Avengers Endgame: 10 Unexpected Consequences To Reversing The Snap
They said ‘whatever it takes’. Well, it took, and it took… and it kept on taking.
In the last couple of months there have been endless discussions about the implications of the events of Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame; not to mention some of the plot holes exposed by all the machinations required to pull off such a complicated, massive two-part story.
With a story as big as this, even in a three-hour movie there will always be things they didn’t have time to get into. In particular, the consequences of those two universe-shattering snaps, five years apart, will reverberate across the world for decades to come.
When Thanos snapped his fingers at the of Infinity War, he unleashed the worst act of genocide the universe had ever seen, causing long-lasting damage to everyone who was left. Now supposedly, Banner’s reversal of Thanos’ snap two thirds of the way through Endgame reverses those ill effects and restores the universe to the way it should be… but we don’t always get what we want.
Some consequences are obvious. Many of Peter Parker’s high school classmates will be adults with jobs and even families. Wakanda will surely have chosen a new king; how is the Black Panther going to regain his throne? Poor Laura Barton has returned to find her husband is a mass murderer with a price on his head from half a dozen cartels worldwide.
Other repercussions, while not as immediately evident, are potentially even more disastrous. Let’s examine some of the possibilities...
10. The Immediate Collateral Damage
It’s important to realise the scale of the atrocity inflicted by Thanos’ snap. At the end of Avengers: Infinity War, we had a taste of the collateral damage - a helicopter, presumably having lost its pilot, careens into the side of a New York skyscraper.
Plenty of people have already extrapolated that tragedy outward, proving that far more people actually died as a consequence of the snap than the immediate 50% of the population. Imagine how many airliners were in mid-flight at the time? What about vital crew onboard ships and submarines, or engaged in air traffic control?
What about the hospitals suddenly on a skeleton staff in the middle of an incalculable emergency; or power station, treatment plant and dam employees responsible for maintaining safety measures? The humanitarian cost would spiral into the hundreds of billions.
But that’s just the big, dramatic disaster movie stuff. What about the governments that lost vast numbers of civil servants and politicians? Thanos’ snap radically damaged the decision-making apparatus of whole nations.
New elections would need to be held for the vastly smaller electorate. Wakanda certainly wouldn’t be the only royal family to lose a monarch. Drastic emergency powers would need to be enacted: some regimes would use it as an excuse to mount a coup, destabilising whole regions.
The infrastructure of the entire world took a massive hit, and those ramifications would be felt for decades. Worldwide genocide on this scale would have profound knock-on effects… as would the delayed reversal of that genocide.
9. Those That Were Left Behind
Endgame’s narrative takes a little look at the emotional cost of Thanos’ snap, but on a personal, individual level.
But we’re not just talking about bereavement - we’re talking about loss and grief on a global scale. Think of the devastating effect that 911 had on the United States as a whole - well, that was an attack that killed less than 3000 people, 0.001% of the population. Multiply that by 50,000, and then expand that loss, that grief, to the whole world.
Suicide rates will have spiralled. Everyone will have lost someone; most will have lost far more. This is the kind of overwhelming, incomprehensible tragedy that would bring all of these suddenly smaller communities together; create new family units out of the remains of old ones.
So you’d think that the reversal of the snap and the return of all those who’d been lost would be an automatic win for everyone, right? For many, yes - but what about the spouses who’ve remarried, moved away? What about the young children who’ve grown five years older in someone else’s care?
Then there’s the people - a tiny, precious few, hopefully - who don’t want their snapped back. What about the wives who magically lost their drunk, violent husbands, or the kids who lost the person who’d been abusing them? Thanos remodelled their world too… and not necessarily for the worse. Now those weak, dangerous people are back: confused, angry and looking to reclaim what they believe is theirs.
8. Those That Were Brought Back
Things become even more complicated when you consider how the world would need to deal with the return of the snapped… because they may not have lives to return to.
First, they’re legally dead. Their governments would have had to bring in emergency powers to fast track processing so many dead citizens. Those who’d made a will would have been prioritised, and their property already passed on; it may not even be in the family anymore.
Those without a will may actually be better off: even with fast track processes, probate courts will have been bottlenecked for years, so their property, in limbo, could still be restored to them.
But even after all those family reunions, so much will have changed. Younger siblings may now be older siblings. Many spouses will have moved on, leaving their homes and moving in with family elsewhere, even remarrying. Many of the returned, especially children, may not be able to trace their families. And what about those returned whose loved ones have died in the intervening five years?
