Batman and Robin is one of the most hated (and certainly the most well-known) the many superhero movies that fell flat on their faces. Joel Schumachers directorial decision to film the movie as child-friendly, live-action cartoon was criticized both audiences and viewers alike, and effectively killed the Batman movie franchise for eight years until Christopher Nolan rebooted the thing and changed the game with Batman Begins. All things considered, there were some redeemable features to the movie. To say that Batman and Robin is the worst comic book movie or worst movie ever is unfair. This article will not try and convince you that Batman and Robin is a good movie - rather it will try and help you see past the ice puns and bat-nipples and understand that Batman and Robin was an important movie and that - believe it or not - some good came of it having existed.
10. It Was A Cautionary Tale
The stylistic choices made in Batman and Robin were obviously very poor. While it was perhaps not a terrible idea to portray Batman as a sort of live-action cartoon, the execution was mis-judged. This film strived to be family friendly, but really became only child-friendly as pretty much all adults hated it. The overall dislikable nature of Batman and Robin - in some ways - killed the superhero genre for a bit. However, when superhero movies came back, they were for the most part, far better. For one thing, studios focused less on marketing the movies to children. There may still be toy tie-ins and young fans, but Batman and Robin took such things to an extreme and failed, and thus, nobody since has tried to duplicate that level of child-friendly corporate selling out. Since Batman and Robin, no mainstream superhero movie has marketed so much to children despite the fact that they are a large part of the audience. Batman and Robin taught movie writers that it is important to write for adults. Children will like superheroes regardless, but adults are the critical and important audience (and the ones with money). Batman and Robin served, then, as a massive script of what not to do when writing a superhero movie and some good has come of that.
9. It Was Memorable
If nothing else, Batman and Robin kept Batman in the public eye. For good or bad, it was a memorable movie and kept public interest going in a fading Batman. Batman and Robin is a rather unforgettable viewing experience, which you cannot say for many movies, or even most bad comic book movies. Take Superman Returns. When was the last time you even thought about Superman Returns? That movie came and went with hardly a wave of interest. Batman and Robin, by contrast, ingrained itself in the viewers memories, making it impossible to be forgotten. Among many film buffs (or even casual film viewers) who see so many movies a year they cannot remember half, it is an important thing to make an impression and leave a mark.
8. Uma Thurman
Uma Thurman was a part of Batman and Robin that approached the level of good. She came the closest to understanding the level of camp that could have actually translated to a live action screen. Thurmans performance as Poison Ivy was fully committed. She understood the character. She was seductive, which is doubly impressive when you consider some of the ridiculous styling options they made for her. She was also a legitimate threat. Among two very muscular, physical villains, she holds her own as a formidable villain who gets what she wants through seduction and chemistry instead of brute force. While her performance was overshadowed and undermined by incompetent directing and the overall poor performances from her co-stars, Uma Thurmans had potential. In a better film or with a better director, Poison Ivy could have seemed like a character ripped right from the pages of a comic book.
7. It Is Not The Worst Comic Book Movie Ever Made
Despite Batman and Robin working as a cautionary tale, there have been a few movies after its release that didnt get the memo. For my money, Ang Lees Hulk or the abysmal Green Lantern were both far worse movies. For one thing, they have less on an excuse. Batman and Robin had been released and everyone around them managed to use it as a thing to avoid, but Hulk and the Green Lantern fell right in to the pitfalls Batman and Robin had so obviously laid out, as well as failing in a few ways even Batman and Robin didnt manage to do. Aside from this, I find both of them to be much less enjoyable movies. Of all Batman and Robins problems, the pacing is actually decent (which I could not say about Hulk or The Green Lantern). Both those movies were tediously dull on top of being seriously bad. If nothing else, Batman and Robin is entertaining, which is the main reason people go to see superhero movies. Hulk and The Green Lantern didnt even manage to do that.
6. Feminist Themes
Thinking about women and feminism in Batman lead me to the surprisingly realization that out of the Batman movies, Batman and Robin is one of the most feminist-friendly movies, if not the most so. This comes from the simple fact that this movie has more than one female character. While Bruce Waynes girlfriend is so dull she hardly is worth mentioning and Gossip Gerty is best left forgotten, they at least make a dent in the great gender inequality in Gotham. Main character-wise, we had Poison Ivy, who could be seen as a sign of sexual empowerment. If that is too much of a leap, we have Batgirl, who is the only main female character in a Batman movie to not have a major love plot line focused around her character. Sure, Robin had a thing for her, but it wasnt necessary for the plot. She even saves both our heroes lives and manages not to be a damsel in distress. Batgirl is probably the biggest triumph and her possible downfall of being too sexualized, such as in the scene in which she first dons the suit which is a montage of ass, crotch and boob shots, is undone by the fact that the same shots were applied to Batman and Robin at the beginning of the movie. In this way, Batman and Robin has a strange sort of equality. She even comes out of it with a little more dignity. At least her suit didnt have bat-nipples.
