Annabelle: Creation Review: 6 Ups & 4 Downs

An unexpected improvement.

By Jack Pooley /

Warner Bros.

The latest entry into the fast-expanding Conjuring Universe is out now in cinemas, and critics have largely been calling Annabelle: Creation a surprisingly sturdy, well-crafted horror flick. Who could've seen that coming?

Advertisement

After all, expectations were certainly through the floor after the 2014 original was widely panned by most reviewers for being a dull, mostly scare-free squandering of a decent premise. With the film nevertheless making an insane $256.9 million worldwide, why would Warner Bros. bother putting any more effort into the inevitable follow-up?

Creation certainly isn't a perfect film, but it is yet more solid proof of Hollywood's impressive horror movie resurgence of the last few years, where quality entries into the genre have been in surprising abundance.

Advertisement

Above all else, it's further confirmation that James Wan's cinematic universe isn't just a cynical attempt to milk the cash cow, but actually an entertaining enterprise in its own right...

Downs...

4. There Are Too Many Jump Scares

Warner Bros.

For as many good decisions as the movie makes, it's a damn shame there are so many excessive jump scares in this film. From first minute to last, director David F. Sandberg peppers his film with lazy, obnoxious jumps that can be seen coming a mile off and so end up more irritating and arbitrary than thrilling.

Advertisement

More to the point, even something as simple as a toy gun being fired or someone entering a room will be mixed to be incredibly loud merely for the sake of a ridiculous jump, and barely more than a few minutes go by without yet another one assaulting the audience.

The film is good enough that it really didn't need to rely on such crusty old tricks, and it ends up proving an irritation that detracts from the overall experience.

Advertisement

3. Anthony LaPaglia & Miranda Otto Are Mostly Wasted

Warner Bros.

Anthony LaPaglia and Miranda Otto lead the movie's cast as Samuel and Esther Mullins, a couple who suffered through a terrible tragedy over a decade prior, and are now operating an orphanage for young girls out of their home.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, the script doesn't really give the talented pair much of interest to do. LaPaglia seems like he's going to get something meaty to work with but mostly just walks around staring creepily at the girls and telling them not to misbehave, while Otto spends the majority of the movie confined to a bed and hamming it up for the cheap seats.

Both definitely deserved better, and perhaps if the story has been restructured somewhat (with a mid-film flashback instead being placed chronologically), their characters might've played as a little more interesting. They're not bad by any means, just surprisingly small fixtures in the movie all things considered.

Advertisement

2. Annabelle's Origin Story Isn't That Interesting

Warner Bros.

In case you hadn't figured it out from the title, Annabelle: Creation is an origin story for the titular demonic doll and a prequel to the first film, explaining how Annabelle came to become possessed in the first place.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, though, Annabelle's origins aren't particularly interesting or surprising, and as long as you're basically conscious while watching the film, you'll have most of the basic beats figured out before they're eventually revealed later on.

It's not a terrible origin story by any means, just the most simplistic and generic route they could've gone. "Functional" might be the best descriptor: it's neat and tidy but totally uninspired and derived from any number of other horror movies.

Advertisement

1. The Tone Is All Over The Place

Warner Bros.

As is a problem with many big studio horror movies, there are many times where the film's tone seems to waver, and it's unclear whether the audiences is supposed to be scared or amused.

Advertisement

A number of the film's big scares, particularly those involving visual effects, are more campy and goofy than scary, which makes the film feel more like a Sam Raimi movie at times rather than a legitimately scary horror flick.

Naturally, mileage will vary on just how scary or funny these moments are (and the audience you see the movie with will dictate a lot of this), but there are certainly a number of important moments that inspire more laughter than fear, and that clearly wasn't at least always Sandberg's intent (though the film does also have some genuine, intentional humour).

Advertisement

These issues considered, the film certainly gets more right than it doesn't, so here's everything that works...

Ups...

6. It's A Major Improvement Over The First Film

Warner Bros.