The fact is, communities large and small, united in grief, will have reknit. Look at apocalyptic narratives like The Walking Dead, and how those radical changes affect families, whole societies in only a few years.
What’s it going to be like for those who come back to find this smaller, sadder world, who now find themselves crammed into a life that’s, by and large, left them behind?
7. What Happened To The Sokovia Accords?
Judging by the small glimpses we get of life five years after ’the snap heard around the world’, Steve Rogers and Natasha Romanoff are no longer public enemy number one: he’s free to move around in public, she’s back in the old Avengers HQ directing traffic.
Nothing in Endgame indicates that there are any objections being raised to the use of superpowers or skills. The same is true of Banner in his new Hulk form - he’s able to rescue people from a burning building in the film’s new footage without anyone slapping a restraining order on him.
Then there’s the apparently frictionless resettlement in Norway of a still-significant number of Asgardian refugees, and the lack of political consequences to anyone working in those international and/or extraterrestrial operations that the Black Widow is trying to organise.
The implication is clear: their actions in fighting off yet another alien invasion, not to mention the stunning, tragic aftermath of their one failure, seem have rendered any outstanding charges against them irrelevant and any new charges pointless.
Perhaps it’s also a side effect of so many governments losing so many vital personnel so suddenly: people have to have priorities in global crises, after all.
Whatever the case, the Sokovia Accords are a political memory.
6. A World Without The Sorcerer Supreme
We’ve talked a little about the collateral damage involved in Thanos’ snap: how the loss of the wrong person at the wrong place at the wrong time could cause dozens, maybe hundreds of others to suffer.
Well, the sorcerer Stephen Strange was one of those countless victims - and he was the Sorcerer Supreme of the Earth Dimension, the first and last line of defence for this plane of existence against the myriad horrors that encroach upon our reality from outside space and time.
So what happens in his absence? Do some Council Of Elders somewhere look through their rolodexes to find another powerful wizard to take on the job? Does Wong step up, or - god forbid - Mordo?
Because if not, then there will be an SS-shaped hole in the universe for five years: five years, during which time the whole of this plane of reality will have been left open to abuse by appalling hellspawn with breathtakingly poor hygiene and worse social skills. To quote Terry Pratchett, “the pretty ones look like a cross between an ugly octopus and an angry bicycle.”
But let’s say the Universe replaces the Sorcerer Supreme to avoid exactly this scenario taking place. One assumes that Strange will then have to contend with his replacement upon his resurrection, or relinquish the mantle and no longer be Sorcerer Supreme.
And does Strange’s death - even if only temporary - remove the promise that Dormammu made to him to leave this dimension alone?
5. People Will Take Advantage
In situations like this, the cynical and exploitative will rise up to take advantage of matters for their own gain. Some of these will belong to organised and opportunistic crime: just as many, however, will be part of the millionaire and billionaire class in the developed world. And they’ll do it legally.
Look at Prohibition. The Volstead Act was passed in 1920 to ban the production, importation, transportation, and sale of alcoholic beverages in the USA. Before the law had even come in, the rich were buying up whole warehouses of booze to stash as their private supplies: the rich could still drink, but the poor were dry.
Then the criminal element added bootlegging to their revenue streams. There were over 7,000 violations of the Act within six months; a year later it was nearly 30,000, it rose significantly further over the following decade and those were just the ones they caught.
Now imagine that, but on a global scale and covering every single aspect of people’s lives. The insurance and banking industries contract? That’s a rise in loan sharks and protection rackets. Half the police are dead? That’s an increase in looting and armed robbery.
A proportion of the population are living in sudden desperate poverty? They’re wide open for human trafficking and sexual exploitation: organised crime flourishes in those conditions like knotweed in unkempt gardens. People are griefstricken, living in misery? Cottage industries will arise to provide a variety of coping mechanisms, legal and otherwise, and at extravagant cost.
4. Economic Crises Mean Radical Changes In The Law
The emergency powers needed to deal with this sudden loss of life have already been touched on, but let’s go further.
First, simple mathematics. Half as many people means half as much taxation: right when the majority of governments need to shore up infrastructure and create programmes to deal with the aforementioned aftereffects of worldwide genocide.
When the snapped return, the vast majority will be in no position to immediately begin contributing again, placing an untenable burden on economies that were already stretched to breaking point.