5. It Launched George Clooney's Career
It can be a hard move for a television actor to transfer to the world of film, and few have done this more successfully as George Clooney. After a long and popular stint on ER, Clooney managed to become a Hollywood leading man, winning an Oscar and other major awards over a long and popular career as well as branching off into directing, producing and writing. Bizarrely enough, Batman and Robin helped him achieve his mega-stardom. Before Batman and Robin, Clooney starred in some movies, though no major hits. After Batman and Robin, Clooney started starring in major critical and commercial hits, and continues to star in them today. This phenomenon was best summed up by 30 Rock, which mentions that Clooney managed to have a career because after ER, Clooney had dumb gay Batman. So if you enjoyed Clooneys work Oceans Eleven, O Brother, Where Art Thou?, Up in the Air, The Descendants, or the recent best picture winner Argo, you have dumb gay Batman to thank.
4. Alfred
Perhaps its because most of his co-stars gave such poor performances, but Michael Goughs performance stands out as actually being rather good. Even in the comparably light-hearted Schumacher take on Batman and Robin, the fact that Alfred was dying was a legitimately concerning plot point. Michael Gough made me care about Alfred in a way that none of the other actors made me care about their characters. I was very upset about the possibility of him dying because he was such a crucial part of the series and a redeeming quality of the movie. Without him, everything would be so much worse for both Bruce Wayne and for the viewer. While it was a bit lame that he got saved by Mr. Freezes medicine that looked more like the contents of a glow stick, I was not nearly as annoyed as I should have been, as it meant Alfred got to stick around. Michael Goughs performance was a bright spot in the movie, and all the more impressive that he managed to pull out this great, comparatively subtle performance with such an over-the-top director.
3. It's Accessible
While it was clearly a mistake to use this film as a kids' venture, I do remember watching and enjoying this movie as a child. For me and millions of other 90s kids, Batman and Robin has nostalgic value. We watched it as kids and we enjoyed it because we were too young to know better. Bad though it is, Batman and Robin helped foster my lifelong love of the character and franchise. It entertained me when I was young which made me want to see the new movie series and made me want to read the comics. Batman and Robin is kid-friendly in a way that the others certainly arent. I remember being scared by the Penguin when I was six and being terrified by the Scarecrow when I was 10. Batman and Robin is an appealing movie to children. Having tried to get younger cousins into Batman, I have found that they are often bored by Nolans take on the series. While we learned from the mistake of making Batman and Robin child-friendly, it does have its uses. Batman and Robin is an important stepping stone in making life long Batman and Robin fans. Sure, theyll move on to better things as they get older, but if you want to get a child into Batman, it is better to start them off with Batman and Robin rather than Batman Begins.
2. It Lead To Christopher Nolan's Batman
Just as Joel Schumachers take on Batman was a direct response to Tim Burtons take on Batman becoming dark, Christopher Nolans version Batman was a direct response to Joel Schumachers Batman. Batmans film history has always been a bit of a tug-of-war between campy and dark and it switches between the two. The campiness of '60s Batman gave way to Burtons dark take, which then turned into Joel Schumachers effort to be more family-friendly. Most recently, we have Christopher Nolan responding to Schumacher by going very far back in the other direction and making The Dark Knight very dark indeed. Had Batman and Robin not been made, Batman would likely have continued to crank out sequels to the level of Batman Forever. We would likely have never had the breakthrough of the superhero genre known as Batman Begins because, as far as production companies are concerned, if it aint broke, dont fix it. We would have never gotten Nolans very grounded out-of-the-box take. Batman and Robin gave Nolan a movie to avoid at all costs. Nolans movie took Batman and Robin and its elements and threw them out entirely, starting from the ground up, in a completely new direction. If the price for getting The Dark Knight trilogy is Batman and Robin, its a price Im willing to pay.
1. It's Hilariously Entertaining
To be quite honest, I dont understand people who dont like Batman & Robin. Its so funny that Id rather watch it than I would most comedies. Batman & Robin fails hilariously on so many levels that you cant look away, and dont really want to. Overall, Batman is underrated because its so completely enjoyable. Every time you watch it, its almost like a new experience because you notice a new level of bad each time. Its not just bad though, Batman & Robin has transcended into the realm of so-bad-its-good, or at least so-bad-its-hilarious. If nothing else, Batman & Robin is an incredibly entertaining movie. Thats the overall point of movies to me - to be entertained. On most days, Id rather watch it than The Dark Knight because The Dark Knight doesnt have such amusing failures as Robins rubber lips, the bat credit card, or Arnold Schwarzenegger making constant ice puns. Whats not to love? Agree or disagree? Think Batman & Robin is underrated? Let us know in the comments section below.