Avengers 4: 15 Big Questions From Everything We Know So Far

Unpicking the secrets we all want to know...

By Simon Gallagher /

Marvel Studios

If movie spoilers were a currency, there's a very good chance that Avengers 4 Secrets would be at the very top of the chart of value. Forget your gold, your platinum, your diamond - the answer to the great conundrum of how the snap is undone would buy you the most, by some distance.

Advertisement

Inevitably, there's so much hype about the second half of the cinematic Infinity Saga's endgame (but it's not called that, remember) that any scrap of information relating to Avengers 4 will be hoovered up and spat out into a million different interesting fragments from now until next Spring. And that's exactly as Marvel clearly want it (or they wouldn't be guarding the title like the crown jewels).

So far, there hasn't been a great deal of information about the sequel, but thanks to casting updates, set leaks and some reasonable extrapolation of the first film's plot, it is possible to piece together some actual information. And that inevitably inspires a lot of intriguing questions.

Advertisement

So, what are the big questions that come out of everything we know for certain?

15. When Is It Set?

Marvel Studios

What We Know

Advertisement

Blended actress Emma Fuhrmann has been cast as an older Cassie Lang. Cassie Lang who should be around 15 or 16 in the film rather than the 10-year-old version played by Abby Ryder Fortson in the Ant-Man movies.

Clearly, part of the movie at least is going to be set further into the future than Infinity War's end, with one rumour suggesting there will be a five year gap in which the heroes work on adapting Hank Pym's technology to travel back in time somehow. That would certainly fit.

Advertisement

What We Need To Know

Will the movie indeed open five years later? Or will the rumoured time travel element see someone go forward in time too?

Advertisement

Gwyneth Paltrow has also apparently accidentally leaked the fact that she and Tony will be married and have a child in Avengers 4, so it would make sense that we will be skipping to the future. Tragically, though, that could mean that Tony is forced to give up his happy ending to save the universe?

14. Where Was Captain Marvel (And What Did The Page Say)?

Marvel

What We Know

Advertisement

Captain Marvel is coming. Having been paged by Nick Fury at the end of Infinity War, she will presumably arrive on Earth to help guide the heroes to victory (since Kevin Feige has apparently said she will lead "the entire MCU").

What We Need To Know

Advertisement

There's a lot to unpack about Marvel's role. First, what did Nick Fury actually send to Marvel? Was it a catch-all SOS message? In that case, does that mean they were both expecting a catastrophic event to happen? And if so, why wouldn't Marvel be on Earth ready?

That question in itself is a huge one and presumably we'll have an answer when her solo movie comes out next year. Why did she leave Earth after the 90s? And where has she been since then while Earth has faced other attacks (like Loki's invasion) if she was only a page away? There's going to have to be a compelling reason.

Advertisement

13. Could Shuri Become Black Panther?

Marvel Studios

What We Know

Advertisement

T'Challa - the king of Wakanda and Black Panther - is dead (for all intents and purposes), having been one of the heroes disappeared by Thanos' snap. His country is now leaderless, though as with most royal families, T'Chaka and Ramonda made an heir and a spare, so there could be an answer to that issue already made...

What We Need To Know

Advertisement

Shuri obviously already has a role as Wakanda's chief science officer (effectively), but as a princess, she's the next in like for the Wakandan throne and the next most likely candidate to be the new Black Panther. She might not have the Heart-Shaped Herb to fall back on for an improved physical profile, but Shuri is basically Tony Stark thanks to her genius and what she lacks in physical prowess, her brain could more than make up for.

And she'd certainly be a popular replacement for her brother. So could she be in line for a "promotion"? Even a temporary one?

Advertisement

She could, of course, face competition from Okoye and M'Baku as skilled warriors, but they're likely to have their own issues in Avengers 4.

12. Why Is Harley Keener Involved?

Marvel Studios

What We Know

Advertisement

Ty Simpkin, who played Harley Keener in Iron Man 3, has been announced as part of the cast for Avengers 4.

