9 Canon Changes That Would Make Star Wars Instantly Better

Those "What If...?" changes that would make Star Wars that little bit better.

By Gareth Morgan /

There likely isn't a Star Wars fan out there who hasn't found themselves wondering just what this galaxy far, far away would look like if certain key events had, or had not, gone down on or off-screen.

Advertisement

And as evidenced in this rather brilliant r/Star Wars Reddit thread discussing what a bunch of Jedi and Sith lovers would do if they had "UNLIMITED POWER" for a day and could change anything within the current canon, it's clear that there's a whole lot of alterations that would instantly enhance an already beloved saga.

Just imagine if missing adored figures would have popped up in certain features, or if other soul-crushing revelations had actually never reared their ugly heads. One of the most cherished and celebrated franchises of all time would have been that little bit more fascinating, that's for sure.

With all that in mind, let's fire up the ol' hyperdrive and blast into an alternate galaxy far, far away, where little green legends didn't choose to do one hilariously odd thing, awful tunes were never introduced, and a number of epic returns of the Jedi were very much a thing.

9. Leave The Midi-Chlorians Out Of It

Despite only appearing in one Episode, and briefly showing up in the likes of The Clone Wars and Obi-Wan Kenobi, Liam Neeson's Qui-Gon Jinn has gone down in history as one of the most beloved Jedi of the lot.

Advertisement

One thing some fans will never forgive him for, though, is his part in introducing them to the mind-numbing concept of Midi-chlorians.

By taking this mysterious power the Jedi and Sith could wield after committing themselves to learning the ways of the Force and turning it into a measurable ability that can be analysed before proceeding to train an individual, it's safe to say a bit of the magic and fun was lost.

And it's not like Midi-chlorians were frequently mentioned in the time after Jinn explained to young Anakin Skywalker that they were microscopic life-forms living in their cells that tell them the will of the Force anyway.

Having the franchise maintain the mystery of exactly what the Force was and simply giving Jedi and Sith the ability to sense great potential within an individual through it, would definitely have made for a more interesting choice than the dull explanation that tumbled out of poor Jinn's mouth.

8. Yoda Doesn't Use His Lightsaber

Love or love not... there is no in-between when it comes to the visual of Master Yoda flipping around with his little green blade of doom.

Advertisement

And even if you are a big ol' fan of the powerful Jedi roaring and grunting his way through duels with Count Dooku and Darth Sidious, it's still hard to deny that a galaxy where Yoda didn't ever choose to wield a tiny lightsaber would have been fascinating.

A Force user so bloody powerful, he didn't even need to resort to pulling out a pitiful laser sword.

Instead, whenever Yoda found himself in a spot of bother, he could simply disarm and/or pulverise his adversaries through the Force, always staying multiple steps ahead of whatever foe that stood in front of him rather than relying on a tool to get himself out of trouble.

Seeing Yoda and Sidious both leaving the lightsaber duelling to their less powerful allies would have also been a delight, with the two iconic masters unleashing hell on one another via nothing but the power of the Force.

Sidious launching half the Galactic Senate chamber at his little green adversary was fantastic in Episode III: Revenge of the Sith. So, more of that and less of the surreal blade battles would have turned an already good fight into a classic.

7. Padme Lives Long Enough For Leia To Remember Her

One of the weirder moments that pop up during the Original Trilogy during a rewatch comes during Leia Organa's conversation with Luke Skywalker as the latter explains that the two are actually siblings.

Advertisement

According to the princess, she actually remembered her mother and would even tell her brother that "she was very beautiful. Kind, but sad."

The line worked fine back in 1983. But with it eventually being revealed that Padme Amidala died in child-birth during Revenge of the Sith, the dialogue now feels a little bizarre and sticks out as a rather odd plot hole.

Had Padme been able to survive the birth of her twins, and simply decided it was too risky to keep both kids on the same planet, then perhaps there could have been a version of the story where Amidala was able to secretly raise Leia on Alderaan for a few years, and even continue to aid the Rebellion in hiding while Luke was raised on Tatooine.

Vader would have no doubt gotten wind of her survival in the end, of course, and perhaps his need for her to join him could have even led to her eventual demise at the hands of an incensed fallen Anakin if Amidala refused.

Padme not ridiculously dying of a broken heart would have not only filled in a jarring plot hole, it would have likely led to an even more impactful end for this underutilised freedom fighter.

6. If He Did Somehow Survive, The Emperor Being Alive Is Hinted At Long Before Episode IX

There will be those out there who would be quick to rip Episode IX's strange mega return right out of canon altogether if they had the chance. And you can't exactly blame them.

Advertisement

The way Emperor Palpatine's eventual comeback was handled was just plain lazy, with J. J. Abrams and co. simply telling fans out of the gate that "The dead speak!" before trying to justify Sidious' return by noting how he'd actually been pulling the strings from the shadows for years all along.

You know, after transferring his spirit into a cloned version of himself. As you do.

These developments actually wouldn't have been anywhere near as jarring had there been even a few hints and teases at Palpatine still being a force in the galaxy throughout the prior two sequel Episodes, though.

Something as simple as hinting at Supreme Leader Snoke being manipulated by or answering to a dark force from afar, or maybe even having Palpatine's voice pop up inside Kylo Ren's head in the wake of cutting down the strandcast in Episode VIII, would have worked a treat.

Even the smallest of suggestions that the prior six films' big bad had found a way to cheat death in the almost five hours of screentime that preceded Episode IX would have made his re-emergence feel like it wasn't just randomly thrown in as an attempt to make even more dollar off of excessive nostalgia.

