9 Improvements Needed For A Successful Assassin's Creed Sequel
How about a historical movie that actually focuses on the past?
In the lead up to the release of Assassin's Creed, hope was high that this may be the first movie adaptation of a popular video game that would succeed despite the flops gone before it.
This hope increased hugely when a great cast of actors, led by Michael Fassbender, were announced for the project and promising trailers followed. They showed stunning visuals of 15th Century Spain, heart-pounding action scenes and an element of mystery surrounding the modern day events.
Unfortunately, no curse was broken. Assassin's Creed failed to hit the mark and has been heavily derided critically. Despite this, the franchise's planned sequels still appear to be going ahead and the movie industry seems undeterred as many other video game adaptations are scheduled for 2017 (Tomb Raider, Minecraft and Sonic the Hedgehog).
However, if the planned Assassin's Creed sequels do go ahead then there is much room for improvement.
Here's what the franchise needs to make a comeback...
9. Explore The Past More
The Problem
The Assassin's Creed movie failed to take advantage of some of the better elements from the video game series, particularly in terms of how the game's present the past. The player spends the vast majority of their time exploring a vibrant world with interesting characters.
Unfortunately, the film chose to focus on less interesting elements in the modern day, pretty much completely fudging the appeal of the franchise in the first place.
The Solution
Better utilising the past in the sequel by expanding the world around Aguilar and developing an interesting plot that embraces the surroundings and its people of that time period will be a significant improvement on the soulless world we were given this time out.
Furthermore, using the series to focus on different periods of time rather than the modern day will prevent the films from getting stale. Providing a varied setting and new characters to introduce in each film.
8. Make Action Scenes More Immersive
The Problem
The action scenes in Assassin's Creed feature the biggest failure of the film but arguably also feature the film's most redeeming moments.
The failure surrounds the use of the Animus during the film's fight scenes. In a departure from the games, in which the Animus is nothing more than a medical table with a headset, the film utilises a large machine that allows Lynch to move in sync with his ancestor.
The filmmakers are clearly proud of this innovation and choose to show us it every chance they get. Unfortunately, this often meddles with any immersion the audience may acquire in the film's very good and often spectacular action scenes. We are frequently yanked out of exhilarating fights in 15th Century Spain to be shown Lynch being flung around by a giant arm, completely ruining the investment in the scene that the combat has built up.
The Solution
To put it plainly, this needs to be dumped in the sequel. The Animus mechanism itself isn't necessarily a bad idea and could be used in several visually interesting ways, however removing the audience from the past mid-scene is something that has to go.
7. Use Historically Significant Figures
The Problem
Possibly as part of the way the film chose to hamstring its presentation of the past, it also didn't use real life figures as the games do so well.
The games have always done a great job of showing the Assassins and Templars are pivotal organisations in the history of the world and giving the audience an inside look at how this secret conflict impacted key moments across time.
From featuring figures such as Alexander Graham Bell, Napoleon Bonaparte and Pope Alexander VI to having primary characters influence moments like the American Revolution, Italian Resistance and the Golden Age of Piracy. Seeing how Aguilar interacts with similar characters in his time period, friend or foe, as well as if he can influence major points in history will add interesting plot elements with plenty of room for further exploration.
The Solution
As well as shifting the primary focus of the film from the modern day to the past, an Assassin's Creed sequel should also look to draw from the games in the way they utilise historically significant time periods and key figures.
6. Set Up Assassins Vs Templars Better
The Problem
One failure of Assassin's Creed, across both the past and modern day timelines, was establishing the Assassins vs Templars conflict. We are told it has gone on for centuries and is a bloody feud but are never shown the roots of the conflict or any real reasons why the fight still continues to this day.
In the past, we are placed in the middle of an ongoing conflict that is underdeveloped and any understandable vitriol between the two sides is not established. The case is similar for the modern day, where the end goal of the Templars plan is very murky and the Assassin's appear erratic and unorganised. It's not a great start.
The Solution
Further explaining the current goals of both sides would give the audience a clearer picture of the main motivations of the opposing forces.
A sequel should show us what each side has suffered across time in battle with the other as well as their current goals and why the Assassin's must succeed against the Templars.
