Avengers: Endgame - How Thanos' Snap ACTUALLY Worked

The anatomy of the MCU's Decimation event...

By Simon Gallagher /

Marvel Studios

When Infinity War's devastating end seemingly brought an end to Thanos' mission to rebalance the universe - at least in terms of allowing him to achieve his objective of wiping out half of the universe's life - the loudest question on most fan's minds was what the actual f*ck was going on. As the initial pain wore off, we all began to pose more questions, like Captain America stuck in a loop and unable to move on from the Decimation.

Advertisement

How would the Avengers undo the snap? How could they possibly hope to fight Thanos again? If they decided to time travel, how would they make sure they didn't wipe themselves and their allies out of the timeline entirely? And how would they even time travel in the first place?! It's all very concerning and while Endgame is just around the corner, that's no medicine for the anxiety. The questions are just too big.

But what about that one big question nobody seems to be asking because of the mythology of the film we've been fed for the past ten years or so? What about the question of how the Infinity Gauntlet actually allows Thanos to kill half of existence?

Advertisement

On the paper the MCU has printed, the answer is something along the lines of the following: the Infinity Stones are hugely powerful elemental crystals borne out of the big bang, which control an essential aspect of existence. They don't have total control over those aspects, but are powerful enough to be able to manipulate them. It stands to reason that controlling all together means the ability to control every aspect of existence.

Thanks to the need for dramatic limits, it was established in the MCU that no two Stones should be kept together, because of their volatility (even alone in the wrong hands they're dangerous) and that even the most powerful of wielders would need a Gauntlet (or another specially made artifact) to allow them to temporarily harness that full power. And of course, it was firmly established that while all of the Stones are individually powerful and can be amplified by others, they cannot reach full potential until they're all together.

Advertisement

That wasn't introduced solely because it meant Thanos had to hunt each of the Stones, it was also introduced to fit in with the idea of the Avengers themselves being far stronger as a unit than they are individually. Even the Gods, supermen and aliens. It's a clever little conceit that is the key to taking down Thanos.

Marvel Studios

But none of that explains how the Decimation worked. It explains the narrative context of the Stones and sort of leaves the real explanation to a hand-wave of magic. They're infinitely powerful merely because they're infinitely powerful. But in a comic book movie universe that seeks to be THIS grounded, and which has more often than not come up with a scientific explanation for everything (aside for Doctor Strange's mysticism, but even then, that's rooted in inter-dimensional travel so it's not entirely unscientific), there needs to be an explanation. And that's what we're here for. You lucky devils.

Advertisement

So let's pick apart from each of the Stones works together to allow Thanos to achieve his Decimation, because while each controls an aspect of existence, their powers also combine perfectly to create a mass extinction event possible.

But first, a real world science lesson that seeks to work out how an essentially magical artifact can work in a grounded work of science. And it all comes down to quantum energy.

Advertisement

Quantum Theory is a broad spectrum banner that basically allows theorists to posit lots of wild ideas because it is a field geared consciously around ignoring conventional laws of physics. That's why the Quantum Realm is called what it is and positioned as a sort of anything goes realm of chaos where time doesn't matter. In fact, there's a very good chance that all of the aspects of existence that the Stones control do not affect the Quantum Realm. If time has no meaning that's already a fairly big indication and the time vortexes mentioned in Ant-Man & The Wasp probably suggest Space Stone like behaviour occurs naturally.

Using the hand-waving "Quantum Energy" excuse might as well be an indication that there is a whole dimension in the MCU where science means nothing. Where all bets are off. Want to know why the Infinity Saga writers and diret=ctors have talked up the importance of the Quantum Realm in Endgame? Because it's where science doesn't matter, where the Stones don't matter and where the explanation for the Stones' power has its roots.

Advertisement

Quantum Theory might as well mean fringe science and that's precisely where the Gauntlet's mechanics come in. Because the Gauntlet is powerful even beyond metaphysical ideas like the essential characteristics of existence - hence being able to control them - the science here is... atypical. It exists, most logically, by its own established rules.

So how do we explain it all using the Stones?

Advertisement

4. The Power Stone

Marvel Studios

It would be easy to simply consider The Power Stone as merely the energy supply for the Decimation. There's a big clue, after all, in the name. It can control the destructive force of the universe - hence Ronan's desire to control it to help him destroy Xandar.

It isn't just a power source though: the key characteristic of the Stone is its ability to amplify existing powers, as well as anyone who uses it's strength and durability. Thanos uses it for various small feats of power in Infinity War, including torturing Thor and uses it in battle with the Avengers to project destructive energy beams similar to those that destroyed the Collector's home within Knowhere.