5. Find A Way To Add Ahsoka Tano Into Episode III

Now sure, it would have been absolutely impossible to chuck Anakin Skywalker's iconic padawan into the mayhem seen going down in Episode III: Revenge of the Sith back in 2005, mostly due to the fact Ahsoka Tano didn't debut until 2008 during The Clone Wars animated movie.

Advertisement

However, over the years, George Lucas hasn't exactly been afraid of adding a few figures into the background of his various Star Wars flicks.

So, would it really be that difficult to find a way to inject some much-needed Tano into the climax of the prequel trilogy, even for a blink-and-you'll-miss-it cameo as Order 66 begins to unfold?

The Clone Wars animated series does a superb job of filling in exactly what she was getting up to at the time of the final days of the war, with Tano helping to take down Maul on Mandalore after leaving the Order behind.

But the fact she's then not even mentioned on-screen during the fall of her master in that all-important Episode after being such a huge influence on Anakin's life in their days of fighting the Separatists, will always feel odd when rewatching that final prequel.

4. Get Rid Of Jedi Rocks

There's nothing wrong with a little silliness in the galaxy far, far away.

Advertisement

However, you can have too much of a good/dumb thing, and that very much became clear back when George Lucas decided to swap out a certain Jabba the Hutt's palace tune for... whatever the hell Jedi Rocks was.

On top of the in your face song itself being all kinds of bad, the dodgy CGI used to bring to life Joh Yowza's silly howls and Sy Snootles attempts to entertain the mighty space slug, quickly cemented this alteration as one of the worst in Star Wars history.

But the way to salvage this excruciating moment of jizz - the style of Star Wars music on show, you dirty souls - is simple: just bring back the Lapti Nek banger that was present in the scene before that unwanted 1997 Jedi Rocks debut.

Seeing a slightly clunky animatronic version of Snootles warble her way through this funky tune is a surreal blast and doesn't stick out like a sore thumb in the way her CGI counterpart eventually did when placed in front of the rest of the non-digital Max Rebo Band.

This moment of musical fun wasn't broken, folks. So, in this alternate canon, Lucas' CGI meddling wouldn't have affected this particular piece of jizz.

3. Anakin Skywalker Speaks To Kylo Ren In The Sequels

Similarly to Ahsoka Tano's absence in the prequels feeling quite strange in the wake of eventually learning just how significant a part she played in the Clone Wars, the lack of major appearance from her fallen master in the sequels was also a bit odd.

Advertisement

Throughout the trilogy, Kylo Ren had obsessed over his grandfather and dedicated himself to finishing what Vader started. But rather than playing a big role in eventually nudging the troubled Ben Solo back towards the light, it's the Force-user's own father who decides to appear in front of him on Kef Bir.

It was sweet to see Han Solo pop back up as a vision/memory in front of his boy and be the person who helped bring Ben back from the darkness. But having Anakin in that position instead, or even showing up moments before Solo's memory appears, as a Force Ghost would have been unquestionably powerful.

After spending so much of his life idolising the Sith Lord Anakin eventually became, hearing from a redeemed one-time Vader that there was still good in him and time for Solo to make up for his mistakes could've turned a heartwarming sequence into an even more moving Skywalker Saga moment.

And seeing Hayden Christensen back on the big-screen as Skywalker is always a bonus, too!

2. Keep Rey As A Nobody

Along with the Emperor "somehow" returning, another revelation very much split the franchise in Episode IX.

Advertisement

After it was sensationally noted in The Last Jedi that Rey wasn't actually related to any of the galaxy's most famous Force-users and was little more than a "nobody" who was incredibly strong with the Force, J. J. Abrams and the gang came along and decided "nah, let's just make her Palpatine's granddaughter instead!"

It was a baffling call back in 2019, and it has aged like a pint of blue milk in the years since.

Making Rey just your Average Jane who remarkably ended up being one of the most important and powerful people in this universe, was a bold and admirable move. It told viewers that anyone could make a difference and find it in them to become the hero of the story.

And sticking with that idea instead of having her strangely be revealed as a Palpatine all along wouldn't have just been a more inspiring message to throw out into the world, it would have also kept the galaxy from feeling so much smaller by the time The Rise of Skywalker reached its underwhelming end.

1. A Stormtrooper Rebellion

Now here's a change that none other than Finn himself would make if he was given the opportunity to slightly alter Star Wars canon.

Advertisement

As John Boyega would explain when talking to Vanity Fair about what he'd change about the story told in the films he was involved in, a "stormtrooper rebellion" is something he certainly feels should have been a part of the sequel trilogy.

Oh, and he also thought Luke Skywalker deserved more moments of redemption after Episode VIII.

But when it comes to that other stormtrooper idea, Boyega would eventually note to Yahoo! how he felt original Episode IX director Colin Trevorrow was going to tell the story of Finn leading a bunch of reformed troopers into battle against the First Order on Coruscant, referring to early concept art that eventually dropped online showing his one-time stormtrooper waving the blue flag of rebellion alongside the likes of Poe and Rose.

Getting to watch Finn bring his time in the Skywalker Saga to an end as a person who helped inspire and lead a group of one-time stormtroopers, in a fight for the galaxy against the dark forces that had kidnapped them as children, would have been undoubtedly awesome.

Though anything would have been better than the way the character was depressingly nudged to one side during the rather disappointing end to this nine-movie tale.

Advertisement