What We Need To Know

Advertisement

The big question is why? There's no way he will be playing a major role (because introducing such an obscure character to be pivotal to the story would just be weird), so we can probably expect something more like a cameo. And there's a pretty depressing reason that cameo might occur.

Could Keener be brought back in for a key event like Tony Stark's funeral? That can be the only real reason for someone with a personal link to the character but only a vague link to his story to be involved, barring the unlikely possibility that he's going to be introduced as a legacy Iron Man replacement or something along those lines.

Advertisement

So it probably isn't looking good for Tony...

11. How Will BARF Be Key?

Marvel Studios

What We Know

Advertisement

On MTV‘s Happy Sad Confused podcast, Avengers 4 director Joe Russo said fans should rewatch Civil War if they are looking for clues about the upcoming sequel:

“Certainly, there is a five minute sequence in Civil War around a piece of technology that was laid in for a very specific reason. If you go back and look at that film, you may get a hint as to the direction.”

His hint is clearly towards Tony Stark's delightfully-named BARF technology, which appears in the opening act of Civil War.

Advertisement

What We Need To Know

How exactly can a technology that Stark says is "an extremely costly method of hijacking the hippocampus... to clear traumatic memories" tangibly affect the plot? Could it be used tohijack Thanos' mind to manipulate him into taking back the snap? Or could it be something more sci-fi than that - like Stark retuning it to be a time travel device?

Advertisement

The latter is unlikely and it could well be that the Russos simply dropped that hint to suggest a reason for the set leaks showing the past will be revisited in Avengers 4. But then again, nothing in the MCU now is added without it paying off and BARF doesn't feel like it really has been yet. So there's definitely something there to be revealed.

10. Did Doctor Strange Have A Plan?

Marvel

What We Know

Advertisement

Doctor Strange visited the millions of possible futures during the climax of Infinity War to see how to ensure that the heroes won, coming back with the startling revelation that only one approach could possibly lead to victory. He then seemingly allowed himself to be killed after giving up the Time Stone and letting Thanos win.

What We Need To Know

Advertisement

So what gives? Did he actually do something as part of a secret plan that we didn't get to see in order to position the chess pieces in a way that would ensure victory? Did he time travel to warn Nick Fury he'd need to contact Captain Marvel? Did he se the Time Stone another way?

Or - more likely - did he simply realise that pawn sacrifices are the only way to win chess in the long-term, with the added safety net of knowing that he would be returned from the dead? After all, he couldn't SEE a victory he was dead for. So perhaps his plan was simply inaction?

Advertisement

Here's a bit of theorising to get your mind working...

Advertisement

9. Why Does Hawkeye Become Ronin (And What Happens In Tokyo)?

Marvel Comics

What We Know

Advertisement

Thanks initially to set leaks and then official images of Hawkeye, we know that Clint Barton is in for a bit of a make-over for Avengers 4. This follows the revelation that he's under house arrest during Infinity War after choosing to hand himself in and take a deal to be with his family.

Also, there was at least one sequence of the sequel set in Tokyo (where casting calls asked for Japanese gangsters, hinting at the involvement of the Yakuza) and that noth Jeremy Renner's Hawkeye and Scarlet Johansson's Black Widow filmed those scenes.

Advertisement

What We Need To Know

Firstly, how he's no longer under house arrest. Are the Accords (and thus their fallout) completely done now? Has the government forgiven him and Scott Lang and freed them? Or is it something more sinister that could feed into why he's now Ronin.

Advertisement

Could it be that his family were killed by Thanos when he snapped and that turned Barton darker and more edgy? It'd certainly fit his evolution into Ronin in the comics. And it would explain why he's back on active duty when he'd retired.

And then there's the Tokyo question. If the film is indeed set later, could we be looking at an Avengers mission to clean up the Yakuza? Or might there be more to it tying to other villains - as in the rumour that the Yakuza are actually Skrulls in disguise and the mission is being led by Captain Marvel... Either way, it's an interesting mystery.

