Amsterdam Review: 5 Ups & 5 Downs

As infuriating as it is entertaining.

By Jack Pooley /

20th Century Studios

At the start of the year, David O. Russell's new period dramedy Amsterdam seemed like a solid gold Oscar threat, yet after rumours began to swirl of less-than-stellar test screenings and it didn't play at any fall film festivals, it seemed like Russell might be serving up a stone cold turkey.

Advertisement

And indeed, Amsterdam has received a thorough shellacking from critics so far, who have rightly taken Russell's swollen, meandering - yet undeniably curious - piece of work to task.

Is Amsterdam a terrible movie? Absolutely not, yet it is a massive disappointment considering the absurd number of talented people involved with its creation.

Advertisement

Feelings for the understandably controversial Russell aside, he's a tremendously talented filmmaker who, despite his major successes over the last decade with Silver Linings Playbook and American Hustle, has taken a big swing and a miss here.

As a result, Disney is basically sending Russell's poorly-marketed film out to die, without a hope in hell of recouping its huge $80 million budget.

Advertisement

And so, while Amsterdam isn't the disasterpiece more hyperbolic voices might suggest, it's certainly a misfire of intent.

And so, here's what it just doesn't get right...

Advertisement

Downs...

5. The Convoluted, Messy Narrative

20th Century Studios

Though Amsterdam's narrative - part murder-mystery, part political conspiracy thriller - isn't actually that complicated if you break it down point-by-point, O. Russell's script tries its absolute damnedest to twist it into a convoluted, at times scarcely comprehensible mess.

Advertisement

What begins simply enough, with our three main characters becoming prime suspects in the murder of U.S. Senator Bill Meekins, is complicated by timeline shifts, globetrotting, and motivations that change on the turn of a dime.

One suspects O. Russell was attempting to pay homage to intentionally scatterbrained mystery capers from the Golden Age of Cinema, yet it doesn't quite translate in this case.

Advertisement

As a result, viewers may find themselves confused by what's going on at certain points, while feel whacked over the head with the prevailing themes and ideas at others.

All in all it adds up to a bewildering stew of a story that many may ultimately feel isn't worth the 134 minutes they'll invest watching it.

Advertisement

4. It's A Tonal Trainwreck

20th Century Studios

Amsterdam is a prime example of a movie that never strikes a consistent tone, pinballing wildly from daft comedy to dead serious social commentary on an utter whim.

Advertisement

Though it certainly isn't impossible to reconcile the light and dark elements of the narrative with a sharp enough script, in this case O. Russell has abjectly failed at that, delivering a film that feels offputtingly schizophrenic from scene to scene.

Given its rather jumpy, jarring editing at times - something we'll get to shortly - one suspects Russell did a lot of work to try and iron out the tone in post-production, but the end result is still pretty unwieldly - especially for a large-budget adult drama aimed at mainstream audiences.

Advertisement

If somebody watched this movie and their reaction was simply, "What the hell did I just see?," it would be tough to blame them.

3. John David Washington's Off-Key Performance

20th Century Studios

Though Amsterdam's ensemble cast basically delivers in spite of the aforementioned issues, there is one surprising weak link in the pack, and that's John David Washington.

Advertisement

Washington plays lawyer and war veteran Harold Woodsman - basically the best pal of the film's protagonist Dr. Burt Berendsen (Christian Bale), and the movie's second lead character.

Yet Washington's performance comes off as strangely leaden throughout, especially during his scenes with Margot Robbie's former nurse Valerie Voze.

Advertisement

Despite their romantic entanglement, there's little chemistry to be found, and given the quality of Robbie's performance, it feels like the blame lies more on Washington's side.

It of course doesn't help that Washington spends most of the movie paired with two actors whose performances are expertly dialled in, but even so, it's an oddly low-energy, lackluster effort from the otherwise talented actor.

Advertisement

2. The Sloppy Editing

20th Century Studios

Despite David O. Russell again re-teaming with his reliable editor Jay Cassidy - who has earned two Best Film Editing Oscar nominations for his work with the director - something about their collaboration this time is rather off.

Advertisement

First and foremost, Amsterdam is way too long - countless scenes drag on far longer than they need to, and the film's third act in particular feels egregiously over-egged, wrapping up long after its point has been made.

It feels like Russell wasn't quite able to kill his darlings this time and simply allowed his cast to riff off however they liked, elongating scenes well past their point of tolerance.

Advertisement

Even at a more basic level, the editing is actively distracting: Russell will regularly cut between takes that retain little spatial continuity, meaning characters are doing something totally different when cutting from a close-up to a wide shot.

It's possible that Russell intentionally wanted to give the film a dreamlike, unreal style, yet when it ends up pulling the audience out of the movie, it clearly wasn't worth it.

