Avengers: Endgame Review - 11 Ups & 4 Downs

"Whatever it takes!"

By Simon Gallagher /

Marvel Studios

The first Age Of The MCU is over. The Infinity Saga has ended and some of the original Avengers' stories have come to satisfying (or devastating) conclusions. If it feels a little like you've been put through the wringer, it's because you have. Both Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame put such a high premium on emotional intensity and trauma in their stories that it's natural to feel a little battered.

Advertisement

Luckily, the mascara can be reapplied and red eyes will subside eventually and what we'll be left with is the very real picture that the last 11 years of Marvel Studio's incredible expanded universe have been some of the most rewarding, enriching and entertaining film-making of all time.

While it's somewhat inevitable that there will be lots of extremes and binaries applied to Endgame (is it good or bad? Is it better than Infinity War or worse?), the reality is that it is a complex experience. It is both magnificently entertaining and problematic. Both brilliant and frustrating at times. But what matters is the balance, just as it does to Thanos.

Advertisement

Now, with the film out in cinemas, let's look at how well the film achieves its goals and what doesn't quite work. First the positives...

Ups

11. The Marketing Has Been GENIUS...

Marvel Studios

When the Russos claimed that there was a lot of misdirection in the marketing and even fake scenes that had been shot they really weren't kidding. Several trailer shots were manipulated to remove entirely characters and lots more were artfully concealed out of context to completely throw us all off.

Advertisement

Even the introduction of the idea of a Vision/Scarlet Witch TV show seems to have been a masterful stroke, because it suggested something inherent by its very existence.

Watching that film and comparing it to the expectations we all had (well, those of you not trained implicitly to hoover up all spoilers and leaks as a matter of course), it's nothing like it could have been. Nothing like we were led to believe it might be, apart from in the broadest strokes.

Advertisement

10. ...And There ARE Shocks

Marvel Studios

And on the same point, it's impressive how much of the film the studio managed to keep locked down. Sure, there were lots of leaks that were absolutely spot on, but through a campaign encouraging the consideration of misdirection and the not-exactly unconscious encouragement of the spread of fake leaks (or so I suspect), they managed to ball up the real leaks with falsities.

Advertisement

That meant that certain of the more ridiculous, unexpected elements that leaked were simply batted away as impossible because of their absurdity.

And even beyond that, there are some key story elements that happen - and crucially, some that DON'T - that will have come as a surprise to even the most committed of spoiler fiends. In 2019, with this film ranking as the most valuable possibly ever in spoiler terms, that is incredibly impressive.

Advertisement

There really is something to be said about being willing to be sillier than anyone would think viable.

9. The Commitment To Spectacle

Marvel Studios

As with Avengers: Infinity War, Endgame is deeply invested in grand moments. Unlike Infinity War, they don't come particularly frequently, because the focus is mostly on one extended set-piece in particular which forms the centre-piece for the final third of the movie.

Advertisement

In short, that final third is some of the most breath-taking, bewildering, astonishing film spectacle anyone will ever witness. Not just in terms of comic book movies. Not just in war movies. And it would be entirely unprecedented were it not for the fact that the Russos did it once already with Wakanda.

Still, the spectacle here feels just like what you'd expect of a second part: it is an escalation. There are more characters, more team-up choreography, more meme-able moments and it's all so incredibly intoxicating that you won't remember any of the holes or messiness or self-indulgent hints up to it.

Advertisement

8. It Genuinely Is The Right Ending

Marvel Studios

We've been primed to think of this as an ending since long before Infinity War came out. It's not only the full-stop on Phase 3 or to the Infinity Saga, it's also the end of the First Age Of The Avengers.

Advertisement

And rather cleverly, while it was called the Infinity Saga, that seems to have been misdirection to hide the fact that this was in fact the Tony Stark Saga. Sure, the endings for some of the other original characters - Hawkeye, Thanos, and Captain America in particular - are great and very satisfying, but in the end, the real story was the Iron Man one.

Even without spoiling it, it's an incredible pay-off to how his story has developed from the moment he appeared back in 2008 and this ending is just brilliantly well crafted from top to bottom. Interestingly, it also comes with the caveat of important things yet to come too, which is clearly key.

Advertisement

7. Paul Rudd (And Some Other People Who Are Funny Too)

Marvel Studios

If there's anything that people will focus on as divisive in this film, a lot of it is probably linked to the use of humour - not merely in frequency, but in terms of where it comes in proximity with huge, tense or emotionally challenging moments.

