Aaron Eckhart: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

By Daniel Mumby /

This week sees the UK release of I, Frankenstein, a new take on Mary Shelley's classic creation based on the graphic novel by Kevin Grevioux. Taking place largely after the events of Shelley's novel, it entails the monster Adam (Aaron Eckhart) being recruited by the queen of the gargoyles (Miranda Otto) to fight off ancient demons let by Naberius (Bill Nighy). Throw in a bunch of stuff about fallen angels and an evil plan involving zombies, and you have either a camp classic in the making or another Van Helsing. In truth, it's rather fitting that Eckhart should be playing the Monster in this film. His career up to this point has somewhat resembled Shelley's Monster, being cobbled together from lots of different, often misshaped bits that can fascinate and repel in equal measure. Like many of the actors we've covered in these articles, Eckhart is capable of delivering a good performance, but all too often he's given terrible material to work with, and sometimes he makes the very least out of a given role. Today we're taking a look back at the highs and lows of Eckhart's career thus far, singling out give performances which made him a force to be reckoned with and five turns of which he should really be ashamed. Let's start on a positive note, however, with a touch of deja vu...

5. George - Erin Brockovich (2000)

Last week, Simon Gallagher took us through the highs and lows of Julia Roberts' career. We begin our countdown with one of the films that he singled out, a film which won Roberts an Oscar and which still holds up at the better end of Hollywood biopics. But for all the praise lavished on Roberts or her seasoned co-star Albert Finney, Eckhart deserves his fair share of the plaudits. Erin Brockovich follows the fiery title character (Roberts), an unemployed single mother of three who begins the film by losing a court case through bad behaviour. Having been given a job by her lawyer (Finney) out of sympathy, she comes across evidence that Pacific Gas and Electic (PG&E) have been poisoning the water supply of Hinkley, California with the carcinogen hexavalent chromium. The rest of the film concerns Erin's fight against both the corporation and the nay-sayers who don't believe she's qualified enough to take on the case. While there's no denying that Brockovich is Roberts' film, her character wouldn't be anything like as memorable without a range of (mostly male) characters to bounce off. George is to all appearances an unlikeable character: he's a scuzzy biker who tries to apologise to Erin by offering to buy her dinner, and then leaves when the case starts hotting up. But Eckhart holds our attention throughout, charming us at first and then bringing out the restless elements of the character as his relationship with Erin develops. If nothing else, it's a good solid base from which to start out countdown.

4. Stan Krolak - The Pledge (2001)

In my article on Keira Knightley from earlier this month, I argued that The Jacket was a film that deserved a lot more recognition, in spite of Knightley poor performance as the female lead. The Pledge is another film which deserves to be re-examined by audiences - the difference being that this time the two leads are working in perfect harmony. Based on the novel of the same name by Friedrich Durrenmatt, The Pledge centres on Jack Nicholson's Jerry Black, a police detective whose retirement party is interrupted by the discovery of a murdered young girl called Ginny. Black assists Detective Stan Krolak (Eckhart) in the case, swearing to Ginny's mother that he will find the killer. What follows is an increasingly grim and tense story in which Black is forced to use another young girl as bait in his increasingly obssesive attempts to bring the killer out into the open... Directed by Sean Penn, The Pledge is a gripping and unusual detective story which makes the very best out of a stellar cast. Nicholson dominates proceedings, much as he has done throughout his career, but Eckhart is a good match for him. Nicholson's gravelly tone and more dolorous delivery are complimented by Eckhart's aggressive, often cynical nature, and unlike his performance in The Core (more on that later) he actually looks the part - even with that moustache. In short, The Pledge is very underrated and its performances give you all the more reason to check it out.

3. Harvey Dent/Two-Face - The Dark Knight (2008)

There would be a certain amount of fanboy outrage if I didn't include this on the list. It's the role which made Eckhard internationally famous, and there's no denying that Christopher Nolan got a very good performance out of him. It's only so low on this list because there's an argument that his character was somewhat surplus to requirement, and that the third act of The Dark Knight would have been somewhat more focussed without Two-Face. There's no point recapping the plot of The Dark Knight: if you're reading this article, you've either seen it or know the basic outline. Harvey Dent is brought on board early in the film as Gotham's new District Attorney, who aims to eradicate the Mob and soon falls foul of the Joker (Heath Ledger). Horribly disfigured in an accident which also kills Rachel Dawes (Maggie Gyllenhaal), he re-emerges with the Joker's help as the villanous Two-Face, who decides the fate of his potential victims on the toss of a coin. Previous attempts at Two-Face have tended to veer towards comedy, whether it's Tommy Lee Jones' performance in Batman Forever or his appearance in Batman: The Animated Series. But under Nolan's meticulous eye, Eckhart does a really good job at bringing out the desperation and anger of the character. While the motion-capture make-up is really eye-catching, Eckhart doesn't let it dominate his performance, providing grace and determination as Harvey Dent and then channeling ruthless energy after his accident. While Ledger always takes the limelight, it's still a job well done.