Advertisement

1. David O. Russell's Flat Direction

20th Century Studios

Again, as much as there's a very strong argument to be made that David O. Russell is a pretty terrible human being, his filmmaking accomplishments speak for themselves.

Advertisement

He's an exceptional actors' director who has guided numerous performers to Oscar wins and nominations over the years, yet throughout Amsterdam it's tough to shake the feeling that the filmmaker - whose last film, Joy, was released way back in 2015 - has rather lost his step.

The confidence and self-assurance present in both Silver Linings Playbook and American Hustle is rarely glimpsed throughout Amsterdam, which feels considerably more skittish and uneven.

Advertisement

Whereas in those films Russell felt entirely in control of every aspect of the production, here it feels more like the project got away from him, and it's largely due to the efforts of the cast and the technical aspects that the film is still quite watchable.

And to that note, here's what actually makes Amsterdam still worth watching...

Advertisement

Ups...

5. Christian Bale's Excellent Performance

20th Century Studios

Without hesitation, Christian Bale easily takes MVP honours here, giving a characteristically excellent performance that outclasses everything else around him.

Advertisement

Though most of the cast fares well against Russell's script, it's Bale who proves most adept at modulating the wavering, uneven tone, managing to combine the tragic and comedic elements of his character into an entertaining whole.

It helps that Bale's Dr. Berendsen is an incredibly sympathetic and hard-done-by protagonist, yet given the off-kilter nature of the script, it can't have been easy for even an actor as incredible as Bale to get a firm handle on who he's playing.

Advertisement

And yet, Bale knocks it out of the park, as shouldn't really surprise anyone that's been following his career. Without his outstanding work, Amsterdam wouldn't be nearly as compelling.

4. The Sharp Cinematography & Production Design

20th Century Studios

It also shouldn't surprise anyone that Amsterdam is quite the handsome piece of work, given that it was lensed by legendary, three-time Oscar-winning cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki (Gravity, Birdman, The Revenant).

Advertisement

Even though Lubezki's fine compositions are constantly battling the hack-and-slash editing, his famed use of wide angle lenses serves him well here, often lending the film a heightened, hyperreal look that befits its stranger-than-fiction story.

A lot of the credit also has to go to the first-rate production design, which likely accounts for much of that $80 million budget. The below-the-line crew in general have done a fantastic job of evoking the 1930s, from street facias to cars, building interiors, and costumes.

Advertisement

In the very least, then, it's a pretty piece of work to look at.

3. The INSANE Ensemble Cast

20th Century Studios

Amsterdam touts perhaps the best ensemble cast of the entire year, and the sheer number of talented actors who show up in this thing frankly becomes ridiculous.

Advertisement

Beyond the fine upfront work from Christian Bale and Margot Robbie, Robert De Niro is also rather terrific as the well-meaning General Gil Dillenbeck, while Anya Taylor-Joy and Rami Malek are dryly funny as a pair of well-to-do siblings who play a crucial part in the wider story.

Elsewhere Mike Myers and Michael Shannon are hilarious as two conspicuous undercover spies, and Matthias Schoenaerts and Alessandro Nivola steal basically every scene they're in as two bumbling detectives working on the central murder case.

Advertisement

Beyond that, there are so many actors who show up for a quick scene or two: Chris Rock, Zoe SaldaƱa, Timothy Olyphant, Andrea Riseborough, Ed Begley Jr., and Leland Orser. Hell, even Taylor Swift is in this thing for a brief spell and, honestly, not too bad.

While the sheer star-studdedness risks pulling audiences out of the story, there is an undeniable fun in seeing so many skilled performers working together, even if only for a couple of scenes a pop.

Advertisement

2. Its Timely Themes

20th Century Studios

For better and sometimes worse, Amsterdam is the most timely film of David O. Russell's entire career.

Advertisement

Without going into too much detail regarding the plot's direction, there is a deeply committed attempt to parallel its story with certain traumatic events in recent American politics.

Russell is very clearly decrying fascist hatemongers who attempt to seize power while turning a nation's citizens against each other through manufactured hate and, yes, fake news.

Advertisement

And though Russell's script ultimately bashes the audience over the head with these ideas by film's end, it's still interesting to see a director of his general abrasiveness put such an earnest message into one of his movies.

1. It Basically Works As A Comedy

20th Century Studios

If you look at Amsterdam less as a drama depicting events that sometimes actually happened and more as a kooky, absurdist farce, it goes down much smoother.

Advertisement

After all, while the film's dramatics don't always convince, it is a consistently amusing piece of work, if often dryly so, which probably should've leaned even harder into the comedy side of things.

When it focuses on being a quirky character comedy using a real-life political backdrop, it often sings, even if the humour can be quashed by the film's aggressively all-over-the-place tone.

Advertisement

With a major editorial overhaul, Amsterdam probably could've been whittled into a leaner, more outwardly comedic offering, given that there are still many laughs to be had, and they're largely the most entertaining parts of the movie.