9 “Perfect” Casting Decisions That Went Horribly Wrong
Talk about your missed opportunities...
The great actor Max Von Sydow once said that "there are casting directors with lots of imagination, but also some with not as much imagination." It's an observation that underpins the importance of casting and how the decisions made can make or break a film.
Once described as the "unsung heroes" of the movie business, casting directors have been responsible for some of cinema's most memorable characters. From Anthony Hopkins as Hannibal Lecter in The Silence Of The Lambs to Robert Downey Jr. as Tony Stark/Iron Man, classic movies and the iconic performances that define them came about thanks to these perfect casting decisions.
But it doesn't always work out for the best, and a seemingly perfect role can turn into something truly, embarrassingly awful. Sometimes this happens when the actor inexplicably drops the ball, but it doesn't always have to be their fault, and "creative influences" outside of their control can be enough to derail their performance. Whatever the cause, perfection in casting isn't always a guarantee of perfection in execution...
9. Christian Bale As John Connor - Terminator Salvation
It's reasonable to suggest that filling the shoes of Edward Furlong - who played the young John Connor in Terminator 2: Judgement Day - wasn't going to be too difficult. While Furlong was competent (if a little whiny and precocious) his successor in Rise Of The Machines, Nick Stahl, was entirely forgettable, meaning that anyone who stepped into Connor's shoes for Terminator Salvation didn't have too much to compete with.
Christian Bale seemed like the perfect fit for the leader of the rebellion in Terminator Salvation, with fans excited to finally get to see the action unfold in the future world in which the machines were in full gear with their war against humanity. With two instalments of the Dark Knight trilogy under his belt, Bale's action hero credentials were well established and fans could expect another towering performance of an iconic character.
Unfortunately, thanks to some predictably lacklustre direction from the risible McG and a sloppy, incoherent script too focused on shoehorning in references (although obviously not to the same extent as this year's equally terrible Terminator Genisys), Bale's presence was all but completely wasted in a generic and unmemorable role. It says something that the one thing most people remember about Salvation is Bale's notorious on-set rant - a performance more passionate than anything in the actual film.
But at least Bale's incarnation of the character managed to resemble the essence of the role we were familiar with from previous entries in the franchise - his transformation into uber-villain in Terminator Genisys was one of the worst story decisions in the series so far.
8. Sir Ben Kingsley As The Mandarin/Trevor Slattery - Iron Man 3
Anyone who has seen Don Logan in Sexy Beast knows that Ben Kingsley is more than capable of shifting away from the kindly persona everyone recognizes from his performance in Gandhi towards something much more dark and sinister - it's a towering performance and one of the best gangster villains of all time. It's also one reason why the announcement that Kingsley was set to play Mandarin in Iron Man 3 was so well received by fans of the comics.
Judging by the Iron Man 3 trailers it seemed as if the casting of Kingsley as the Mandarin would work out just fine - it presented a suitably menacing presence which appeared to make the most of this great actor (even if there was a slightly racist undercurrent to his portrait of this terrorist persona). Unfortunately, as fans know all too well, something went horribly wrong along the way to the final credits, and his character was revealed not as the familiar Iron Man villain but as an alcoholic British actor merely pretending to be the leader of The Ten Rings.
Of course, we can't blame Kingsley for this seemingly perfect casting going horribly wrong - he handles the switch from the Mandarin to Trevor Slattery as well as anyone could hope to. In this case the fault lies with writer-director Shane Black. In his hands, a character who has become synonymous with the art of warfare was reduced to little more than a cheap gag disguised as a weak plot twist.
7. Tom Hanks As Professor G.H. Dorr - The Ladykillers
It was always going to be questionable as to whether or not remaking The Ladykillers - the classic Ealing Studios comedy about a gang of incompetent crooks who move in with a sweet old lady so they can plan and execute their next heist - was going to be a good idea. But if anyone was going to pull it off it was the Coen brothers, who had already made great comedies exhibiting the same quirky sensibilities as the original's director, Alexander Mackendrick.
