Alternative Oscars 2018: The Nominees & Winners For Every Category
Fixing the Academy's mistakes.
With the 90th Academy Awards just around the corner, film buffs are readying themselves for the big night by catching up on any nominees they might've missed...but mostly just complaining about their favourite movies which got "snubbed."
Though the Academy has made a concerted effort to be more diverse and open-minded with its nominations in the last decade - after the Oscars were torn a new one for snubbing The Dark Knight in most major categories - this year's slate of nominees demonstrates they still have a lot of work to do.
With the average age of an Oscar voter being 63, there's clearly a bias towards a certain type of movie, at the detriment of more contemporary and bleeding edge cinema which may clash with their stubborn ideals about what an Oscar film should be.
With several of 2017's most acclaimed movies, both blockbusters and art-house hits, being left off the nomination slate, it's time to right the Academy's wrongs by running down every major category, selecting our own field of nominees and then an ultimate winner.
Of course, not every great movie can get nominated, but the Academy proved this year that, while it's making baby-steps towards being more relevant, it still needs to shake loose the cobwebs to feel truly in-touch with audiences at large...
20. Best Supporting Actor
WINNER: Willem Dafoe (The Florida Project)
This year was absolutely jam-packed with strong supporting turns, and though Sam Rockwell will inevitably be going home with the Oscar, Willem Dafoe's performance as compassionate motel manager Bobby Hicks is ultimately just a little more deserving.
The fact that Dafoe's still Oscar-less in the fourth decade of his career is, frankly, absolutely ridiculous, and what a delight it would've been to see him on the Oscar podium.
Elsewhere, Patrick Stewart certainly deserved some love for his sublime work in Logan, Armie Hammer being snubbed for Call Me by Your Name was absolutely criminal, and Blade Runner 2049 saw Harrison Ford deliver his best work in years and years.
RUNNERS-UP:
2. Sam Rockwell (Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri)
3. Patrick Stewart (Logan)
4. Armie Hammer (Call Me by Your Name)
5. Harrison Ford (Blade Runner 2049)
19. Best Visual Effects
WINNER: War for the Planet of the Apes
Though it's looking increasingly likely that War for the Planet of the Apes is going to be snubbed for the Best Visual Effects Oscar - much like its two predecessors - it is, by any logical metric, the most jaw-dropping visual effects showcase of any movie released last year.
Perhaps Academy voters have been thrown off by the performance capture aspect of the effects, for though probable winner Blade Runner 2049's extensive effects work is absolutely stunning, it doesn't quite reach the mind-bogglingly lifelike quality of all those apes.
RUNNERS-UP:
2. Blade Runner 2049
3. Dunkirk
4. Star Wars: The Last Jedi
5. Okja
18. Best Supporting Actress
WINNER: Allison Janney (I, Tonya)
There's no version of the Oscars where Allison Janney isn't walking away with an Oscar for her deliriously entertaining work as Tonya Harding's mother LaVona in I, Tonya, and rightly so.
The Academy left several highly-praised performance off the docket this year, though, most embarrassingly the brilliant Holly Hunter in The Big Sick, who over the summer seemed like a sure-fire nominee and even a possible winner.
Elsewhere it's shocking that The Florida Project's Bria Vinaite never picked up much awards traction, nor Ana de Armas' iconic portrayal of Joi in Blade Runner 2049, who is so crucial to the movie's emotional core.
RUNNERS-UP:
2. Holly Hunter (The Big Sick)
3. Laurie Metcalf (Lady Bird)
4. Bria Vinaite (The Florida Project)
5. Ana de Armas (Blade Runner 2049)
17. Best Cinematography
WINNER: Blade Runner 2049
If Roger Deakins doesn't finally win the Best Cinematography Oscar for Blade Runner 2049 - on his 14th nomination no less - the Internet is going to implode.
Though Deakins does face strong competition with Dunkirk's Hoyte van Hoytema in particular, the narrative around Deakins' past snubbing makes it more likely he will, indeed, finally triumph. It's going to be one hell of a moment, and he totally deserves it.
This is always a loaded category, but we sprung for some left-field choices that the Academy ignored, with The Florida Project's gorgeously evocative lensing and A Ghost Story's hauntingly boxed-in visuals.
RUNNERS-UP:
2. Dunkirk
3. The Florida Project
4. The Shape of Water
5. A Ghost Story
16. Best Documentary Feature
WINNER: Strong Island
The Best Documentary field is always a bit of a crap shoot: it's hard to predict who will be nominated, let alone win, and often the best documentaries of the year don't even make it to the final five.
Strong Island, director Yance Ford's investigation into the 1992 murder of his brother, is by far the year's most affecting and resonant doc, while the Academy didn't even bother to nominate the incredible Syria-set docs Cries from Syria and City of Ghosts.
Incredulously, Netflix also didn't push their deeply affecting doc Kingdom of Us, despite it scoring rave reviews ever since release. The streaming giant's sports doping doc Icarus is the most likely winner: a terrific film, but best documentary of the year? Not quite.
RUNNERS-UP:
2. Cries from Syria
3. City of Ghosts
4. Icarus
5. Kingdom of Us
15. Best Original Screenplay
WINNER: Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri
There were many terrific original scripts last year, but none as brilliantly, ferociously hilarious and surprisingly affecting as Martin McDonagh's for Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri.
The Academy snubbed two of the year's best screenplays, though: how The Florida Project and Phantom Thread didn't make the cut is beyond mystifying.
Our final fifth slot was filled by the brilliant Chilean drama A Fantastic Woman, which offered up a tremendously compassionate look at the daily struggles of the trans community, but was predictably ignored in this category.
RUNNERS-UP:
2. The Florida Project
3. Get Out
4. Phantom Thread
5. A Fantastic Woman
14. Best Foreign Language Film
WINNER: A Fantastic Woman
Indeed, Sebastián Lelio's drama is a remarkable character piece, shining a light onto a subset of society rarely given their time on-screen. It's probably going home with the actual Oscar, too, so props to the Academy for actually getting this one right.
To be honest, they got the category mostly right, though we'd substitute out Lebanese drama The Insult for Angelina Jolie's harrowing account of life under Cambodia's Communist Khmer Rouge regime, First They Killed My Father.
RUNNERS-UP:
2. Loveless
3. On Body & Soul
4. First They Killed My Father
5. The Square
13. Best Adapted Screenplay
WINNER: Blade Runner 2049
Some might argue that Blade Runner 2049's narrative is too sparse and too reliant on its style to win an Oscar, but with its unconventional exploration of the hero myth - which it totally flips on its head with a brilliant third-act reveal - and how terrifically it lived up to the previous film, it deserves to be recognised.
Elsewhere the Academy basically nailed this category, nominating some more populist picks - Logan, The Disaster Artist and Molly's Game - alongside the movie that's actually going to win: Call Me by Your Name.
RUNNERS-UP:
2. Logan
3. The Disaster Artist
4. Call Me by Your Name
5. Molly's Game
12. Best Costume Design
WINNER: Phantom Thread
What a shock it'd be if anything other than Paul Thomas Anderson's drama about high-fashion won the Best Costume Design award. Though this category does allow less conventionally Oscar-baiting films to get nominated, it's almost always dominated by period fare, which is honestly a little boring.
We've shaken things up by including It, because Pennywise's costume was incredible; Star Wars: The Last Jedi, because the various uniforms and attires were memorable and iconic; and Thor: Ragnarok, because the colourful adornments helped the movie feel like something more than just another superhero film.
RUNNERS-UP:
2. It
3. Star Wars: The Last Jedi
4. Thor: Ragnarok
5. Beauty & The Beast