them all together. George Lucas famously took a new tact Star Wars 1930s serial-invoking opening crawl, while Christopher Nolan hasnt used them since Insomnia (and has made a trait out of only showing the title card at the very end). Guillermo Del Toros method is a little different. Instead, he uses the first fifteen minutes before the title card of some of his films as a prologue, like a feature length TV episode. The problem with that is immediately obvious; while a viewer can turn off from a TV show at any time, in a cinema your options are severely limited. It's not like you can change the channel you're sat in a dark room with popcorn, after all. You're already plenty hooked. It doesnt really matter though, as long theres something interesting to grab you in that first quarter of an hour. This technique was well used in Hellboy, which managed to pack all the origin story you needed (as well as some plot set-up), but in last years Pacific Rim it felt stretched. Theres insane amounts of exposition (good), followed by a meet-and-greet with our human characters (predictable) and an action sequence that should have your inner child screaming, but instead has you trying to convince yourself it is. It's too aimless for such a risky film.
7. The Simpsons Movie
Despite the show already being well in decline The Simpsons Movie was met with well-earned positivity, re-echoing the show's original ethos and putting the characters in a perilous situation deserving of a full screen adventure. Although, as is to be expected with a shared writers pool, the film did at points rely heavily on the show's more recent, more obvious style, which had led to the mass exodus of previously die-hard viewers. Being a three-act TV series, The Simpsons plots tended to fall into a set structure; youd have an opening first act that allowed for some creative, unlinked escapades before the two acts concerning the episodes actual plot kicked in. The film also followed this structure, only scaled up to feature length. Now part of that was out of necessity to give all the beloved Springfieldians their own cameos, but it led to an opening that not only felt detached from the later developments (a lot more important in a film than on TV), but had the movie temporarily devolve into weariness. The whole Bart and Homer pain-dare-thing is in the spirit of the show at the time of release (i.e. trying too hard), while its fleeting relevance to the plot is a big issue when re-watching the film.
6. Big
Going against the curb of the surprisingly saturated genre of age-changing comedies, Big didn't go the body swap route, instead having Josh Baskin simply age eighteen years overnight. Makes as just about as much sense as body swapping, I guess. Although its enduring legacy seems to be just that big keyboards are cool, Big proved a massive smash hit back in 1988 and put Tom Hanks on the map as an instantly likeable leading man. It mostly holds up today too, which cant be said of all eighties favourites. However, in amongst the carefree tone, theres a slight problem that irks me every time I watch it. Josh is a slightly geeky, but for all intents and purposes typical, twelve year old boy. He likes toys, is going through his first crush and spends all his free time with his best friend. But even though this a character we all can immediately relate to, the film still spends plenty of time establishing his quirks just so you definitely know that he is. The issue here, as with any big concept movie, is that you go into Big ready for Josh to get his big-ness on, so any added time spent shooting the breeze is amplified. This is a minor complaint in the film and one that appears in screenplays of all genres, but Big, so perfect otherwise, stands out as a big offender.
5. Youre Next
With a seen-it-before style home invasion trailer and a reliance on cool-looking but generic animal masks (from the posters this and The Purge feel interchangeable), Youre Next marketed itself as a regular horror with aspirations above its station. Boy, was it not. For Youre Next was 2013s The Evil Dead (take that definite article lacking Evil Dead). Relentlessly creative with relatable characters and never failing to find humour in its ridiculousness (I stuck a blender on his head and killed him is as immortal a line as anything said by Jordan Belfort), it was one of the years unexpected gems. Sadly, after years on the horror festival circuit, it never really connected with audiences. I could easily claim its our tell-to-laugh society (even the biggest comedies get their major laughs from moments in the trailer, where audiences know they can laugh) not being able to decipher the humour following that bland marketing campaign, but I think the issue is actually with the film itself. The first half an hour is the generic horror we all thought we were getting. Nicely shot and atmospheric it may be, but its a well worn set up that only reaffirms the films modest aims. The humour comes as a surprise and you need to be really open to it to not come out po-faced.
