Barbie Review: 8 Ups & 2 Downs
Is it plastic or fantastic?
Gestating all the way back in 2014, the Barbie movie was hit by endless changes in writers, directors, studios and actors. (Amy Schumer was set to play the lead role originally.) For a time, it looked like a live-action feature centred around Mattel's most iconic toy would never see the light of day.
But after a long and arduous journey, Barbie is finally here. In this fantasy comedy, the world's most recognised doll, Barbie, (Margot Robbie) finds herself no longer content in Barbieland, compelling her and Ken (Ryan Gosling) to go on an adventure together.
As simple as the premise sounds, fans believed this film would be something special, since it was co-written and helmed by esteemed director, Greta Gerwig. Coupled with the star-studded cast and the innovative promotions, Barbie looked like it had the potential to be one of the biggest hits of the year.
So, is Barbie a success or a lazy cash-grab? Did Gerwig strike gold again or has her winning streak come to an end. There's a lot to unpack here, so let's dive right in.
Come on, Barbie! Let's go, party!
10. DOWNS - Some Cast Members Are Wasted
Being one of the hottest brands on the planet, it was expected that Barbie would boast a monumental cast.
But Barbie doesn't just have an ensemble, but an army of talented performers, including Michael Cera, Simu Liu, Kingsley Ben-Adir, Kate McKinnon, Helen Mirren, John Cena, and countless more.
Although plenty of the stars get their moment to shine, just as many are woefully underutilised. Despite the talents of Ncuti Gatwa and Rob Brydon, they comes across as glorified cameos. Nicola Coughlan and Ritu Arya had heir own personalised posters, and yet, their characters only show up for a few seconds. Because of these blink-and-you-will-them appearances, it seems like the filmmakers didn't know what to do with these actors, but cast them anyway for their starpower.
Then there's Will Ferrell. His character, The Mattel CEO, is instrumental to the plot, and yet the cowbell-loving comedian disappears for a sizeable chunk of the run-time, making it easy to forget he's in the movie. Ferrell is solid in the role, but this compounds the argument that he and many of his co-stars should've been given more to work with.
9. The Third Act Gets A Little Messy
Although the best films can be let down by a predictable third act, Barbie's last few scenes never venture towards the formulaic route. Rather than having a showdown with a straightforward villain, the final 30 minutes juggles a ton of different material, including musical numbers, characters switching sides, last-moment revelations, profound messages, a gaggle of gags, and some meta humour for good measure.
Even though Barbie has to be commended for avoiding the conventional ending, it shoots itself in the foot a little. Because the climax bends over backwards to avoid storytelling cliches, it instead concludes with what can only be described as a jumble of ideas.
These ideas are clever in their own right, but cancel each other out, since there's too many. The last-third tries to have a thought-provoking message on so many topics, it becomes counter-productive.
Now, that's not suggesting Barbie's ending is awful or underwhelming. It's just not as airtight as everything that preceded it. Barbie would've been borderline perfect if ten or fifteen minutes of content was left on the cutting room floor, especially when things are wrapping up.
Now that those criticisms are out of the way, let's look at all the good stuff Barbie has to offer.
8. UPS - Margot Robbie Was Born To Play Barbie
Margot Robbie doesn't just make a great Barbie - she is Barbie. Although the Suicide Squad star has knocked it out of the park time and time again throughout her incredible career, her portrayal as Mattel's prized toy is out of this world.
Playing Stereotypical Barbie (that's literally her name,) Robbie initially plays the role as naive, vapid, and childishly joyful. With her stilted movements and robotic gestures, she shows how Barbie is limited by her plasticine body. The Aussie star performs her janky movements so effortlessly, there are times where Barbie looks like a literal doll when viewed from a distance.
As impressive as this display is, it's when Barbie starts developing complex emotions when Robbie shows her A-material. Portraying Barbie as confused and scared is fascinating, since Robbie realistically conveys these sentiments as if it's the first time her character has experienced them. Watching Barbie suppressing her feelings, so she can maintain her happy-go-lucky persona is surprisingly touching and heart-breaking.
Moments like this show Margot Robbie has a talent for making Barbie feel like a children's toy and a flesh-and-blood human being at the same time.
7. Ryan Gosling's Ken Steals The Show
Barbie's name may be on the film's title, but it's Ryan Gosling's Ken who steals the whole show.
Even though Gosling is better-known for drama, the double Oscar-nominee has proven in The Nice Guys, Crazy Stupid Love, and other features to have a knack for comedy.
But in Barbie, Gosling took his talents to a whole new level. Barbie has a plethora of comedic actors, but Gosling is sure to bring about the most laughs. His comic delivery and timing is on point in every scene. Even when he's invested in a deeply dramatic confrontation Gosling still finds a way to pepper each line and movement with his signature Kenergy. (Also, the musical numbers prove he's a surprisingly amazing singer.)
However, Ken isn't just funny, but surprisingly complex. Gosling effortlessly portrays Barbie's wannabe boyfriend as a tragic figure, a joke, a bitter rival, an upstanding guy, and a toxic man-baby. On top of that, he's able to flip from one persona to another on a dime.
In a nutshell, Ken isn't just the most entertaining element of Barbie - this performance is among Gosling's best work.
6. It's Visually Magnificent
After Barbiemania took the world by storm, Mattel started churning out Barbie accessories like there was no tomorrow. Before long, Barbie's showy car, luscious house, and obtrusively bright clothes were as much a part of her identity as her permanently pointed feet.
As such, it was imperative for screenwriters, Greta Gerwig and Noam Baumbach, to capture the aesthetic of Barbie's toyetic world. Fortunately, the film crew went above and beyond to make Barbieland feel like a real place, while still looking unmistakably fake. (The water on the beach is clearly a cardboard cutout.) Even if a location is shown for a moment or an item is tucked away in a corner, it's clear the set designers and prop crew put 110% into making every visual "pop" on-screen.