5. Cut Down Modern Day Exposition
The Problem
The Assassin's Creed movie chooses to focus heavily on the present day, something completely at odds with its source material. The Assassin's Creed games have always used the modern day as a vehicle for mystery and intrigue, giving the player subtle hints as to what the bigger picture is, whilst the past provides the main content of the story.
The film chooses to use Callum Lynch's experience with the Animus as the focal point of the story and avoids any elements of wonder or suspicion, beyond some ever-so-slightly mysterious characters. Boring sequences of exposition frequently douse any mystery surrounding the Abstergo facility and its prisoners.
The Solution
A sequel should choose to embrace the Assassin's mantra 'work in the dark to serve the light' and feature Lynch uncovering more about the Assassins and the Templars.
4. Fix The Wayward Tone
The Problem
The tone of the Assassin's Creed movie is a mixed bag and often bewildering. Much of the film is extremely serious and downright dull. The characters (and actors/actresses) seem to lack passion and motivation for what is occurring, driven merely by the plot they are following rather than a desire to accomplish their goals.
However, there appears to be some attempt to kerb the misery but it fails remarkably. In several scenes, Lynch is portrayed as unhinged and wacky. He screams maniacally when forced into the Animus and seems to mock his surroundings in a, somewhat meta, cafeteria exposition scene when he exclaims 'what the f**k is going on here?'
Early on in the film, there is a scene where Lynch comically stumbles through the Abstergo facility, and frankly, it's unclear if this is intended as comic relief or is just Fassbender hamming up his physical acting. These quirky scenes seem completely out of place with rest of the film and turn a tedious film into a bit of a tonal mess.
The Solution
Whilst the filmmakers may have had the right idea in breaking up the slower moments in the film with some humour, it is poorly executed. A sequel should take a step away from the dreary tone but avoid any offbeat elements. A less serious tone that promotes the enjoyment, camaraderie and exhilaration Lynch/Aguilar feels from being an Assassin, rather than just a mindless hitman, would greatly endear him and the rest of the characters to the audience.
3. Explore The Lore
The Problem
Not only do the Assassin's Creed games elaborately manipulate more recent history to add importance to the role of the Assassins and the Templars, but they also delve into the creation of Earth and mankind itself as part of the story's lore.
The mystery surrounds the Isu, a godlike race also known as the First Civilisation. It adds supernatural elements and plot lines to past and present timelines.
The Solution
Utilising this on the big screen provides opportunities to explore a larger over-arching purpose for the series as well as exciting and mystical visuals that differ from the film's norm.
2. Better Character Development
The Problem
Assassin's Creed's characters lack development across the board. The Assassin's in both the past and present are criminally underdeveloped, speaking few lines and given little emotional motivation. Delving deeper into the brotherhood between the Assassin's and how they feel about the Templars would make them thoroughly more relatable and a group that the audience is more likely to root for.
The biggest faux pas, in terms of character development, has to be the protagonist, Callum Lynch. Throughout the film, Lynch is a thoroughly two-dimensional character. Portrayed as nothing more than a slightly emotional unstable criminal.
Despite acting on his mother's death on several occasions, it isn't mentioned enough to have really seemed to have affected him. It is also unclear as to why he becomes so enthused with helping the Assassin's as he shows little interest in anything that is going on around him, seeming nothing more than a passenger.
The Solution
The sequel should delve into the life Lynch has left behind as well as what has caused him to be so invested in the Assassin's brotherhood now. This should go a long way to develop the character's personality because, as of now, he has none.
1. Make Us Care For The Antagonists
The Problem
Not developing the antagonists as actual bad guys by showing the audience their nefarious actions is an error many films fail to address and Assassin's Creed is no different.
It is never explained to the audience why the Templars are so bad. Their plan of controlling humans' free will is undoubtedly evil but what have they done so far to gain their reputation as tyrants?
The Solution
Whether it is in the past or present, the filmmakers need to include scenes that demonstrate what the Templars are capable of to give the audience a reason to fear their actions and crave their defeat.
What would you like to see from an Assassin's Creed movie sequel? Share your thoughts and suggestions below in the comments thread.