First things first, this is unquestionably a massive improvement over the, frankly, really quite terrible original 2014 movie. Everything from the writing to the acting, direction, cinematography, editing and musical score are all vastly superior, ensuring that no matter this film's flaws, it's at least a major step in the right direction after the lazy horror stylings of its predecessor.

Advertisement

Whereas the first film seemed like a cynical attempt to cash in on the Conjuring franchise, this actually feels like a somewhat meaningful expansion of the universe, and even with its issues, certainly doesn't seem like a hastily-assembled effort churned out as quickly and cheaply as possible for an easy buck.

5. The Excellent Young Cast

Warner Bros.

Probably the most praise-worthy aspect of the entire movie is the fantastic cast of terrifically talented young actresses. Talitha Bateman as physically disabled orphan Janice and Lulu Wilson (who was also so good in last year's Ouija: Origin of Evil) as her pal Linda, are especially impressive and help bring plenty of humanity to the table.

Advertisement

Bad child actors can sink any movie no matter how good it otherwise is, but thankfully producer James Wan has a real knack for casting talented kids in all of these Conjuring Universe movies.

Though some of the orphan actresses do admittedly look a little old for their age (some of them are in their early-to-mid twenties and it shows), they make for a compelling team of terrified characters all the same, and yes, they can scream with the best of them.

Advertisement

4. David F. Sandberg's Impressive Direction

Warner Bros.

Warner Bros. knew what they were doing when they hired David F. Sandberg to helm this movie, considering the immense success of his feature debut last year, Lights Out, which scored positive reviews from critics and made almost 30x its $5 million budget at the box office.

Advertisement

Sandberg's certainly a step up from the first movie's director, John R. Leonetti, the man previously responsible for the disaster that was Mortal Kombat: Annihilation, in any case.

Though Sandberg is certainly battling an uneven script at times, he makes the absolute best of it with intriguing camerawork that fully exploits dark spaces for all they're worth, and certainly gets the most out of his young cast too.

Advertisement

The film cements that Sandberg has quite a future in the industry if he continues to perform at this level, having already been hired by Warner Bros. to direct the upcoming DC Extended Universe superhero movie Shazam.

3. Stephanie Sigman's Compelling Performance

Warner Bros.

Though it at first seems like Anthony LaPaglia and Miranda Otto are going to be the movie's adult protagonists, it really ends up being Stephanie Sigman, who you might recognise from her small role at the start of Spectre or from Netflix's hit show Narcos.

Advertisement

She plays Sister Charlotte, a nun charged with looking after the young orphan girls, and brings unexpected nuance to a character who could so easily have been a one-dimensional horror cliche.

Rather, Sigman makes Charlotte a dignified, likeable and resourceful heroine in her own right, ensuring she's easy to root for and you genuinely care when she's put in danger.

Advertisement

2. It's Creepy & Atmospheric

Warner Bros.

Though the scares themselves are pretty hit-and-miss, Sandberg does a fine job building a creepy and unsettling mood from the outset. It's easy to get wrapped up in this world and believe what's going on, compared to the first movie, which never really rose above bland actors playing out a pretend scary movie on a film set.

Advertisement

Thanks to the sharp cinematography and compelling cast, Creation builds up an uneasy sense of dread that permeates throughout, even though it's sometimes upended by the film's aforementioned divergences into campy territory.

In this respect the movie might actually benefit more from a home viewing rather than a theatrical one, where you can soak in the mood without an audience nervously giggling around you.

Advertisement

1. The Smart, Satisfying Ending

Warner Bros.

While the film's general explanation for Annabelle's possession isn't all that interesting, it does end on a compelling and slightly less predictable note that neatly folds the movie into the rest of the Conjuring Universe.

Advertisement

No spoilers here of course, but it's a fairly elegant solution that's not overly convoluted or complex, but draws a distinct line between all these movies in a satisfying manner.

Whether or not the finale leaves you eager to see another of these films in the future, if this was the last Annabelle movie, this would be a fine way to leave it. But it's probably not the last one, let's be honest.

Advertisement

What did you think of Annabelle: Creation?