Advertisement

For the Snap, the Power Stone amplifies the energy signatures of the other Stones at the same time as making Thanos durable enough to withstand the impact of the Decimation himself. It is both energy supply and insulator.

[Continued Page 1 of 3]

Advertisement

3. The Space And Time Stones

Marvel Studios

In scientific terms, an object cannot truly exist without a relationship with both space and time. An event cannot truly happen if not in three dimensional space. And since the Space and Time Stones control those aspects of existence, they are key to allowing Thanos to manipulate all matter in the universe simultaneously.

Advertisement

In effect, because all objects and events are defined by how they move through spacetime as a unified material (which is what Einstein defined in his general theory of relativity), Thanos needs to control both in order to make ANYTHING happen using the Gauntlet. It's almost best to consider the unified Space and Time Stones as the Gauntlets grip on every single piece of matter in the universe for that brief moment that Thanos snaps his fingers.

2. The Mind And Soul Stones

Marvel Studios

It seems that the relationship between the Mind and the Soul Stones is what allows Thanos to choose his targets and also to snuff out their life force.

Advertisement

The Mind Stone can control consciousness, which is clearly a major part of living. It is not entirely a scientific concept, though there are lots of strains of Quantum Theory that deal with consciousness that would require lots of impenetrable language and several degrees to decipher in any meainingful way. The important thing is that there is some thinking to suggest that consciousness is a direct response to neurological energy and the interaction of particles, like all physics.

The Mind Stone seemingly works like Cerebro in X-Men, locking onto those signatures to control them and identifying which half of the targets will be wiped out. It effectively chooses half of consciousness to take away.

Advertisement

The Soul Stone is linked with more of a metaphysical element, but we know that it is linked to the soul. It not only grants the user some control over life and death, but it also contains a pocket dimension where the user can communicate with the souls of the dead. This pocket dimension, presumably, is another of the MCU's "afterlife" constructs, like Valhalla, which are essentially other dimensions, to give them scientific grounding. If the exchange between Thanos and Gamora is anything to go by, this Soul World is the means through which Thanos send his victims from the living realm to the dead once the Mind Stone has targeted them.

Together they fundamentally control the two sides of conscious life - neurological consciousness and the essence of life, as embodied by the Soul.

Advertisement

And finally, the Reality Stone...

[Continued Page 2 of 3]

Advertisement

1. The Reality Stone

Marvel Studios

If the Time and Space Stones determine how Thanos can interact with all manner and make an "event" happen, the Reality Stone governs how he changes that matter. It is the Stone responsible for that grim but not entirely uncool fading effect that had such an impact when his Snap victims died.

Advertisement

As is established in Infinity War, the Reality Stone can change matter to reflect false realities. It is a means by which the wielder may rearrange matter, like turning the Guardians into ribbons so they cannot fight him or turning laser bolts into bubbles. The Time and Space Stones allow Thanos to grip the universe's very matter, but the Reality Stone allows him to arrange it all as he sees fit.

Obviously without the Mind and Soul Stone, Thanos manipulation of matter would include "decimating" all the other types of matter that is linked to conscious existence. He wouldn't simply wipe out half of life, he'd wipe out half of all matter, which would not be ideal. And without the Power Stone he couldn't hope to do any of it on a scale as large as he needs for the Decimation.

Advertisement

Each Stone is a cog in a powerful engine and in order for Thanos to enact his very specific plan, he needs them all to do very specific jobs. It may look like he's snapping his fingers - a simple act - but the scientific theory beneath it suggests an incredibly complex event. Which is precisely why Thanos is accurate in saying that it cost him everything and why the Russos were so keen to reiterate that the snap fundamentally broke him.

All of this suggests that the only way to undo the Snap is to recreate exactly the circumstances of the first event or to bring in anomalous science that overrides all of that. For either of those things to be true, we have to turn to the realm where science doesn't matter (or at least not in conventional terms): the Quantum Realm.

Advertisement

For there to be time travel, the laws of Time have to be suspended. For there to be interdimensional travel, the laws of Space have to be suspended. For there to be a resurrection, the laws of finite consciousness have to be suspended. For there to be an event of equal magnitude to the Decimation (in order to reverse it), the laws of power have to be suspended. All that's left is Quantum Theory, Quantum Energy and the Quantum Realm.

Well, they did say that it would be key...

Advertisement