Its an odd world we live in where a talented actor who is smart enough to have garnered two Academy Awards in two completely different categories being cast as Batman leads to fan uproar, but the announcement of a new, forced installment of a franchise already stretched too far is met with seeming joy. Thats less about my cynicism of the continuation of the Harry Potter and more about my pure bemusement that Ben Affleck's appointment as Batman has been viewed as bad thing. Now the majority of the furore is over we can actually look forward to the potential this offers the character. Affleck has said in interviews this is a tired, weary and seasoned Batman (fueling thoughts that the role was originally intended to be a return for Christian Bale), which offers an exciting new direction for a character weve always had to sit through an origin story for before getting to the good stuff. The Dark Knight Rises touched on a run-down Dark Knight, but for a reboot to start there is an unexpected plus of his appearance in Man Of Steel 2. With an experienced Batman naturally comes the whole Batman Family - the gang of crimefighters slowly brought together over Bruce Waynes escapades - who Zack Snyder would be stupid to not include to some degree in Batman Vs. Superman. But who should play them? Today I'm putting forward my personal suggestions, working off the notion of a crew ten years down the line from where the rest of the films have been. Some are pretty out there, although I dont think any would get as strong a response as Affleck if they actually happened. Theres been various different assemblies of the Bat Family over the years in the comics and each member has multiple versions, making whittling down who to include and what iteration tricky. But as Man Of Steel played pretty loose with Superman mythology I've not taken a similar general feel rather than straight adaptation tact.
6. Dick Grayson/Robin/Nightwing
Robin embodies everything that is worth mocking about Batman and it's been proven hard to bring to screen in any serious manner; its no coincidence the films he appears in are the series most mocked. The thing is, in the comics Dick Grayson is a pretty interesting character; he actually out grows the Robin mantle and becomes Nightwing, a hero of Gotham in his own right. With the mature Batman taking this later development would be a smart move, having Grayson already adopted the new alter ego. First Choice: Jake Gyllenhaal Gyllenhaal is one of the those actors with indeterminable age (just look at how he went from schoolboy in Donnie Darko to experienced farmer in Brokeback Mountain in the space of four years), which makes him perfect for Bruce Waynes grown up ward; while the actor himself is thirty two he could easily pass for younger in flashbacks if need be. His standout roles in Zodiac and Prisoners show an unfaltering, if unstable, drive that is essential is youre aging this normally teenage character. Worth Considering: Logan Lerman You want an actual boy wonder? Fine. Logan Lerman is shaping up to be a real screen presence after a damaged turn in The Perks Of Being A Wallflower and with his only blockbuster work thus far being the titular demi-God in the Percy Jackson series, he could do with a serious revitalisation. Or Why Not: Matt Damon When Affleck was announced as the Dark Knight, everyone immediately joked that Damon was going to be Robin. Silly, but why the hell not?
5. Alfred Pennyworth
Alfred has been through some pretty zany incarnations, starting out as a bumbling detective, taking many years before he settled down as the Wayne family butler. Given we're doing an old Batman a brave move would be to simply kill off Alfred, but that's a little bit of a disservice to a fan favourite. With the only prerequisite of playing him having to be English (because how odd would it be for him to have an American accent), hes already been portrayed by some great actors, so whoever gets the job has some big shoes to fill. First Choice: Christopher Plummer Theres been rumours floating around that Warner have been trying to get Timothy Dalton in to play the butler, which in my mind goes against the notion of a mature Batman. Given hes been caring for Bruce for a good thirty years, you need someone who was already at a respectable age when the Waynes were killed, so were talking someone in their eighties. Few actors that age are as suited to the role (and still working) than Christopher Plummer; at eighty three hes older than Caine, but when were dealing with an aging Batman, you need an aging Alfred too. Worth Considering: Terence Stamp I was originally going to put John Cleese here, but theres a real danger hed skirt into the comedic kitsch he did with Q in the Brosnan Bond, which isnt Alfred no matter how camp you take your Batman. Stamp is an actor whos really grown on me over the past couple of years and he'd be a choice for the role as out there as Caine. Or Why Not: Michael Caine Caine was so awesome as Alfred that I dont think anyone would complain to see him return in this new take. Bond kept Judi Dench when it rebooted, so theres no reason everyones favourite cockney cant stick around.
4. Selina Kyle/Catwoman
Not originally part of the Bat family, Catwomans flitting status between hero and villain eventually led to her shacking up with Bruce Wayne, making for an incredibly enticing antihero for producers to bring to the screen. And they have, incredibly successfully. Including her in the film means the two leads have no ambiguity in their love interest, but given how tired a trope thats becoming in every superhero film it's not really a bad thing. First Choice: Salma Hayek As with Batman, having Selina Kyle aged is a smart move to help differentiate this new version from the Michelle Pfeiffer and Anne Hathaway interpretations (oddly enough both equally defining). So you want a mature actress whos still alluring and has the chops to go up opposite Affleck... My mind immediately jumps to Salma Hayek and now it wont leave; she fits the bill perfectly and really could do with a high profile escape from her association with the Grown Ups series. Worth Considering: Anne Hathaway I was joking when I said bringing Caine back, but this time Im deadly serious. After The Dark Knight Rises everyone was eager for a Catwoman spin off with Hathaway (who managed to steal the show despite being peripheral to the plot) and while thats unlikely (Halle Berry sealed the characters standalone fate almost a decade ago), her appearance here isn't. Hathaway would no doubt be happy to return and once she was in that suit again anyone moaning over continuity should be won over. Or Why Not: Jennifer Lopez From the fan reaction it seems many think the reason Affleck was cast was his high profile turn in Gigli. In that spirit, Snyder would be smart to bring in the other half of thats films winning duo. Stand back mind the inevitable sparks.