Alec Guinness was an Ealing regular and his performance as Professor Marcus in The Ladykillers surely ranks as one of the all-time great comic villains, and if any American actor stood a chance of filling his shoes it was Tom Hanks. Hanks shares the same broad appeal and lovable nature as Guinness, and the chance of seeing him twist this persona into something comically sinister - complete with crooked teeth and insincere smile - was one many fans of the original hoped would be worth the wait.
Unfortunately, renaming the character to Professor Goldthwait Higginson Dorr wasn't the only significant change the Coen brothers made in their remake of The Ladykillers, which accounts for the miserable 55% rating currently held on Rotten Tomatoes. The lowbrow humour ran against the subtleties of the original and the whole thing felt far too cartoonish for its own good - and that goes especially for Hanks's performance, which was a missed opportunity to shine in a comedy role if ever there was one.
That said, he's still funnier in The Ladykillers than he is in Steven Spielberg's The Terminal, which is a film most people would rather forget completely.
6. Tommy Lee Jones As Harvey Dent/Two-Face - Batman Forever
Casting iconic comic book villains always gets more attention than most other casting decisions. With such a huge fanbase behind the Batman universe, getting it wrong can not only mean a loss in box office returns but also invoking the wrath of millions of angry nerds out for blood.
The problem with Tommy Lee Jones's performance as Harvey Dent/Two-Face was summed up by one critic, who described it as "a Joker knock-off rather than a multi-layered rogue." Hammy and over the top (although to be fair, also completely in keeping with the overall tone of director Joel Schumacher's unfortunate vision of where the franchise should go), it bore a lot more in common with his turn as a terrorist in Under Siege than the complex performance from Aaron Eckhart in The Dark Knight. In short, in the words of another critic it was "a complete mockery of the character."
Still, it was another 90s blockbuster hit to add to JFK, The Fugitive and Natural Born Killers, and with Men In Black on the horizon it's unlikely Jones lost any sleep over the criticism his portrayal of Two-Face drew from Batman's legions of fans. We can all be thankful that Nolan came along and eventually put things right again.
5. Johnny Depp As Willy Wonka - Charlie And The Chocolate Factory
Ever since his first collaboration with Tim Burton in the title role of Edward Scissorhands, Johnny Depp has developed an obvious penchant for wacky characters who require distinct make-up and headgear. It's a tendency for over the top roles which has, over the years, led to more than a little derision from critical circles (if you want evidence check out Mark Kermode's hilariously scathing reviews of the Pirates Of The Caribbean movies).
As risible as many of Depp's performances in recent years have been, the decision to cast him as Willy Wonka in the Tim Burton adaptation of Roald Dahl's Charlie And The Chocolate Factory seemed like a perfect fit. With a wonderful combination of magical eccentricity blended with a sinister undertone, it seemed like this was a perfect opportunity to deliver the definitive "Burtonesque" performance and finally move onto something different.
Charlie And The Chocolate Factory ended up as a missed opportunity for Depp, a far cry from the groundbreaking turn by Gene Wilder in the original adaptation (who called the film "an insult" in 2013), which felt far too strained by comparison. As the late, great critic Roger Ebert expressed it, "What was Depp thinking of?"
4. Jim Carrey As The Riddler - Batman Forever
If there's one lesson we can take from this exercise in "perfect" casting decisions gone horribly, horribly wrong, it's that we shouldn't ever trust Joel Schumacher with a comic book movie. Batman Forever boasts not one but two potentially amazing casting decisions which in the end were all but completely wasted.
Jim Carrey certainly can't be faulted for throwing his all into this ridiculously camp rendition of The Riddler - it's clearly what the script called for, inexplicably harking back to the 1960s TV series. But few marks are awarded for effort alone, and in this instance his over-exuberant performance ends up being zany and weird in all the worst ways (think of a children's party clown hired from Craigslist and you're in the right ballpark). It has far more in common with slapstick and vaudeville, something Schumacher no doubt encouraged against any advise to the contrary.
In case you're wondering why no one from the atrocious Batman And Robin managed to make it onto this list, the answer lies in the inclusion of two characters from Batman Forever - by the time Schumacher came to making his follow up no one in their right mind dared to suggest that anything remotely approaching "perfect" could be hoped for.