Advertisement

But very impressively, the film never really shoehorns any comedy in in a way that some other MCU movies have in the past to less success. And it's mostly because the comedy duties fall to Thor, Rocket and, in particular, Paul Rudd, who is to be cherished and protected at all costs.

Rudd's fish-out-of-water comedy spirit works incredibly well here: we know he's not the same as the other heroes and there's enormous reward in it. He's also key to the plot, obviously and he gets a great spectacle moment late on, but he knits lots of scenes together with some very welcome levity that shouldn't be ignored.

Advertisement

6. Starting With A Bang (Again)

Marvel Comics

Just as Infinity War's opening act was breathlessly begun with the deaths of Loki and Heimdall, Endgame starts from a similarly motivated stand-point to show us where we stand for the rest of the movie.

Advertisement

The opening is a scene chosen precisely to make you feel, strongly, that there are going to be some serious emotional stakes here. It's not the same as that scene in space in Infinity War, but you feel the blows even stronger in this case because of their intimacy and that's pretty much the biggest lesson Marvel seem to have learned since their earliest days.

The beginning also lends itself to Hawkeye's storyline, which is wonderfully compelling right up until he's called into active duty and it's all surprisingly grown-up (particularly for a film of this rating). The new "Ronin" figure is a legitimate badass, whose motivation is as dark as it is utterly convincing and it all satisfyingly pays off the story that was seeded way back in Avengers: Age Of Ultron.

Advertisement

And speaking of great character arcs...

5. Hulk's Entire Storyline

Marvel Studios

You might think that it's a bit of a shame that lots of Hulk's storyline in Endgame has successfully been leaked in terms of what stage his character is at with marrying his human side to his Hulk side, but the pay-off here is just genius. Last we saw of him, Banner was calling him a big green a-hole, but he's come along way since.

Advertisement

Not only is the first appearance of the new-improved Banner one of the most hilarious of the entire MCU, but it also fits with the way the character has been heading since Age Of Ultron too. Mark Ruffalo told us that this was going to be the culmination of that arc and he wasn't wrong, but even knowing some things about it, the actual moment of revelation and pretty much everything that follows for Hulk is completely infectious.

Props too to the effects department, because Hulk has never looked as impressive. Serious amounts of the budget have clearly gone into capturing that.

Advertisement

4. The Emotional Gut Punch

Marvel

While the satisfying element of the ending - and Tony Stark's arc in particular - have already warranted close inspection, it's important to address another part of the ending: the emotional toll it takes.

Advertisement

Sure, there's a slight whiff of Lord Of The Rings: Return Of The King's inability to deliver one concise full-stop but that the approach isn't necessarily a bad thing and it actually achieves something that few will have thought possible. It matches Infinity War's ending for emotional impact.

In actual fact, there's something to be said for the idea that Endgame's most provocatively tear-jerking moment is more authentic than Infinity War's. It certainly has more character depth behind it and the emotion you'll feel is a lot more complex than the drama the Russos manipulated into the Decimation and its aftermath.

Advertisement

If you don't cry at least once in this film, you've a heart of stone.

3. The Character Work

Marvel Studios

Part of the reason why the film is so long and another reason for its satisfaction rating being so high is the craft with which the writers and the Russos approached character development. Even though this was SUPPOSED to be an escalation and you might have expected everything to be turned up to 11, the things the creators actually turned up mostly were the characters.

Advertisement

There's a lot more Cap here than there was in Infinity War, there's further examination of Tony Stark's reactions to trauma, there's a whole new dynamic for Thor and Hawkeye and Black Widow and Hulk are completely different too. And despite all of the changes, nothing feels like an ass-pull: everything is set up and measured thanks to the luxury of time afforded by the decision to focus mostly on a smaller core cast.

Barely anyone that matters up to the point of the change of gear into the third act sees any of their story-telling compromised (Rocket SLIGHTLY takes a backseat, but he's not an OG Avenger, so it's justified) and that's impressive in a film of this scale.

Advertisement

2. The Guardians 3 Set-Up

Marvel

Inevitably, lots of talk will turn to what comes next in the MCU after the end of Endgame and there are lots of interesting theories to posit at this point. Quite what the ending means to the Avengers Initiative is a pretty big question, who might not return for future movies is another, but the best part of it all is the suggestion of what Guardians Of The Galaxy Vol 3 is going to look like.

Advertisement

There's a very brief mention of what the story is going to focus on, as well as what we already know about Adam Warlock and the Sovereign's renewed involvement and a VERY interesting development for the line-up too.