3. Barbara Gordon/Batgirl/Oracle
Batgirls only screen outing was Batman And Robin, a film so ridiculed it needs no fancy introduction on my part. There she was the niece of Alfred, but the most famous iteration of the character is Barbara Gordon, daughter of the Police Commissioner. Crippled by the Joker in The Killing Joke, she became Oracle, a wheelchair bound techie who aids the rest of the team, which is where she really should be when Batman Vs. Superman kicks off. First Choice: Rooney Mara If you want to show off someone internally wounded as well as physically, you could go a lot worse than the girl who out-Lisbethed Noomi Rapace. Rooney Mara has risen from obscurity over the past few years, David Finchers Dragon Tattoo remake making way for the twisted (in both writing and subject) Side Effects and and an upcoming teaming with Terrence Mallick, but this film would send her star even higher. For The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo she fully transformed herself into Lisbeth, showing a devotion Oracle would benefit from. Worth Considering: Carey Mulligan Like Gyllenhaal, Mulligan is as gifted at shifting her age on screen as she is as an actress and its easy to imagine her slipping into either the suit or the wheelchair with little acting effort. The problem here is that unlike Mara its just harder to imagine her having a crime fighting past, making her a nice, if not ideal, choice. Or Why Not: Selena Gomez With Justin Bieber reportedly being eyed for Robin, why not pop another child star in just in case Batman fighting Superman isn't enough to grab kids attention?
2. James Gordon
While The Dark Knight Trilogy brought us exciting views on many of the stalwarts, the standout for me has to be Gary Oldman as Commissioner Gordon. Tying the character directly into Batmans origin made for some cracking recurring beats, culminating in the best of Bales cryptic identity reveals. Itd be easy to cut him out for fear of skirting too close to whats come before, but if we get Oracle the Commissioner has to appear in some form. First Choice: Michael Douglas Initially this choice feels like a hokey reference to Wall Street - there he was also a (morally completely different) Gordon and Mulligans father - but while its out there, hes the best man for the job. If were in a Gotham where Batman is just part of the furniture, we can go to the opposite of what Oldman did in The Dark Knight Rises and have a content, rested Gordon who is on the brink of natural retirement. Over his career Douglas has proven himself a versatile actor and this would be a great way to capitalise on his post-Liberace hype. Worth Considering: Leonardo DiCaprio For no reason other than he is one of the best actors working today, we should get Leonardo DiCaprio as ol Jim Gordon. Having never shown any interest in the superhero genre I've just about accepted well never see him suit up to fight good or evil, but can just about see him in a supporting role. There is of course an age issue (hes younger than Affleck), but having been around since his late teens, in audience minds he could get away with playing considerably older. Or Why Not: Robert De Niro Because hes at that point where hell do just about anything. And I guess he could be OK at it, maybe.
1. The Joker
Not part of the Bat Family in any way, the Joker is such an essential part of the Dark Knight mythos that I might as well have a stab at him while I'm here. The Joker, more than any other character that appeared in Nolans trilogy, is the hardest to recast. Heath Ledger remains the only actor to win an Oscar for a superhero movie for his turn as the mad clown and any new actor coming into the role really risks only aping what he did. First Choice: Willem Dafoe You dont want Joker stealing the show from this incredibly high concept, so as with every other key player this would be him a few years down the line; hes had his crime spree and is now locked up. So different and a little more conventional than Ledger, Dafoe has channelled this character before for his schizophrenic Norman Osborn, so would be perfect for a small cameo (any more would distract from the fact this is actually a Superman movie). Given his superhero legacy is set to be overwritten by Chris Cooper in the coming years, he might as well have a stab as the biggest of all. Worth Considering: Michael Sheen When thinking of people to take on the Joker Michael Sheen was the first to jump to mind. A great character actor who gives each of his performances the same in depth reverence (be they Prime Ministers, political interviews or Ziggy Stardust-aping bartenders), he has a face that lends itself to the Clown Prince of Crime. But he comes with a catch; hes just too close to Ledger. Obviously older, hes still in the same area and would likely anger a few too many fans. Or Why Not: Mark Hamill Hamill has voiced most of the characters animated and video game outings, so why not give him a chance to do the full look and, along with Star Wars, make 2015 The Year Hamill Returned. How would you cast the Bat Family? Have your say down in the comments.