And boy were they right.
3. Paul Giamatti As Aleksei Sytsevich/Rhino - The Amazing Spider-Man 2
Before the release of The Amazing Spider-Man 2 fans had no expectations of how Spidey villain Rhino should be portrayed on the screen, and with an actor such as Paul Giamatti lined up for the role they were no doubt completely justified in hoping for something interesting on the horizon. The heavy presence of Giamatti's Rhino in the trailer certainly suggested the character was going to have a substantial role in the movie.
With the character representing something entirely new in terms of big screen comic book villains, the Academy Award winning actor usually associated with far more intelligent and demanding roles promised to bring some gravitas to the role, and in casting such a celebrated actor it seemed as if Sony had big plans for Rhino. Sadly, the end result has gone down as one of the most laughably misjudged performances in any comic book movie, which in light of Arnold Schwarzenegger's Mr. Freeze is saying something.
What compelled Giamatti to put on that atrocious accent is anyone's guess (although some fingers no doubt pointed towards director Marc Webb). Worse still, Sony originally had plans to bring him back and punish fans even more with The Amazing Spider-Man 3, the cancellation of which is surely something we can all be thankful for.
2. Michael Shannon As General Zod - Man Of Steel
First things first: in no conceivable way is Michael Shannon's performance in Man Of Steel on the same level of awfulness as Paul Giamatti's hammy turn as Rhino in The Amazing Spider-Man 2. But in terms of potentially "perfect" casting decisions that failed to deliver the goods, Shannon's Zod was easily the more disappointing of the two.
When it comes to playing psychopathic villains few actors working in Hollywood do it as well as Michael Shannon. Ever since his scene-stealing turn as corrupt FBI agent Nelson Van Alden in Boardwalk Empire he's proven himself to be the master of menace, putting his cold and penetrating stare to effective use, particularly as real-life murderer Richard Kuklinski in The Iceman. But the problem with his performance as Zod is just how one-note it is, delivering "Shannon the psychopath" without anything else of substance.
You could of course argue that this is all that's required of a villain like General Zod and that Shannon is simply fulfilling the expectations of the character. But this would be a weak defence of a character who had so much more potential to be far more complex and intriguing than he turned out. As we've come to realize, however, complex and intriguing aren't qualities usually associated with Zack Snyder movies.
1. Christoph Waltz As Franz Oberhauser/Ernst Stavros Blofeld - Spectre
Younger movie fans who have discovered Bond in the Daniel Craig era have a distinct advantage over those of us who grew up with everyone's favourite British secret agent playing on repeat every year on the television. Their expectations for the franchise - and the villains Bond goes up against - are informed not by the iconic performances of the past but by the current standards of action cinema.
In this respect director Sam Mendes strives to recreate the success of Spectre's predecessor Skyfall, where he did a great job of linking the past and present, updating the look and feel of Bond while at the same time retaining that quintessentially British feel which makes the series so appealing. With that in mind, it's such a shame that the casting of Christoph Waltz as arch-villain Franz Oberhauser - aka Ernst Stavros Blofeld - fell so short of expectations.
Waltz is the go-to-guy for villains in contemporary cinema, yet his performance in Spectre barely registers as a good villain when compared to Casino Royale's Le Chiffre or Skyfall's Raul Silva, never mind Goldfinger.
What went wrong? Aside from being woefully underdeveloped (particularly harmful to the effectiveness of his character in light of the "twist"), there's something basic and rudimentary about Waltz's performance itself, as if he's striving to distill the essence - and simplicity - of "the Bond villain" rather than trying to inject something new. The result is a Blofeld with very little scope or mystery, as much as Mendes tries to create it by frequently placing him in shadows.
With Spectre, Sam Mendes tried too hard to merge the playfulness of Bond circa-1960s with the grittiness expected from Daniel Craig, and Waltz's performance as Blofeld suffered as a consequence. But at least he made an effort - the less said about Craig's commitment to the character this time around the better.
Do you agree with the choices on this list? What other "perfect" casting decisions turned out to be huge disappointments?