Advertisement

8. Can Gamora Be Saved From Soul World?

Marvel Studios

What We Know

Advertisement

After Thanos snaps his fingers and half of existence crumbles to dust, there was a strange sequence in which he met Gamora again as a child on a mysterious red-baked version of her home planet. It was all very ethereal and seemed to be some sort of spiritual plane of existence, with the Russos later letting slip that it was set within the Soul Stone.

In a Q&A at Iowa City High School (via TheRealStanLee.com), Joe Russo confirmed as much:

Advertisement
“Yeah, it’s implied that it’s the Soul Stone. It’s all orange around, then [Thanos] is inside the Soul Stone with the amount of power that it took to snap his fingers – he has this out-of-body experience.”

That quote was later clarified somewhat saying Gamora's presence was "a spiritual representation of her."

What We Need To Know

Advertisement

So is she actually in the Soul World? Is that clarification just a means to cover their backs? And if she is indeed physically trapped within the Soul Stone, can she be rescued?

We know there's a strong hint that Gamora returns from set videos and details Zoe Saldana has shared herself, so there's a chance we're going to see exactly that. And the fact that none of the "time travel" leaks have shown Nebula or Rocket might suggest they go on an alternative mission to try and find Gamora as the key to defeating Thanos?

Advertisement

7. Will The Hulk/Banner Conflict Lead To "Professor Hulk"?

Marvel Studios

What We Know

Advertisement

Established over a three movie arc, Hulk and Bruce Banner's dynamic has changed massively from the start of the MCU. As Thor: Ragnarok revealed, Banner's fears about maintaining control came to be a reality and in Infinity War Hulk bit back at Banner "using him" whenever he needed the help but never letting him "drive" when there wasn't a threat.

Avengers 4 will mark the third movie in - and conclusion to - that particular arc as Mark Ruffalo has previously established.

Advertisement

What We Need To Know

Is the conflict going to end with a victor? Could Banner banish Hulk altogether? Would he even want to? Or could Hulk take control again as he did in Thor: Ragnarok and kick Banner out entirely? He certainly seems pissed off enough.

Advertisement

More likely, thanks to the allegedly official artwork for Avengers 4 showing Hulk wearing a costume and appearing smaller, it could be that we get to see an amalgamation of the characters. The so-called Professor Hulk could be introduced as a marriage of Banner/Hulk's personalities, which would presumably resolve their battle over control.

6. Is It Time Travel Or An Alternate Dimension?

Marvel Studios

What We Know

Advertisement

Set leaks from early on in production schedule seemed to show Captain America wearing his costume from The Avengers (the first movie, rather than the group of people), while the set appeared to be the Battle Of New York from the same movie. So it would seem that some heroes are going back to 2012 thanks to the devices they were wearing on their hands in the set photos.

But then, Kevin Feige has made it very clear that Ant-Man And The Wasp's plot is key to Avengers 4 and we already know how important multiverse travel is going to be in that, given the plot involves rescuing Janet Van Dyne from the Quantum Realm. The suggestion, based on the film's importance, is that they will actually travel to other dimensions to thwart Thanos.

Advertisement

What We Need To Know

So which is it? Are the devices "normal" time travel devices? Or do they allow the users to travel to alternate dimensions that are at different stages of the timeline (or are completely different universes)?

Advertisement

Or maybe it's a combination of the two? Perhaps the Quantum Realm (where time doesn't matter, remember) can be used as a crossroads to any point in time? That would offer a solution to both conundrums and would be legitimately satisfying.

5. What Is THAT Massive Scene?

Marvel Studios/Instagram

What We Know

Advertisement

There's at least one huge scene in which the entire MCU cast (aside from a couple of dead characters) will be appearing, including Janet Van Dyne and Hank Pym (as revealed by Sebastian Stan in an interview). Apparently, it will be the biggest ever MCU scene.

What We Need To Know

Advertisement

What is the nature of the scene? Is it a battle? If so, what sort of threat would require the entire reunited cast of characters (presumably it comes after the snap victims are resurrected if Bucky is involved) to come together?