2. Nick Naylor - Thank You For Smoking (2005)

One thing that Eckhart has done consistently throughout his career is playing slimy, unlikeable or corrupted characters. Sometimes this has worked against him, as in a couple of the examples we'll encounter later in this article. But in the hands of a good director and an interesting script, he can really pull off something special. Directed by Jason Reitman (son of Ghostbusters director Ivan Reitman), Thank You For Smoking is based on Christopher Buckley's 1994 book of the same name. It follows the life of Nick Naylor, a pro-tobacco lobbyist who campaigns in favour of smoking product placement and denies the links between smoking and cancer. But his life changes forever when he is kidnapped and exposed to high quantities of nicotine, which almost kills him and renders him unable to smoke again. While the satire in Reitman's film doesn't go as far as perhaps it could, the film is a great vehicle for Eckhart as an actor. He pulls off the same trick that Woody Harrelson managed in The People vs. Larry Flynt, namely making the audience emphasise with a dishonest, reprehensible scumbag. Eckhart's facial characteristics (the straight hair, thin smile and beady eyes) bring out the reptilian nature of his character, and his comic delivery is quite superb - though not as superb as our final choice...

1. Chad - In The Company of Men (1997)

Before he practically torched his career with the ill-fated remake of The Wicker Man, Neil LaBute was a very highly regarded filmmaker. In addition to his burgeoning reputation as a playwright, he gave Eckhart his first few big gigs. But whatever good qualities he brought to Your Friends and Neighbours, Nurse Betty or Possession, he has never bettered his first collaboration with LaBute, In The Company of Men. In The Company of Men revolves around Chad (Eckhart) and Howard (Matt Molloy), two chauvinistic middle managers who are assigned to a temporary office for six weeks to work on a special project. Embittered by previous experiences with women, they hatch a plan to ruin the life of their deaf co-worker Christine (Stacy Edwards), by both wooing her simultaneously and then both breaking up with her. But as things start to go wrong with their work projects, things take a much more ruthless turn with the romance as well... In The Company of Men is a riotous black comedy with a lot of brains, playing with preconceived notions of sexism and offering a few surprises along the way. But while many of the plaudits focussed on LaBute (including a Sundance trophy and an Independent Spirit Award), Eckhart's sublime central performance should have been celebrated just as much. His edgy, uncompromising manner, coupled with a deep commitment to the material, results in a powerhouse performance every bit as compelling as Tom Cruise's turn in Magnolia. While Harvey Dent may come to define his career, this remains his finest work. Having enjoyed Eckhart's company thus far, let's move on to five films in which he was rotten to the core...

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Dr. Josh Keyes - The Core (2003)

The late-1990s and early-2000s saw the disaster movie make a big comeback. But where once this genre had given us comparatively well-written works like The Towering Inferno and The Poseidon Adventure, this wave gave us Twister, Armageddon and that terrible remake of Godzilla. The Core is less imfamous than some of these films, but it's just as bad - or just as stupid, at any rate. The Core imagines a world in which the rotation of the Earth's core has stopped, meaning that within a year the planet's magnetic field will collapse, irradiating everything. A team of scientists led by Dr. Josh Keyes (Eckhart) tunnel down towards the centre of the Earth to plant nuclear charges which will restart the core's rotation. Things only get sillier from there, involving a plot twist about government-controlled earthquakes and a material called Unobtanium - adding it to the long list of films that James Cameron ripped off when he was making Avatar. While The Core isn't as head-bangingly awful as Armageddon, it's still a pretty bad film. Jon Amiel is a decent dramatic director, having made his name on TV with The Singing Detective, but he's out of his depth in a special effects-laden blockbuster. Eckhart doesn't help matters either, turning in a wooden performance and looking far too buff and chiselled to pass for a working geologist. Overall it's dull, forgettable fare which can't hold a candle to Journey to the Centre of the Earth (the original version, in case you were wondering).