Without wandering into too spoilerific territory, that has quickly become the most exciting film on Marvel's immediate slate and it can't come quickly enough. Considering the majority of the Guardians are barely even in this movie, that's some going.

Advertisement

1. Some Of The Pay-Offs Are Insanely Rewarding

Marvel Studios

There's something you need to know right out of the gate at this point: when fan service is done badly, it's called fan service. When it's done brilliantly, it's called a pay-off. Somehow, the idea of catering to fans is now a dirty concept, but it's not always a bad thing when it's done right.

Advertisement

And for a lot of the time, the Russos get the balance right. There are complex, organically built character moments and clever pay-offs throughout, but there are also completely meme-able moments too. Captain America gets one. Hulk gets a couple. Ant-Man gets one. Iron Man gets a huge one. A whole sub-group of heroes gets one. Pepper Potts gets one.

None of those ones are anything but beautifully rewarding and they will be the moments that transcend the limits of this film. They're the things we will talk about for years to come, quite apart from the excellent but more subtle writing, and some of them are truly the best spots in the entire MCU.

Advertisement

And now to the Negatives...

Downs

4. It's Genuinely Full Of Plot-Holes

Marvel Studios

There are lots of really, really satisfying moments in this film. There are scenes that will have you on the verge of punching the air (or actually doing it if you aren't a Brit with a reductive sense of decorum and cinema etiquette, in fact) and there are moments that will make you laugh and cry in equal measure. Thanks to those moments, it's easy to forgive the fact that this film is utterly ludicrous.

Advertisement

The plot takes the only viable option and adds some interesting conceits to it, but there's a lot of hand-waving (like the attempt to explain causality and paradoxes that just seems wilfully obtuse to stop you listening properly or something) and when you start to pick it apart, it's full of massive plot holes.

There are two in particular that actually threaten to ruin the end of the film - and certainly the end of two major character arcs and the more distance there is between you and the jaw-dropping spectacle, the louder they shout.

Advertisement

3. The Treatment Of PTSD Is BAD

Marvel Studios

Without spoiling the specifics, let's just say that Thor goes through a major change in this movie thanks specifically to his part in "failing" to stop Thanos at the end of Infinity War. It's the latest in a series of examinations of culpability and PTSD and given how well the MCU has dealt with both to date, you'd think it would be done very well.

Advertisement

But for all of the memeable qualities this new Thor comes with, there's a pretty big, very insistent problem with his character that is partly linked to the disparity between his make-up as a comedy character (on the back of Thor: Ragnarok) and the reverence given to PTSD in this franchise so far.

Look at anything beneath Thor's surface and it feels a little like his mental health (which SHOULD be in tatters given what he's been through) is the butt of the joke. And that's not really on.

Advertisement

2. There's Too Much Fan-Service At Times

Marvel Studios

Remember that point about the distinction between pay-offs and fan-service? Well, here it comes again, because there are times - particularly during the fist two thirds where the film begins to stray into the realms of back-slapping fan-service.

Advertisement

There are even times when the directors might as well have turned to the camera with a knowing wink. As with Captain America's backside, for instance, or Cap's new weapon or the treatment of a pair of favourites from Thor: Ragnarok. They're telling us they KNOW what we want and that they're happy for us to have it. But that their participation is a very conscious part of the transaction.

Yes, it's good to get a lot of what we want, but if everything is the sweetest pie you've ever tasted, would you really want to gorge?

Advertisement

It also feels somewhat like the end of Cap's story sets up a future that simply hasn't been earned. Yes, it's a new direction, but everything has to be seeded in earlier films for something that major to be pulled out last minute.

1. Some Of The CGI Is Really, Really Bad (In IMAX At Least)

Marvel Studios

This might be a problem limited to the IMAX screenings, but that's something a traditional screen watcher will have to confirm down in the comments. Basically, a lot of the CGI in the first act is extremely ropey.

Advertisement

The sequence showing Ant-Man's experiments into time travel are a particularly glaring example as Paul Rudd's face is digitally added to his suit visor and somehow looks magnified massively.

Worse still is the distracting green screen work in most of the Avengers Facility sequences. Whether that's more down to IMAX rather than poor effects work remains to be seen, but the decision to shoot so many of the backgrounds in those sequences and dding digital backgrounds costs the film something in the highest definition.

Advertisement

That also goes for the emaciated Tony Stark from right at the start and one de-aged character from one of the "time heist" sequences, who aren't quite right under the added scrutiny of IMAX.

What did you think of Avengers: Endgame? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.

Advertisement