If, as promised, it's like a comic book splash page, that would certainly fit, but it doesn't answer the question. Strictly speaking, this is one of the single most exciting opportunities for Avengers 4 and it's bound to be one of the most hyped elements.

Advertisement

4. Is Red Skull Done?

Marvel Studios

What We Know

Advertisement

When Gamora and Thanos traveled to Vormir to find the Soul Stone, they encountered a cursed Red Skull, who had been press-ganged into being the Stone's Guardian for his obsessive desire to collect the Infinity Stones (or at least one of them).

When Thanos retrieved the Stone by sacrificing Gamora, he was seemingly transported away from the mountain top and given the Stone and nothing more was heard of the Guardian.

Advertisement

What We Need To Know

Was that it for Red Skull? If the Soul World is to be introduced, he will likely be a valuable secret keeper who will need to be consulted by whoever goes after Gamora, which means he could return.

Advertisement

But if he has no Stone to guard, how can he be a Guardian?

The other thing that suggests he might not be done is the fact that he's cursed. It's not like the Stone being in possession of someone necessarily means he'd just be freed of that curse. It seemed more like your eternal sort of deal, after all. So he could still be stuck haunting Vormir.

Advertisement

3. Will EVERYONE Return From The Dead?

Marvel Studios

What We Know

Advertisement

Though the likes of Spider-Man, Black Panther, Doctor Strange and most of the Guardians Of The Galaxy were killed off, they all have sequels (either announced or considered to be in the planning stages). We also know that several of the supposedly dead characters have been filming Avengers 4 scenes, so they're likely to return in some way.

And of course there were some characters who were killed before the snap, so they would be a different consideration entirely.

Advertisement

What We Need To Know

Resurrections are inevitable, but will they be a blanket deal? Will the snap be entirely undone in one go with everyone simply being undisappeared? Or will the Soul Stone keep hold of some of its prizes?

Advertisement

Presumably, Gamora will return since she was sacrificed to a Stone, but Vision, Loki and Heimdall seem like they're goners forever since they were killed by brute force alone. So there's definitely different levels of dead here.

2. What Sacrifices Will Be Made?

Marvel Studios

What We Know

Advertisement

According to the ALLEGED first synopsis for the film - which will be no more than a placeholder if it is legitimate - the surviving heroes will come to realise that huge sacrifices will have to be made for them to undo what Thanos did to the universe.

On top of that, a theory suggests that Thor's vision in Age Of Ultron was actually misinterpreted as only dealing with Ultron, when in fact it refered to Thanos. And the extended version of that scene mentions sacrifice as the only way to win too.

Advertisement

What We Need To Know

What do those sacrifices mean? Will the rumour that the survivors will trade their own lives to save those who are dead turn out to be true? Will they be the cost paid to the Soul Stone in exchange for undoing Thanos' actions?

Advertisement

Or will it be slightly different - a sacrifice of their roles in a different way, which links into the last question...

1. Will The Stones Be Destroyed - Or Separated And Defended?

Marvel Studios

What We Know

Advertisement

Thanos WILL be defeated, one way of another. How he is beaten is probably the most valuable spoiler of 2019 (and in MCU history), but it's what comes after that matters even more.

What We Need To Know

Advertisement

In the comics, the Infinity Watch exists to each take a Stone and defend it, spreading them out across the galaxy. Could we see the same thing happen in Avengers 4, with the surviving heroes taking a Stone each to guard with the caveat that they have to give up everything they know and love in service of the role?

Or will the fact that Wanda was able to destroy the Mind Stone (albeit temporarily) come back into play with all of the Stones being destroyed outright? Hiding them would only work to a certain extent (and it's not like Thanos didn't manage to get them all together when they were split up anyway) and there's always a threat of someone getting big ideas of their power. Destroying them would offer a more permanent solution, assuming it's possible.

Advertisement

Quite how Doctor Strange and the sorcerors would feel about the destruction of the Eye Of Agamotto remains to be seen, admittedly...

Advertisement