4. Lee Blanchard - The Black Dahlia (2006)

Back in the 1970s, Brian De Palma was being touted alongside the likes of Martin Scorsese and Francis Ford Coppola. Certainly he and Marty have a passion for classic cinema, as evidenced by the large number of Hitchcock references littered throughout his films. But as time went on, he increasingly became a director known for pursuing style over substance, and no film epitomises this more than The Black Dahlia. The Black Dahlia is a neo-noir crime thriller written by James Ellroy, who also wrote the brilliant L. A. Confidential. Set in Los Angeles in 1947, it follows two detectives (Eckhart and Josh Hartnett) who are investigating the murder and dismemberment of Elizabeth Short (Mia Kirshner), dubbed 'The Black Dahlia' by the press. Their search leads them on a convoluted path involving a lesbian nightclub, a pornographic film and the enigmatic Madeleine Lescott (Hilary Swank), who looks just like the murdered woman... Despite its credentials, The Black Dahlia is a very shallow film whose pretty visuals swamp both the story and the characters. Eckhart looks lost and confused for most of the film, as if he'd only been shown the script five minutes before the cameras started rolling. This makes his more violent moments later on feel disconnected; they don't convey the desperation of his character, they just come across as awkward and jarring. The whole film sees great talent being squandered, in a sign of just how far De Palma has fallen. And speaking of fallen...

3. President Benjamin Asher - Olympus Has Fallen (2013)

Last year two films were released with the same basic premise: a group of terrorists attack and destroy the White House. One of them, White House Down, saw Roland Emmerich on full idiotic form, delivering an action thriller that was enjoyable purely for how incredibly silly it was. The other, Olympus Has Fallen, fared better commercially but is somewhat po-faced by comparison. Olympus Has Fallen begins with the President (Eckhart) losing his wife (Ashley Judd) in a car accident near Camp David at Christmas. He places the blame on Special Agent Mike Banning (Gerard Butler) and has him removed from the Presidential Detail. Some time later, North Korean terrorists take over the White House and hold the President captive. Now Banning is the only person who can save them... Many actors have come a cropper playing the President in action films, since the role generally entails either being stupid or delivering exposition - hence why Morgan Freeman was so good at it in Deep Impact. Eckhart's performance here is indicative of the film as a whole: he's taking everything far too seriously, being intense and looking to maintain his dignity but over-egging it so much that it becomes boring and unbelievable. While this is a better-made film than White House Down, Eckhart's performance goes some way to making it a lot less fun.

2. Dr. Burke Ryan - Love Happens (2009)

It seems that no reasonably high-profile actor or actress is immune from appearing in rubbish rom-coms. While everyone needs to pay their bills, once you become identified with bad rom-coms it can take years to shift the reputation - just ask Matthew McConnaughey. Eckhart has only delved into the genre once so far, with Love Happens - and based upon the results, we hope it never happens again. Directed by the brilliantly-named Brandon Camp, Love Happens stars Eckhart as Dr. Burke Ryan, a successful self-help author who is still grieving from the death of his wife. Whilst giving a workshop in Seattle, he meets creative florist Eloise (Jennifer Aniston). As they spend more time together, Ryan begins to realise he's not been following his own advice and slowly comes to terms with his emotional problems. A plot summary like that would lead you to think that you're in for a mawkish ride, but the greatest crime with Love Happens is how dull it is. Aniston and Eckhart have absolutely no chemistry, their characters barely develop in a meaningful way, and the whole plot is completely uninspiring. In the hands of someone like the late Nora Ephron, this might have been rescued into something a little more spiky, but as it stands it's another reminder of how wooden Eckhart can be when he's really not interested in the part he's playing.

1. Staff Sergeant Michael Nantz - Battle: Los Angeles (2011)

The recurring theme with Eckhart's bad work is that they are boring, wooden or one-note performances. They are the performances of an actor who is either confused by the material (The Black Dahlia), uninterested in the part (Love Happens) or just unable to connect with the role in a meaningful way (Olympus Has Fallen). But when you're looking for a film which combines all these things into one awful package, you need look no further than Battle: Los Angeles. Battle: Los Angeles is a sci-fi action war film which begins with Earth being bombarded by a series of meteorites. The meteorites turn out to contain aliens, who intend to colonise the planet. As an all-out ground war begins in LA, Staff Sergeant Michael Nantz (Eckhart) is put in charge of a Marine platoon, which sets about trying to evacuate helpless civilians. The film is directed by Jonathan Liebesman, who previously helmed The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning and who is now working on the new Ninja Turtles movie. Battle: Los Angeles is everything you would expect from a war film made by one of Michael Bay's best friends: it's loud, incoherent, horribly shot and has no believable human beings in it. But for all this, Eckhart is one of the film's biggest let-downs: having been given the only half-decent role, he does nothing with it. He spends all his time either looking grim or slightly startled, and his numerous expository monologues are delivered without a hint of nuance or empathy. It's a really dull and pointless performance in an equally dull and pointless film. Disagree with my choices? Drop me a comment below or visit Mumby at the Movies for more reviews...