This would lead to numerous poorer nations plunging into debt. Look at the recent crisis in Greece, the longest running recession of any developed nation, where draconian austerity and reforms led to a humanitarian crisis, poverty and loss of income countrywide, increasing social exclusion, turning the political system on its head and resulting in the loss of hundreds of thousands of the more well-educated and well-off as they sought a better life elsewhere.
Well, post-Endgame practically every country would be suffering that level of crisis or worse, and enacting the kind of scary-ass legislation that previously you could only read about in the dystopian fiction section of the bookshop.
We’re talking increased basic taxation, the debriding of basic services, restriction of movement, martial law in places: the whole totalitarian nine yards.
3. The House Of Maximoff
Taking a quick break from all this jolly talk of worldwide horror, let’s look at Wanda Maximoff.
In Marvel Comics’ Avengers continuty, the Scarlet Witch has the power to alter reality. The ability to change what’s real affects her perception of what’s real and - long story short - she has a nervous breakdown and attacks the Avengers; killing Hawkeye, Ant-Man and the Vision and creating an alternate reality, a supposed paradise in which everybody gets what they want.
There’s more (much more) - but that’s the gist. Now in the MCU, Wanda Maximoff has suffered her own series of tragedies: she lost her parents in a bombing attack when she was ten, and was groomed by terrorists, volunteering later on in life to be experimented on using the Mind Stone. Joining up with the Avengers, her twin was killed; she then fell in love with the Vision, who was murdered by Thanos, who then murdered her.
Five years later, this woman born of a lifetime of loss and trauma - her DNA rewritten by an Infinity Stone - is reborn in a world that has completely forgotten Sokovia, her brother, her lover and herself. She never even got to bury or say goodbye to Vision.
What might happen to this Wanda Maximoff? The scene is theoretically set for another breakdown, but how far do her powers really go in the cinematic universe? Can she bring back Quicksilver and Vision? Black Widow?
Can this Scarlet Witch rewrite reality to her whim?
2. The Delayed Collateral Damage
With any world-changing event, the national and global infrastructure and resources that manage the population shrinks to accommodate a drastically smaller population.
Look at what happened after each world war. 75-80 million people died in World War II. It took Western Europe fifteen years to recover, including the recovery of the birth rate and the working population and hits on education, nutrition and production.
Now, the world population as of 2018 was around 7.6 billion. That’s 3.8 billion people dead in Thanos’ snap, or over forty times as many as died in World War II. Whole industries would lose half the demand for their services and half the staff that provided them: thousands of businesses would shut down.
It gets worse. The world’s financial institutions rely on equilibrium to operate. Let’s say ABC Insurance loses half its customers; that’s a drastic drop in revenue, and the customers who are left are certain to be making more claims, so suddenly more money is going out than coming in. Well, most financial institutions would be in that same sinking boat, with no one in a position to bail them out.
And after five years, with the global economy shrunk to the size of a walnut but beginning to show signs of adjusting to the new normal, those 3.8 billion people suddenly reappear. In a single day, the demand for goods and services rockets back to 2018 levels... but with a 2023 economy left to deal with it.
These are the conditions for societal collapse and worldwide poverty.
1. World Peace
Stark’s retired and living by the lake; Thor is on a downward spiral in New Asgard; the happy and well-adjusted Banner has become a celebrity firefighter; and Hawkeye’s working on extending the second stage of grief into a lifestyle choice.
Captain America? Natasha makes a crack about him coming home to do his laundry. It’s a reference to what college kids do when they drop back in to see the parents, and implies that Cap hasn’t been around either. In point of fact, until the time heist we don’t see Steve suited up for any reason.
The others might have prioritised whatever they’re working through, but Captain America doesn’t take days off. The only reason he’d be heading up support groups and not kicking ass is that there are no asses to kick.
Natasha is coordinating efforts on the part of the few remaining heroes, but it’s obvious she’s not needed. No one has anything to report, and they clearly haven’t for some time. In her own way, Natasha’s as broken as Hawkeye: the team was her way of atoning for all the damage she caused, and they failed. That hairstyle’s not her new look - the usually immaculate Black Widow hasn’t cut or coloured her hair since Infinity War’s platinum bob.
Those rises in street level crime we talked about are certainly real (hence Barton’s vendetta): but Avengers level stuff? Conflicts between countries? Terrorism, alien invasions, badass world-dominating supervillains? They don’t seem to exist anymore.
Thanos brought peace to the world.