It's also worth mentioning how the director subtly relies on visuals over dialogue to tell the story. When Ken and Barbie enter The Real World, there are two separate scenes depicting the pair having an emotional awakening after being exposed to humanity. What makes both sequences so effective is how neither of them contain dialogue. Instead, everything they're feeling is conveyed through simple visuals, reaction shots, and the actors' nuanced facial expressions.
Even though this film adaptation perfectly encapsulates the over-the-top aspects of Barbie, Gerwig knows when to rein it in, and use understated imagery instead.
5. It's The 2023's Funniest Movie
Much like the titular star, the Barbie movie is something that struggles to fit into a box. But if it had to be classified as one thing, Barbie is a comedy, above all else. The reason why is simple - it's absolutely hilarious.
Interestingly, it's not Barbie's quantity of jokes that make it funny, but how diverse the humour is. It boasts a beautiful mixture of well-written jokes, silly puns, deliberately dumb one-liners, and inventive visual nods.
Although some wisecracks are groan-inducing and cheesy, they still work, since the film counterbalances them with material that teeters on crude. (Like how the characters keeps referencing how nobody bought the Midge doll because she's pregnant.)
The depravation gags are on full-swing, since the film belittles itself, Mattel, consumers, toys, and Margot Robbie's casting. (It even pokes fun at The Snyder Cut of the Justice League!)
When a joke doesn't work, it doesn't have time to fall flat, since the scenes move on quickly, stopping the movie from losing momentum. Humour may be highly subjective, but it's challenging not to giggle at Barbie's vast versatility in its comedy.
4. Gloria Is The Movie's Secret Weapon
As hilarious as it is to watch the Kens and Barbies acting like, well, Kens and Barbies, the film wouldn't function without an emotional core. To tap into something thought-provoking and visceral, the narrative needs a real human character. Because dolls serve as avatars to the children who play with them, it was wise for Barbie to team up with a person who lives in The Real World, Gloria (America Ferrera).
Despite being a Barbie movie, it often feels like it's about Gloria's life. Watching her trying to keep it together while dealing with real-life problems grounds the story in reality.
Although viewers may struggle to empathise with Ken's inability to "beach," anyone can feel what Gloria is going through. Because Gloria can convey emotion in a way dolls can't, the most hard-hitting moments stem from her.
Even though Gloria gives numerous speeches that are on the verge of preachy, they never fail to incite a sentimental response. In fact, her monologues are among the best parts of the movie, purely because of America Ferrera's career-best performance.
Fans will flock to the theatres to see Barbie and Ken, but it's Gloria who leaves the biggest emotional impact.
3. The Rules Of Barbieland Are Genius
Greta Gerwig's Barbie doesn't just capture the the look of the iconic doll but the feel of it. The inhabitants of Barbieland are well-aware they are dolls, which is why they move around and interact as if they are being played with.
Mirrors don't contain glass, since it would be too dangerous to include in a doll set. Showers don't disperse water, since it's not a real machine. Instead of walking, dolls inexplicably float to where they need to go, as if a child is picking them up and placing them in their new destination. The characters' dialogue is so clunky, it sounds like a child wrote it (because they did). The Barbies and Kens sometimes move in an unnatural way to emulate the clumsy way kids play with them. (And in case you were wondering, yes, Barbie references the age-old gag how she and Ken aren't packing anything downstairs.)
If mishandled or overused, this concept could wear thin fast. Fortunately, the filmmakers keep finding new ways to play with it (no pun intended). Not only does this gag never outstay its welcome, it perfectly captures what it feels like to play with a toy.
2. It Criticises Patriarchy And Matriarchy Effectively
The citizens of Barbieland are led to believe their role model status has fixed women problems across the globe. But when Barbie ventures into The Real World, she discovers she's regularly objectified by men. (She learns this the hard way.) On top of that, she's horrified to see her toyline company, Mattel, is run by the opposite sex.
Although exploring themes like this can be too on-the-nose, Barbie rarely goes down the obvious path. It's no surprise Barbie confronts the problems with commercialism, product oversaturation, and capitalism.
But it also deals with cliques, gender toxicity, and herd mentality in a way that's surprisingly realistic, despite the fantastical backdrop. These moments rarely come across as lecturous, since they strike an emotional cord, while remaining entertaining and funny.
Also, Barbie isn't afraid to do a takedown on its own IP. Throughout the story, the film repeatedly highlights how the concept of Barbie can affect people negatively, since it incentivises its demographic to pursue an impossible standard of beauty they can't maintain.
Even though such issues could've been glossed over, these discussions are the backbone of the plot, making Barbie astonishingly multi-faceted.
1. It's Surprisingly Subversive
No matter how compelling a movie is, it's often shackled by the storytelling formula. And since Barbie seems like a safe property, it looks like the narrative will be as straightforward as possible.
But for the most part, viewers will have no inkling which direction Barbie's plot is heading. Every ten minutes or so, Barbie's adventures hit a genuinely unexpected snag, giving no indication what trials and tribulations await our titular character. When it reaches its third act, viewers will still be clueless what the story is culminating to.
But it's not just the plot that feels fresh, but the tropes. Although the story literally toys with cliches like "will they/won't they?," it's done in a way that doesn't appear derivative.
Because Barbie is a massive brand, it's reasonable to assume this film adaptation would serve as vehicle to sell toys. Ironically, Barbie regularly highlights the danger of its brand, to the point where Mattel becomes the butt-end of the joke.
Barbie may centre around a plastic doll, but it still manages to connects to people in a way that feels very real.