4. Star Wars Episode II: Attack Of The Clones
George Lucas (circa 1977) had it right. Starting your space epic with a good dose of action gets audiences on board. The sequels explored the limits of this idea (Empire and Jedis superb openings are more slow burner than A New Hopes) and cemented the Star Wars movie structure. While the The Phantom Menace and Revenge Of The Sith stuck to this general idea with varying degrees of success, for some reason the 2002 iteration of Lucas thought some experimenting was need for Attack Of The Clones. Starting with an explosion, but then devolving into say-how-you-feel talking, the lead up to the speeder chase is a trial of watching-someone-piece-together-a-jigsaw slowness. Needless to say, it's frustrating. It's like Lucas tried to replicate Empires gradual character roll call and stake setting (as RedLetterMedia pointed out, he wanted the films to rhyme), but forgot we didnt know the characters in their current form and, as Episode I's backlash taught us, no one really cared about the galactic politics. Episode II isnt the train wreck fans always claim (it lulls, yes, but for every Anakin whine theres an Obi-Wan fighting Jango Fett), but you can't blame those who lost interest five minutes in. They needed to be enthralled, and sadly, they weren't.
3. Taken
Taken has a fair bit going for it. The action is creative, theres no pandering for a family friendly rating (thats what sequels are for) and Liam Neeson brings a gruff but knowing seriousness that changed his career. But all that only applies to what happen after the first twenty minutes. The first twenty minutes of Taken could easily be from a light drama-comedy, presenting Neeson as a regular retired shmo (albeit with a cool job) trying to connect with his daughter but hampered by his protectiveness and overshadowed by her rich stepfather. While delivered with conviction (if not nuance) by the actors, you cant skirt away from the fact this is all box ticking so the plot can be said to have emotional heft. I guess you could argue where the opening's coming from fits the film's overarching theme of parental protection, but we dont need to spend this long on it. These family issues make Taken feel closer to Die Hard than it really should and its likely there where director Pierre Morel and producer Luc Besson took inspiration. Taken, however, isnt Die Hard and Neeson is a strong enough actor to be able to convey emotion without it needed to be said out loud.
2. 21 Jump Street
In a story similar to Youre Next, 21 Jump Street marketed itself as a pretty standard comedy (burdened further with the added stigma of being a remake), but ended up delivering something surprisingly sharp. Channing Tatum pulled a McConaughey months before Matthew did in Killer Joe, while Jonah Hill played a role that wasnt simply hyper, awkward fat guy (so what if it was hyper, slightly less awkward thin guy). But, just like Youre Next, it doesnt feel confident enough to strike out until half an hour in. Films obviously always need to set up their key elements and get characters to where they need to be for the action to occur, but Jump Street plays these moments without the skill it uses later with the seemingly simple-drugs-in-school plot. We see school enemies become buddies, theyre both show as incompetent in their own lovable ways and their issues are handily boiled down to simple plot points. When Nick Offerman cheekily avoids saying the films title (37 Jump Street. Wait, that doesn't sound right.) you think its all over; it's all smugness from here on in. Thankfully, this is unexpectedly the start of everything good with the film, giving us police Captain Ice Cube and Korean Jesus and never looking back. Now unexpected directorial power-team Phil Lord and Chris Miller know people buy their concept, hopefully 22 Jump Street (excitingly only a few months away) will get to the funny a little quicker. Hey, a man can dream.
1. The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey
'My dear Frodo, you asked me once if I had told you everything there was to know about my adventures. And while I can honestly say I've told you the truth, I may not have told you all of it. 'Now before I spend ages telling you every minutiae of said adventures, including things there was no way I witnessed or was even aware of, let me tell you about another adventure. Its slightly relevant to my adventures, although once again dont question how I know it in such explicit detail. Oh, but before we get to the relevant things let me set up a town that bears no importance to my adventure or really the pre-adventure. There's also a dragon, but I dont feel I have the time to describe him just yet, even though I later saw him the flesh. 'Dont worry though. Once Ive told this story, that makes Galadriels rings monologue look like a slight childrens book, Ill excite you with washing-up songs and unmemorable dwarfs and, after a bit more exposition, well finally begin that journey I mentioned. It'll only take two short chapters/half a long film. 'Oh, I also forgot to mention this jewel thing which is kinda important, but Ill just mention that midway through because I think by then we'll be due some exposition.' - Bilbo Baggins
Im so glad to be back in Middle Earth. Know of any more rare films start terribly and end up quite good? Head to the comments and let us know.